• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
And you are missing mine. First, let's talk about your preferred method of cleaning

For many of the worst albums I acquire, it is insufficient. Mold, fungus, tar, etc will scoff at that.

With newish vinyl, sure, your method is fine.

As for the vinyl itself, it's far tougher than you might think.

I'll agree, youtube vids are a mixed bag, so don't trouble yourself with the obvious goofs.

In other words, you and I aren't the police of the internet, so don't feel obliged to correct all the things you don't agree with.

Far less stressful that way, friend.

I agree with the spirit of your intent. However, myself, I prefer listening to music as opposed to mixing up formulas and spending hours cleaning records. A
 
Arthur as in your FaceBook discussions, you can't try to convince people to see things your way only, in the different methods of cleaning records. Bashing those methods is really counter productive. Your posts here as in FB are super negative of anyone that thinks beyond your method. An actual chemist has weighed in on this discussion by starting this thread. I as many others have learned volumes with posts like this. At the end of the day it's personal preference and what helps you sleep good at night pretty much. The final answer to listening to an LP at it's finest is multi faceted and deep or shallow, this is one of them. I was hoping directing you here might help you see the light (and hear the sound!)
 
Arthur as in your FaceBook discussions, you can't try to convince people to see things your way only, in the different methods of cleaning records. Bashing those methods is really counter productive. Your posts here as in FB are super negative of anyone that thinks beyond your method. An actual chemist has weighed in on this discussion by starting this thread. I as many others have learned volumes with posts like this. At the end of the day it's personal preference and what helps you sleep good at night pretty much. The final answer to listening to an LP at it's finest is multi faceted and deep or shallow, this is one of them. I was hoping directing you here might help you see the light (and hear the sound!)
I listen to music, not chemistry. But thanks.
 
Then why post on this thread? Some things don't change.
Why? Because I am trying to help folks to realize that cleaning is only the start. And that the clicks and pops they hear, quite often, are caused by things other than dust and particles. And that there are alternative cartridges and syli available that are less resonant, that will minimize the noise.
 
Why? Because I am trying to help folks to realize that cleaning is only the start. And that the clicks and pops they hear, quite often, are caused by things other than dust and particles. And that there are alternative cartridges and syli available that are less resonant, that will minimize the noise.


I understand what you're trying to get across - All the cleaning in the world won't change some albums, and certain styli/carts are more forgiving.

I think we all understand that, and thanks for pointing that out. As for cleaning, there's a lot of ways to skin that particular cat. I'd be interested in your opinion on my thread, seen here.

http://audiokarma.org/forums/index....of-fact-fiction-and-collective-wisdom.633407/

Now, would you be so kind as to recommend some of these combinations?? I'd be VERY interested in hearing what carts/stylus combos are good to reduce overall pops/clicks. I have a huge library of some pretty hard to find stuff, and I'd PREFER to listen to the record, instead of my digitally corrected version.

This thread has already lost us a very erudite member, who was kind enough to lend his expertise. I'll plead once more, please keep it civil. Thank you, everyone.
 
I have had nice success with the Audio Technica P-Mount cartridge, the 3482P, with a conical stylus. I think the carts real secret sauce is the carbon fiber cantilever, making it much less resonant, while de-emphasizing the clicks and pops associated with the dreaded "thrift store vinyl". Yes, it can be fitted to a 1/2" mount with a simple adaptor that maybe sells for $5.00. And, being a P-Mount, it tracks at a whopping 1 1/4 grams, for those afraid they are going to carve their vinyl up.
 
Arthur I think the majority of members here are quite aware of alternative cartridges and have quite a number of expensive tables with exotic carts, and it shouldn't be our place to inform them that it might be their thrift store LP's are all full of scratches. I can only assume that they along with myself are quite aware that scratches can't be cleaned out, and for one I don't have a bunch of crappy scratched records nor do I have any P-Mount AT carts, or even any conical stylus for that matter.

You have posted your formula, great if you like yours better use it. We don't need you using a hammer to constantly keep informing us of what you use, once is enough, and then let others make their choice. I read the OP's post and honestly his information was quite informative, highly educational in the material he provided so the last thing we need is someone relentlessly pushing their needless opposition to his information. We almost lost all this info let us not have someone keep pushing the envelope to the point it gets shut down again. Personally I think the early post with such great information would be a good sticky, I mean we all try to get help from those who have knowledge beyond ours, and once we do, we should be thankful of the advice rather than dogmatically posting negative comments regarding the helpful posters.
 
Last edited:
In all fairness, Ken, I actually DID request a suggested stylus/cart combo that might be a little easier on beat up stuff.

And I don't use beat up records because I'm cool, or poor, or some other reason. Mostly, it's just all I find around here, and many of these old records are quite rare.

And again, let's not mistake scratches for something cleaning can remove. This seems pretty self-explanatory. I'm listening to Drive By Truckers (Southern Rock Opera) and there's noise in it, tho I literally JUST opened it. Listened before AND after a spindisc/scrub with triton/rinse, and that helped a few spots (one where the needle jumped first time around) but still quite noisy.

Some vinyl just sucks.
 
Good in that it is enough for 5 gallons of cleaning mix.
Making that much cleaning mix from so little ingredient is why I was willing to go ahead, even if the price per ml seemed silly. Right now I use the cleaning solution from Spin Clean. I don't even want to know what 5 gallons of that would cost, so in the end, not a silly price per ml at all. Next up: Mix up a batch and give it a try using the same process I follow now. More later...
 
Arthur I think the majority of members here are quite aware of alternative cartridges and have quite a number of expensive tables with exotic carts, and it shouldn't be our place to inform them that it might be their thrift store LP's are all full of scratches. I can only assume that they along with myself are quite aware that scratches can't be cleaned out, and for one I don't have a bunch of crappy scratched records nor do I have any P-Mount AT carts, or even any conical stylus for that matter.

You have posted your formula, great if you like yours better use it. We don't need you using a hammer to constantly keep informing us of what you use, once is enough, and then let others make their choice. I read the OP's post and honestly his information was quite informative, highly educational in the material he provided so the last thing we need is someone relentlessly pushing their needless opposition to his information. We almost lost all this info let us not have someone keep pushing the envelope to the point it gets shut down again. Personally I think the early post with such great information would be a good sticky, I mean we all try to get help from those who have knowledge beyond ours, and once we do, we should be thankful of the advice rather than dogmatically posting negative comments regarding the helpful posters.
Using one styli/cart combo to play all your vinyl might be ill advised, at best. Isn't that why, in part, they are interchangeable? Amazing that very few seem to take advantage of this great feature.
 
For some they are interchangeable, for others not so much. Back when I ran a Tri-Planar a cart swap was a good two plus hour exercise all-in, so I just didn't do it. That's one of the reasons I only buy NM records.
 
For some they are interchangeable, for others not so much. Back when I ran a Tri-Planar a cart swap was a good two plus hour exercise all-in, so I just didn't do it. That's one of the reasons I only buy NM records.
A built headshell, once built, should not take two hours to interchange. If you limit yourself to "NM" vinyl, your listening is going to be limited as a result.
 
You assume every arm has an interchangeable headshell.

My listening isn't limited because I've a minimum condition I'll accept.
 
Using one styli/cart combo to play all your vinyl might be ill advised, at best. Isn't that why, in part, they are interchangeable? Amazing that very few seem to take advantage of this great feature.
Arther your 52 years old, most members here are around that age. Are we all stupid? I mean really your acting like no body knows anything, but you are showing a limited knowledge on your own part.
If you ever seen a high end tonearm you would know they don't have removable head shells. So if I follow you should I by lesser quality arm?

I also can't afford 7-8 $2,500 cartridges, should I sell them off and buy 10 $150 cartridges?
 
Arther your 52 years old, most members here are around that age. Are we all stupid? I mean really your acting like no body knows anything, but you are showing a limited knowledge on your own part.
If you ever seen a high end tonearm you would know they don't have removable head shells. So if I follow you should I by lesser quality arm?

I also can't afford 7-8 $2,500 cartridges, should I sell them off and buy 10 $150 cartridges?
And, I know how to spell names. -Arthur
 
I tried a carbon cantilever once....(Tonar JT-555)...didn't play more than a few records with it. I bought it because I was curious what an affordable, non-metallic cantilever would sound. Turns out on simple acoustic stuff like jazz and chamber music...which it did best in my opinion...it reproduced a harmonic texture obscured by colouration, and anything of a highly dynamic nature like rock or orchestral, the sound just became confused. If it had a conical stylus it might've served well for hiding surface imperfections, but the sound quality itself simply didn't convey what I'm looking for. As far as noise reduction is served, it was a bit like throwing the baby out with the bathwater.

The cartridge is not a bad deal for what you get, and I'm sure it would fit better on a more forgiving or modest system.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom