• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

McIntosh Haters

Your logic escapes me. You seem to be saying that mac gear needs to remain expensive so that mac owners can sell their gear and afford to upgrade. Wouldn't it be easier to upgrade if it were less expensive? A bit circular methinks.

If it were less expensive it would be easier to afford....but maybe harder to find since more people would be in "buying mode", decreasing what was available to purchase
 
If it were less expensive it would be easier to afford....but maybe harder to find since more people would be in "buying mode", decreasing what was available to purchase
And the the law of supply and demand would increase the price. The point in the first place was to reduce demand by bad-mouthing it. Not that it would ever work, just a pipe dream... Hey, wait a minute! Maybe that's what all the mac haters are tring to do:)
 
And the the law of supply and demand would increase the price. The point in the first place was to reduce demand by bad-mouthing it. Not that it would ever work, just a pipe dream... Hey, wait a minute! Maybe that's what all the mac haters are tring to do:)
BTW, I seen your thread on Head Room, if your speakers where mine I'd want at least a 200 watt amp to drive them (150 Watt speakers). That give you 50 watts of head room so your not listening to clipped music al the time. Most people only look at clipping for speaker damage when in reality your clipping all the transient peaks of the music off. In other words you not getting all the music or the quality of the music.
 
I will say this: I owned MC2100's run in mono driven by a Citation 17S Preamp running Janszen Z-824 speakers in the 70's and I and many others were blown away by the system. I tried to replicate the rig in the late nineties driving Green Mountain Audio Continuum 1's and was disappointed even after sending them and a pristine C28 to Terry Dewickt for updating. I replaced them on Roy Johnson's recommendation and those speakers just came to life. I have a great appreciation of McIntosh gear, but that lack of synergy sent me down a new path, and I never went back. The lesson is that sometimes lack of synergy moves us in a different direction. Not a knock on McIntosh gear at all.
Regards,
Jim
 
I already have great sound. What I need is more power. I'm a tube guy, and while I'm sure a pair of Dynaco mk3s would make me perfectly happy soundwise, a pair of mc60s would just look soooo much sexier. And those don't come cheap.

You could have both (much better deals available on MK3s though
 
I got into tube audio when I was a starving grad student, so Dynaco was an option. McIntosh was not.

I'm the first to say that there is a lot of room for improvement on the Dynacos. The ST-70 is hamstrung by an inadequate power supply (single rectifier and marginally adequate PT). The MkIIIs in stock form never sound good to me because I don't think the 6AN8 can gracefully swing enough drive voltage for a pair of 6550s/KT88s. However, I have rebuilt two pairs of Dynaco MkIIIs with much improved driver boards and beefed up power supplies and had the opportunity to compare one of these pairs directly to a McIntosh 275. The highly modified MkIIIs were, to my ear, in roughly the same performance class. Not as pretty and more likely to burn up a power transformer, but competitive.

I now repair tube amps professionally, including McIntosh, and I learned how partly by analyzing the compromises that Hafler made to make budget equipment and learning how to get around those compromises. Would I have learned as much starting with McIntosh? Probably not :-)
 
A Dynaco ST-70 (35 watts, 1% THD, damping factor 15) would "blow away" an MC 6500 (120 watts, 0.005% THD, damping factor 230)? How can I even respond to such nonsense?
Having owned a pair of refurb'd Dynaco MkIII's, I can tell you that the Dynaco amps are completely outclassed by Mcintosh gear, in my experience. I've mentioned in these pages that I acquired my pair of Mc2100's for a pair of MkIII's in a straight up trade. In spite of the cosmetic deficiencies of my 2100's, I still regard the trade as a fantastic deal. There is simply no sonic comparison, and I mean, not even close.
 
I got into tube audio when I was a starving grad student, so Dynaco was an option. McIntosh was not.
Ebay changed everything. In the old days the only place to find decent used stuff was as a trade-in at a dealer. The same was true for good camera equipment. Mac is still expensive but I would bet the difference is not as great as in the 70's. Tube equipment is a bad example though. It is now "hot" like Beanie Babies."
 
Not a "hater" by any means, but I am an outsider of sorts. I confess that the cosmetics a bit over the top for me and the use of meters on preamps and turntables just plain silly. My first experience is the 70s wasn't particularly good hearing a C28/2105 combination. While not *bad*, the results were just insipid as compared to Audio Research gear at the time. Having said that, there's no question that Mac has always produced the highest quality product - far greater than any Dyna. The ST-70 was a classic of sorts, but I'd take a 240 any day. I'm delighted to say that they seem to be back on the performance curve they established early on with current products.

I got an opportunity to tour the factory years ago when business took me to the Binghamton area. My host was very gracious and I confessed that I was not a big fan. He acknowledged the limitation of some of earlier gear and gave me a grand tour. There's no question of the pride taken by the workers there. The water jet glass etching process is a sight to behold!

We ended by hearing some selections in their audio room using their largest speakers, the monster three-chassis amps and one of the top end preamps. The results were certainly nice, but not as transparent as I've heard with a reviewer's friend's spectacular Scaena 1.6 based system - who coincidentally really liked the 2301 amps.
 

Attachments

  • scaena16.jpg
    scaena16.jpg
    82.7 KB · Views: 37
tumblr_m3kraeDnn51qhy6c9o6_400.gif
 
Not a "hater" by any means, but I am an outsider of sorts. I confess that the cosmetics a bit over the top for me and the use of meters on preamps and turntables just plain silly. My first experience is the 70s wasn't particularly good hearing a C28/2105 combination. While not *bad*, the results were just insipid as compared to Audio Research gear at the time.

The problem I have with comparisons such as this is that you hear the gear through speakers. If there is no synergy between the gear and the speakers, you are going to be disappointed. If the synergy is there, that impression will stay in your memory.

I was reading a thread last night, and one respondent stated they hated the word synergy, because it doesn't mean anything to them. Well, synergy is magic! Synergy is Led Zeppelin, Genesis, the Rolling Stones, Simon and Garfunkle, the Cult, Nirvana, and the Beatles. Without synergy, you will have a band that no one remembers, or remembers badly. It is not measurable! It is that undefinable something that makes a great team, great! I know this must drive the engineers crazy, but it is real. You just don't know how to measure it yet.
 
The problem I have with comparisons such as this is that you hear the gear through speakers. If there is no synergy between the gear and the speakers, you are going to be disappointed.
Agree completely on the need for system matching. Perhaps Bozak speakers were a poor match.

OTOH, I've heard from other former owners who weren't crazy about the sound of these late 60's era SS units.
 
Agree completely on the need for system matching. Perhaps Bozak speakers were a poor match.

OTOH, I've heard from other former owners who weren't crazy about the sound of these late 60's era SS units.

Rudy Bozak used McIntosh equipment to voice some of his speakers. Folks that don't like early Mac gear usually like a more sterile sound like some newer SS units have. The early Mac SS gear was made to sound like tube gear for a reason. Early SS by competitors sounded grainy and had germanium transistors. McIntosh purposely waited until better sounding transistors became available before they released any SS gear. I've yet to find any gear I hate. I like some better than others and some not at all. Just think hate is an over used word by some who are too lazy to articulate what they are really trying to say. Just one man's opinion so take it was a dose of salt.
 
Rudy Bozak and McIntosh had a close working relationship in the early days and there are many accounts of Mc-Bozak setups back in the day. I'd be extremely surprised if they were a poor match.

Personally I haven't found much sonic difference between first gen Mc SS and early Mc tube amplifiers.
 
My first experience is the 70s wasn't particularly good hearing a C28/2105 combination. While not *bad*, the results were just insipid as compared to Audio Research gear at the time.

I owned an ARC D-115 MK II power amp for about 20 years and as my friends said, it was "my baby." I also rebuilt an ARC SP3A-1 Preamp for a friend - new poly caps and precision resistors in the signal paths, a nice stepped volume control sourced from ARC and general clean up. The SP3A-1 / D-115 MkII combo was fabulous. (Alas I had to return the SP3 and never did get the SP10 I wanted back then.)

In 2007-ish, I got a Mc2505 as a novelty / collectable I guess. I listened for about 5 minutes and it sounded fuzzy as I expected for old SS equipment so I turned it off and shipped it to Terry DeWick for electrical restoration. When I got it back, I hooked it up and and was amazed (floored) by the sound. The ARC D-115 sat on a shelf nearby for about a year and I never felt the urge to hook it back up. Ultimately I replaced the D-115 with a slightly less powerful Mc275 IV and put the Mc2505 into a "vintage" system. Happily sold my D-115 and my Klyne SK-5A preamp (in favor a Mc 220) and don't miss anything at all.

I've never heard a C28, so cannot comment. For the record, I'm not a fan of the meters on the turntables or on preamps, although they would not be show stoppers and most Mc equipment is very attractive. But I'm in it for the sound. If the sound was insipid or even slightly inferior to ARC or others, I would not have a house full of McIntosh.

Anyway, that is my experience - so far.
 
The early Mac SS gear was made to sound like tube gear for a reason. Early SS by competitors sounded grainy and had germanium transistors.
I'll certainly agree that grainy has never been my goal. My favorite SS amps from the 70s (and pretty much any following decade) are Nelson Pass' designs starting with Threshold.

By comparison, however, an Audio Research SP-3a sounded more like live music to me than a C28.

I've yet to find any gear I hate.
Well the Crown IC-150 wins for being the worst component I've ever heard. :)
 
Last edited:
Hmmm; my Concert Grands were the only speaker I've ever owned that I preferred a Japanese amp over a Mac amp driving them. I didn't care for the sound of either my 2100 or my 2125 driving them but they seemed to come alive with a Yamaha C4-M4 combo. I was thinking at the time if I had stumbled upon this combo early on I may not have ever looked beyond it. The Mac's sadly just did not have that synergy with the grands
 
Rudy Bozak used McIntosh equipment to voice some of his speakers. Folks that don't like early Mac gear usually like a more sterile sound like some newer SS units have. The early Mac SS gear was made to sound like tube gear for a reason. Early SS by competitors sounded grainy and had germanium transistors. McIntosh purposely waited until better sounding transistors became available before they released any SS gear. I've yet to find any gear I hate. I like some better than others and some not at all. Just think hate is an over used word by some who are too lazy to articulate what they are really trying to say. Just one man's opinion so take it was a dose of salt.
One of the reasons I like the early SS Marantz equipment. Old man Marantz didnt want to switch to SS until transistors got better, and tried to emulate the Marantz tube sound. McIntosh must have done the same. Years ago I would hang out at a local antique shop just to listen to the owners tube Mc mono blocks and Mc preamp.
 
Back
Top Bottom