• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Interesting speaker/driver design

Brian, I think we're splitting hairs... I could trot out my own resume in the speaker business which included both P&L responsibility and hands-on product management & development for several years, but I don't think we're advancing the discussion much in the process.

With no other input than the pics provided, I will stick with my opinion that these are cheap, low end speakers. If the brand owner paid any premium for that off-centered design, they got taken. At least when we did it there was a reason... and a plausible story to take to market, semi-premium pricing that reflected the costs (we also tooled the entire cast basket family for a complete set of automotive sizes, ouch), and performance that justified the choice. Still a bad decision but might have worked out better under different conditions.

John
 
I know nothing about the driver and never have seen the speaker. The only justification I can think of is that being a full range driver the intent has something to do with attempting to have the cone to work better in certain areas at certain frequencies and aid in the dispersion. Just a wag. If correct, the concept might be interesting as it could benefit that single driver system concept. As a kid, I grew up in my father's store that had a service bench and was the warranty station for automotive radios from all the auto company's and many aftermarket suppliers. I used to attend the GM and Fomoco radio service schools and 1 lesson learned was why they then tended to use oval speakers. It was for that very reason as back then the speakers offered were full range, years before coaxial and triaxial offerings. As a premium driver, the option was the same speakers with a whizzer. Some European speaker companies likewise used oval full range drivers in some of their higher end small enclosure systems and marketed them as having extended h.f. And better bass by using the oval design. I remember Grundig in particular doing this for some years.

Without seeing the backside, I can not tell if these are cheap junk or otherwise. Or pass any opinion. You may be correct they are cheap low end products. I have seen drivers of all types that look like they should be great and totally such and vice versa.

John, I agree we likely are splitting hairs.
 
Does anyone remember that Yamaha speaker shaped like an ear? That looked a bit off center. In more ways than one!
billw
 
Does anyone remember that Yamaha speaker shaped like an ear? That looked a bit off center. In more ways than one!
billw
Yes, I do. It was developed from a license agreement the company had with BES. Used a flat diaphram that looked like the same material as the foam coffee cups and the motor assembly was called a hammer. I seem to remember the Yamaha was a 2-way version. The shape was part marketing and partly for the frequency response of each section. Bertagni was originally from Argentina if memory serves me but relocated to California. They also licensed the technology to Fisher and Leak. BES marketed speakers under its own name, the largest being essentially a stacked pair of the otherwise totl. They did not sell well and had issues with the glue cementing the hammer to the diaphragms.

There are a couple of threads here about them and they show up for auction from time to time. Opinions vary as root quality. The company also made automotive and weather resistant speakers that while not big sellers in the consumer market did well with manufacturers of trains, buses and the like as they were very thin and incorporated the grill.

A few years ago the company was still around but, out of the audio market concentrating on inwall and commercial units. I have not followed it for some time but, I think it finally folded.
 
From post #9:

attachment.php


Pretty decent sized motor for that diameter driver, but nothing else that jumps out as being more costly.

Although they didn't shift the voice coil that far off-center, I can tell you that you can definitely impact the dispersion pattern by doing so. That's the only reason we fooled with the concept in the first place. Looking at the front of the enclosure, that may have been the intent for these also.

Here's pics of one of the smaller coax models, borrowed from a BMW forum. Can't tell as much from the rear view as the front, but we moved the voice coil/motor components quite a bit off-center:

attachment.php


attachment.php


Die-cast basket, Santoprene surround, a patented neodymium underhung motor, etc. etc. ... these things were very innovative. Too bad they came along when 12V audio was fading fast.


John
 
Back
Top Bottom