• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

McIntosh Haters

For what it's worth, I think McIntosh is more Disney than they are Bose. Bear with me here, I'm making a specific analogy.

Disney charges a very high amount for admission to their parks, but they have to; they run close to the physical limit of how many people they can serve comfortably. Similarly, I would argue that McIntosh has a certain production capacity they can meet and they price accordingly. It might be possible to sell their products for less, but you'd have a years-long waiting list. Simple supply/demand capitalism at work. One assumes if this wasn't so, they wouldn't stay in business at current pricing.

On the other hand you have Bose, who mass produces incredibly cheap and poorly made components. They also charge high prices, through the power of intense marketing and requiring independent floor space so true A/B comparisons are impossible. They are truly striking at the status symbol folks, and those who believe a higher sticker price must mean it's a better product. See also: Beats headphones. Bose is deception, at best the dark side of advertising and capitalism with the goal of fleecing an uninformed buyer.

I'm entirely fine with the way McIntosh does business. I don't think they want to grow into a multinational mass producer, and they've deliberately structured their product lines and pricing accordingly. This has a side effect of making them status symbols for some, but I do not believe this is the intent. Not at all.
When Ferrari went public they were making about 8000 cars a year. To satisfy investors they stated they were going increase production to somewhere over 9000 cars. They didn't want to cheapen the brand by increasing availability. This is probably why the used/vintage market for Mac equipment is so strong and pieces are somewhat hard to come by (with prices to match). Growth is forced to increase slowly.
 
One nut (among many) made one comment that bothered a member. We've all been peeved about something someone said sometime about something. I'm somewhat surprised what kind of legs this thing grew (i probably shouldn't be). I went for the ride. I'm out.:crazy::bye::hug:
 
Oh, I don't know. Lots of folks are quick to dismiss McIntosh as overpriced, designed for lawyers and doctors, marketed as status versus sound, etc. I've always approached audio from a value perspective - and value has absolutely nothing to do with price. As Tom Bodett of Motel 6 once said, "Value is achieved when service exceeds expectation." That's where McIntosh has always shined for me. But, you'd never know it from sitting on the sidelines and dismissing it for all the things one thinks it isn't.

One of the best metrics of value is the resale price versus the new price - considering that as a percentage of course. McIntosh has been tops in this metric for as long as I can remember. And, when the company makes a point in their advertising that many would choose to own a used McIntosh versus anything else, they're absolutely correct. I mean, look at most of us here at AK.

At the end of the day, audio is a fun hobby. I can't recall disparaging any brand or product . . . other than Gibson's Yorx All-In-Wonder maybe - and even then, not seriously. Hell, given the right software, even it could make beautiful music!
 
Oh, I don't know. Lots of folks are quick to dismiss McIntosh as overpriced, designed for lawyers and doctors, marketed as status versus sound, etc. I've always approached audio from a value perspective - and value has absolutely nothing to do with price. As Tom Bodett of Motel 6 once said, "Value is achieved when service exceeds expectation." That's where McIntosh has always shined for me. But, you'd never know it from sitting on the sidelines and dismissing it for all the things one thinks it isn't.

One of the best metrics of value is the resale price versus the new price - considering that as a percentage of course. McIntosh has been tops in this metric for as long as I can remember. And, when the company makes a point in their advertising that many would choose to own a used McIntosh versus anything else, they're absolutely correct. I mean, look at most of us here at AK.

At the end of the day, audio is a fun hobby. I can't recall disparaging any brand or product . . . other than Gibson's Yorx All-In-Wonder maybe - and even then, not seriously. Hell, given the right software, even it could make beautiful music!

Agreed, and this coming from someone that doesn't own any Mac gear whatsoever.

What do I have that compares to Mac? Well, Luxman... yeah. Good luck trying to get support for that without firing up the soldering iron yourself. You pays your money and makes your choice.

Price of admission *is* steep for the average guy. But Mac has always been on my radar. Someday... (unless I find some nice Accuphase stuff... but same comment applies)
 
Mcintosh ran "clinics" around the country to test gear for all comers, primarily to assure Mac owners their amps and other components met specs, serviced them when possible when needed, and noted which other lines met specs and which did not. IIRC, Marantz tube amps stood out with Mac's own, routinely meeting and exceeding specs. Good silicon solid state amps eventually leveled the playing field re meeting specs, Mac amps typically exceed rated specs by a substantial margin.
Someone please link more info on Dave O'Brian's road show clinics.

They Dynaco ST70 was rated at less than 1% at 35W (normally about 0.5%) and less than 0.05% at 1W.

Here's some other specifications of some other tube amps, I'll leave you to decide if any may sound "better"
Amp 1:
Power output: 30W into 8Ω (mono) Frequency response: 20Hz to 30kHz Total harmonic distortion: 0.3% Damping factor: 12
Amp 2
Power output: 40W into 8Ω (mono) Frequency response: 20Hz to 20kHz Total harmonic distortion: 0.5%
Amp 3
Power output: 60W into 8Ω (mono) Frequency response: 20Hz to 30kHz Total harmonic distortion: 0.5% Damping factor: 12
Amp 4
Power output: 75W into 8Ω (mono) Frequency response: 20Hz to 20kHz Total harmonic distortion: 0.5% Damping factor: 18
Amp 5
Power output: 75W per channel into 8Ω (stereo), 150W into 8Ω (mono) Frequency response: 16Hz to 40kHz Total harmonic distortion: 0.5% Damping factor: greater than 10.
Amp 6 (perhaps this is the closest to your comparison):
Power output: 130 watts per channel into 8Ω (stereo) Frequency response: 10Hz to 100kHz Total harmonic distortion: 0.5% Damping factor: 18

Specifications for many do not tell the whole story, even with McIntosh gear.
 
At the end of the day, audio is a fun hobby. I can't recall disparaging any brand or product . . . other than Gibson's Yorx All-In-Wonder maybe - and even then, not seriously. Hell, given the right software, even it could make beautiful music!

I think Tony has the right idea. It's also a shame he hasn't heard the heavenly sound from the Yorx system. :)
 
Bob Carver was famously turtored by Stewart Hegeman, iirc. Stu was responsible for the Ultralinear Citation II and straight pentode Citation V amps, amongst other varied accomplishments.
 
Be rock steady & steadfast in your choices. Don't be swayed or influenced by others opinions. Until that guy starts paying the bills.... he can roll under that rock and stay there. Until then, keep on enjoying your gear.
(Besides me thinks it's also a wee bit of a socio/economic thing too.)
 
I get it... you're drawing the parallel between *some* McIntosh owners and e.g. the portion of the BMW, Porsche, or Corvette clubs that I don't really identify with that much. (I do drive a BMW, but I'm not that guy that has all the logo apparel nor do I look down my nose at "lesser" vehicles. I am also right there with you on your other point, I'd much rather have my old '55 Studebaker - which was far from stock, although was built using 99% stuff from the Studebaker parts bin - back, even though the Bimmer is way faster and better handling, but I have to make some concessions to practicality.)

Thing is, I don't really run into that attitude that much. It may be, however, that pretty much the only people I know who own McIntosh gear are also here on AK.

In 1998-99 I worked for a company that integrated Smart-home technology with Audio/Video installations. If you wanted to walk in the door and turn some music on in the west-wing bathroom, open the blinds, and make sure the bathroom was at 80 degrees, you could do that by one of the 50+ touch-screens that were installed anywhere in the house. We peddled brands like McIntosh, B&K, AMX, Lutron, Crestron, Paradigm, Integra and Focal. We had contracts in Aspen, Boulder, Breckenridge and Jackson Hole WY. These were all new homes in the 10-15 mil range. We would wire during rough and finish during trim. Not one of these clients had an audio equipment package under 50k, and most approached 100k. All of those clients could be considered "elite". So my exposure to Mac owners has been limited/focused on a different demographic until I found AK.

My opinion has come a long way from just 18 years ago. 18 years ago, I would never had owned Mac, not because of their product, but because I thought it was another unattainable extravagance only for the upper echelon of capitalism. Thanks to AK, my world has expanded.
 
It was discussed in the McIntosh book that the Company had never undertook a formal study of what its own customer demographic was and when they finally got around to it (around 1993 or so) the results stunned management: Something like 40% were under the age of 40 and most of those were regular working class people. Then president Ron Fone even received a letter from an customer who was a truck driver who was extremely upset that his occupation had not been included in the survey. Said Ron Fone: Everything we had assumed about our customer was wrong. (Paraphrased).

That said, the suggestion that McIntosh ownership is the sole province of the top 1% (or something similar) is just plain wrong.
 
It was discussed in the McIntosh book that the Company had never undertook a formal study of what its own customer demographic was and when they finally got around to it (around 1993 or so) the results stunned management: Something like 40% were under the age of 40 and most of those were regular working class people. Then president Ron Fone even received a letter from an customer who was a truck driver who was extremely upset that his occupation had not been included in the survey. Said Ron Fone: Everything we had assumed about our customer was wrong. (Paraphrased).

That said, the suggestion that McIntosh ownership is the sole province of the top 1% (or something similar) is just plain wrong.
I do work in multi million dollar homes, some of the most affluent on the San Francisco Peninsula, and have never seen Mac in any of them. They, when building or remoding a home have everything built in to the walls with big rack systems that handle everything. It's a lot more like pro gear you would see in a business.

In the hobby I do know affluent people but they are buying mac gear because they are into audio and the hobby. So yes the vast majority are just audiophiles of mostly working class that like the equipment, saving their pennies to get what they want. .
 
[QUOTE="biscuithead, post: 10071176, member: 175617"

My opinion has come a long way from just 18 years ago. 18 years ago, I would never had owned Mac, not because of their product, but because I thought it was another unattainable extravagance only for the upper echelon of capitalism. Thanks to AK, my world has expanded.[/QUOTE]

I was immeasurably impressed by Mcintosh at a very young age. I was so impressed, that I held the belief that I 'could never afford it' for many, many years.
That has been the only down side of Mcintosh equipment for me. :-)
 
I'm afraid I'm missing your point. Is it that specs won't tell me which amp sounds better? If so, perhaps you don't understand my point, which is, based on the specs, the Dynaco has very little chance of "blowing away" an MC 6500. They may both sound very good.

My apologies, I misinterpreted your initial comment if you are suggesting they could both sound very good.

For anyone who was wondering, here's the identities of the amps I spec'ed:
Amp 1 - MC30
Amp 2 - MC40
Amp 3 - MC60
Amp 4 - MC75
Amp 5 - MC275, circa early 2000's
Amp 6 - MC2000

Would it ignite a friendly discussion or firestorm to wonder which of the above amps could or would sound as good as or better than the OP's amp given the same system, although being the OP's is an integrated unit, preamp choice could sizably influence the outcome? And its not for just the sake of tube vs solid state.

I've always wondered among Mc owners whether they feel there are (fairly recognizable) differences in Mc amps or preamps? And whether there have been some poor or relatively "not good" sounding McIntosh products even if they were operating at spec and correctly? Another thread topic?
 
Hate? How does somebody actually hate an inanimate object? I can see hating the neighbor who leaves junk in the yard or the one who leaves his dog to bark half the night, but how does one go about hating an amplifier? It can't think, have an opposing viewpoint, or any of the other things that we hate one another for. If someone appears to hate a brand of anything I strongly suspect it is directed at the owner, either out of envy for the haves, or guilt for the have nots.
 
Hate? How does somebody actually hate an inanimate object? I can see hating the neighbor who leaves junk in the yard or the one who leaves his dog to bark half the night, but how does one go about hating an amplifier? It can't think, have an opposing viewpoint, or any of the other things that we hate one another for. If someone appears to hate a brand of anything I strongly suspect it is directed at the owner, either out of envy for the haves, or guilt for the have nots.

I couldn't think of the right words to post when I first read this thread.
You nailed it. Thank you.
 
My Dad was an audio nut back in the sixties. When he took me along to an audio store and I saw the McIntosh blue, I was hooked. I was maybe ten at the time and it took me another forty years but I have had numerous pieces Mac equipment in my system.
 
Back
Top Bottom