• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
For records, the effect of solvents on plasticizer is less than leaching of other additives. In modern LPs, the PVC is in a copolymer with PVA, which has the plasticizing effect, and is difficult to extract. The included stabilizers, conditioners, and lubricants are indeed solvent extractable (they can also be extracted with detergent which is why we need to be careful). One can measure increased frictional resistance, and the resulting increased noise, after treating a record with solvent (experiments at RCA and Shure for examples). I would be interested in more scientific measurements on your treatments with stylus friction and dynamic range in mind as I think it is important before proclaiming that it is OK to treat records with solvents. Also, are any of the solvents beneficial to cleaning...do they bring anything to the table by doing something the detergents do not? I previously summarized some of the common compounds in resin formulas in post #1548. Perhaps your partner could contribute to this list. There are others additives that are proprietary, including specialized plasticizers, depending on the manufacturer. All of these additives are all there for a reason, and we need to be mindful of retaining them for both record performance and long term stability. That's all I was getting at. People sometimes misinterpret this to mean we are saying that alcohol melts records. Nothing could be further from the truth.
 
Last edited:
For records, the effect of solvents on plasticizer is less than leaching of other additives. In modern LPs, the PVC is in a copolymer with PVA, which has the plasticizing effect, and is difficult to extract. The included stabilizers, conditioners, and lubricants are indeed solvent extractable (they can also be extracted with detergent which is why we need to be careful). One can measure increased frictional resistance, and the resulting increased noise, after treating a record with solvent (experiments at RCA and Shure for examples). I would be interested in more scientific measurements on your treatments with stylus friction and dynamic range in mind as I think it is important before proclaiming that it is OK to treat records with solvents. Also, are any of the solvents beneficial to cleaning...do they bring anything to the table by doing something the detergents do not? I previously summarized some of the common compounds in resin formulas in post #1548. Perhaps your partner could contribute to this list. There are others additives that are proprietary, including specialized plasticizers, depending on the manufacturer. All of these additives are all there for a reason, and we need to be mindful of retaining them for both record performance and long term stability. That's all I was getting at. People sometimes misinterpret this to mean we are saying that alcohol melts records. Nothing could be further from the truth.
So we agree that plasticisers are safe, but the worry is lubricants and conditioners which will be basically removed with detergents anyway. There is nothing really that is in the plastic that is going to be removed with alcohol, yes there may be something on the surface that may or may not be beneficial that could be removed but most normal cleaning will remove it anyway. The question of what solvents like alcohol bring to the table is simple, and that is it is almost impossible to remove many types of grime without it. Buy a record used which has lived in a smokers house and alcohol is the only thing that will get it clean.
Chris
 
Hello all,
Been doing my best to digest the info here. This is what I had been using prior to reading this thread:
Mix of record cleaning solution:
3/4 gallon distilled water
1/4 gallon alcohol
19ml of wetting agent (ILFOTOL)

What I do:
Wet the record thoroughly with cleaning solution and let it set for maybe 15-20 seconds.
Vacuum off with Squeaky Clean RCM
Thoroughly wet with distilled water
Vacuum off

Questions:
Is my solution too harsh with too much alcohol?
I have quite a lot of ILFOTOL still. Can someone recommend me a solution more in line with what is recommended in this thread if possible? Or should I ditch the ILFOTOL and just use the recommended solutions here?

Appreciate any insight.
Thanks!
 
So I've made my first bit of solution and I have some undissolved bits at the bottom of my mix. I'm not sure if it's the EDTA or not? This is after it sat overnight cause I heard the Triton can take a while to integrate. Any tips?

IMG_20181102_092055.jpg
 
I had some precipitate in my concentrate and ended up throwing it out. I tried to heat it up to see if it would go into solution but it didn't. I made 16oz of the cleaning solution, from that concentrate, that is clear and I'm still using it. I'll eventually make some more concentrate.
 
Hi I posted this back in January. No one commented on it, Can any of the chemical experts like @phantomrebel weigh in on this product?

How about this product I use at my restaurant for getting rid of grease and other tough stains, Grease Gobbler ( http://www.emulso.com/product/grease-gobbler/ ).

I recently used it in its ratio of 50/50 we mix for work to clean a stubborn stylus that had crud 10 cleanings with Stylast could not remove. One application of the 50/50 Grease gobbler
removed it 100% !!! I have tried a mix of that with some Distilled water and De natured alcohol and about 10% Grease gobbler for a really dirty record. It worked well but I have no way of telling if it had any adverse affects to the record. It worked better than some record doctor cleaner I have been using.

http://www.emulso.com/data-sheets/grease-gobbler-tech.pdf

http://www.emulso.com/data-sheets/grease-gobbler-safety.pdf

But As a stylus cleaner I am sticking with it when I find a used cartridge/stylus with massive gunk on it.



Athanasios


Thanks guys

Athanasios
 
Last edited:
@phantomrebel

How about this product I use at my restaurant for getting rid of grease and other tough stains, Grease Gobbler ( http://www.emulso.com/product/grease-gobbler/ ).

I recently used it in its ratio of 50/50 we mix for work to clean a stubborn stylus that had crud 10 cleanings with Stylast could not remove. One application of the 50/50 Grease gobbler
removed it 100% !!! I have tried a mix of that with some Distilled water and De natured alcohol and about 10% Grease gobbler for a really dirty record. It worked well but I have no way of telling if it had any adverse affects to the record. It worked better than some record doctor cleaner I have been using.

http://www.emulso.com/data-sheets/grease-gobbler-tech.pdf

http://www.emulso.com/data-sheets/grease-gobbler-safety.pdf

But As a stylus cleaner I am sticking with it when I find a used cartridge/stylus with massive gunk on it.



Athanasios
 
Last edited:
So, what I would like to ask is: is there a "conditioner" for LP's that would both remove grime, dust, surface grease while preserving the pvc/vinyl components? I'm a lazy and cheap teacher who likes to experiment with this stuff. I've cleaned a couple dozen really beat up Goodwill specials at this point, detailed on the other vinyl cleaning thread, and with 90+ pages here, I'm wondering if my question has been asked? I'm good on the Triton 100 and pure Isopropyl Alcohol, distilled water, and paint pad "gentle" scrub (used something similar and it worked great.)... and now I've gotten thru 40 pages here, so I gave this thread the College Try, but the Iron Bowl came on and, well... The beers came out of the fridge and one thing has lead to another... I'm interested to know from a chemist's POV, is there anything that both cleans AND conditions at the same time so the vinyl won't be compromised?
 
Nashou: Sorry, been moving the beach house, then the holidays, and haven't had much time to read this thread. I would not use that Grease Gobbler on my records. Primarily because it is a caustic mix of salts, pyrophosphate and potassium hydroxide. The pH is up there around 13, way too basic. These mixes are fantastic at cleaning glassware but anything containing a strong oxyanion I would never recommended for records. If it works for you, I understand, I just think it would strip endogenous additives like lubricants off the record surface and potentially make it susceptible to static so I would personally avoid it.
drjohnny: a neutral quat- based cleaner would do what you describe. This is what we have come up with in this thread. Some use an all-in-one shampoo/conditioner, but these generally contain lots of additional ingredients we might not want on our records so we are making our own pure mixes. So a good quat surfactant would do the trick (both clean and condition) if you can source it, and something like Hepastat has been recommended because it contains a good mix of them without too much other stuff at the dilutions used.
 
Last edited:
Virex II was recommended earlier (post #1348) and used successfully by AVfan (post# 1365). It is a great substitute and almost identical. It is mostly 10-20% Quat (N-alkyl Dimethyl Benzyl Ammonium Chloride and Didecyl dimethyl ammonium chloride), 1-5% Ethanol, and 1-5% non-ionic detergent (Lauryldimethylamine oxide). I'd use it alone at 1:1000 dilution or enhance with additional detergent if you wish. MSDS here: https://sds.diversey.com/private/document.aspx?prd=MS0801116~~PDF~~MTR~~ANEP~~EN~~~~&productName=Virex II 256&productName_option=d__^value&productID_option=d__~value~&language=d__-1 shows it also contains EDTA (like Hepastat).
 
Last edited:
Virex II was recommended earlier (post #1348) and used successfully by AVfan (post# 1365). It is a great substitute and almost identical. It is mostly 10-20% Quat (N-alkyl Dimethyl Benzyl Ammonium Chloride and Didecyl dimethyl ammonium chloride), 1-5% Ethanol, and 1-5% non-ionic detergent (Lauryldimethylamine oxide). I'd use it alone at 1:1000 dilution or enhance with additional detergent if you wish. MSDS here: https://sds.diversey.com/private/document.aspx?prd=MS0801116~~PDF~~MTR~~ANEP~~EN~~~~&productName=Virex II 256&productName_option=d__^value&productID_option=d__~value~&language=d__-1 shows it also contains EDTA (like Hepastat).

Another option for quats are pool algaecides. For sale at Canadian Tire is 4L of a 15% solution of n-alkyl dimethyl benzyl ammonium chlorides. Also available in 5% and 40% concentrations. There does not appear to be any other ingredients (well water, and maybe a light green/blue dye). I am using this as part of a wet cleaning solution with distilled water and isopropyl alcohol just before playing a record. The link for these products is:

https://www.canadiantire.ca/en/outdoor-living/pools-accessories/chemicals/algaecides.html
 
I've got a question that will expose my ignorance...

I just bought a jug of Brighton Hepastat 256. How the heck do I "open it" or whatever it takes to dispense? I unscrewed the cap and removed the foil/plastic film but when I tip it, nothing comes out. There are 2 tiny holes in the topmost plastic - when I stick a toothpick in either of the holes, a diaphragm just below the visible top flexes. Am I supposed to poke a hole in that diaphragm?
 
I've got a question that will expose my ignorance...

I just bought a jug of Brighton Hepastat 256. How the heck do I "open it" or whatever it takes to dispense? I unscrewed the cap and removed the foil/plastic film but when I tip it, nothing comes out. There are 2 tiny holes in the topmost plastic - when I stick a toothpick in either of the holes, a diaphragm just below the visible top flexes. Am I supposed to poke a hole in that diaphragm?
That bottle is meant to go into a special dispenser. For safety reasons, it's very difficult to dispense the product from the bottle. That said, it's not that difficult to remove the entire plug/dispensing/safety apparatus (and it is surprisingly large and complex once you get it out). First, make sure you are wearing gloves and eye protection. Then you can just use pliers to grab the rim of the plastic disc that covers the hole and then pull the whole thing loose. You will likely splash at least a little of the Hepastat as you do this, so make sure it's not sitting on top of prized family photos or anything like that. And, again, make sure to protect yourself from the undiluted Hepastat.
 
Ahh! Thanks for the info. I carefully used a paring knife to easily pry the disc out, along with the attached mechanism.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom