• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
I find it truly ironic that one of the most interesting threads I have read and paid heed to on any forum ever (and I am a member of a lot) has had its primary contributor/originator (I think) severed from the discussion along with some very valuable information that went with him. I shake my head in disbelief. FWIW - thank you Dr Vince! Your advice has worked for me. I hope you can return in another guise as I did in a similar (but different) forum quite a while back for merely offering an opinion in the midst of a similar debate where a whole bunch of folks were banned - One or two had taken it to a personal level and the admin saw fit to exercise a wide ban (as is his prerogative I guess) on folks including me as newbie to the forum at the time. I think I was back on within 5 minutes with nobody the wiser and to this day a healthy contributor....
I find it easier nowadays to simply use a healthy helping of the "ignore" filter once things get out of hand and self righteous bozos are involved.....
;-)
 
Last edited:
@Timothy Flath

- 3 ml Triton X-100
- 65 ml IPA (99%)
- 1,000 ml DI water

based on 20°C, this will give the following approximate weight percentages;

Triton X-100 = 0.3%
IPA = 4.8%
Back on track after my rant above - Muchos Gracias Compadre (SP?) - I will likely go higher in IPA only because my mostly second hand vinyl collection is not super valuable and easily replaceable and I am not so worried about the harmful effects of IPA on plasticizers etc. My only question is: Don't you have to remove the 68 ml from the 1000 ml for those numbers to work? I guess it doesn't really matter as precision of the mix isn't super critical if I recall correctly what Dr Vince said.
Will use by mixing triton into the IPA first to aid mixing then slowly add water....
Good that I have everyone here as well checking my bad math from earlier on - many thanks ;-)
 
My pleasure @Timothy Flath.

The total weight of the batch that I calculated is about 1054,3 grams (1000 g water, 51,1 g 99% IPA and 3,2 g X-100). Since the IPA is 1% water, there is 50,6 g of pure IPA in the batch. So the weight fraction of pure IPA is 50,6/1054,3 = 0.048 (4.8%). For X-100, 3,2/1054,3 = 0.003 (0.3%).

The volumes are calculated by using the respective densities (about 0,79 g/ml for the IPA).

Think I will be making up a batch of this myself for the Spin Clean.
 
I too am very thankful for the knowledge Vince has given to us. I believe there is even more for us to learn about record cleaning, and for that I hope he returns at some point to impart more knowledge.

If not, I wouldn't hold it against him. He went above and beyond, and his contribution has been greater than most people (myself included) in this forum.

One thing I've been wondering is if there are signs that too much Triton is being used. Some albums I clean and it seems like they're impossible to fully rinse. Maybe I accidentally used a little too much Triton and there's still some left over in the grooves, even after 2 or 3 rinse and vacuum cycles. Has anyone else experienced this before?
 
One thing I've been wondering is if there are signs that too much Triton is being used. Some albums I clean and it seems like they're impossible to fully rinse. Maybe I accidentally used a little too much Triton and there's still some left over in the grooves, even after 2 or 3 rinse and vacuum cycles. Has anyone else experienced this before?
Only truly good rinse is to spray the record, flushing the rinse water down the drain as one would rinse a dinner plate. Applying the rinse to the record on an RCM with the intention of vacuuming it up is a slow process of gradual dilution. This ignores the fact that the wand gasket is contaminated with surfactant.

The good news is that a little surfactant left on the record is a good thing, as Vince1 pointed out. We want some of the destat and lube properties left behind.
 
As a data point regarding too much Triton, my Triton mix at 0.5% rinses off nicely. I do two rinses as the first one shows there is still enough surfactant to cause the rinse #1 to spread out evenly over the record surface. The second rinse beads up as pure water would be expected to do. I also use a cotton facial makeup removal pad cut in half for each rinse so there is never any contamination from one rinse to the next or from one record to the next.
 
My pleasure @Timothy Flath.

The total weight of the batch that I calculated is about 1054,3 grams (1000 g water, 51,1 g 99% IPA and 3,2 g X-100). Since the IPA is 1% water, there is 50,6 g of pure IPA in the batch. So the weight fraction of pure IPA is 50,6/1054,3 = 0.048 (4.8%). For X-100, 3,2/1054,3 = 0.003 (0.3%).

The volumes are calculated by using the respective densities (about 0,79 g/ml for the IPA).

Think I will be making up a batch of this myself for the Spin Clean.

Gotcha - you are going by %weight vice %Vol? Kinda reminds me of beer wars early on when folks were touting stronger bier (it is the German in me that forces the spelling here)...
 
Gotcha - you are going by %weight vice %Vol? Kinda reminds me of beer wars early on when folks were touting stronger bier (it is the German in me that forces the spelling here)...

Yes, mass percent. Volume percents get wonky sometimes, especially since small alchohols (e.g. methanol, ethanol, propanols, etc.) mix with water to give smaller volumes than the component parts.

I do remember those beer wars. And BTW - this was the first time that I have used commas in the place of decimal points. Felt odd at first, but I could get used to it.
 
Last edited:
Yes, mass percent. Volume percents get wonky sometimes, especially since small alchohols (e.g. methanol, ethanol, propanols, etc.) mix with water to give smaller volumes than the component parts.

I do remember those beer wars. And BTW - this was the first time that I have used commas in the place of decimal points. Felt odd at first, but I could get used to it.
Heh, Mass vs weight - my old Phys-Chem Prof would have beat me with a wet noodle had he read my post :-)
 
Man, if P-Chem profs aren't sadistic enough just by dishing out that thermostatistical agony. The noodling treatment would no doubt be crossing some sort of humanistic line.

Please let me know if the formula that we discussed works for you. I need to make up a new batch soon, and forgot the proportions that I used for the small amount of remaining solution that I have.
 
Does anyone else use their Triton/IPA/water solution to lightly moisten a brush (e.g. Dishwasher) to give a quick wipe prior to playing? I've heard it stated that such treatment could force dust down into the grooves, but it is something that I find myself doing out of habit prior to every play.

I have just started using a can of compressed "air" to try to blow the dust off of an album prior to play, with limited success. Has anyone else tried this with good results?
 
You use compressed air. :whip:You can just spray them with a combination of Lysol and Scrubbing Bubbles! I've used this once about 5 minutes ago and the record came out pristine. No damage at all and I highly recommend it right before the Windex and after the Lava soap scrub. :banana: YMMV though.:lurk:
 
^ I've tried this a bunch of times and have trouble keeping the liquid "air" off the record. Works but I find a 1 inch sable paint brush from an art store to do a much better job. Doesn't really have to be sable as they are now difficult to get do to import restrictions. Just visit your local art store and get something natural that looks like the left most image in the picture.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kolinsky_sable-hair_brush
This works far better than those carbon fiber brushes advertised as record brushes IMHO.
 
I've noticed that as well WntrMute2. I find that I have to wait until the can has been depleted a bit before I use it for record cleaning service, to make sure that the liquid doesn't get on the album. I find that the larger particles can be blown off with this method, but I have problems removing the finer stuff. Hence the use of the brush.

Thanks for the tip on the sable brush.
 
Does anyone else use their Triton/IPA/water solution to lightly moisten a brush (e.g. Dishwasher) to give a quick wipe prior to playing? I've heard it stated that such treatment could force dust down into the grooves, but it is something that I find myself doing out of habit prior to every play.

I have just started using a can of compressed "air" to try to blow the dust off of an album prior to play, with limited success. Has anyone else tried this with good results?
I used to use a squeeze bulb, the kind photographer's use to dust camera lenses. Worked ok, but I once got too close to work on a particularly pesky speck and accidentally hit the record with it. The result wasn't audible, but didn't look too pretty. The bulb comes with a brush, which in retrospect would've been smarter to leave on, but it diffused the air to the point where the air alone no longer did anything.

The Discwasher works on the principle of humidity, hence, anything more than plain water is more likely to cause problems down the road.
 
Does anyone else use their Triton/IPA/water solution to lightly moisten a brush (e.g. Dishwasher) to give a quick wipe prior to playing? I've heard it stated that such treatment could force dust down into the grooves, but it is something that I find myself doing out of habit prior to every play.

I have just started using a can of compressed "air" to try to blow the dust off of an album prior to play, with limited success. Has anyone else tried this with good results?
I pretty much do this every third time I play a record these days (except I use the Dr. Vince's Triton/IPA/DH20 home brew and the paint pad brushes from home depot - one for detergent and one for DH2O rinse)) - it sounds so smokin' great and takes almost no time to rip up a couple of records in a queue! In between the rotation I just use a quick clean with a carbon fibre brush.


Here is my setup with super easy to use Squeakyclean MK3 RCM:


And I just completed all my TT mods last night with the addition of a cool Thorens label 3D print:

IMG_3753.jpg

IMG_3758.jpg


Complete Mod thread is here (only thing still missing is a thick granite base that will reside between the black PVC adjustable feet and the Chrome cone in cup feet on the TT itself):
http://audiokarma.org/forums/index....rens-td-165-turntable-for-restoration.699495/
 
Last edited:
That's exactly what I was wondering about @ripblade.

It would be cool if there was a small, handheld vacuum device that was available to touch up albums on the platter before playing. I'm going to explore my local Lowe's this week to see if there is something available that I may be able to adapt for this service.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom