• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not at all, the info here is open source. I would wish there would be some credit to the source (AK) by some of these organizations. Maybe some contribute, I don't know. That said, this new formulation has cost a lot of time and money to research and develop. I personally paid for half the cost and think it would be silly to just throw it out there for people to monetize. It needs protections first. I guess I've come to that realization and succumb to partners' wishes. My post was just explaining that, as previously I stated I was anxious to share immediately.

I wouldnt expect anyone to freely share their research into a product that they plan on putting on the market.. Im also not surprised that someone took your previous recipe and marketed it without mentioning where you could find the recipe for free online..
 
I wouldnt expect anyone to freely share their research into a product that they plan on putting on the market.. Im also not surprised that someone took your previous recipe and marketed it without mentioning where you could find the recipe for free online..
True, but not my recipe...OUR recipe. Many here contributed to testing and fine tuning it. I'm not surprised or upset about it...I'm merely commenting that I'm going a different path with this new mix.
 
It might not be a bad idea to move the discussion to the members area when/if you decide to discuss the details of your new research.. Even though you are applying for patents, it would still take money and time to enforce them..
 
It might not be a bad idea to move the discussion to the members area when/if you decide to discuss the details of your new research.. Even though you are applying for patents, it would still take money and time to enforce them..
Unless the ingredients are proprietary, I'm not sure a patent is enforceable at all. Minor substitutions in ingredients and quantities can render any form of infringement difficult to prove.

The best protection is to simply not disclose the formula publicly.
 
Unless the ingredients are proprietary, I'm not sure a patent is enforceable at all. Minor substitutions in ingredients and quantities can render any form of infringement difficult to prove.

I dont know much about patent law, but I would be surprised if a new record cleaning product would even be patentable.. It would have to be both novel, and non obvious to others who work in that field..
 
Thanks all, for contributing.

Very good stuff!

I'm having a tough time finding Hepastat 256 in the Toronto area. Will any quat do? I found Epquat by Lawrason local to me which apparantly does all the same germ/virus/bacteria killing that Hepastat does.

Would Epquat be ok, and what are the differences if anyone knows?

Thanks guys!
The number of uses for quats is surprising. I am in the Toronto area and so no Hepastat256. However, you can try a pool algaecide instead. Acquarius Liquid Algaecide from Canadian Tire: 5% N-Alkyl (40% C12, 50% C14, 10% C16) Di-ethyl Benzyl Ammonium Chloride. No other ingredients listed though I imagine the pale green colour is a die of some sort. Should do the trick as an anti-static agent.
 
The number of uses for quats is surprising. I am in the Toronto area and so no Hepastat256. However, you can try a pool algaecide instead. Acquarius Liquid Algaecide from Canadian Tire: 5% N-Alkyl (40% C12, 50% C14, 10% C16) Di-ethyl Benzyl Ammonium Chloride. No other ingredients listed though I imagine the pale green colour is a die of some sort. Should do the trick as an anti-static agent.
What kind of concentration do you recommend for the pool algaecide? I have some of that around and have been tempted to mess with it, but I'd love a starting point.
 
Unless the ingredients are proprietary, I'm not sure a patent is enforceable at all. Minor substitutions in ingredients and quantities can render any form of infringement difficult to prove.
The best protection is to simply not disclose the formula publicly.

I dont know much about patent law, but I would be surprised if a new record cleaning product would even be patentable.. It would have to be both novel, and non obvious to others who work in that field..

These are very good points. Record cleaning solutions have been historically patented (the Discwasher fluids for example) but they typically are combined with an applicator device. The group I'm collaborating with is mainly interested in my fluid to go with the device they've developed and they wish to pursue patents. I am not interested in any if this as I feel there isn't enough money in it to be significant. I do it for fun. I have a version of the fluid that anyone can make and am free to share it (the part I solely payed for), I just won't until they have their protections in place. Easy to argue that it is novel and not obvious, just follow the pharmaceutical models. Again, it's not about the money, it's about principle to me: you should not profit from others ideas unless you at least participate, credit, or compensate them (I know it happens all the time, but I no longer wish to facilitate it). I will also repeat that the quat based formulations described in this thread work just fine. The new formulation only offers minor practical improvements.
 
Last edited:
I apologize for being away from this for awhile. We just finalized a new formulation. I regret that I will not be openly sharing the recipe here however, at least not until patents are filed. During our research, we uncovered a number of companies marketing products (and even services...e.g. P.V.F.) based on the previous quat recipe and it is obvious they obtained the recipe from this thread as this is where it was first shared and discussed. Unless they are contributing to AK, it seems silly to be doing their research for free while they profit. None of their websites or marketing info mentions this site or credits any members and they even claim the idea (including some that actually use Hepastat) is their own. The quat recipes here are now "open-source" and they work very well so all is good.

Wow, that's excellent. After the night I spent in the emergency room getting Hepastat flushed out of my face and eyeballs, the idea of a functional commercial product has gained some traction in my eyes (get it?). Remember people wear eye protection when working with chemicals -- especially when being a dumb-ass and prying the dispenser top off the Hepastat bottle.

Not at all, the info here is open source. I would wish there would be some credit to the source (AK) by some of these organizations. Maybe some contribute, I don't know. That said, this new formulation has cost a lot of time and money to research and develop. I personally paid for half the cost and think it would be silly to just throw it out there for people to monetize. It needs protections first. I guess I've come to that realization and succumb to partners' wishes. My post was just explaining that, as previously in this thread I posted I would share it immediately.

Yeah, I understand this. I've done some day-job work in open-source online community and while most of the people understand the *spirit* in which information is shared, others can only see shortcuts and $$ signs.

I think phantom's irritation is justified. I'm also not surprised that there are products taking advantage of the work done here without giving recognition, because people suck.

Indeed, see above.

It might not be a bad idea to move the discussion to the members area when/if you decide to discuss the details of your new research.. Even though you are applying for patents, it would still take money and time to enforce them..
Unfortunately(and I'm not saying this just because I'm not a paying member), this probably isn't going to help. Just because someone pays an AK membership doesn't mean they participate in these discussions and share their wisdom, experiences and so on. In fact, I've seen cases where people have used their membership or other financial support of a community or other website as a justification for profiting on the work shared. As Engineer Nate says:
people suck.
 
What kind of concentration do you recommend for the pool algaecide? I have some of that around and have been tempted to mess with it, but I'd love a starting point.
Now, I am not using this with an ultrasonic cleaner, just as an anti-static additive in my home-made D4 replacement fluid. The bottle notes it is in a 5% concentration (assume 95% water) so take your guidance from that. I would work with a very small amount (1-2%) in any solution you mix up, but that is not based on much use as yet - I am still running through my bottles of Spinclean fluid, so not using a lot of this yet. A little more on ADBAC from another post of mine regarding the Acquarius product:

n-alkyl(40% C12, 50% C14, 10% C16)
Dimethyl Benzyl Ammonium Chlorides 5%

(The same product is available in a 15% formulation)
There is no listing of other ingredients or of PH of the mixture. There is a Canadian government control document under the P.C.P. (Pest Control Products) Act for product 16898 that will take you (well, a google search will take you) to an evaluation document for Alkyl Dimethyl Benzyl Ammonium Chloride (ADBAC) which describes its use as an algaecide, disinfectant, and wood preserver in 100+ registered products in Canada (16898 is the Canadian Tire Algaecide). On page 15 they note that "ADBAC is hydrolytically stable under abiotic and buffered conditions over the pH 5–9 range". I think that means I can assume the PH of the algaecide is in the same range so no more than a mild acid or mild base. There is no mention of the use of this product as an anti-static agent. Does this sound promising?
 
Librarian...I remember when this happened to you. How are your eyes? Any lasting effects? I actually thought about you the other day when I opened a bottle of hair product for my wife and it got me right in the eye. It contained a lot of chemicals (including a quat!) and burned like hell. Up at my house above 8000ft, even opening a yogurt is hazardous as most everything is packaged near sea level. It all goes Poof. I wear contacts so it was really painful trying to get the contact out with such a sensitive red eye. Anyways, hope all is well and your experience serves as a continuous warning to us all.
 
Last edited:
The bottle notes it is in a 5% concentration (assume 95% water) so take your guidance from that. I would work with a very small amount (1-2%) in any solution you mix up, but that is not based on much use as yet - I am still running through my bottles of Spinclean fluid, so not using a lot of this yet. A little more on ADBAC from another post of mine regarding the Acquarius product:

n-alkyl(40% C12, 50% C14, 10% C16)
Dimethyl Benzyl Ammonium Chlorides 5%

Interesting. For some reason I thought I had the same stuff but I just checked my bottle downstairs. It's a totally different brand and everything. So much for my memory-- the one I have is Halt50 Algaecide which is listed on the bottle as a 50% concentration of Didecyl Dimethyl Ammonium Chloride. A quick search for the MSDS shows it has another 10 percent ethanol, with the balance water. So yeah. Totally different. At this point I think I'll just keep this for the spa and the hepastat for the vinyl (and my eye protection for both).
 
Librarian...I remember when this happened to you. How are your eyes? Any lasting effects? I actually thought about you the other day when I opened a bottle of hair product for my wife and it got me right in the eye. It contained a lot of chemicals (including a quat!) and burned like hell. Up at my house above 8000ft, even opening a yogurt is hazardous as most everything is packaged near sea level. It all goes Poof. I wear contacts so it was really painful trying to get the contact out with such a sensitive red eye. Anyways, hope all is well and your experience serves as a continuous warning to us all.

Thanks phantomrebel! Fortunately zero lasting impact on my eyes, though they were sensitive for a good six months. Had I been wearing contacts it could have been much worse, the doc said. Surprisingly the worst long-term damage was a spot on my wrist where the full-strength hepastat snuck under my watchband. I took multiple showers in this period after the mishap, but the hepastat didn't get fully cleared away until it started burning a week later later, forcing me to remove the band and try to clean my wrist. The burn just wouldn't heal -- it'd scar up then become irritated again and start over with the burn again. Eventually they biopsied it (nothing) then finally my doctor froze the scar with nitrogen and it healed up fine. Whew!

Careful out there everyone -- hepastat, hair products, yogurt -- keep it all where it belongs (cereal bowl, hair, and records!) and away from your eyes and flesh!
 
Last edited:
Interesting. For some reason I thought I had the same stuff but I just checked my bottle downstairs. It's a totally different brand and everything. So much for my memory-- the one I have is Halt50 Algaecide which is listed on the bottle as a 50% concentration of Didecyl Dimethyl Ammonium Chloride. A quick search for the MSDS shows it has another 10 percent ethanol, with the balance water. So yeah. Totally different. At this point I think I'll just keep this for the spa and the hepastat for the vinyl (and my eye protection for both).
That compound works well in record cleaning solutions. It has both antimicrobial and anti-static properties (in fact, it is VERY similar to distearyl dimethyl ammonium chloride, one of the first fabric softeners). The only issue is that you have to keep stocks at concentrations that don't solidify at cold temperatures (where it form wax-like flakes- Note that some of the long chain surfactants in Hepastat can do this as well). Since you are using a commercial preparation this shouldn't be an issue. Store it at room temp as nothing will grow in it. I also wouldn't worry about pH since it is only slightly basic and you are likely diluting it 1000-fold or more in your cleaning solution. Obviously, follow precautions listed on bottle ;).

This reminds me...I saw an earlier post where someone's Triton became cloudy when stored in the fridge. This is normal....just warm it up and it will go back in.
 
So... who's got the best recipe for use in a Spin Clean?

I'll tell you one thing. Regardless if it's on here for free, I would still pay for a gallon because I don't want to buy/store large amounts of chems like the ones mentioned in previous posts when I only need a drop or two.

If someone is monetizing a recipe that is on here for free without saying anything, well that sucks. In fact, it's bad marketing because I believe that the vast majority of AKers would be most likely to buy a record cleaning solution from a recipe that we saw here and that has been discussed extensively as well as used and reviewed.

Someone not only sucks, but is missing out on a captive audience that wants/needs the product.
 
The first batch of Hepastat I bought, did in fact get cold enough to form a wax like cap. I remember asking you about this. I ended up giving that to a friend who details cars, so it didn't go to waste. This new batch of 256/triton has been fine. I set aside a bottle when I made the first new batch, and probably won't ever open it, just to see if it will go funky. It still looks like it did, and its stored in a cabinet so no direct sunlight, and temp controlled.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom