• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

McIntosh Haters

I remember seeing a McIntosh ad in maybe a Popular Mechanics magazine in the early 1980s at the age of maybe 13 or 14. I was like - wow. There's McIntosh and then there's everything else. I filled out the little card in the magazine and sent it in to get a free packet from McIntosh. It came a few weeks later. It included an introductory letter from Gordon Gow, a bunch of ad slicks for preamps, amplifiers, speakers, etc. and a price sheet - which my father read aloud in disbelief. I still have it!
 
and a price sheet - which my father read aloud in disbelief.

That's what my father would have done also. I always remember when I was a kid and my parents took me shopping for what ever. I would always gravitate to the best and most expensive, I wasn't ever looking at prices it was always the quality I liked and that's what I had to have. Well at least when I had to pay for it.
 
I haven't read every post in this thread but thought to add my own thoughts to it. I own a modified Stereo 70 and Mac MA 6200. The Dyna has a rebuilt and more bullet proof solid state power supply and upgraded coupling capacitors that eliminated the problems with muddy treble and midrange (read the Van Alstine stereo 70 rebuild article for the reason why the amp had that issue). Even with those changes the Dyna is not the equal of the Mac.

There is a point to this however. The McIntosh gear is very deeply into the realm of diminishing returns, meaning a very small increase in performance will bring with it a large increase in price. I also think that the name itself also adds cost to the purchase, some would describe that as value. Do I think it was work the price of admission to join Mac, for sure YES! Did I pay more for the Mac then for something that would perform equally well? I probably did. Do I mind, normally I would, but for this purchase I don't. Why? I first ran across McIntosh back in the late 60's and its performance and beauty just blew me away. I have lusted after one since then. I finally got my Mac about 2 years ago and needed to spend about 9 months bringing it back to life. (Some unobtainium parts were broken / missing and I had to make my own circuit board, devise a mounting for it, and find and install 6 pole, double throw switches on it that would mate with the front panel cutouts for the pushbuttons. All that took a while.) Even with all that work involved in the repair, the amp was worth every bit of it. Also, even in that poor shape, it cost more then anything else in my system, ever.

If you want great sound at good price, it is had to wrong with Dyna. If you want the best, there may be other units out there in the same class as Mac, but as far as I'm concerned, there are none better.

So ignore the haters, turn the volume on the Mac up to drown them out, listen to the music you want and forget looking for a Dyna, you won't need it, not as long as your Mac works.

Shelly_D
 
This is kind of the opposite of the "McIntosh Snobs" thread. I have a used MA6500 integrated, my first McIntosh. I have enjoyed it for over a year.

Recently I purchased a turntable shelf from a local guy off Craig's List. He had all kinds of vintage gear. Giant speakers with drivers that looked like satellite dishes, and a bunch of vintage tube gear. He demoed his stuff, and of course, it sounded great for the short demo I got.

I asked him what he thought of McIntosh, and said it was "good to sell", insinuating that it does not perform that well but commands good money, or at least he meant it does not perform as well as it costs. He oddly then asked if my integrated had tone controls, to which I replied that it does but that I leave them at the center position, to which he made a crack like "with McIntosh you should definitely use the tone controls!" He also rolled his eyes when I said my music of choice it rock music. Lol. He was actually a nice guy, but definitely an audio snob....

So what is the deal? Is McIntosh more style and marketing than performance? I know the question coming is "do you like yours?", and I do, but maybe it is out of ignorance since I have never had better.

He also said a vintage Dynaco ST-70 would likely "blow my McIntosh away". Next thing I know, I am looking at ST-70s on Ebay. Argh.

Those of you who are McIntosh fans and fans of other brands, how does McIntosh hold up? Is my MA6500 a good representation of at least decent McIntosh gear?

It's hard to say what the motivation behind his negative assesment is, but I'll say this. I have owned a Dyna Stereo 70 coupled with a PAS3-X preamp. When I was using it, I thought it was the best sounding hi-fi around. I was extremely happy, and proud of that system. Then a good friend brought his newly acquired Mac 1700 receiver over for a listen. It was a night & day difference with my Altec Flamenco's. It wasn't long after that I had acquired McIntosh of my own. While the Dyna was a decent system, it could not compare in terms of build quality, reliability or sonic quality.

While I haven't had first hand experience with the MA6500, I'll say that I've probably owned 15 or more pieces of Mac gear over several decades. The constant throughout all the gear was the consistency of the attributes that I mentioned.
That, plus it made the music I listen to sound good. I'm sure that there are other manufacturers that could provide the same level of satisfaction, but I've never felt the need to look elsewhere.
 
Hate? How does somebody actually hate an inanimate object? I can see hating the neighbor who leaves junk in the yard or the one who leaves his dog to bark half the night, but how does one go about hating an amplifier? It can't think, have an opposing viewpoint, or any of the other things that we hate one another for. If someone appears to hate a brand of anything I strongly suspect it is directed at the owner, either out of envy for the haves, or guilt for the have nots.

'Hate? How does somebody actually hate an inanimate object?''

I take it that you have never owned a Chrysler product!:rflmao:
 
'Hate? How does somebody actually hate an inanimate object?''

I take it that you have never owned a Chrysler product!:rflmao:

That's a good one.
0rofl.gif
 
As for hating Mac,I know some techs who do,and I was one of them.In the pre-internet days,before you could find information on just about any piece of equipment,working on SS Mac usually entailed rather expensive,time consuming long distance calls (this predates the days of super cheap long distance plans) to McIntosh to find out just what type that bloody house-numbered transistor you needed to replace really was.

Although some were ''specially selected'' and required direct Mac replacements,which they were more than happy to sell you,most were generic types that the manufacturer (unlike many others I have had the misfortune of dealing with!) was happy to share information on.That and their willingness to support and distribute service information to ''independents'' made me a Mac supporter long before I ever actually owned one of their products. Thou shalt not covet? Yeah,good luck with that.....

There is no higher product recommendation/endorsement than that which comes from the service tech. Period.
 
A quick comment, my father has been in business for over 50 years, owning 2 brickyards at one point.
He says that with any business, you have 3 things: quality, service, and price.

You can pick only 2 of these things.

Quality and service = costly.
Service and price> quality
Price and quality> service
 
Though their products will always be out of reach budget wise, I have used and set up systems with Mc equipment helping out at a freinds home theater company. The amps take a lot of abuse, They are built to last. Customers #1 feedback is the attention to detail, And sound. No clue why people knock them.
 
There is enough division in the word . Here we are on Audiokarma the home of all audio no attitude talking about
hating a brand of audio gear . I have no gear made by that company . I pick my components on there merits as they fit my needs
This forum is for bringing people together with the same passion Great Sound . Hate divides us
 
'Hate? How does somebody actually hate an inanimate object?''

I take it that you have never owned a Chrysler product!:rflmao:
Oh heck yeah, I've owned many from all the big 3. My first car was a 64 Plymouth with no engine at 16 years old which I found a 383 and installed it myself. Our 2013 jeep Patriot coughed up a transmission at 20k miles this summer and was in the shop for 6 weeks. Still I don't hate the car, maybe the dealer who sat on it and lied to us every week when we called, in fact not doing anything to it until we called Chrysler. The fact is the only emotional response I would possibly have towards McIntosh or any other high end product is envy. Maybe others actually experience the hate emotion towards them however but that is just weird to me.
 
... Still I don't hate the car, maybe the dealer who sat on it and lied to us every week when we called, in fact not doing anything to it until we called Chrysler.

It wouldn't surprise me at all if the dealer was being held up by Chrysler. Your call, direct from the customer, was what it took to cut the bureaucracy the dealer was trying to wade through.
 
It wouldn't surprise me at all if the dealer was being held up by Chrysler. Your call, direct from the customer, was what it took to cut the bureaucracy the dealer was trying to wade through.
That is possible. The Jeep dealership was newly handed to them and they claimed they only had one mechanic thus far certified to work on them, this in an area of probably a 600 mile radius. Once we got in touch with Chrysler things moved fast. They actually had a new transmission flown to Juneau! That must have cost them... In hindsight they probably did their best but didn't like being lied to just the same..
 
Lets see my Dodge Ram 2500 Diesel is 15 years old and has had two repair issues, the clock spring in the steering assembly which was replaced under warranty and a leaky fill valve on the Air-conditioning system, Compared to my Ford F350 that cost me over a $1000 dollars a year for glow plugs, plug controllers, front end parts , injection pumps, Alternators, clutches and bad paint the Dodge has been a dream.even if it was built in Mexico. The Ford was built in Canada. When the Dodge reaches 20 years old I'll make my final judgement. Right now I would buy another one, same model, same accessories. I guess I would update from a cassette player, and would want a GPS>
 
Lets see my Dodge Ram 2500 Diesel is 15 years old and has had two repair issues, the clock spring in the steering assembly which was replaced under warranty and a leaky fill valve on the Air-conditioning system, Compared to my Ford F350 that cost me over a $1000 dollars a year for glow plugs, plug controllers, front end parts , injection pumps, Alternators, clutches and bad paint the Dodge has been a dream.even if it was built in Mexico. The Ford was built in Canada. When the Dodge reaches 20 years old I'll make my final judgement. Right now I would buy another one, same model, same accessories. I guess I would update from a cassette player, and would want a GPS>

I own a 1996 Cummins 2500 also... had it since new, 200k. The engine is untouched, everything else has been replaced. I still don't hate Dodge... and I LOVE my cassette player! :)
 
Well this thread had to eventually go to automobiles I guess. Back to McIntosh , I can't for the life of me find anything to hate about them. They represent about everything I like actually. Great old American company, some of the highest quality available, still surviving 67 years later. These things I find endearing and even if one will never grace my living room, I am glad they are out there..
 
I can't see anyone hating a Mac. They certainly could find a lot of "better bang for the buck" gear.
I like the classic big blue glass and big watt amps just fine. But the mc275 is THE Mac amp.
Mac preamps, not so much love. I've owned vintage and modern (used) high end stuff.
I tend to enjoy it all. I just have never run into that good deal on a Mac, so I've never owned one.
Ever the dumbest CL user knows Mac stuff should cost $$$.
 
Back
Top Bottom