• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Question about Opamps

I knew that thread, but nothing is said about the considerations using this (AD797) Opamp.

Why not a circuit build around the NE5532?

Nothing may have been said but the AD797's was used as it is a low noise op amp suited to MC cart amplification because of their low impedance.

All surrounding components were carefully chosen to get the best out of this op amp.

A NE5532 would not be suitable in this case and is not recommended by the manufacturers.

Also if the NE5532 was equal or better than an AD797 at 1/10th the cost I would have used it.

If cheaper components were as good as dearer ones in general then you would be using the cheapest amp available, would you not?
 
It's not just the AD797. TI states, explicitly:

That statement alone should be a sticky on the DIY forum. Too many people want to "roll" and think you can just swap things willy-nilly. This isn't a comment directed at you, just a comment in general.

You didn't hear me say there is one superb opamp for all applications.

That would be like audio heaven. :banana:

Like everything in the audio chain, everything you choose must be carefully chosen to fit together :music:
 
Nothing may have been said but the AD797's was used as it is a low noise op amp suited to MC cart amplification because of their low impedance.

All surrounding components were carefully chosen to get the best out of this op amp.

A NE5532 would not be suitable in this case and is not recommended by the manufacturers.

Also if the NE5532 was equal or better than an AD797 at 1/10th the cost I would have used it.

If cheaper components were as good as dearer ones in general then you would be using the cheapest amp available, would you not?

As I said I understood from the TI website the AD797 is critical (not as interchangeable like other opamps, use it in an optimized environment) and as you explained used because of it's low impedance for a MC circuit.

What would you suggest for a MM amplifier (if the rest of the circuit is optimized?) Is there a better option for the NE5532 and what would be needed to justify that choice (what optimization for the circuit)?
 
I've been designing with opamps professionally for 35+ years. Without question, the sonic differences between op amps are VASTLY, VASTLY over-rated. I know as well as anyone about bandwidth and noise differences, and slew rate and drift and output stage biasing and bypassing and compensating and and and. It's my job and I also taught some undergrad classes at MIT on it. I've developed audio chips with AD and others, I work with them every day, and my rent gets paid by the quality of my ears, my choices and my design decisions.

A few years ago, an unexpected fedex package arrived at my lab. National was nice enough to send me a pile of their latest audio offerings... damn are they good! I love them. I happily added them to my drawers of AD's and TI' and JRC's. But, let's be real here. In 1975 I was designing circuits using LM318's or fast compensated 301's, later with 45XX's, that no golden ear on earth could distinguish from the those Nationals under actual listening conditions. And we did the listening tests many times to verify that.

Enough of this foolishness already!

-k
 
Last edited:
Whatever foolishness might be attributed to swapping opamps, I'd venture to say that it's pretty minor compared to much of the other massive idiocy in the audio domain.
 
I've been designing with opamps professionally for 35+ years. Without question, the sonic differences between op amps are VASTLY, VASTLY over-rated. I know as well as anyone about bandwidth and noise differences, and slew rate and drift and output stage biasing and bypassing and compensating and and and. It's my job and I also taught some undergrad classes at MIT on it. I've developed audio chips with AD and others, I work with them every day, and my rent gets paid by the quality of my ears, my choices and my design decisions.

A few years ago, an unexpected fedex package arrived at my lab. National was nice enough to send me a pile of their latest audio offerings... damn are they good! I love them. I happily added them to my drawers of AD's and TI' and JRC's. But, let's be real here. In 1975 I was designing circuits using LM318's or fast compensated 301's, later with 45XX's, that no golden ear on earth could distinguish from the those Nationals under actual listening conditions. And we did the listening tests many times to verify that.

Enough of this foolishness already!

-k

That's the problem with the internet these days. Knowledge and experience have been replaced by internet folklore.

There are so many boards where people say they want to replace a JRC op-amp because they are JUNK and replace it with a Burr-Brown because that's what some other guy did that had absolutely no knowledge of electronics.

If you were to ask them what's wrong with JRC op-amps they would only be able to regurgitate internet rumors.

There are other boards for the Ibanez tube screamer that just go gaga over some old JRC 4558 op-amps that were apparently manufactured in a magical place and time. Apparently no other JRC 4558s can ever sound as good as those so you need to hunt down these special vintage ones. :D
 
Whatever foolishness might be attributed to swapping opamps, I'd venture to say that it's pretty minor compared to much of the other massive idiocy in the audio domain.

OK, but it is indicative of an "everything makes a difference" approach that is quite insidious, and which has badly hurt the high end. Anyway, life is long, and I'm sure I will complain about many more things yet!

-k
 
This kind of stuff was around in audio magazines going back to the 1950's. It probably reached its pre-internet peak in the British mags of the 70's, along with TAS and, to a lesser extent, Stereophile. Now, it has exploded again.

Having said that, I agree 100% with what you say. For all its positives, the internet is a vast source of disinformation and self-proclaimed wisdom.

-k


That's the problem with the internet these days. Knowledge and experience have been replaced by internet folklore.

There are so many boards where people say they want to replace a JRC op-amp because they are JUNK and replace it with a Burr-Brown because that's what some other guy did that had absolutely no knowledge of electronics.

If you were to ask them what's wrong with JRC op-amps they would only be able to regurgitate internet rumors.

There are other boards for the Ibanez tube screamer that just go gaga over some old JRC 4558 op-amps that were apparently manufactured in a magical place and time. Apparently no other JRC 4558s can ever sound as good as those so you need to hunt down these special vintage ones. :D
 
Very good points; ConradH, Echowars and Ken Kantor

Many of us (especially myself) are looking for that inexpensive 'magic bullet' so we can earn brownie points with ourselves and our friends. Where just replacing something might look good on paper we are solving one problem that might create another. Many Op Amps have specific current and voltage requirements and we read something on the internet and we become experts.

If you want to impress your doctor just say to him 'Oh I how all about that I read it on the internet' and what his expression? Like we are both equals now! 'Ya doc why don't you just look it up and get with the program'...

I always use the analogy that I rarely see a remodeled house that really works. When you add a family room the living room becomes obsolete or do you want a bathroom as big as a bedroom? WAF? Or a new reading room?

I closed in a doorway in a dining room once.
Simple? I got more space but I also got rid of the air flow.

Like 'Pink Champagne on Ice we are all prisoners of our own devise'

Michael
 
OK, but it is indicative of an "everything makes a difference" approach that is quite insidious, and which has badly hurt the high end. Anyway, life is long, and I'm sure I will complain about many more things yet!

-k
Well put. I wish you were closer so I could buy you a beer (or a good cup of Joe if beer isn't an option) and we could sit and complain about a whole slew of things. :D
 
Well put. I wish you were closer so I could buy you a beer (or a good cup of Joe if beer isn't an option) and we could sit and complain about a whole slew of things. :D

Nice idea... remind me where you are located?

Oh, KC... yeah, I haven't been to KC in many years. Ah well, here's an internet toast! LSB's Up!!!

-k
 
Last edited:
But why develop other opamps if the old ones are still good enough and you can't hear differences?

@HypnoToad: another topic on the AD797--> http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/solid-state/160149-lme49990-audio-op-amp-better-than-ad797-4.html

Huh? The same reason why new amps are developed, new microphones are developed, new switches are developed, new cars, menus and sitcoms are developed: To try and sell more stuff!

Besides, audio is but one slice of the market for op amps, and most of the hardcore development work is financed by other applications. Chip vendors take a few of their low noise, low GBW designs, tweak them up and charge a premium for them as "audio" op amps. Seems pretty straight forward from a business perspective, to me.

-k
 
Last night I was thinking about the kids who buy $100 aftermarket spoilers and bolt them onto their Hondas and Toyotas. Then they drive around totally convinced that they have achieved a noticeable improvement in traction and stability. "Why, of course Toyota didn't put this on! They had to keep the price down! But, me, I'm interested in top performance, so adding this is a no-brainer improvement. You should try it."

Sound familiar?

-k
 

Attachments

  • spoil1.jpeg
    spoil1.jpeg
    9.5 KB · Views: 12
  • spoil2.jpeg
    spoil2.jpeg
    8.2 KB · Views: 9
  • spoil6.jpeg
    spoil6.jpeg
    8.8 KB · Views: 9
  • spoil4.jpeg
    spoil4.jpeg
    8.3 KB · Views: 13
  • spoil5.jpeg
    spoil5.jpeg
    8.4 KB · Views: 7
  • spoil3.jpeg
    spoil3.jpeg
    7.8 KB · Views: 7
The same kids who buy those spoilers think they've added 100 hp to their car because they bought an air filter that promised 15 hp, an exhaust that promised 25 hp, spark plugs that added 5 hp,etc....hey add up all the claimed numbers and it's 100 hp more, right?

Of course, take the car out to the drag strip and the actual results might show the car is SLOWER...but of course you can't trust those actual measurements, it's how the car feels and it feels faster so therefore it is!
 
Lets liken op amps to car tires, simply putting wide tires without make other changes to the cars suspension, steering etc would not give optimum performance.

But designing a car from the ground up, those tires would give superior performance to standard tires, this is without dispute.

Using an AD797 in the right application such as a low noise, low impedance preamp, with the optimum component values it would easily outperform a NE5532.
 
The same kids who buy those spoilers think they've added 100 hp to their car because they bought an air filter that promised 15 hp, an exhaust that promised 25 hp, spark plugs that added 5 hp,etc....hey add up all the claimed numbers and it's 100 hp more, right?

Of course, take the car out to the drag strip and the actual results might show the car is SLOWER...but of course you can't trust those actual measurements, it's how the car feels and it feels faster so therefore it is!

Yup. I used to drive around on a Ninja 900. It was 1984 and it was the first year they were made. We all had to change the exhausts to something aftermarket and "better". It was a 4 into 2 exhaust system and one of the first after market vendors was Supertrapp. There was all of these discussions going around about jetting, number of discs to use, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. So we all did the running state of the art changes, because we didn't have our own dynomometers to dial in the performance for ourselves. We could tell the performance was improved because of the feeling of power and the sound, etc.

Long story short, when we went to the races to see the superbike races, we heard, or I should say didn't hear, these almost silent Ninja's going around the track. The story was, the factory pipes made the most power and the most usable power. Aftermarket pipes were allowed too.
 
Back
Top Bottom