• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
I use a vacuum wand that hooks up to a small shop vacuum. Works like a charm.

I have several small shop vacuums including a Fein that would be perfect. But I'm trying to visualize the vacuum wand you're using and how you hook it up. Where did you get the wand? Can you post a pic?
 
I have several small shop vacuums including a Fein that would be perfect. But I'm trying to visualize the vacuum wand you're using and how you hook it up. Where did you get the wand? Can you post a pic?
Be careful here. The PM system is better than the open forums for this.

Rich P
 
I will try that. A great suggestion. Your conclusion that even distilled water causes noise if left to naturally dry means that there are large numbers of participants on this forum, as well as others, who are creating noise on their records by allowing them to air dry after a clean water rinse.

What about the forced air drying on an RCM like the Audio Desk or the KL Audio units, that dry a record in four minutes with a huge channel of forced air? That is forced drying through evaporation rather than vacuuming off the records. Same result?

What do you use for vacuuming? I have an old Nitty Gritty Pro which still works fine and can perform that function.

Many thanks again. BTW, I greatly enjoyed the small line you include under your posts to define an audiophile!
I use a shop vac and a device called Squeaky Clean. The less water that stays on the record the less noise you will hear..
 
I don't think this opinion is correct at all. Many of us enjoy completely clean, noise-free records. The problem of cracks and pops becomes a physical one, where there is damage to the record itself (typically small scratches, but sometimes wear or manufacturing defects) that no amount of cleaning will ever fix. That fact has been posted hundreds of times here. I encourage new members to read through the entire thread and examine these posts, along with those showing micrographs of perfectly clean records. It IS entirely possible to thoroughly clean a record. I will agree, there are definitely limitations to the media, but comparisons to digital files is not why we are here. That said, if one is digitizing their records, it is certainly advantageous to clean them first as well as possible (while maintaining endogenous lubrication), whether using a filter or not.
 
You are good with the Hepastat (your doing a 1:1000 dilution resulting in a little over 0.02% quat, which is within the suggested range). I can't say on the iso as you don't say what stock % you are starting with. Likewise,I don't know what conc. Tergitol is in that product. Let us know how it works out!

thanks for checking, i'm using 91% iso. it's cheaper than ordering the good stuff i figured close enough.
the tergikleen i got a couple years ago and ive just been trying to use it up, they call for 10-20 drops per gallon, as far as i can tell its a blend of s9 and s7. I might just reserve that for manual cleaning on the vacuum machine and buy some triton x for the ultrasonic bath.

strange thing is people talk about suds with their bath and mine has none at all.
 
I can shake the heck out of my partially filled bottled of cleaning solution which contains Triton, distilled water, and alcohol and it doesn't suds up. Anyone getting a lot of suds must be using a much stronger concentration of Triton. If so, you are using too much. It takes me 2 vacuuming processes and two rinses, to get distilled water to bead up properly, following an application of my cleaning solution. Imagine if I'd use even more triton. there would be a residue, for sure, as the 1st rinse (despite vacuuming off the cleaning solution) doesn't bead up.

EDIT: actually, a 1/2 empty bottle, when shaken, does cause foaming. mea culpa.
 
Last edited:
I get some sudsing if I shakes my Triton premix. It also suds on the record when I scrub it. After I vacuum it then rinse with distilled water the DW beads up before it's vacuumed off.

BTW my premix is only DW and Triton.

I would say that I actually have Triton 114. Could anyone comment on whether 114 is good or bad or otherwise?
 
Speaking of the premix... I have a little precipitate now that it's been a while. Should I pitch it or just filter it out? Shaking it doesn't break it up.
 
Punchback: Triton X-114 is structurally very similar to Triton X-100. For our uses they are functionally interchangeable.
Surfactants within the Triton X series only differ in the length of the ethylene oxide unit side chains, (in X-100 it is 9-10 units long; in X-114 it is 7-8). see this reference: https://dowac.custhelp.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/1652/related/1
Similarly, surfactants within the Tergitol 15-S series differ by the length of their side chains (e.g. 15-S-3 and 15-S-9 have ~3 and ~9 ethylene oxide side chain units, respectively).

The chain lengths are averages within a mixture, since they are expensive to separate after synthesis (So a S-3 and S-9 mix isn't that much different than S-7). The difference isn't that critical to basic cleaning: they were separated for specific applications, like solubilization of a specific membrane protein in biochemistry or isolation of particular components in an industrial application. However, chain length gives the detergents different physical properties that do concern us (it makes a difference how soluble they are in water, for example).
The shorter the side chain length, the lower the tendency to foam (lower foam height) so X-114 will foam less than X-100. see https://dowac.custhelp.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/1660/related/1/
The shorter length also lowers cloud point, so X-114 is less likely to separate or form a precipitate when stored at at lower temperatures.
If your mix doesn't clear up upon warming, I'd toss it. You do not want any precipitate on your records.

EDIT: Sorry to some for going off on a technical explanation. The important thing is that non-ionic detergents (whether Triton or Tergitol, whether X-100, 114, 15-S-7, S-9 or whatever) have the ability to disrupt the surface tension of water and solubilize contaminants without introducing any charge into the system. That's why they are recommended for record cleaning and most any of them that are water soluble will do the job. Most often, the choice comes down to what is available in your area.
 
Last edited:
correction for a previous post--if i shake my 1/2 empty bottle of solution it DOES foam up. I had mis-remembered what happens when I shake it. apologies.
 
Looking at EngineerNate's PDFs; if I use the 91% ISO to 99%, should I lower the amount of ISO due to the higher concentration?
 
Interesting test, but this conclusion goes against scientific evidence. As any compatibility chart will show (e.g.https://www.calpaclab.com/pvc-polyvinyl-chloride-chemical-compatibility-chart/), many of those solvents (e.g. acetone) have severe effects on PVC-based polymers. Furthermore, extraction of chemicals within PVC-based products have been measured (using MS-HPLC, for example) with even mild solvents like alcohol at concentrations over 60%. So while the record may appear and play OK, it certainly is different than the original composition. Could be fine for common or short-term records, but the idea behind this thread was for long-term preservation of collectables. Records are chemically tough, but like all plastics, they do have a useful life span. This life may be over 100 years, and I wouldn't want to shorten it doing things that might not be fatal, but are scientifically known to be harmful. Same reason I don't smoke, though I don't judge those that do.




You are good with the Hepastat (your doing a 1:1000 dilution resulting in a little over 0.02% quat, which is within the suggested range). I can't say on the iso as you don't say what stock % you are starting with. Likewise,I don't know what conc. Tergitol is in that product. Let us know how it works out!


This has been addressed many times in this thread, but in summary:
1.Photoflo contains a non-ionic detergent (5-10%), but is mostly propylene glycol (25-30%). The glycol is a problem. Ilfotol is better, as it only contains the non-ionic detergent (they don't specify, but it is an alcohol ethoxylate, exactly like Triton). Problem is it is only 1-5% detergent so you are paying dearly compared to pure Triton.
2. Small amount of foam is a good thing. You can reduce the concentration of the detergent if it becomes bothersome. That said, there is no excuse for not rinsing a record after deep cleaning with any detergent. It is an important step as folks here have attested. Also why aren't you using a quat in the mix? I know Rushton uses them as I gave him the recipe. Finally, if drying is an issue, you might want to invest in a vacuum RCM. This will allow a quick rinse step after the US and greatly facilitate drying...win-win!
Point is the tiny amount of time we use alcohol to clean a record it is not significant and there is no evidence I have seen that sell this idea to me. Also how long do you guys want the record to last? I have been cleaning mine with isopropyl alcohol for decades, I am 47 now and hope to be able to still hear well enough to enjoy them the rest of my life, but dont really care what happens to them after that. My test demonstrated one thing that is they wont be in contact with alcohol or any solvent long enough to do any audible damage in my life time and longer so irrelevant Some may claim they can measure so tiny leaching but honestly you are more likely to damage you record by replay than washing it.
Chris
 
Point is the tiny amount of time we use alcohol to clean a record it is not significant and there is no evidence I have seen that sell this idea to me. Also how long do you guys want the record to last? I have been cleaning mine with isopropyl alcohol for decades, I am 47 now and hope to be able to still hear well enough to enjoy them the rest of my life, but dont really care what happens to them after that. My test demonstrated one thing that is they wont be in contact with alcohol or any solvent long enough to do any audible damage in my life time and longer so irrelevant Some may claim they can measure so tiny leaching but honestly you are more likely to damage you record by replay than washing it.
Chris
Moderation Note:

Heads up on your input to this thread. The title of this thread is unfortunate. There are many ways that folks have been using for years. If what you do and use works for you, that is quite acceptable, but it is not the topic or intent of this thread.

This thread is specifically intended to squeeze the last drop of goodness from our cleaning processes. There is "good enough" and there is "not good at all." This thread is shooting at the getting as close to perfect as we can get. If you want to talk about general record cleaning, there are plenty of threads on the subject here on AK. If you want to participate in the "as good as you can get get with modern science," this is a thread to enjoy.

Concepts for various chemicals and processes have been discussed previously in this thread. Having addressed those, we are now into serious refinement and understanding. Please honor the intent of this thread, pick another thread to enjoy, or feel free to start your own.

Rich P
 
Moderation Note:

Heads up on your input to this thread. The title of this thread is unfortunate. There are many ways that folks have been using for years. If what you do and use works for you, that is quite acceptable, but it is not the topic or intent of this thread.

This thread is specifically intended to squeeze the last drop of goodness from our cleaning processes. There is "good enough" and there is "not good at all." This thread is shooting at the getting as close to perfect as we can get. If you want to talk about general record cleaning, there are plenty of threads on the subject here on AK. If you want to participate in the "as good as you can get get with modern science," this is a thread to enjoy.

Concepts for various chemicals and processes have been discussed previously in this thread. Having addressed those, we are now into serious refinement and understanding. Please honor the intent of this thread, pick another thread to enjoy, or feel free to start your own.

Rich P
I had no intention of disrupting the thread or moving it off topic, actually it is a topic I am interested in as my albums are into the thousands. I conducted my solvent tests on VE for this reason as there is a lot of internet psudo science on the subject. My reason for posting my comments here on this thread were that the folks here are making a recipe for a cleaning solution which is great. My issue is we are steering the recipe in a particular direction with false facts. I am the dummy in the family, buy I have a masters degree. My partner has a Phd and she has worked many years post Doc and she is seriously well publish in a number of subjects including polymers. Personally one of my businesses steered my the way of plastics. I developed and designed a bipod for FTR shooting and for it to make weight restrictions with increasingly heavy rifles I needed the top and feet and ankles to be made of composites and plastics so I went into business with an expert in plastic moulding. This alcohol and leaching from the plastic question I put to my new business partner. His response was any plasticiser found in alcohol after a contact with a record would almost for sure come from plasticiser dissolved in the release agents. He also said any stripped from the vinyl would be unlikely and if they were it would be totally insignificant amounts. My partner said similar long ago but it was interesting talking to someone in the industry.
My 2c re the recipe is what damage can be done to the record or the stylus if the record is not cleaned properly? Used records smoking residue is terrible to remove how can this be removed without alcohol?
I did my own experiments a number of years back and I had some success with photographic wetting agent but nothing removed stubborn grime like alcohol could. I now have my own decent microscope so thinking to do tests again and will try the results of this thread too. My idea is to get a really dirty charity shop record cut it up into strips and examine each strip under the microscope. Then clean each strip with test solution and recheck under microscope to see how much grime has been removed. Plasticisers aside how clean the test samples are after this test will be interesting.
Chris
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom