I used kit #3 from simply speakers for my 8's and 9's, i took off the old dust caps and used the plastic shims from simply speakers to align the voice coils, if you use this kit i would call simply speakers and buy 5 new dust caps, one extra just incase you screw up, ask for the plastic shims to align the voice coil, the hardest part of the job is removing the old glue, can't say anything about the other kits because i never used them.