• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
My Results: I recently built a vacuum record cleaning machine and cleaned some used lp's I had purchased using 25% IPA 75% distilled water and Johnson's Baby Shampoo. These records were filthy and most of the pops/crackles were not heard anymore . Then this thread was started and I decided to use safer, better ingredients. I mixed a batch of Vince's Ultimate Wash Solution, post #412 page 21. I re-cleaned the previous cleaned lp's and noticed spots that had not come clean before were now gone.

A few other used lp's I have do not sound the best. They sounded muffled with not much treble/cymbals. After cleaning with Vince's wash, these records sound much better, a little brighter with more treble/cymbals.

Yes, there is some work involved in finding, buying, mixing, storing Vince's recipe, but I feel it's worth the effort. What I'm not too excited about is cleaning all my lp's and storing the cleaned records/jackets in new poly sleeves! Oh well, it's a lot easier than porting cylinder heads, which I should be doing before summer.
 
Last edited:
Those are quite impressive results tcss, and glad to hear you are using quality reagents. I am not, however, comfortable with calling this "Vince's wash" as I did not invent non-ionic detergents nor am the first to use them to clean LPs. The preservationists deserve all the credit, I just advocate their formulations in ways people here might be able to utilize. That said, I am curious about the increased response you are experiencing in the higher frequencies. I've noticed this as well, but cannot attribute it to any specific physical condition. Anybody have ideas on this?
Cylinder head porting: now there is an area that I wouldn't know where to even start. Awesome that you have keen mechanical abilities and have extended them to building your own VCM.
 
Last edited:
As mentioned previously, vinyl records contain stabilizers added to prevent PVC breakdown during heat pressing. These stabilizers are metal stearate compounds and are important as they also scavenge the acid breakdown product (HCl) produced as a record ages or is exposed to UV light. Once produced, the acid causes further breakdown (the reaction is autocatalytic). As these stabilizers are not covalently bound and contain similar long chain hydrophobic regions, I was wondering whether they could inadvertently be removed by the detergents used in our washes.

After asking around, it appears this isn’t a concern. The easiest way to illustrate the reasoning is to think of a dirty bathtub: Soap scum is a result of metals in hard water reacting with the stearates in soap where they form an insoluble precipitate that attaches to the tub surface. So we have delt with metal stearates in normal life. As you know if you’ve ever tried, this scum cannot easily be removed with detergent or alcohol. Remedies for its removal typically involve using extremes in pH like Vinegar (acetic acid pH 2.4) or ammonia (pH 11.6) which work well. We wash at neutral pH so the ability of our wash to solubilize and extract these important stabilizers is very low, particularly as they are incorporated into the vinyl polymer matrix.

This also illustrates yet another reason to avoid the use of extreme pH commercial home cleaners on our records.
 
My Results: I recently built a vacuum record cleaning machine and cleaned some used lp's I had purchased using 25% IPA 75% distilled water and Johnson's Baby Shampoo. These records were filthy and most of the pops/crackles were not heard anymore . Then this thread was started and I decided to use safer, better ingredients. I mixed a batch of Vince's Ultimate Wash Solution, post #412 page 21. I re-cleaned the previous cleaned lp's and noticed spots that had not come clean before were now gone.
And if you just cleaned them twice do you not think they would have gotten cleaner anyway, even with just water?
A stylus in fact helps clean a record that has not been played in quite a while or ever. If you wash a record getting it cleaner, then play the stylus will loosen deeper and more dirt. Washing it again will always help, along with playing a record more. A record new and old should not be judged by the first play, play it at least three times to have your stylus mate and polish the groove.
 
Last edited:
Soap scum is a result of metals in hard water reacting with the stearates in soap where they form an insoluble precipitate that attaches to the tub surface. So we have delt with metal stearates in normal life. As you know if you’ve ever tried, this scum cannot easily be removed with detergent or alcohol. Remedies for its removal typically involve using extremes in pH like Vinegar (acetic acid pH 2.4) or ammonia (pH 11.6) which work well. We wash at neutral pH so the ability of our wash to solubilize and extract these important stabilizers is very low, particularly as they are incorporated into the vinyl polymer matrix.

This also illustrates yet another reason to avoid the use of extreme pH commercial home cleaners on our records.
Interesting. This also explains why PVA glue is effective at removing soap scum from vinyl when an approved Tergitol wash won't touch it.

How does soap scum wind up on records one might ask? I guess it's when unscrupulous vendors try to pass off a VG as NM by cleaning it with a dirty, worn out RCM wand using a crappy home-made mixture without bothering to perform even a single rinse.

These records are out there and there's plenty of them, IME. :mad:
 
And if you just cleaned them twice do you not think they would have gotten cleaner anyway, even with just water?
A stylus in fact helps clean a record that has not been played in quite a while or ever. If you wash a record getting it cleaner, then play the stylus will loosen deeper and more dirt. Washing it again will always help, along with playing a record more. A record new and old should not be judged by the first play, play it at least three times to have your stylus mate and polish the groove.


I figured someone would think this, but did not want to make a long story out of my post. I cleaned some of these lp's 3 times with the first solution tiring to get them clean. As for playing a record to help clean it and rewash, I tried this hoping to clear up a noisy lp. it did not help. I have too many records and not enough time to clean more than once and it will take me a few years to listen to each one once. I am not going to play them and not listen to them. The lp's I purchased in the 70's look clean, a few paper scuffs and scratch free, except the first ones I purchased pre teenager and the record player I used back then. It's these used lp's I have been buying that are in terrible shape. My wife says I'm weird when I show her some of my 40 year old records ( and jackets ) that looks like new and I have not cleaned any of them yet.
 
Ah-oh. The Windexers have followed us here with more of their wive's tales! ;)

Years ago there was a school of thought that records should not be cleaned as the stylus would do the work. This has been entirely disproven. While large dry particles like paper can be pushed away, the high heat from stylus friction can actually make groove-bound organic contaminants more difficult to remove. This is why we clean records before playing them. It is like (You know I like crude analogies) cleaning a dirty dish before or after it was baked. Food comes right off with water and a little detergent on the unbaked dish. You'll need something super strong like oven cleaner for baked on organics.
 
Vince, I really have no skin in this game, since I don't clean my albums with Windex.

Aren't you just the slightest bit embarrassed about your condescending attitude?
Oh, come on, the huge wink didn't given indication of where I was coming from? People are getting way too serious here lately.
 
A little background might help: 427 and I got into it on another thread regarding windex and that comment was meant for him. As a self-described smart ass, I'm sure he got the joke, and he is not a windex user either. Sorry if it offended anyone.
 
Vince, you're a wonderful resource, and I feel your experience in this field gives you more liberty than, say, me. I know beans about chemistry, and with your help, I have to glue only the most difficult of records.

Which means more listening time.

I know, I know, you don't like the glue, but for those records where it's that or toss, I glue. Sometimes, I save them.
 
Vince, you're a wonderful resource, and I feel your experience in this field gives you more liberty than, say, me. I know beans about chemistry, and with your help, I have to glue only the most difficult of records.

Which means more listening time.

I know, I know, you don't like the glue, but for those records where it's that or toss, I glue. Sometimes, I save them.
Thanks James. And I'm learning to like glue because, like you say, it works on the most difficult records. We all learn from each other.
 
No worries. All my posts in this thread are deleted and people can now ask the great painter 427 all about record cleaning. I've moved to another forum. Good luck to all!

Moderator Edit: I restored the content. The author's departure was of his own choosing. He did not want his name attached to AK, so it has been removed.
Luvvinvinyl
 
Last edited by a moderator:
As someone who has stayed abreast of this conversation, though also opted to stay out of it, I now have to comment.

Because this quote right here...

And I'm learning to like glue because, like you say, there is no question it works on difficult records. We all learn from each other

...has me floored.

After reading all million or so pages of this thread, and the other thousand of the 'Windex' one, I am amazed to read you suggest the possibility that wood-glue might actually be a safe(ish) alternative - even if only for stubborn records, and I'm curious to hear how you'll make it less acidic.

I, myself, have used the wood-glue method. Several times, it presented no problem, and fantastic results. But one time, it did not go as planned, and turned out slightly disastrous - only to be remedied by, you guessed it, more glue to remove the glue that seemed to permanently adhere to my record.

I got lucky, and Buffett's Greatist Hits is a silent gem now. But I also learned a valuable lesson in what risks are involved in unconventional methods.

Vince, don't take me pointing this out the wrong way. I've learned a lot from you while lurking this thread and the other. Enough so that I've tracked down the tergitol stuff to make my own cleaning mixture and be done with it knowing I'm using the best known formula to clean records without harming them. :thumbsup:

But I also respect the innovation and creativity for this age-old problem that others are bringing to the (turn)table.

The baby soap idea has me intrigued since it's powerful enough yet gentle enough to clean the crap off of babies.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom