• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Moving up the stream

Try a pair of wire coat hangers, that might be good. Come to think of it, somebody has already done that and gave a brief review of it somewhere, cannot recall where though.

Isn't this a great hobby?
 
Try a pair of wire coat hangers, that might be good. Come to think of it, somebody has already done that and gave a brief review of it somewhere, cannot recall where though.

Isn't this a great hobby?

That is hardcore...
 
Cool, that will work! Sorry about the coat hanger bit, just trying to add a bit of fun into it....or maybe not. I'll get my hat and coat now.
 
Cables are somewhat annoying because all it is is finding a series of matches. So evaluating them as a "sound" is largely worthless because they will sound different in different systems - or make no impact likely due to the weakest link.

In a complete mix and match system of say two sources you could have something like this

Speakers from company A
Preamplifier from company B
Power amplifier from company C
CD player from company D (H if you separate these into transport/DAC)
Turntable/arm/cart from company E/F/G

You could in theory have 8 components from 8 manufacturers all using 8 different internal wires with 8 different connectors

Your system is as good as the worst wire. If it is giving you 60% then sticking on a cable that is giving you 100% is only giving you 100% of 60%.

Or to use this thread's vocab if cable the cable in the speaker from company A is using a big ole "smearing cable" then using some expensive speaker cable outside the speaker box can't fix the speaker's internal cable.

Very few companies have control of the entire chain where they make all the parts from cartridge to speaker voice coil and even fewer of the ones who do ensure the same cable or cable material is used throughout the chain.
 
I think sadly, this is basically true of the entire setup, not just cables when we try to describe or understand the sound of any one component. Sometimes I would almost go as far as saying that reviews and opinions of anyone's are about as valid as nothing at all except for their own. Which kind of makes all of these forums and magazine reviews etc. really rather pointless to some degree. Especially when you look at how most people do not keep a "reference" point long enough to really know how a different component(s), cable, etc. does indeed effect the sonics of said system-if at all. Kind of like mixing some sort of exotic drink, add a bit of this and that, flavor to taste and let it rip. There are certainly no absolutes-except maybe the vodka...

I say the above in general terms, I realize a lot of us here do indeed have some sort of idea of the sound we like and know-our reference so to speak, so not discounting that at all really. But it really does point to how important it is for anything to be listened to in ones own listening space, with said gear.

Not sure exactly where I was going with this thought as it really can create more issues than it probably is worth. After all, this is an audio forum and here I am too....More times than not, I just enjoy reading about each persons journey and what their systems are doing for them.

Carry on.
 
I understand, completely. It's impossible to replace someone else's with your own. I started these threads in the hopes of helping people who have similar taste in music. As I get close to completing my system, I realize that nothing can be left to speculation and, to some extent, experience. Like you said, there are just too many variables to have identical conclusions. Everything is relative...
 
I have a pair of Proac Response 1.5 (and two pair of Harbeth's as well) and I was about to recommend a used Jadis Orchestra Reference tube amp, the music is super detailed but never sharp, it sounds very "live", the bass is very good too. But since you listen to classical music it's probably better with more power after all and then I was thinking of Musical Fidelity. I heard the bigger M6i some weeks ago and loved it, everything about it! The smaller M3i should be good as well. But maybe a used M6i would be the best choice if you can find one? I think you can be pretty sure of that it isn't less good than it's smaller brother.

Cables, I know nothing about cables.

wba_177896.JPG


1_m6i-front.png
 
I have a pair of Proac Response 1.5 (and two pair of Harbeth's as well) and I was about to recommend a used Jadis Orchestra Reference tube amp, the music is super detailed but never sharp, it sounds very "live", the bass is very good too. But since you listen to classical music it's probably better with more power after all and then I was thinking of Musical Fidelity. I heard the bigger M6i some weeks ago and loved it, everything about it! The smaller M3i should be good as well. But maybe a used M6i would be the best choice if you can find one? I think you can be pretty sure of that it isn't less good than it's smaller brother.

Funny you mention Musical Fidelity...M3i is on its way!
 
Back to the drawing board

Musical Fidelity M3i - I was impressed enough to purchase it, but first impression was not everything. Initial impression of warm and punchy soon turned weary. The longer I listened, I couldn't understand why my jaw was clenching and constantly having a headache. I think this amplifier pushes out the mid, giving a nice impression of presence. It works a treat with jazz vocals, but I couldn't stand listening to orchestral music. I still wouldn't call the treble bright, but it's THIN. Combined with pungent bass, it caused fatigue in a way I didn't think was possible. I started to think that this amplifier sounds very much tweaked to cover up shortcomings. Pleasing and ear-catching at first, but it barely scratched the surface of my speakers.

Special note about the build quality. Perhaps it's not fair to expect everything at this price level, but there was a tremendous amount of crosstalk between inputs. Also, one channel in one of the inputs emitted a sustained, high pitched noise at high volume. The other channel was much less affected. I think it was being affected by its proximity to the transformer. The replacement unit did the same. All of the problems are virtually inaudible at low volume.

Ultimately, I was sad to return an amplifier that cost very little for the things it does very well. It would've been fantastic for a second system, but I must move on. I'm now a firm believer in home demo.
 
That stinks. Sounds like the amp has a design flaw or perhaps there is a manufacturing defect. Hopefully you can find a suitable amp without to much hassle.
 
That stinks. Sounds like the amp has a design flaw or perhaps there is a manufacturing defect. Hopefully you can find a suitable amp without to much hassle.

Yeah, it's likely a design flaw...or one of those things that drives owners crazy but measures out fine. :no:
 
Perhaps it's time to revisit a couple of the amps you didn't like as much for a home demo. Never know.
 
Yeah, it's likely a design flaw...or one of those things that drives owners crazy but measures out fine. :no:

You know an amp you might like is the Sugden A48B which can be had for around $350 on the second hand market. It is a class A/B amplifier of about 65-70 watts. It doesn't do flash and pyrotechnics but it has very good pitch and sounds valve like in a good way. It's a bit of an old fashioned sound but has no frequency limiters and was built well - the problems in terms of repair was the power on light which would fail (mine never worked) but I chose the Sugden A48B over the Musical Fidelity A300 in direct comparison. So for $350 it was a bargoon.

475544-sugden_a48b_intergrated_amp_in_super_condition_2_x_66_watts.jpg
 
Musical Fidelity M3i - I was impressed enough to purchase it, but first impression was not everything. Initial impression of warm and punchy soon turned weary. The longer I listened, I couldn't understand why my jaw was clenching and constantly having a headache. I think this amplifier pushes out the mid, giving a nice impression of presence. It works a treat with jazz vocals, but I couldn't stand listening to orchestral music. I still wouldn't call the treble bright, but it's THIN. Combined with pungent bass, it caused fatigue in a way I didn't think was possible. I started to think that this amplifier sounds very much tweaked to cover up shortcomings. Pleasing and ear-catching at first, but it barely scratched the surface of my speakers.

Special note about the build quality. Perhaps it's not fair to expect everything at this price level, but there was a tremendous amount of crosstalk between inputs. Also, one channel in one of the inputs emitted a sustained, high pitched noise at high volume. The other channel was much less affected. I think it was being affected by its proximity to the transformer. The replacement unit did the same. All of the problems are virtually inaudible at low volume.

Ultimately, I was sad to return an amplifier that cost very little for the things it does very well. It would've been fantastic for a second system, but I must move on. I'm now a firm believer in home demo.

Home demo is always a good thing. From what you discribed....sounds like a very serious case of missing synergy from the amp speakers and interconnects.
What cabling and speakers are you using?
 
Back
Top Bottom