• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
The stuff above. If there was an exact science to cleaning records, than why are these 1000's of formulas, and rituals? And, no two alike?

Well because we have all sorts of different budgets, and ways of working within that budget in this hobby. Then we also have many individuals that like to try things out in an effort to better their listening experience.

There is nothing wrong with that at all, I do my cleaning my way and what works for me. If someone has another way I don't feel the need to prove them wrong in what they do. I will say something if asked a question, "is brillo and lacquer thinner good for washing records?" NO!!

That said I'm sure this formula works fine and far better than some others I have seen and would never do to my records.
 
Going further, does record cleaning necessitate exact science?

... Like I can shower with Irish Spring or Lever 2000. They're both valid ways of getting myself clean.
 
I am using a real simple "formula" of distilled water, 91% isopropyl, and a couple of drops of dishwash rinse to break surface tension. and I use it with a DiscWasher style brush. I really cannot see how, or why, it needs to be more elaborate than that.
 
Going further, does record cleaning necessitate exact science?

... Like I can shower with Irish Spring or Lever 2000. They're both valid ways of getting myself clean.
No, but a lot of people come across as psuedo chemists and frustrated scientists with their formulas and rituals.
 
I am using a real simple "formula" of distilled water, 91% isopropyl, and a couple of drops of dishwash rinse to break surface tension. and I use it with a DiscWasher style brush. I really cannot see how, or why, it needs to be more elaborate than that.
If that's good enough for you, then by all means keep using that cleaning solution.
 
One thing that got me thinking is...

Ken Boyd pointed out in another thread that vacuum platter tables came under scrutiny back in the late 80s early 90s. A fairly low vacuum holding the record to the platter can pull plasticisers out of the record so they made adjustment to the amount of vacuum they use.

Today it's very common to use RCM with a very powerful vacuum...:idea:

Are we destroying records cleaning them....

Once a record is open we have cause and effect....it's a consumable really and never meant to stay new forever.
 
Last edited:
I am using a real simple "formula" of distilled water, 91% isopropyl, and a couple of drops of dishwash rinse to break surface tension. and I use it with a DiscWasher style brush.

Perfectly reasonable. The "voodoo chemical" Tergitol, mentioned above is pretty much the same as your dishwash rinse (they're both used as surfactants) with the minor difference being the Tergitol is non-ionic which theoretically (err, hypothetically?) could reduce static charge. Some people are adding conditioners or de-molding agents to maybe help with other climate related effects. I don't know if it's voodoo so much as it is experimentation.

I really cannot see how, or why, it needs to be more elaborate than that.

And maybe it doesn't need to be more elaborate than that, but sometimes I'm fine with McDonald's, while other times I want Five Guys and other times still I want steak. They all serve the same functional purpose which is to keep me alive. I don't go around slapping Taco Bell out of people's hands because I don't see how or why it needs to be more elaborate than some meat in between slices of bread. A world with just McDonald's sounds like a bleak one indeed.
 
Or, is some of the cleaning futile? I submit that many of those going through torture, spending time and money, lots of it, cleaning records, may be misdirecting their efforts. In many cases, the clicks and pops people here from vintage vinyl is not due to dust and debris, but from scratches. And, trying things such as using a conical stylus on a carbon fiber cantilever can help to minimize clicks and pops. Much less resonant than an elliptical. I use an elliptical with my new, or like new vinyl.
 
Or, is some of the cleaning futile? I submit that many of those going through torture, spending time and money, lots of it, cleaning records, may be misdirecting their efforts. In many cases, the clicks and pops people here from vintage vinyl is not due to dust and debris, but from scratches. And, trying things such as using a conical stylus on a carbon fiber cantilever can help to minimize clicks and pops. Much less resonant than an elliptical. I use an elliptical with my new, or like new vinyl.
Ok, I see where you're coming from. A conical stylus with it's large scanning radius will bypass many of the finer crags in the groove wall, but this is has nothing to do with resonance as I can see. The best example I have for the quiet playing of noisy records is the Shure M44-7; not only is it conical but has the drooping output at the top frequency that characterizes the Shure "sound". Again, this is not related to resonance but merely the masking of noises by minimizing them.
 
I am using a real simple "formula" of distilled water, 91% isopropyl, and a couple of drops of dishwash rinse to break surface tension. and I use it with a DiscWasher style brush. I really cannot see how, or why, it needs to be more elaborate than that.

I used the method you discuss. Worked fine for some albums, others not so much.
the goal is clean, pleasurable listening.

Or in the case of this thread, an actual chemist.

I'd posit vince and his amazing answers to random questions to be all the evidence I need. Dude went waaaaaaaay beyond my pay grade, and nothing he has suggested to me has harmed my records. In fact, my records are about as clean as they can get.

We are all looking for the same results.
 
Perfectly reasonable. The "voodoo chemical" Tergitol, mentioned above is pretty much the same as your dishwash rinse (they're both used as surfactants) with the minor difference being the Tergitol is non-ionic which theoretically (err, hypothetically?) could reduce static charge. Some people are adding conditioners or de-molding agents to maybe help with other climate related effects. I don't know if it's voodoo so much as it is experimentation.



And maybe it doesn't need to be more elaborate than that, but sometimes I'm fine with McDonald's, while other times I want Five Guys and other times still I want steak. They all serve the same functional purpose which is to keep me alive. I don't go around slapping Taco Bell out of people's hands because I don't see how or why it needs to be more elaborate than some meat in between slices of bread. A world with just McDonald's sounds like a bleak one indeed.

And kind of a silly analogy to use with cleaning vinyl.
 
I used the method you discuss. Worked fine for some albums, others not so much.
the goal is clean, pleasurable listening.



I'd posit vince and his amazing answers to random questions to be all the evidence I need. Dude went waaaaaaaay beyond my pay grade, and nothing he has suggested to me has harmed my records. In fact, my records are about as clean as they can get.

We are all looking for the same results.
Sure, I get that, but watch some of the videos posted on YouTube for some high comedic relief. The real funny part is that most of the people showing their voodoo off say "it works great", yet, provide no tangible proof, after 20-30 steps of OCD and torture.
 
Sure, I get that, but watch some of the videos posted on YouTube for some high comedic relief. The real funny part is that most of the people showing their voodoo off say "it works great", yet, provide no tangible proof, after 20-30 steps of OCD and torture.


Some people are obsessive that way, whether it is golf, cooking, or picking their nose.
just human nature, I suppose.

Me, I love the challenge of bringing back someone's forgotten gem with various cleaning methods, digital software, etc.
right now, my fledgling Brubeck collection of vinyl, all second hand and tired, could be downloaded from youtube with superior results, but where is the fun in that?
 
Some people are obsessive that way, whether it is golf, cooking, or picking their nose.
just human nature, I suppose.

Me, I love the challenge of bringing back someone's forgotten gem with various cleaning methods, digital software, etc.
right now, my fledgling Brubeck collection of vinyl, all second hand and tired, could be downloaded from youtube with superior results, but where is the fun in that?
You are missing my point here. The point being that scratches, warps, imperfections, can all cause pops and clicks. Quite often I see people practically scrubbing the grooves out of their vinyl, wondering why they cannot get rid of clicks and pops. And, the beauty of a turntable is indeed interchangeable cartridges. Yet, they play stuff with an elliptical, and then wonder why the noise is so pronounced. That's one reason, A conical does a much better job with "thrift store" vinyl, as it is less resonant. Use one with a carbon fiber cantilever, and you have even more of a chance of better sounding vintage vinyl.
 
And you are missing mine. First, let's talk about your preferred method of cleaning

For many of the worst albums I acquire, it is insufficient. Mold, fungus, tar, etc will scoff at that.

With newish vinyl, sure, your method is fine.

As for the vinyl itself, it's far tougher than you might think.

I'll agree, youtube vids are a mixed bag, so don't trouble yourself with the obvious goofs.

In other words, you and I aren't the police of the internet, so don't feel obliged to correct all the things you don't agree with.

Far less stressful that way, friend.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom