• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
I tried a carbon cantilever once....(Tonar JT-555)...didn't play more than a few records with it. I bought it because I was curious what an affordable, non-metallic cantilever would sound. Turns out on simple acoustic stuff like jazz and chamber music...which it did best in my opinion...it reproduced a harmonic texture obscured by colouration, and anything of a highly dynamic nature like rock or orchestral, the sound just became confused. If it had a conical stylus it might've served well for hiding surface imperfections, but the sound quality itself simply didn't convey what I'm looking for. As far as noise reduction is served, it was a bit like throwing the baby out with the bathwater.

The cartridge is not a bad deal for what you get, and I'm sure it would fit better on a more forgiving or modest system.
In this hobby, one size does not fit all. On some tone arms, carbon fiber is used for a reason.
 
And what about my comment?
It's like talking to a wall Dan. Don't even waste your time with this guy.

He doesn't believe in record cleaning, you know, because of all the voodoo involved.

He comes here to ask questions but then puts down any advice he receives as unnecessary or as OCD.

Always negativity with this guy.

Best to put him on the ignore list.
 
It's like talking to a wall Dan. Don't even waste your time with this guy.

He doesn't believe in record cleaning, you know, because of all the voodoo involved.

He comes here to ask questions but then puts down any advice he receives as unnecessary or as OCD.

Always negativity with this guy.

Best to put him on the ignore list.
"He" cleans his records, but does not scrub them, or jump through 20-30 hoops to do so. But, thanks.
 
I listen to music, not equipment.
Your the one flipping a record cleaning thread into equipment used. And while I do agree a cart can make a huge difference in the noise it picks up. I don't agree with ten members needing to have to tell you we're not stupid. And on and on and on and on you go.

FWIW
I don't spend much time cleaning records, my tables get setup and is done right the first time and that's the way the stay. I listen to music, but on really nice equipment so I can listen to it the best I can make it.
 
Arthur I pointed you here because I though you might learn a bit about "record cleaning". I was aware of the risk of you sounding this way but I figured you might get the idea of cleaning and the many level of same. There are a lot of very good peeps on here with more experience than you and I combined. You really need to listen as well as post. As far as this post, It's been hijacked.....

Back on track....I use FhotoFlo but found out there was something better via Vincent1...THANKS! I have a large bottle and use a few drops. I'm sticking with a maybe second best method in that it can get expensive bouncing around. The rest of my mix is par for the course. I deep clean my records when I get them and that's about it. The rest is maintenance.

Knowledge is knowing a tomato is a fruit; Wisdom is not putting it in a fruit salad.
 
Interesting, I was ready about some chemicals actually changing the chemical composition of the surface of vinyl. I wonder what the various methods of cleaning does to vinyl as it changes hands? I'm guessing some used vinyl has gone through an embedded chemical cocktail of sorts.
 
Arthur I pointed you here because I though you might learn a bit about "record cleaning". I was aware of the risk of you sounding this way but I figured you might get the idea of cleaning and the many level of same. There are a lot of very good peeps on here with more experience than you and I combined. You really need to listen as well as post. As far as this post, It's been hijacked.....

Back on track....I use FhotoFlo but found out there was something better via Vincent1...THANKS! I have a large bottle and use a few drops. I'm sticking with a maybe second best method in that it can get expensive bouncing around. The rest of my mix is par for the course. I deep clean my records when I get them and that's about it. The rest is maintenance.

Knowledge is knowing a tomato is a fruit; Wisdom is not putting it in a fruit salad.
You used PhotoFlo on your vinyl, and you're going to teach ME about vinyl cleaning? I have developed thousands of rolls of film in my own darkroom. You do not use that stuff on vinyl. Maybe I should teach you something about film development.
 
I feel the need (again) to recap on this 34th page of the thread - and also because I decided to give the Triton X-100 a try.
For a 50 ml solution:
(1 teaspoon = 4.929 ml> say 5 ml for those using droppers)
5 ml (1 teaspoon) of Triton X-100
45 ml (9 teaspoons) of Distilled Water
Mix solution and let sit approx 10 hrs (overnight) or add 99% IPA to speed dilution

From Vince "You want a final concentration of detergent around 0.1 to 0.2%"
50 ml = 1.69 oz
1 gal = 128 oz
1.69 oz solution / 128 (oz/gal) water = 0.013 =1.3%
therefore
1.69 oz of solution to 1 gal water = 1.3%;
1.69 oz of solution to 10 gal water = 0.13%;
Use 5 ml solution per gallon of water

Edit: Vince later stated in certain words that you can use a higher concentration (1%) for "dirtier" records. 1% would be the complete 50ml solution in to the 1 gallon of water.


So for my 10 L Ultrasonic Cleaner that uses 2 gals of Distilled Water, I would need 10 ml of solution.
For the Spin Clean tank that uses 24 ozs (.1875 gals) of Distilled Water, I would need 2 ml of solution.
 
Last edited:
5ml of straight Triton in 1 gallon of water is .13%. Using the 10% pre-mix you will need 50 ml to 1 gal to get .13% final concentration.
or stated this way
50ml ( 1.69 oz ) to 1 gal water = 1.3% Then figure using the triton solution of 10% by volume, the 1.3% becomes .13%
 
Last edited:
You used PhotoFlo on your vinyl, and you're going to teach ME about vinyl cleaning? I have developed thousands of rolls of film in my own darkroom. You do not use that stuff on vinyl. Maybe I should teach you something about film development.

Not getting into a pissing match here like on FaceBook. I have already explained to you the PhotoFlo connection. I really won't repeat myself again and most here know the story. It's not the best based on the observations by Vince but not the worst either, as a serficant. Let's keep the "Vinyl cleaning" post going shall we. Regards
 
FWIW:

Right before Vince left, and then this thread strayed a bit into equipment, there was a mention of the possibility of baby soap, for it's non-harshness, as another easily accessible option, though it hadn't been confirmed.

. Detergent containing shampoos will be "no more tears" or for babys when they have neutral pH. I'd actually recommend them for record cleaning as the major detergent in them (cocamidopropyl betaine) is zwitterionic and the good ones contain less perfumes and dyes, but they always seem to add an anionic (SDS) to it.

For the record (and records in case anyone wants to try), I checked around the net and found that J&J Head to Toe Baby Wash has a pH of 6.5-7.0 - about as neutral as you can get.

The only thing that was in there that IIRC was discussed here was that most baby soap, J&J included, has the added ingredient of a scent, but that the other ingredients looked promising.

I am not advocating, nor denying this product as an alternative, only just following up with a little searching I did after reading the post about the baby soap possibility.

I'd be happy to try it out since it's cheap and readily accessible, and I've got a couple more flea market finds that would be no major loss.

Disclaimer: I'm not a chemist, nor have I played one on TV, so I don't have access to scanning electron microscopes to see if any damage occurred at the plasticizer/vinyl level, but I'd be happy to report back anything I see/hear.

EDIT: Found and added "Guest's" reference to baby soap.
 
Last edited:
Let's stop the back and forth, This topic is not going to save the world from imminent demise for God's sake. If you can't stay on the tracks and be respectful, you will be banned! I have never banned anyone, but this is and has been an ugly read. This is cleaning vinyl, not saving the world from disaster! All parties are on notice, and I am watching this thread!
Respectfully,
Jim
 
Thanks for the recap GPJeff. I think that I may try the same Triton brew in my Spin Clean this weekend.
 
I was the person who posted that I was using Johnson's baby shampoo. Baby shampoo isn't terrible, but it is primarily SDS and full of other things like fragrance that offer no benefit. Hard to tell if its detrimental.
 
I can think of no reason that baby shampoo would be detrimental to record albums. There is nothing in its composition that would indicate that it would be.
 
Just wanted to say that you do not have to make a pre-mix of Triton. I used straight Triton, letting it dissolve in 1 oz of water and 1 oz of IPA.Then filled up my 16 oz container with water. (I also put in a quat and EDTA ).
 
I was the person who posted that I was using Johnson's baby shampoo. Baby shampoo isn't terrible, but it is primarily SDS and full of other things like fragrance that offer no benefit. Hard to tell if its detrimental.

Cool. :thumbsup: When looking for the pH earlier, I found the pH of J&J Baby Shampoo (no tears) was 5.5. Turns out, the head/toe baby wash is even more neutral (@ 6.5 - 7), however, it does have the Sodium Tri(something) Sulfate (possibly some variation of SDS) and a light scent.

Though like I mentioned before, chemistry isn't my thing, but it may be more gentle than some of the other things we've tried - scrubbing bubbles comes instantly to mind! LOL
 
I feel the need (again) to recap on this 34th page of the thread - and also because I decided to give the Triton X-100 a try.
For a 50 ml solution:
(1 teaspoon = 4.929 ml> say 5 ml for those using droppers)
5 ml (1 teaspoon) of Triton X-100
45 ml (9 teaspoons) of Distilled Water
Mix solution and let sit approx 10 hrs (overnight) or add 99% IPA to speed dilution

From Vince "You want a final concentration of detergent around 0.1 to 0.2%"
50 ml = 1.69 oz
1 gal = 128 oz
1.69 oz solution / 128 (oz/gal) water = 0.013 =1.3%
therefore
1.69 oz of solution to 1 gal water = 1.3%;
1.69 oz of solution to 10 gal water = 0.13%;
Use 5 ml solution per gallon of water

Edit: Vince later stated in certain words that you can use a higher concentration (1%) for "dirtier" records. 1% would be the complete 50ml solution in to the 1 gallon of water.


So for my 10 L Ultrasonic Cleaner that uses 2 gals of Distilled Water, I would need 10 ml of solution.
For the Spin Clean tank that uses 24 ozs (.1875 gals) of Distilled Water, I would need 2 ml of solution.

Even easier for me is to add 5ml of concentrate to 1000ml of water and let sit overnight. Dissolved by morning and you have a 0.05 percent solution. Works great all on its own. No mold or mildew is growing in that liter after 2 months of storage in a cool location. Good work running the chemist off. He can't have known what he was talking about. Baby shampoo is far preferable.
 
Even easier for me is to add 5ml of concentrate to 1000ml of water and let sit overnight. Dissolved by morning and you have a 0.05 percent solution. Works great all on its own. No mold or mildew is growing in that liter after 2 months of storage in a cool location.
" Good work running the chemist off. He can't have known what he was talking about. Baby shampoo is far preferable."

I haven't had time to read the part about the chemist being run off. That must have been a heated argument of sorts. I did read the part about the admin banning anyone that continues this type of behavior.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom