• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

I'm sitting opposite these 15A/Betsy OBs tonight, listening to Supertramp. It's wall of sound down here. I don't understand how others have found the 15As to be light in deep bass. I've actually had to tweak the lower registers down because they dominate otherwise. Crossed at 120 hz, the bass is tight, just the sound of that massive diaphragm doing its thing in free air, no port noise, no excessive boom. A couple of hours in, I think I genuinely like the sound better than my Focal floorstanders upstairs. Again, the wall of sound. I enjoyed the Betsys on their own, but they absolutely required sub support for me to enjoy them alone. Not so with the 15As on board. I am deeply impressed. Pictures of these OBs will not impress, but goddamn they sound good to me.

I also can highly recommend the use of an AVR to defray the crossover issues and signal management when bi-amping, at least for beginners like me. I know they aren't audiophile approved, but the LFE signal on my AVR is easily configurable from 40 hz to 200 hz. Furthermore, the room correction algorithm did a great job of blending gain levels between the 15As and Betsys so that the drivers work together really well.

Wall of sound!

If they sound good to you, super... go with 'em.

And to say the Alpha 15s are not musical... right after this guy is enthralled with them... come on. Please don't crap on someone. It's just not good form.
 
I've finally finished my open baffles with the Zenith 49CZ802 drivers. Everything was done in the living room of my small apartment with a plunge router, a cordless drill and some hand tools.
I asked about bass augmentation on these forums a few weeks ago. When I realized that adding bass augmentation would require buying a plate amp in addition to the Alpha 15As, I decided to hold off on the purchases and to augment the bass a little with folding wings.

Well the speakers sound just phenomenal. I'm sure more bass would be great, but they really sound very good now with the wings open. I have to say that the combination of the Musical Paradise 301-MKIII, homemade Duelund Coherent Audio DCA16GA tinned-copper wire interconnects and speaker cables and the Zeniths are really wonderful.

Here are some pics ...



View attachment 1173484

View attachment 1173485

View attachment 1173487

Excellent! The 802's are a gift from heaven. The most complete full range driver I've experience. Turn them upside down and see if you hear a bit more bass.
 
Last edited:
The Alpha 15A is far and away the most popular OB woofer. Commercial OB designs from Hawthorne, Emerald Physics, Spacial and True Audio have used them. There are better woofers but you'll pay a lot more and then have to come up with a way to EQ them. I think they're musical and it's not uncommon to see them used as full range drivers. With the Alphas I get good articulated bass from good recordings. I have an SACD of "Griot Liberte" and Buster William's double bass is in my room. Incredibly accurate and detailed even in the lowest registers. If you listen to poorly recorded bass tracks you'll get a lot of the thump thump.
 
It's funny that you mentioned their sometimes-use as FR drivers, because as I was working to wrangle wires last night, at one point I had connected speakers such that one of the 15As was getting the 120 hz-and-up signal by mistake and I was surprised by how good they sounded before switching them to correct wiring. I don't fret mkane's comments about the 15As, since he's much further down the OB road than me. At least for now though, I'm really pleased with how these bad boys sound.

For those who have used 15As with Betsys, where have you found most pleasing crossover point? I can cross between 40 hz and 200 hz. The YPAO room correction has decided to set it at 120 hz but I'm interested in opinions on better settings.

Thanks all!

The Alpha 15A is far and away the most popular OB woofer. Commercial OB designs from Hawthorne, Emerald Physics, Spacial and True Audio have used them. There are better woofers but you'll pay a lot more and then have to come up with a way to EQ them. I think they're musical and it's not uncommon to see them used as full range drivers. With the Alphas I get good articulated bass from good recordings. I have an SACD of "Griot Liberte" and Buster William's double bass is in my room. Incredibly accurate and detailed even in the lowest registers. If you listen to poorly recorded bass tracks you'll get a lot of the thump thump.
 
I've been away from this forum for a long time. Having a son will derail any projects for several years! But thanks to Poultrygeist, I had evolved from having the Betsys and Alphas running in parallel to having the Betsys in their own baffles and one Alpha 15a as a subwoofer, connected to a Dayton Audio SA100 plate amp. Yeah, this makes all the difference in the world. I have to find the right crossover setting, but this is amazingly good.
 

Attachments

  • Unknown.jpeg
    Unknown.jpeg
    76.7 KB · Views: 69
I've been away from this forum for a long time. Having a son will derail any projects for several years! But thanks to Poultrygeist, I had evolved from having the Betsys and Alphas running in parallel to having the Betsys in their own baffles and one Alpha 15a as a subwoofer, connected to a Dayton Audio SA100 plate amp. Yeah, this makes all the difference in the world. I have to find the right crossover setting, but this is amazingly good.

Great job!
 
Has anyone here tried the Tang Band W4-1879 4" full ranger in a woofer assisted full range OB set up? If so, how did you like it? Any glaring weaknesses?
 
Beautiful work!

I've been away from this forum for a long time. Having a son will derail any projects for several years! But thanks to Poultrygeist, I had evolved from having the Betsys and Alphas running in parallel to having the Betsys in their own baffles and one Alpha 15a as a subwoofer, connected to a Dayton Audio SA100 plate amp. Yeah, this makes all the difference in the world. I have to find the right crossover setting, but this is amazingly good.
 
I'm not a fan of the music but there's a lot of sound coming from this guy's OB single driver speakers. I've met him and he builds some incredible gear.

 
Hey Poultry. What speakers is that guy using in post #2550? They sound PDG. And I believe I have the skill set to build something similar.
 
Hey Poultry. What speakers is that guy using in post #2550? They sound PDG. And I believe I have the skill set to build something similar.

Vintage Grundigs with alnico magnets. They have leather surrounds which you don't see every day. You certainly do have the skills so it's just a matter of deciding on what you want to build.
 
Last edited:
I have been enjoying my OB's based on the Eminence 12 LTA, 15 Alpha & ASD 1001 in an unfinished state all winter. Once the weather got nice, I started working on improving their looks. I am now declaring them finished. I glued pieces of wood to the MDF skeleton that a local cabinet shop puts in bins outside for people to burn in their fireplace. Thus, though I made many trips to get the pieces, the wood was free. It is actually 1\4" MDF with a decorative face.IMG_20180531_185558.jpg
 
I love the look of those and I would guess they sound fantastic as well. Can you describe the sound you are getting from them and how they are set up to be amplified? I built a pair of Alpha15/Betsy pseudo-Caintucks over the winter, and they too are still being used unfinished. They are much more basic than your setup but will still benefit from sanding of edges and clean up before calling them finished. I have marveled at the sound they produce, which is big, open and unlike any other speakers I've ever had. I also love the look of those gigantic woofers!



I have been enjoying my OB's based on the Eminence 12 LTA, 15 Alpha & ASD 1001 in an unfinished state all winter. Once the weather got nice, I started working on improving their looks. I am now declaring them finished. I glued pieces of wood to the MDF skeleton that a local cabinet shop puts in bins outside for people to burn in their fireplace. Thus, though I made many trips to get the pieces, the wood was free. It is actually 1\4" MDF with a decorative face.View attachment 1202251
 
I have been enjoying my OB's based on the Eminence 12 LTA, 15 Alpha & ASD 1001 in an unfinished state all winter. Once the weather got nice, I started working on improving their looks. I am now declaring them finished. I glued pieces of wood to the MDF skeleton that a local cabinet shop puts in bins outside for people to burn in their fireplace. Thus, though I made many trips to get the pieces, the wood was free. It is actually 1\4" MDF with a decorative face.View attachment 1202251

Those look great and I know from experience how good they sound. :thumbsup:
 
I like the sound overall better than anything I have ever had before. I would describe the sound as having depth and sounding quite real. David, I will try to lay out my current hook up. All sources are connected to my Bottlehead Foreplay II pre-amp. For my Turntable, I go to a Sansui receiver and pre-out of that to the Bottlehead pre. I have y-connectors on the output of the Bottlehead. From there, one lead goes to my SET tube monoblocks that power the Eminence Beta 12 LTA. One per side, of course. The other lead (on each side) go to a Behringer CX2310. From the Behringer to a slightly modified old Sonic Impact amp that powers the Eminence 15 Alphas. FWIW I will mention a few observations. Feel free (anyone to comment).

I listened to some Voigt Pipes based on the Fostex 166 for a few years. I used the $28 Sonic Impact for awhile after my kid destroyed my H.H. Scott. The Sonic Impact was very dynamic and clean, but had too much upper mid-range for my tastes. I did the most basic mod, which was to replace the caps that the geeks on the forums had determined were limiting the bass in the original design. That turned out to be very worthwhile, and I did get a lot more (deeper) bass than before. Next, I built some Folded Horns (the Bigger Is Better BIB) based on the Fostex 208 sigma. I got a Cary Audio Rocket 88 and listened to the Fostex 208/Cary combination for many years. The bass on the $2500 Cary was not as tight and tuneful as the modded Sonic Impact, but the midrange was way more to my liking.

I was lucky enough to make friends with the late Paul Weitzel. He designed and produced high end amplifiers for a living, but had never done a flea powered SET amp before. Over a period of 4 years, I would travel the one and a half hours to his shop. He would do a little bit of work on one of the monoblocks from what he thought would work in his head. He would send me home with some parts, and I would copy his work into the other monoblock. Shortly before he died of undiagnosed pancreatic cancer he sent me home to power them up. I was supposed to bring them back after a few weeks and then let him know how I would like to change the sound. As it turned out, I would never go back before attending his funeral.

The amps are based on the 45 tube, so I probably have two watts at most. It is enough (barely) in my room. The interesting point that I wanted to make with all this is the following. Now that I have the SET amps, I would say that I almost consider them to be mandatory to really make the 166 pipes or the 208 BIB's sing. I have not done much A/B testing, but the one time I did with these OB's, it seemed the OB's liked both amps. In other words more of a which flavor do you prefer question. One the other hand, as good as the Cary was, I thought the SET amps blew it away with the other two speakers. The SET amps solved the shoutiness problem better than anything else I had done.

Here comes the next thing I discovered that came as a big surprise. I started out powering the Alpha's with the Cary. I attenuated them as much as I could with the Berhinger. One day I decided to try having the Sonic Impact doing bass duties. And, I liked it better! No offense to the Cary, and I would much prefer the Cary on the LTA's vs the Sonic Impact on the LTA's. But I found that I actually preferred the $28 SI playing the Alpha's to the $2500 Cary doing bass duties on the Alpha's.

The ASD 1001 tweeters are also connected in parallel with the 12" LTA's, powered by the flea watt SET's. The + leg of the 1001 has a 1 uF and a 0.33 uF. The caps are in parallel and in series with the tweeter. Thus, a capacitance of 1.33 uF for each side. Someone on some forum had raved about this dirt cheap caps made by Vishay, so I ordered enough to try .47 though 1.5 uF. My only complaint is that the leads are just tiny stubs. I almost forgot, that between the SET amps and the speakers, I have a pair of autoformers. The autoformers allow me to double, triple or quadruple the impedance that the amps see. I think my SET's like a little higher impedance. It makes everything tighten up. However, it can get a little "mean" to the ears of you go up too much.

The other day I turned the Berhinger on while having the Sonic Impact (bass amp) off. I noticed a change in the sound. Like a small dB reduction. I also discovered that I could hear an element of the upper bass when I had the alpha's off, that I was missing when I had them on. The bass I have with just the LTA's is a little cleaner sounding than with the whole thing. This does not mean that I don't want the Alpha's playing! Just an observation that verifies what some have said, that there is something special about connecting an amp directly to one single full range driver. It is also true, that everything is a trade off. For now, I am very pleased to have the Alpha's in the H-Frames. Although at this moment, I am running them set to 60 to 80 Htz, and have both the input and output volume controls as far counter clockwise as they will go. That does not shut them off. I think I want to try adding those 5 gallon bucket subs to the system someday and see where that leads me. It is not that I think I need more bass, but the hope that I can get better bass. And, I am not saying that I am unhappy with the bass that I have. I guess it is just that audiophilia thing.

I do like the speakers positioned out from the back wall. But, I don't like people tripping over the chords.

I want to that PG and all again for inspiring me to build these things!
 
I'm impressed with this new class D powering the Lowthers in flat baffles. The Volt+D ( TPA3118 ) comes from India and includes all film caps in the signal path. It's the best sounding of all my TPA amps. I'm using a TPA3116/Astron to power the Alpha woofers.

P1010028.jpg
 
I like the sound overall better than anything I have ever had before. I would describe the sound as having depth and sounding quite real. David, I will try to lay out my current hook up. All sources are connected to my Bottlehead Foreplay II pre-amp. For my Turntable, I go to a Sansui receiver and pre-out of that to the Bottlehead pre. I have y-connectors on the output of the Bottlehead. From there, one lead goes to my SET tube monoblocks that power the Eminence Beta 12 LTA. One per side, of course. The other lead (on each side) go to a Behringer CX2310. From the Behringer to a slightly modified old Sonic Impact amp that powers the Eminence 15 Alphas. FWIW I will mention a few observations. Feel free (anyone to comment).

I listened to some Voigt Pipes based on the Fostex 166 for a few years. I used the $28 Sonic Impact for awhile after my kid destroyed my H.H. Scott. The Sonic Impact was very dynamic and clean, but had too much upper mid-range for my tastes. I did the most basic mod, which was to replace the caps that the geeks on the forums had determined were limiting the bass in the original design. That turned out to be very worthwhile, and I did get a lot more (deeper) bass than before. Next, I built some Folded Horns (the Bigger Is Better BIB) based on the Fostex 208 sigma. I got a Cary Audio Rocket 88 and listened to the Fostex 208/Cary combination for many years. The bass on the $2500 Cary was not as tight and tuneful as the modded Sonic Impact, but the midrange was way more to my liking.

I was lucky enough to make friends with the late Paul Weitzel. He designed and produced high end amplifiers for a living, but had never done a flea powered SET amp before. Over a period of 4 years, I would travel the one and a half hours to his shop. He would do a little bit of work on one of the monoblocks from what he thought would work in his head. He would send me home with some parts, and I would copy his work into the other monoblock. Shortly before he died of undiagnosed pancreatic cancer he sent me home to power them up. I was supposed to bring them back after a few weeks and then let him know how I would like to change the sound. As it turned out, I would never go back before attending his funeral.

The amps are based on the 45 tube, so I probably have two watts at most. It is enough (barely) in my room. The interesting point that I wanted to make with all this is the following. Now that I have the SET amps, I would say that I almost consider them to be mandatory to really make the 166 pipes or the 208 BIB's sing. I have not done much A/B testing, but the one time I did with these OB's, it seemed the OB's liked both amps. In other words more of a which flavor do you prefer question. One the other hand, as good as the Cary was, I thought the SET amps blew it away with the other two speakers. The SET amps solved the shoutiness problem better than anything else I had done.

Here comes the next thing I discovered that came as a big surprise. I started out powering the Alpha's with the Cary. I attenuated them as much as I could with the Berhinger. One day I decided to try having the Sonic Impact doing bass duties. And, I liked it better! No offense to the Cary, and I would much prefer the Cary on the LTA's vs the Sonic Impact on the LTA's. But I found that I actually preferred the $28 SI playing the Alpha's to the $2500 Cary doing bass duties on the Alpha's.

The ASD 1001 tweeters are also connected in parallel with the 12" LTA's, powered by the flea watt SET's. The + leg of the 1001 has a 1 uF and a 0.33 uF. The caps are in parallel and in series with the tweeter. Thus, a capacitance of 1.33 uF for each side. Someone on some forum had raved about this dirt cheap caps made by Vishay, so I ordered enough to try .47 though 1.5 uF. My only complaint is that the leads are just tiny stubs. I almost forgot, that between the SET amps and the speakers, I have a pair of autoformers. The autoformers allow me to double, triple or quadruple the impedance that the amps see. I think my SET's like a little higher impedance. It makes everything tighten up. However, it can get a little "mean" to the ears of you go up too much.

The other day I turned the Berhinger on while having the Sonic Impact (bass amp) off. I noticed a change in the sound. Like a small dB reduction. I also discovered that I could hear an element of the upper bass when I had the alpha's off, that I was missing when I had them on. The bass I have with just the LTA's is a little cleaner sounding than with the whole thing. This does not mean that I don't want the Alpha's playing! Just an observation that verifies what some have said, that there is something special about connecting an amp directly to one single full range driver. It is also true, that everything is a trade off. For now, I am very pleased to have the Alpha's in the H-Frames. Although at this moment, I am running them set to 60 to 80 Htz, and have both the input and output volume controls as far counter clockwise as they will go. That does not shut them off. I think I want to try adding those 5 gallon bucket subs to the system someday and see where that leads me. It is not that I think I need more bass, but the hope that I can get better bass. And, I am not saying that I am unhappy with the bass that I have. I guess it is just that audiophilia thing.

I do like the speakers positioned out from the back wall. But, I don't like people tripping over the chords.

I want to that PG and all again for inspiring me to build these things!

FWIW I listen with the Behringer's low input and low output cranked up to around 3 o'clock and LF crossover at 10 o'clock. I struggle reading the tiny numbers on the dial. I also really like it's separate sub output with frequency and gain control which could also be used with the Alphas. I have an 8 inch diy sub connected to this output which gives a bit of visceral impact that OB's can't deliver. The H-frame Alphas extend to 40hz which works well as that covers over 90% of what I listen to but the little sub goes lower and adds weight. In my other system I use the bucket subs for the same purpose.

For clarification I only use the Behringer with the Alpha woofers. The HF driver is wired straight to it's amp with nothing in the signal path except the tweeter caps.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom