• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Open Baffle Epiphany!

Here is an example of a fairly decent, but economical driver for OB use.

http://www.parts-express.com/goldwood-gw-8003-8-8-full-range-driver-w-whizzer--290-379

This Goldwood, as a single driver is...umm...modest in quality and you'd have to watch excursion. Stacked, it actually gets decent. Two drivers a side, better but 3 or 4 starts to really cook. On about a 20" size, it packs a really decent punch on the bottom end. Out of a quite a few 8" drivers I've played with, it probably does the best on the bottom end out of them all. Good enough I'd suggest many wouldn't want for more. But if you do, it does good enough to skip a 12 or 15" and go right to a separate boxed sub you may already have around.



It only goes high enough to do just ok, despite how they rate it. I'd suggest a rear firing augmenting tweeter if you want much above about 14K. Some little horn or something. Look at efficiency and keep it high enough to meet or exceed the mains, and you've got a pretty fair 1.5 way setup.

For the money and trouble to make it, you'd be hard pressed to not feel pretty good about it!

EV3

I agree! That is what I have on my TV setup, and they sound great all by themselves, especially after my Yamaha AVR did the auto EQ claibration. The bass is great, the midrange is awesome, and the highs are there but on the soft side. I cannot hear above 14khz anyway, too many years of playing drums. Peace and goodwill.
 
Two more questions. How does one determine the best size full range drivers to pair with the Eminence or other bass drivers?
Also how much difference in bass output would there be using 12 in. rather than 15 in bass drivers? Thanks.

cubdog

I would like to know the answer to this too. Peace and goodwill.
 
Two more questions. How does one determine the best size full range drivers to pair with the Eminence or other bass drivers?
Also how much difference in bass output would there be using 12 in. rather than 15 in bass drivers? Thanks.

cubdog

It depends on how much you want to spend and how much power you have to drive them. The Alphas aren't that expensive so I'd recommend spending more on the full range drivers especially since you plan to go all out with the nice wood baffles. Many 8 inch drivers do share the same cut out but not the Betsys.

Anything larger than an 8 inch is more likely to need a tweeter to fill in the highs. I'll try and make up a list of FR drivers that are commonly used in OB.

Generally the smaller drivers tend to be less efficient while the larger drivers are more efficient. The Goldwood that evsentry recommends wouldn't work for me as my SET's make 3.5 wpc which is not enough for an 87 db driver. I have to only consider 93 db drivers and above but there are still plenty of options.

The MiniDSP I know is a great option but I have no experience with it. I'm not quite ready for digital crossovers yet as I just recently bought the Ashly but may go that route in the future. I'm still getting acquainted with old fashioned analog active crossovers with dials to turn and tweak.
 
I'm not sure I follow. Let's assume I'll use the 15 in Alphas although from an aesthetic point of view I'd prefer the 12 in. model. Anyway, what determines what size driver is best for the upper frequencies? I've seen everything from 3 inch to 8 inch drivers used. Sorry, I'll be asking the same questions over and over. As I stated before, I'm in way over my head. Thanks again.

cubdog
 
I'm not sure I follow. Let's assume I'll use the 15 in Alphas although from an aesthetic point of view I'd prefer the 12 in. model. Anyway, what determines what size driver is best for the upper frequencies? I've seen everything from 3 inch to 8 inch drivers used.

If you want to use a passive crossover then matching the SPL/2.83V/m values for the drivers on an OB is what counts. For one Alpha 15A this usually means a 3 or 4 inch full range driver with a SPL/2.83V/m of between 88 and 90 dB. For two Alpha 15A woofers a 6 or 8 inch driver with a SPL/2.83V/m of between 94 and 96 dB is probably a good match. Using a passive crossover takes some skill to get it right.

If you want to use an active crossover the size of the full range driver in not an important variable because you can match the levels using the boost built into the crossover. This is the easier approach but it requires an active crossover, two amps, and the necessary cabling. This option provides the most flexibility for trying different full range drivers to see which one you like best.

Both crossover approaches can work very well.
 
Generally the smaller drivers tend to be less efficient while the larger drivers are more efficient. The Goldwood that evsentry recommends wouldn't work for me as my SET's make 3.5 wpc which is not enough for an 87 db driver. I have to only consider 93 db drivers and above but there are still plenty of options.

This is a good point. Consider your system intended style! The GW model as a single driver is probably below reasonable for fleewatt power.

In my case with a stack of them, a 10w amp does great! But you must consider not just the quoted efficiency of the drivers but also your amps output impedance to achieve control. If going with a passive crossover, maybe more power to control is good. With a big driver as the bottom, often people wind up with more control necessary. Also depends on your listening style.

For what it's worth, I'd suggest trying to get a listen to the driver you're choosing as the fullrange. Quality here is what you're going to be listening to the heart of your music through. You can listen to a naked driver in your hand and pretty much tell how smooth it is and how desirable. No crossover nor eq can fix if quality is lacking. I found it in the TB 8" drivers.

It is a joy to see people experimenting and starting down the OB path!

EV3
 
Going on what MJK said, I cannot stress enough how much easier it is to get a handle on this stuff...matching driver levels, crossover points, etc....if you use an active crossover and multiple amps. There is no better way to get an instant understanding of what each adjustment does and the impact it has on the performance of the design. To sit and have to change out a cap or caps each time you want even the slightest adjustment just seems like an exercise in madness, to me....given the active crossover method is easy to grasp and not expensive to implement. You twist a knob and see exactly what the new value is and the sonic result. You want to do the same thing with passives? Do some calculations to figure out which size cap will get you where you think you want to be, solder that thing in, have a listen, think about it, think about what it sounded like with the old cap, wonder if you hear a difference or one that you like, decide you need to hear the old cap in there again, get out the soldering iron and take out the new one to put the old one back in...OR...twist a knob back and forth. Done.

- Michael
 
Going on what MJK said, I cannot stress enough how much easier it is to get a handle on this stuff...matching driver levels, crossover points, etc....if you use an active crossover and multiple amps. There is no better way to get an instant understanding of what each adjustment does and the impact it has on the performance of the design. To sit and have to change out a cap or caps each time you want even the slightest adjustment just seems like an exercise in madness, to me....given the active crossover method is easy to grasp and not expensive to implement. You twist a knob and see exactly what the new value is and the sonic result. You want to do the same thing with passives? Do some calculations to figure out which size cap will get you where you think you want to be, solder that thing in, have a listen, think about it, think about what it sounded like with the old cap, wonder if you hear a difference or one that you like, decide you need to hear the old cap in there again, get out the soldering iron and take out the new one to put the old one back in...OR...twist a knob back and forth. Done.

- Michael

Couldn't agree more. If I had to implement a passive network for my OB's I'd be lost. A few boutique caps can cost more than the price of an active crossover.
 
How is the Mini DSP different from an active crossover? Is it a type of active crossover or something entirely different?

cubdog
 
I have been reading with great interest. I was thinking about buying a vintage set of speakers, but this looks like more fun. just trying to get a handle on what I would like to use for a driver. I have a lot to read and learn.
 
With the miniDSP there are no adjustments that can be made on the fly. It's more set and forget unless it's permanently attached to a PC. Is that correct?
 
The miniDSP is very adjustable on the fly. Crossover parameters and eq. You have attached a computer to do that. Once all set, then the computer isn't necessary.

EV3
 
I THINK...you just reattach the computer to reset the parameters. laptop would be easiest i imagine

If this is true, it does act much like a conventional active crossover. The difference being a computer is used to make the adjustments rather than the crossover unit itself. So then, the next question. What makes one, unit/system, better than the other?

cubdog
 
Going on what MJK said, I cannot stress enough how much easier it is to get a handle on this stuff...matching driver levels, crossover points, etc....if you use an active crossover and multiple amps.- Michael

This technology transformed automotive audio into what it is today.

Meanwhile, I'm slowly going over a Yamaha R 700 Natural Sound receiver that I plan on using to power 8 inch F-R single driver open baffle speakers. My thoughts are that this system might make for a good single driver OB setup. If worse comes to worse, I'll add tweeters to the mix...
 
Where did you get your DSP from Wes? I really know nothing about these. Do I need one for each speakers or just one for both?

cubdog

I got it directly from MiniDSP.
So far I've taken it out of the box once but haven't gotten to play with it at all. Haven't even had time to download the software yet.
If we get this big snow, I'll hopefully have a chance to get going to this whole bucketsub project:
http://www.audiokarma.org/forums/showthread.php?t=573119

I'll be updating that thread as the process comes along. My plan is to use the DSP with the current speaker first, then do the bucketsubs. I should get the DSP plugged up tomorrow at least.
 
Back
Top Bottom