• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
Some people swear by the 60 or 80 kHz machines but after doing the math on bubble size on the 40 kHz machine the bubbles are small enough to get into the smallest record grooves and 40 khz bubbles have more energy than the 60 or 80 kHz bubbles.
Could you elaborate on the bubble size of 40 khz vs 80 khz ultrasonic bath units? I use a cheap us cleaner from eBay, I think it's 35 kHz. 80 kHz units cost quite a bit more. It would be nice to have definitive answer whether the more expensive, higher frequency US moachines make a difference vs. the cheap 35-40 kHz Chinese units from eBay.
Thanks!
 
Someone will still try for a 16,000,000 kHz claiming all other frequencies won't work.

My 40 kHz works wonders. I did not opt for the higher frequencies either.
 
Based on the graph in that article, it looks like a 40 kHz machine will produce bubbles with a diameter of about 16 microns. The RIAA standard for the minimum width of a stereo groove is 25.4 microns. At least as far as the size of the bubbles goes, it seems like 40 kHz should work just fine.
Actually the size of the bubbles will be around 8 microns with a 40 kHz machine. The 40 kHz is only one fifth the distance from the 50 kHz line.
 
Actually the size of the bubbles will be around 8 microns with a 40 kHz machine. The 40 kHz is only one fifth the distance from the 50 kHz line.
The graph is of radius, but I converted it to a diameter, since I thought that would be a better comparison to the overall width of the groove.
 
I'm using the following formula for cleaning by gentle scrubbing followed by a hand vac:

HepaStat 256 1.00 ml
Triton X-100 1.40 ml
IPA 91% 25.00 ml
DH20 472.60 ml
TOTAL 500.00 ml

I follow with two DH2O rinse/scrub/vac cycles. I read in this forum that some are adding 3% ethyl alcohol to the second rinse. My question is 'wouldn't that wash away some of the desirable molecular residue?
I asked this about a year ago; but don't believe I ever got an answer.
 
I'm using the following formula for cleaning by gentle scrubbing followed by a hand vac:

HepaStat 256 1.00 ml
Triton X-100 1.40 ml
IPA 91% 25.00 ml
DH20 472.60 ml
TOTAL 500.00 ml

I follow with two DH2O rinse/scrub/vac cycles. I read in this forum that some are adding 3% ethyl alcohol to the second rinse. My question is 'wouldn't that wash away some of the desirable molecular residue?
I asked this about a year ago; but don't believe I ever got an answer.
I don't think the answer is clear since it hasn't been studied to my knowledge. At this low concentration, perhaps the interaction of the alcohol with water is stronger than that with the quat and the interaction of the quat with the record is not disrupted. This assumes no other ions (like salts) in the mixture, which would change everything since water would rather hold hands with the salt ion then the alcohol (this is how one can separate phases). It's a good question. I believe folks add the alcohol to better disperse the rinse solution (lower surface tension) and perhaps aid in drying. I don't know how this effects the bound quat under dilute conditions, but I use just dH2O since I, like you, rinse using a vacuum (VPI RCM in my case) which leaves the surface fairly dry.
EDIT: That said, you can strip the surfactant off a record surface with 95% IPA. You can test this as the surfactant surface will normally hold water and the stripped surface will not. This is why some of us also worry about endogenous lubricants. One study on cleaning artifacts (previously referenced in this thread) shows the threshold is above 50% alcohol before extraction takes place. The ability to hold molecular water is what gives quats their antistatic property so stripping them defeats the purpose of their inclusion in wash solutions. I suppose it would be pretty easy to test what effect 3% IPA has on this. Consider though, that the quat bound to the record in a solution that contained 5-15% IPA (in many recipes) to begin with.
 
Last edited:
I don't think the answer is clear since it hasn't been studied to my knowledge. At this low concentration, perhaps the interaction of the alcohol with water is stronger than that with the quat and the interaction of the quat with the record is not disrupted. This assumes no other ions (like salts) in the mixture, which would change everything since water would rather hold hands with the salt ion then the alcohol (this is how one can separate phases). It's a good question. I believe folks add the alcohol to better disperse the rinse solution (lower surface tension) and perhaps aid in drying. I don't know how this effects the bound quat under dilute conditions, but I use just dH2O since I, like you, rinse using a vacuum (VPI RCM in my case) which leaves the surface fairly dry.
EDIT: That said, you can strip the surfactant off a record surface with 95% IPA. You can test this as the surfactant surface will normally hold water and the stripped surface will not. This is why some of us also worry about endogenous lubricants. One study on cleaning artifacts (previously referenced in this thread) shows the threshold is above 50% alcohol before extraction takes place. The ability to hold molecular water is what gives quats their antistatic property so stripping them defeats the purpose of their inclusion in wash solutions. I suppose it would be pretty easy to test what effect 3% IPA has on this. Consider though, that the quat bound to the record in a solution that contained 5-15% IPA (in many recipes) to begin with.
Thanks so much for your cogent explanation. For some reason, the snippet I read referred to Ethyl alcohol as being preferred over IPA; but based on your illumination and the fact that things are working well as they are, it's probably safer for me to just drink the stuff. Once again, I am in your debt.
 
Thanks so much for your cogent explanation. For some reason, the snippet I read referred to Ethyl alcohol as being preferred over IPA; but based on your illumination and the fact that things are working well as they are, it's probably safer for me to just drink the stuff. Once again, I am in your debt.
Sorry, I missed that you originally stated ethyl alcohol, not isopropyl. By and large they are interchangeable, but the ethanol would be preferred since it is less hydrophobic (smaller side chain) and therefore less likely to compete with quat binding.
 
I think he is saying that a 40 kHz machine's cavitation bubble is small enough to fit in a record groove.
 
Sorry, I missed that you originally stated ethyl alcohol, not isopropyl. By and large they are interchangeable, but the ethanol would be preferred since it is less hydrophobic (smaller side chain) and therefore less likely to compete with quat binding.
Would that go for the original wash formula as well, or is the objective different?
 
Would that go for the original wash formula as well, or is the objective different?
My opinion has always been that ethanol is better than isopropanol in the cleaning solution. The issue is that few people have access to 99%+ so they use vodka or something that has contaminants so 99% isopropanol is a better substitute. I suspect commercial solutions typically contain isopropanol in place of ethanol so that they do not require special labelling (or maybe even taxation)?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom