• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
Than a conical? I do believe so.

Why would one stylus shape be more resonant than another? Tip mass and cantilever material/length are going to contribute to the resonant frequency, but I can't see how shape can affect the degree of resonance. That's new one.
 
Why would one stylus shape be more resonant than another? Tip mass and cantilever material/length are going to contribute to the resonant frequency, but I can't see how shape can affect the degree of resonance. That's new one.
It's news to me, too.
 
Stylus and cartridge play a very big roll as to what you hear in the grooves when it comes to "Noise". That's why I feel all the record reviews people want to post saying a record sounds crappy, but then don't want to say what equipment they used to base their opinion on.
 
So the greater the amount of resonance there is the more pops and clicks you'll hear? Does this mean if I'm hearing a lot of pops/clicks I have a tonearm/cartridge/stylus mismatch?
 
Records get dirty. I've used Discwasher since the 70s. I was never happy with the results until i read Vince's formula and bough H*ball's magic wand. I am buying new sleeves now. I pulled my parents, heavy smokers, 78s from the 50s and random LPs from the 60s and 70s to clean and the results were outstanding on Dual with black Grado and a Clearaudio w/ $1000 cart. YMMV but I am disappointed how this turned out as a fairly new AKer but long time audio guy.
 
So the greater the amount of resonance there is the more pops and clicks you'll hear? Does this mean if I'm hearing a lot of pops/clicks I have a tonearm/cartridge/stylus mismatch?
Is this directed at me?

If so I never made mention of resonance, or cartridge mismatch.

EDIT
This is in fact what I am talking about...
http://audiokarma.org/forums/index.php?threads/after-40-years-i-finally-get-it.686370/#post-9266150

Or this post a member just made..
http://audiokarma.org/forums/index.php?threads/denon-dl-110-sumiko-blue-point-no-2-comparo.709883/
 
Last edited:
Is this directed at me?

If so I never made mention of resonance, or cartridge mismatch.


Nah. Arthur Smith tossed that log into pile:

Most of the pops and cracks, even after extensive cleaning, are from vinyl scratches, or using a more resonant stylus, such as an elliptical. I am not quite sure why very few seem to pick up on this. You can clean these things till your fingers are blue, but dust and particles are only part of the problem.
 
What Arthur Smith brought up particularly interested me because I have some records that look absolutely spotless after cleaning, yet sound too pop/crackily. I was hoping I could blame my cartridge and change that instead of having to replace the LPs!

Maybe a LOMC (like the Blackbird mentioned) will do the trick. I hope I can go a cheaper route!
 
Mike look at the links I just posted in #618

Yup, I don't doubt that different carts and stylus profiles handle noise differently. Haven't seen anything that connects stylus profile with resonance, though, which was the claim.

And I've used Tergitol for years and love it as a record cleaner!
 
Yup, I don't doubt that different carts and stylus profiles handle noise differently. Haven't seen anything that connects stylus profile with resonance, though, which was the claim.

And I've used Tergitol for years and love it as a record cleaner!
My point is not stylus profile but cartridge quality.
I find that a lot of people who are obsessive in record cleaning and Debbie downers for new record remasters/ pressings also fall into the lower quality equipment catigory.
That said records do need to be cleaned, but how much if the cart is not ticking out every pop.
 
The stuff above. If there was an exact science to cleaning records, than why are these 1000's of formulas, and rituals? And, no two alike?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom