• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

Some experience but not a lot. I've played with the 12" ferrite model and a friend got a pair of the same in an 8". In the ferrite, I'd say they are ok but I like the TB's a lot more. I'd like to hear the neo's and the alnico as it seems all the different magnet materials do have some effects on sonics, but so far I've not had the chance.

I've got several models of the Lowthers, several different Fostex, a model of the Dayton's, several different older drivers like EV's and a few of the cheaper lines that PE carries. If you want a driver that's nice enough to not spend time looking at while listening and wish you'd went upscale, not peaky enough to spend all your time trying to come up with traps and eq to correct after you've spent a ton on them, then the TB's are a pretty good value. I've swept them, measured them, played with them in a number of different rooms and I just find the ability to directly connect them to the amp with no corrections needed to have real value. No shout, no weirdness's, no distractions from the music...they enable longer listening sessions without fatigue than any speaker system I've ever had or maybe heard. One industry vet I had over compared them a well know ribbon based speaker maker, but then added, "only better".

If you go single driver in OB, I feel that it can sound really nice, but the lower you try to run them then the more you'll miss the dynamic that comes into play below about 350-400 (depending on driver size etc). Running multiples in a short line gets you lower and lower in that regard. On the top end, with the TB 1808 or 1772, you will think at times that you're missing a little of the highest top end sheen. And then in the performance your listening to they tap a bell or cymbal and it just sounds like it should. Natural. No doubt some want more up there and if you could successfully integrate it, that might be good. But every time you try to have another crossover, another element between the amp and the voice coil, it gets tougher and tougher to keep it natural sounding and keep making music in the room with you...instead of a ready impression of an electronic reproduction of a performance.

EV3
Hmmm. Are they really not good under 350-400? That seems pretty high for an 8" driver, although I know they are being a jack of all trades. I've currently got a sub, and will be adding another driver of the same type to the OBs I'm hoping to build, but they are only supposed to be good up to 300hz. And I've never tried to run them that high. I'd think an 18" would get a little sloppy at those frequencies. Conversely, adding another pair of W8's would see me getting towards $1k alone on drivers, not counting the 18's. My amp is pretty bright, so that doesn't worry me overtly, but it does give me pause if, from what you are saying, the W8 is closer to a wideband midrange driver. I could be looking at it the wrong way, but that's the impression I'm getting.
 
The comment about 350-400Hz wasn't pointed at any driver in particular and certainly not saying they become poor sounding at some number.

What I was trying to say was that as you get lower, at some number like those, that giving more cone area starts to give you more drive, more presence, to those critical freq that are the foundation for a lot of important elements of music. What value you place on that, how you approach that, may well differ for you and how you come at your system in your room space. I feel like with multiple drivers in use there that it works...for me.

I wouldn't think of amazing success running an 18" that high either, but it could be tried.

Generally, for the bass below the mains, I found getting success with staying OB and with multiples, again the count making lots of cone area increasingly critical while OB. I've played with several 15"s OB for the bass reinforcement and a single driver doesn't do it...for me. I settled on 10's that while not expensive drivers do bass very well down to around 35 in room.

What I've found...my rule of thumb, is get out of a driver by at least double it's rated low end spec number. And to get by that low I may be relying on the fact it's in multiples. As far as how high...depend on each drivers sonics I guess. But a lot of the down low stuff gets a lot easier when below a 100hz.

EV3
 
Well, I'll start with 2 of the W8 1808's and the dual 18" subs. I'll see where it goes from there and add drivers as the situation calls for it. Because according to the spec sheet, and FR measurements, the 1808 has a 5dB dropoff from 100hz down to 50, and probably another 3dB down to 40hz. If those specs are correct, (and they state Fs), I should be fine down to around 100-150hz on them. I'm not worried at all about getting the 18's up to that range. I may possibly look into the HF with some ribbons, but considering I have self tested my ears and only hit about 15khz, maybe I don't even need them.
 
Last edited:
We're going to put together a pair of H Frames after the Holidays and see what happens. Might be an overall smaller footprint than what we have now. WAF will go up and that's always a good thing.DSC_0613.JPG
 
Going for it. One glued. One in the wings.Dual 12" servo subs. I'm going to epoxy and paint these. Easier than a veneer for me. The issue is it's effing cold outside. Should I attempt this indoors? And they're just as big as what we currently use downstairs.

DSC_0670.JPG
 
Looking great. Will you be using the GR Research servo like these?

images
 
Not to nitpick, but there are 2 large boxes on the right hand side of the picture, that literally say "GR Research Model SW-12-16FR" on them.

Sorry, my experience with GR is limited. Worded differently do they all use opposed woofers?
 
Last edited:
Sorry, my experience with GR is limited. Worded differently do they all use opposed woofers?
Mounting woofers is up to the buyer. Good idea to be in touch with the fella who cuts these so he can make the cabinets to your desires. There's plenty of options. Grill frames, reveals, round-overs, etc. That empty unit is 70 lbs. The wood used is called Medex. Some sort of CA compliant MDF.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom