• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
The method I use is 1) apply cleaning solution to the record (from a spray bottle) and make several revolutions with a goat hair brush, 2) vacuum, 3) apply distilled water and vacuum (record appearance is that of partial surfactant), 4) apply a second application of distilled water and this time the entire record beads up as expected and as is needed to demonstrate that for all intents and purposes the cleaning solution is totally removed, and vacuum, 5) remove from homemade cleaning "machine", and allow to air dry at least 45 minutes before placing in a MOFO sleeve.

I use pretty much the same method though I don't typically wait 45 minutes to put the clean record in its new sleeve. I do write the date I cleaned the record on the new sleeve.

I'm looking forward to @EngineerNate posting his updated spreadsheet based upon the reduced amounts of Triton and quat cleaner noted by @phantomrebel.
 
I use pretty much the same method though I don't typically wait 45 minutes to put the clean record in its new sleeve. I do write the date I cleaned the record on the new sleeve.

I'm looking forward to @EngineerNate posting his updated spreadsheet based upon the reduced amounts of Triton and quat cleaner noted by @phantomrebel.

Sorry guys! Got home from vacation yesterday and the wife put on a movie and the couch looked very appealing. Forgot completely about updating the sheets. :D
 
Nate, the only sheets you are compelled to update, are the ones you sleep between.

The wife gets mad when I don't help with that particular task. Her standards are a bit higher than mine I'm afraid. :D

I do think I promised to update the calculation spreadsheets somewhere here a few posts back though so I'll try to get that done by the end of the week.
 
Guess I better order some hepastat now that it’s available again
Been using tergikleen and alcohol which seems to do well enough but no harm adding a bit of hepastat

As to people selling the same formula, I’ve seen it on eBay and vinyl stack sends a sample out now with purchases.
Comes with the territory if the internet, someone always wants to make a buck on someone else’s work
 
OK, so I'm reading this from the beginning and I'm only up to Page 24/Post 461, but I ran across a solution that I'm curious about.
It's "active " ingredient is 99% sterile water; it's "inactive" ingredients are sodium chloride,sodium phosphate dibasic, sodium phosphate monobasic. It comes in a 32oz non-resealable plastic container, so it's sterile until you open it.
Is this usable in any form or fashion?
 
The wife gets mad when I don't help with that particular task. Her standards are a bit higher than mine I'm afraid. :D

I do think I promised to update the calculation spreadsheets somewhere here a few posts back though so I'll try to get that done by the end of the week.
Waiting with great expectation!
 
The method I use is 1) apply cleaning solution to the record (from a spray bottle) and make several revolutions with a goat hair brush, 2) vacuum, 3) apply distilled water and vacuum (record appearance is that of partial surfactant), 4) apply a second application of distilled water and this time the entire record beads up as expected and as is needed to demonstrate that for all intents and purposes the cleaning solution is totally removed, and vacuum, 5) remove from homemade cleaning "machine", and allow to air dry at least 45 minutes before placing in a MOFO sleeve.
I do a very similar ritual. I use a squirt bottle to create 2 small pools of solution 180 degrees apart and scrub gently with a microfiber brush - a different brush for each phase. The last wash I vacuum very thoroughly and only wait a short time before placing in the sleeve because I find the cleaning process builds static and the LPs attract dust even though I am running a Hepa filter in the room. I hate static! Well, maybe intensely dislike is a better term. And, yes, I have a Zerostat.
 
I just got to Page 30/Post 581, March 27, 2016, when Guest110/Vince exited. It was his last post here or anywhere on AK. He musta been good and pissed. Sad for us.
 
I just got to Page 30/Post 581, March 27, 2016, when Guest110/Vince exited. It was his last post here or anywhere on AK. He musta been good and pissed. Sad for us.
Yes it was sad. People are sometimes just not very nice. My guess is he is back under a new name but is not contributing to our misery anymore.
 
This topic can sometimes get as heated as wire topics, but here is my 2c. I did a test over at VE with some new junk records that I got with a batch of good stuff. I opened them (tacky country and lift music) and set up my test. I laid out the test lp's on the bench in my workshop and poured a puddle of isopropyl alcohol on the first record (neat) and mentholated spirits on the second again neat, turpentine on the next acetone on the next and dry cleaning fluid on the last. The dry cleaning fluid slightly changed the colour of the record instantly, but even after the over a week of the test (10 days from memory) it still played fine and looked fine under magnification. Non of the other solvents made a jot of difference sonically or visually after 10 days of constant contact with the solvent in question (neat) and it was given a good scrubbing with a brush whenever I passed the bench and topped up with more solvent when needed. The records has 240 hours of constant contact with given solvent during the test and probably 4 years later looking under magnification I still cant see which half of the record had the solvent and sound is same. When we clean a record contact is for seconds and diluted, we also clean every few years, my test was like hundreds of years of cleaning with more harsh solvents than we would ever use with no notable ill effects. Not really a surprise as I still have records I used to clean with neat isopropyl alcohol when I was about 15 and I am 47 now and they are still shiny and they still sound amazing. leaching from vinyl records from my experiment and experience is totally a non issue unless you are using some crazy mad solvent.
Chris
 
doing my first batch with hepastat today, mixed 7.5ml hepastat, 30ml iso and 30drops tergikleen for a 2gallon US run.
i THINK the math works out on that, ive seen different mixtures most are for a bigger concentration.
 
Paully, 5ml of Triton per gallon of water should be about right, regardless of how you get to it. Be careful you don't end up with too much Triton in your US bath or you'll have a ton of suds, which you don't want. I recommend starting with less rather than more for your first tests. You can then increase the amount of Triton if you're looking from more cleaning action up until you start getting foam in your tank.

I've been guided by the posts from Rushton and other experts as I learn how to use ultrasonic cleaning -- and would like to thank all of you for your past posts. I'm cleaning records using a Trusonik 10 liter unit. I'm using approximately 3 gallons of distilled water, and spacing the records 1.5 inches apart.


My question concerns the cleaning formula. I'm not mixing in advance, but adding the ingredients directly to the distilled water each time. I'm not rinsing the records afterwards due to lack of time. So, for better or worse, the cleaning formula needs to be aimed at one-step cleaning and drying. I’m also using a drier box that utilizes a 300 cfm fan and a 15 minute timer, built by the same person who sells the V-8 unit. My utility room, where the ultrasonic RCM resides, is dusty. Therefore I’m trying to largely complete the drying process using the box. A record that dries in a box in 15 minutes is far less likely to accumulate dust as compared with a record drying out in the open. I already discovered that records won't dry in 15 minutes, even with a 300 cfm fan, using 3 or 4 drops of Photoflo.

I first used 6 oz (177 ml) of isopropyl alcohol, with 1 teaspoon (5 ml) of Ilford Ifotol, as per the recommendation of Tima on the Vinyl Press site. That resulted in a few bubbles during the cleaning cycle. But it worked well and the amount of Ilford was enough for the records to dry in the drying box.

I next tried 6 oz of alcohol along with 0.5 oz (15 ml) of Triton-X in 3 gallons of distilled water, based on my understanding of what Rushton recommended in the above quote. I mixed the Triton-X and alcohol together first before adding to the water. I tried Triton-X since that type of surfactant is recommended by the Library of Congress and the National Library of Canada. Triton-X appeared to work better for the drying of the records than did the Ilford Ilfotol.

I have attached three photos taken while cleaning with Triton-X, first showing the minimal amount of bubbles while cleaning is underway. Second, the greater amount of foam from 15 ml of Triton-X with 3 gallons of water, when running a pump and filter. But maybe that is understandable due to the agitation caused by the pump and water circulation (I believe at least one gallon per minute, which is not during cleaning and therefore might not a reason to be concerned?) However, the Ilfotol didn't result in similar levels of suds at any point. Finally, a photo of the remaining bubbles after I turned off the pump and waited about 15 minutes.

A few questions:

(1) Chemically, what is the difference between Ilfotol/Photoflo and Triton-X?

The National Library of Canada refers to Tergitol as a "detergent" and only uses that, without any alcohol. So they are using it for cleaning as a detergent, as well as any wetting properties, and recommend that the records be rinsed after using it. So is Tergitol and Triton-X more appropriate for a cleaning regime that must include rinsing afterwards? If so, then Triton-X would not be appropriate for a one-step process. In addition, a water rinse without the use of a wetting agent defeats the purpose, at least for me, as records take far longer to then dry. I need to use a wetting agent.

On the other hand, are Ilfotol/Photoflo primarily wetting agents to assist in the drying of film, photo paper, and in this case, vinyl? And less of a cleaner or detergent? So are those more appropriate to use in one step without rinsing afterwards, but also to assist in drying? Especially when combined with isopropyl alcohol with the alcohol serving as the cleaning agent?

(2) Are the small amount of bubbles/foam next to the records when using Triton-X a cause for concern while cleaning? Are the suds that develop while the pump is working a real problem?

It would be helpful to settle on one of the chemicals, and then by trial and error discover the minimum amount that is necessary to encourage the drying of records. My best guess is that for one-step cleaning and drying, without the use of a water rinse, the best combination might be a chemical that is primarily a wetting agent, like Ilfotol, combined with alcohol. Triton-X appears to also be a detergent, and thus less appropriate for a one-step clean and dry process??

But I would greatly appreciate input from the experts in this forum!

Many thanks in advance for any responses; for your assistance; and for the excellent information provided in this thread

Bubbles on records.jpg Suds after pump off.jpg Suds while pump operates.jpg
 
.... leaching from vinyl records from my experiment and experience is totally a non issue unless you are using some crazy mad solvent...
Chris
Interesting test, but this conclusion goes against scientific evidence. As any compatibility chart will show (e.g.https://www.calpaclab.com/pvc-polyvinyl-chloride-chemical-compatibility-chart/), many of those solvents (e.g. acetone) have severe effects on PVC-based polymers. Furthermore, extraction of chemicals within PVC-based products have been measured (using MS-HPLC, for example) with even mild solvents like alcohol at concentrations over 60%. So while the record may appear and play OK, it certainly is different than the original composition. Could be fine for common or short-term records, but the idea behind this thread was for long-term preservation of collectables. Records are chemically tough, but like all plastics, they do have a useful life span. This life may be over 100 years, and I wouldn't want to shorten it doing things that might not be fatal, but are scientifically known to be harmful. Same reason I don't smoke, though I don't judge those that do.


doing my first batch with hepastat today, mixed 7.5ml hepastat, 30ml iso and 30drops tergikleen for a 2gallon US run.
i THINK the math works out on that, ive seen different mixtures most are for a bigger concentration.

You are good with the Hepastat (your doing a 1:1000 dilution resulting in a little over 0.02% quat, which is within the suggested range). I can't say on the iso as you don't say what stock % you are starting with. Likewise,I don't know what conc. Tergitol is in that product. Let us know how it works out!

A few questions:

(1) Chemically, what is the difference between Ilfotol/Photoflo and Triton-X?


(2) Are the small amount of bubbles/foam next to the records when using Triton-X a cause for concern while cleaning? Are the suds that develop while the pump is working a real problem?

It would be helpful to settle on one of the chemicals, and then by trial and error discover the minimum amount that is necessary to encourage the drying of records. My best guess is that for one-step cleaning and drying, without the use of a water rinse, the best combination might be a chemical that is primarily a wetting agent, like Ilfotol, combined with alcohol. Triton-X appears to also be a detergent, and thus less appropriate for a one-step clean and dry process??
This has been addressed many times in this thread, but in summary:
1.Photoflo contains a non-ionic detergent (5-10%), but is mostly propylene glycol (25-30%). The glycol is a problem. Ilfotol is better, as it only contains the non-ionic detergent (they don't specify, but it is an alcohol ethoxylate, exactly like Triton). Problem is it is only 1-5% detergent so you are paying dearly compared to pure Triton.
2. Small amount of foam is a good thing. You can reduce the concentration of the detergent if it becomes bothersome. That said, there is no excuse for not rinsing a record after deep cleaning with any detergent. It is an important step as folks here have attested. Also why aren't you using a quat in the mix? I know Rushton uses them as I gave him the recipe. Finally, if drying is an issue, you might want to invest in a vacuum RCM. This will allow a quick rinse step after the US and greatly facilitate drying...win-win!
 
Last edited:
This has been addressed many times in this thread, but in summary:
1.Photoflo contains a non-ionic detergent (5-10%), but is mostly propylene glycol (25-30%). The glycol is a problem. Ilfotol is better, as it only contains the non-ionic detergent (they don't specify, but it is an alcohol ethoxylate, exactly like Triton). Problem is it is only 1-5% detergent so you are paying dearly compared to pure Triton.
2. Small amount of foam is a good thing. You can reduce the concentration of the detergent if it becomes bothersome. That said, there is no excuse for not rinsing a record after deep cleaning with any detergent. It is an important step as folks here have attested. Also why aren't you using a quat in the mix? I know Rushton uses them as I gave him the recipe. Finally, if drying is an issue, you might want to invest in a vacuum RCM. This will allow a quick rinse step after the US and greatly facilitate drying...win-win!

Phantomrebel, many thanks for your response. I have attempted to read through the thread, but 90 pages is a lot of ground to cover. I will use Triton-X as per your recommendation. You explain that a "small amount of foam is a good thing," so I assume you believe that the small amount that appeared when I was actually cleaning records is OK. As compared with the considerable foam when the pump and filter were operating.

But I will reduce to 10 ML of Triton-X for 3 gallons of distilled water and see how that works. Should I also continue to use 6 oz of alcohol? Based upon reading this thread, I assume the answer is that I should.

Which specific quat should I use, and how much per gallon of distilled water?

I don't clean enough records, and often enough, to make up batches of cleaning fluids in advance. The most practical approach, for my purpose, is to arrive at a formula where I can just add a specific amount of chemicals to the water in the tank each time. (I'll mix all three chemicals together first, as I understand that is the recommended approach with Triton-X.)
 

I've been guided by the posts from Rushton and other experts as I learn how to use ultrasonic cleaning -- and would like to thank all of you for your past posts. I'm cleaning records using a Trusonik 10 liter unit. I'm using approximately 3 gallons of distilled water, and spacing the records 1.5 inches apart.


My question concerns the cleaning formula. I'm not mixing in advance, but adding the ingredients directly to the distilled water each time. I'm not rinsing the records afterwards due to lack of time. So, for better or worse, the cleaning formula needs to be aimed at one-step cleaning and drying. I’m also using a drier box that utilizes a 300 cfm fan and a 15 minute timer, built by the same person who sells the V-8 unit. My utility room, where the ultrasonic RCM resides, is dusty. Therefore I’m trying to largely complete the drying process using the box. A record that dries in a box in 15 minutes is far less likely to accumulate dust as compared with a record drying out in the open. I already discovered that records won't dry in 15 minutes, even with a 300 cfm fan, using 3 or 4 drops of Photoflo.

I first used 6 oz (177 ml) of isopropyl alcohol, with 1 teaspoon (5 ml) of Ilford Ifotol, as per the recommendation of Tima on the Vinyl Press site. That resulted in a few bubbles during the cleaning cycle. But it worked well and the amount of Ilford was enough for the records to dry in the drying box.

I next tried 6 oz of alcohol along with 0.5 oz (15 ml) of Triton-X in 3 gallons of distilled water, based on my understanding of what Rushton recommended in the above quote. I mixed the Triton-X and alcohol together first before adding to the water. I tried Triton-X since that type of surfactant is recommended by the Library of Congress and the National Library of Canada. Triton-X appeared to work better for the drying of the records than did the Ilford Ilfotol.

I have attached three photos taken while cleaning with Triton-X, first showing the minimal amount of bubbles while cleaning is underway. Second, the greater amount of foam from 15 ml of Triton-X with 3 gallons of water, when running a pump and filter. But maybe that is understandable due to the agitation caused by the pump and water circulation (I believe at least one gallon per minute, which is not during cleaning and therefore might not a reason to be concerned?) However, the Ilfotol didn't result in similar levels of suds at any point. Finally, a photo of the remaining bubbles after I turned off the pump and waited about 15 minutes.

A few questions:

(1) Chemically, what is the difference between Ilfotol/Photoflo and Triton-X?

The National Library of Canada refers to Tergitol as a "detergent" and only uses that, without any alcohol. So they are using it for cleaning as a detergent, as well as any wetting properties, and recommend that the records be rinsed after using it. So is Tergitol and Triton-X more appropriate for a cleaning regime that must include rinsing afterwards? If so, then Triton-X would not be appropriate for a one-step process. In addition, a water rinse without the use of a wetting agent defeats the purpose, at least for me, as records take far longer to then dry. I need to use a wetting agent.

On the other hand, are Ilfotol/Photoflo primarily wetting agents to assist in the drying of film, photo paper, and in this case, vinyl? And less of a cleaner or detergent? So are those more appropriate to use in one step without rinsing afterwards, but also to assist in drying? Especially when combined with isopropyl alcohol with the alcohol serving as the cleaning agent?

(2) Are the small amount of bubbles/foam next to the records when using Triton-X a cause for concern while cleaning? Are the suds that develop while the pump is working a real problem?

It would be helpful to settle on one of the chemicals, and then by trial and error discover the minimum amount that is necessary to encourage the drying of records. My best guess is that for one-step cleaning and drying, without the use of a water rinse, the best combination might be a chemical that is primarily a wetting agent, like Ilfotol, combined with alcohol. Triton-X appears to also be a detergent, and thus less appropriate for a one-step clean and dry process??

But I would greatly appreciate input from the experts in this forum!

Many thanks in advance for any responses; for your assistance; and for the excellent information provided in this thread

View attachment 1309700 View attachment 1309701 View attachment 1309702
No matter what fluid you use it is easy to test it to see if it leaves behind any solids. Just get a record you hate and put a few drops of the cleaning fluid you are using on the record. Spread it out a bit and let it dry. Once dry a quick look at the spot and you will see that no matter what you use it should be vacuum dried. I have tried this with many fluids and nothing will dry without leaving some kind of stain which is solids, surprisingly this includes distilled water rinse.. These solids cause noise. Hope this helps.
 
No matter what fluid you use it is easy to test it to see if it leaves behind any solids. Just get a record you hate and put a few drops of the cleaning fluid you are using on the record. Spread it out a bit and let it dry. Once dry a quick look at the spot and you will see that no matter what you use it should be vacuum dried. I have tried this with many fluids and nothing will dry without leaving some kind of stain which is solids, surprisingly this includes distilled water rinse.. These solids cause noise. Hope this helps.

I will try that. A great suggestion. Your conclusion that even distilled water causes noise if left to naturally dry means that there are large numbers of participants on this forum, as well as others, who are creating noise on their records by allowing them to air dry after a clean water rinse.

What about the forced air drying on an RCM like the Audio Desk or the KL Audio units, that dry a record in four minutes with a huge channel of forced air? That is forced drying through evaporation rather than vacuuming off the records. Same result?

What do you use for vacuuming? I have an old Nitty Gritty Pro which still works fine and can perform that function.

Many thanks again. BTW, I greatly enjoyed the small line you include under your posts to define an audiophile!
 
I use a vacuum wand that hooks up to a small shop vacuum. Works like a charm.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom