• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

Alright,
I'll play. After reading this thread and Poultrygeists love of OB speakers I am going to give it a go. My first time venturing into the OB scene so be patient. But I am not a DIY'er. I want a speaker that is plug and play ready. It seems like the logical choice would be this company.

http://www.caintuckaudio.com/

If you guys have any other suggestions, I am open to them. Thanks!

Do the Caintucks but given the kind of music you play you are probably going to want to augment them with a subwoofer. I have the Betsys in home made baffles and one Eminence Alpha ( an excellent match with the Betsys) providing the low end. I have that hooked to a plate amp like Poultrygeist has done).

20190201_064651.jpg
 
Last edited:
The big Zeniths sold me on Alnico motors. Some say that over time they may need a recharge but I wouldn't risk that for fear the sound would change. My 49CZ802's were made in 1957 and they couldn't sound better.

vintage-zenith-alnico-speakers_1_1af643fa5b278ebbf35998c5be938683.jpg
 
I was going to say the same. If you can find a way to make the 8" work go for it.
I checked eBay for smaller Heppners (and Rolas) but the build and quality doesn't look the same, and some are advertised as tweeters(?)
Maybe they were used as the upper range speakers in 2 way systems:dunno:
BTW, most of the instrument grade speakers roll off at around 5K yet I notice no tweeters on yours. Interesting.

Yes, I too, looked on eBay. Saw some smaller ones but nothing that looked to be "equal/similar" quality to the 8 inch ones I have now.

These Heppners that I have were sold to me as "full range" drivers, though there are no published specs that I can find on them. They sure sound like it. I've A/B'd these Heppners using a speaker switch and compared them to some modern Polk Audio production speakers... and the Heppners are all over the modern speakers. They are short on bass production but I use a subwoofer to handle the lower frequencies. They are clearer, cleaner than anything else I've listened to. I really don't think that a tweeter could add anything extra to them.

The only other drivers I've considered comparing the Heppners to would be some 8 inch Audio Nirvana full range drivers... which I may do some day.
 
Kenny B's OB story:

Hi Fellow OB'ers,haven't been on Ak for 'quite some time',but have to tell you,the 1st place I wanted to head,was right back to this thread to see how projects had evolved .Cool to see it was still happening.

Really enjoyed the positive vibe,camaraderie,that you have all managed to foster & keep moving along,mixed with much useful info,reviews,preferences,honest opinions of drivers,etc.
Helpful and informative right from the get go,& just plain Fun to read!

I like that this thread has helped others get started,and motivated them to just go for it,step out of their comfort zone & try something totally different,even something that seems just a little wacky,as its hard to believe that an idea with basically so simple a start can turn out to be really enjoyable to Listen to,leading us down a new path,ending in more surprise in most cases,giving great results in many cases,with very little outlay,and most times mixed in with a lot of personal satisfaction!

Want to add here,many of you enjoy and can afford to be on the leading edge of the high end driver offerings,etc,& obviously thoroughly enjoy experimenting with new components and TOTL drivers,hey we all like to Dream,please keep the upgrade train moving!

And,especially also like that you have kept close to your heart a 'Sound Stable of decent quality budget choices' that have remained a certain 'Priority,right on through this thread',very,important & necessary in my opinion,as many of us want/need to get the most bang for our buck,especially for those who have just found this thread,and are starting out getting their feet wet in a world of 'Way too Many audio choices!..Thanks,much appreciated!

And Wow,some of you do absolutely beautiful router & woodwork,I want to do better in this area,this year!
Kudos to all who cobble anything handy(like me) together,just to find out what the heck all this 'OB Fuss all about'.

And was blown away when I read,Miron's,trying different materials(the Leather baffles) Cool Bro!
Plus your construction material & methods,and that you have a trained ear,as well, finishing ideas,so many ideas,I love it!

I'm not happy with the paint job on my EP baffles,....hmmm,wall paper,I want to try that on my EP's,very cool,different,affordable,creative,unique choices of finishing speakers,helping us all with their/our acceptance into our homes and listening spaces.

Joy of Joys,finally retired last Dec,so after 50 years of working since I was 16.....Enough,I'm Done!!!....Now,I too' finally' get to enjoy,along with sleeping in till 'Day Light',and with a s.l.o.w coffee,in hand finally got to finish reading this thread right from its start to finish!

What interesting OB audio journey's for many of you too,not at all unlike myself,and like many have experienced very tight budgets/Family obligations/Health,etc,to contend with,along the way,so many of us often only get to dream of the much higher end offerings,and its great on threads like these,we get find out some components are not always as they appear to be(or sound),so that many reviews not quite true,and,in my humble opinion.......I'll put much more faith in a review I'd read from fellow audio folk on AK,vs,say 20 internet reviews,of usually dubious origins?

Like many of you I started into OB,basically with a 3/4 inch flat board,in my case used a d.i.y Fried Coffin sub woofer box,halved to give me 2 baffles with sloped sides,down by woofers,which I thought(after reading a bit) would give me better bass,after trying 2 vintage 12 in Isophon Oval Coaxial units,vertically,then of course trying nearly every garage sale woofer without much success,finally realized,not all woofers are created equal,and most were not designed to work well with OB.....and,like many of you.....so it began...'The Search for the Holy OB',or something like that,and what an Absolute Blast its turned out to be,can't remember having so much Fun,on so little funds!

Vintage Isophon,(not many Zenith round here?....anyways,lets say 'vintage' gave me such a great introduction to OB's huge sound field,plus crazy side 'Extension,going well outside the physical boundaries of my Listening room,this had never happened before!..in this room!.

Wow,1st attempt at d.i.y OB's immediately surprised me with the dynamics,and something I wasn't going to give up,Ever,especially after owning Altecs,+ real life Musician placement,another surprise,upon suddenly having Musicians/instruments being right where they were on our many dvd's concerts.

I must add here I/We prefer a 'Live Sound',especially well recorded dvd's in places like Royal Albert Hall in London England.
The ambience of a hall is heard through our OB's

A recent enjoy,Elton John(Dream ticket 4 dvd set)where he goes back to The Royal Academy of Music,where at "10 years old" Elton received a scholarship,and along with his band playing/working with a whole symphony,is notheing short of Amazing!..String/harp/Horn section to die for!
My God,Talk about POWER', boy does a Symphony paired with a rock band,well R.O.C.K..Holy Crap..as well I think everyone needs to & plays their Very Best,and you realize this you see Elton breath a Big sigh of relief after finishing a tedious piece,also spotted Diana Krall & Elvis Costello in the audience.I bet they got in for Free!

To Me,its so moving to see young Orchestra Musicians letting their hair down,like one mentioned they play behind the beat a tad,whereas Orchestra is spot on,interesting,keeps everyone on their toes,as well,plus on some songs a Full Choir is present....in my opinion,instances like these you need a good stable amp,I use Sugden(Phono)/modified budget Niles)+ modified Hybrid tube pre,and,my ace in the hole,a 1kw transformer to handle those Symphony related,Super complex Musical passages,as digital prefers clean reserve power in the dac department.
Man,forgot how rewarding it is to hear a Full Orchestra,also recommend Brian Adams,Un Plugged playing Hammerstein Ballroom,with talented Young,Julliard School of Music students,boy so many concerts so little time!

And found Listening late night with lights out was like an Out of Body Experience!.....Note:....this was before legalization of cannabis,ha!

This new to me OB experience rattled me so much,I sold my Altec 19 cloned cabs evolved to the Zilch(R.I.P) X-overs,but we did bring them out 1 last time after 4 months to compare,and in my & my Daughter's opinion,and especially as she has the hearing of a bat,decided,kinda sadly it was time to let the 19's go.Hey for 1976 components they were a work od audio art in my opinion.

Though,we don't miss them,at all,and we certainly enjoyed the heck out of them with concerts & Vinyl!

Then I kinda skipped a few steps,cause,'hey I ain't getting any younger',so I had to speed it up a tad!

Ended up with D.I.Y pr EP-4 series,(single 15 in woofer,12 in Coax),over time,naturally evolving to an opportunity to upgrade to newer EP's driver compliments,with huge Super duty vented magnets,cast frames,still paper cones(I still prefer paper over new materials),these are Keepers!......more defined bass,better highs,Wow,so happy,especially as I now have time to slowly savour more musical moments as I 'Relax to Music into my Retirement'.....
Crazy,it took 4 months for these huge cast frame woofers to finally loosen up,talk about stiff cones,holy crap!....I rather prefer listening to them break in,its cool to hear happen!

Now that I've rested up some,and like many of you,planning a few more OB projects.
1st,finish off some diy layered mdf 2.5 in baffles for previous baflles,wall paper here I come,thanks Paul!.
2nd,project,more of a cosmetically driven choice,but they will be a clone of the original look of EP's KC-II line.
From my OB beginning,I've always preferred the look of a Square Top (Rectangular speaker baffle,just my taste for angles),and as our current EP-4 series remind me more of Tombstones,lol,which may not be too far off the mark,as wife would probably like to see me buried with them,ha,ha,along with their super thick,built for action 3 inch thick baffles,1.5 in bases,which weigh almost as much as a t-stone too!

My KC-II knock-offs will utilize cast HD paper 10 in Coax,same HD 10 in mid-woofer below coax, below that,a HD 12 inch woofer,so Dual woofers,because,even though it been quite awhile,I haven't been able to shake wanting to build a set of OB's with dual woofer ports,Man for some reason I really dig that KC Dual ports look,likely as EP used dual 15's in their TOTL model,again just personal cosmetic preferences,which now that I have the time I may in fact be able to start/finish them,sooner than later.
Likely not go as deep,but I don't Listen to much Organ Music,nor care about movie explosions,besides my Big Mains,handle that with ease,whether it be a Full Symphony,or a Moog Synthesizer from early Moody Blues!!

Seems in my situation,once I 'Headed on Down that New "Open Baffle Road,there Was No Going Back!....

The 'Fun' for me,still will always be..... cutting that first piece of wood,and wondering what this pair will sound & look like finished?..
Its that hands on D.I.Y of it all,starting something and finishing it the way you want,sound wise & looks,making it all very personal choices!

Please don't take this as a plug,or advertisement for EP speakers,as I could have easily ended up owning any brand back then,and I just missed out on a pair of the now defunct Hawthorne's,and it was only by a chance opportunity after that some EP OB drivers/passive crossovers from the c-designer came my way,then later,older stock being liquidated,when Carbon Fiber came in,and in my opinion we still took a Big chance that we would like the changes,a huge jump for me,but,as I mentioned,I'm not getting any younger,and,as luck would have it,we really liked what we heard,and when we moved Altecs to a good home,it allowed the upgrade.
I've always had to sell off something dear to me to afford an upgrade,but so far its worked wonders for sound,very well worth taking a chance in the long run!

For those still reading this:...one more thing,after.... 'Enthusiastically reading this 'Entire' thread',I actually got off my butt & moved my OB's out into the room,well.....'Way More'...ending at... 4 ft to rear of baffle,(actually 51 in as my baffles are 3 in thick),and 3 ft to center line of Coax,as recommended in an earlier post.....So far 2 days,Still 'Listening'? 13.5x23 ft room,facing narrow end of room,corner loaded,kinda..

Originally' I started out slowly moving OB's out in one inch increments,over 2 week intervals, slowly more out into the room,finally after a few months,ending at 32 inches out from rear wall to rear of baffle,16 in,in from side walls to side of bases,and within 2 weeks of Listening,removed for good diy corner bass traps.
Base traps with OB,not a Good idea,from my experience,agreed it kills the needed rear wave as mentioned earlier in thread my findings!

But,I'll keep 2-side/1-ceiling(2x4 ft) 1-st refection panels in place,and totally agree a mix of hard and soft surfaces,and in my case we have 2 large Cedar bookcases,so mix-n-match,definitely OB's need,benefit from trial and error listening preferences,with your own reflective points and possibly some absorption will be needed in some rooms?....Experiment,don't rush...Listen!.

The reflective panels,were a left over from our Altecs,and honestly as I/we started soooooo enjoying the EP's,never fatiguing at all,well,we,uhhhhh,had kinda totally forgot about any more 'Positioning'.....for almost 2 years!...

.................Guess,its now safe to say,We like OB!

Thanks PauI I don't think I missed anything,ha,ha!

EP Concert Kenny....Tonight's concert..:D David Gilmour.....A Night to Remember(no bloody kidding!)....Live at Royal Albert Hall...
 
Last edited:
Finish coming when the weather cooperates
View attachment 1386265 .

mkane,

You've really got some impressive gear and speakers. Love all the combinations you've posted and wish I could experience them all. You've tried the GR H-frames with the ultra high end Voxativ and now you've moved to the GR "Little Giant Killers" + Neo 3's. How do they compare?

You've moved away from the SLOB's ( slot loaded OB's ) which means you favor the GR H-frames. Correct?
 
No comparison. H frames win hands down. The wedgies I have on top of the f Frames have an abundance of depth & height, Something the Voxativ lacked. That was no fault of the driver though. I'm sure it was my implementation. Last night I put the Tavish designs phono pre in the mix along with an ES1/Shelter and it was magic. Stunning actually. I've been playing with crossover components as of late.

Yout thread started me on this journey and I thank you, Paul.

DSC_0434.JPG


DSC_0435.JPG
 
Mkane your workmanship,skill set are looking like works of Fine Wood Art,where do you find all your energy!

I'm not sure if at the beginning it was part of your motivation to slowly go smaller-n-smaller,but I think I'm seeing that you have kinda 'Down-Sized,from your original concept speaker foot print? ..... From my view,your newer projects appear to be much smaller than what you started with?

In my opinion,if that was your goal,what you have done is a very desirable OB accomplishment for many of us,to try and fit OB into our Listening areas,however,not sure if the above was intentional at all,or if your partner even noticed this?

Enjoy reading your straightforward opinions,especially as its regarding leading edge speakers etc.,what I'm most impressed with,after your work is that you have incorporated smaller size into your Listening space.

I mentioned I'd moved my EP's out into my room,they're now 51 in out /3ft on center from sides.....Yikes!

They're Definitely,now making an Very Imposing statement,Way more than before,however I'm settling into what I'm hearing,and my ears are adjusting.
Must add I/We have no dogs/cats or Grand Kids at this point(?) so its very easy to leave things without disturbance/damage considerations,unfortunately many of us are not so lucky that way..

.EP Concert Kenny,tonight's concert: Pat Metheny Group....Speaking of now Live..
 
Last edited:
I thought it was mentioned in the decware forum that they were going to be $220 more than the regular Betsy's. But I dont know if it is $330 for the pair or $275 each driver.
 
Apparently, aluminum, nickel, & cobalt is expensive stuff.

I use vintage alnico speakers for my OBs.

There's a bunch of vintagge alnico speakers on eBay for excellent prices.
 
Apparently, aluminum, nickel, & cobalt is expensive stuff
...and you know it ain't the aluminum or nickel. Apparently Cobalt is found in very few parts of the world and due to politics, etc. at one time it became almost unobtanium.
Manufacturers had to resort to a different type of magnet and the ceramic was born. Much cheaper but not as powerful as the Alnico version.
That is why a ceramic magnet speaker has to weigh a ton in comparison to an Alnico one. Instead of that small plug of Alnico you need that huge ceramic ring.
 
Back
Top Bottom