• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
I had excellent results with the Hepastat/Triton mix in my USC, but am curious about this new formulation. Do you think records already cleaned with the previous solution benefit from a re-clean with the new one?
 
I had excellent results with the Hepastat/Triton mix in my USC, but am curious about this new formulation. Do you think records already cleaned with the previous solution benefit from a re-clean with the new one?
No. The principle is the same as previously discussed here: a mixture that includes a quat. The improvements are in ease of use, water solubility, purity, lack of residue, acid neutralization, and long term resistance to static build up. There are minor improvements in contaminant solubilization in lab tests, but in practice there would be little benefit to re-washing records already washed with the Hepastat mix. That mix already works very well and actually has better biocidal properties (useful if you store solutions long term or are starting with moldy records). I should add that we found benefit to reducing the concentrations of detergent and quat significantly in all applications, including Ultrasonic baths so I recommend you go light when making the Hepastat mixes.
 
Last edited:
If someone is monetizing a recipe that is on here for free without saying anything, well that sucks. In fact, it's bad marketing because I believe that the vast majority of AKers would be most likely to buy a record cleaning solution from a recipe that we saw here and that has been discussed extensively as well as used and reviewed.

Someone not only sucks, but is missing out on a captive audience that wants/needs the product.

If @phantomrebel would reveal the formula thieves; I, for one would boycott that firm 'with extreme prejudice!'
 
I won't out the companies selling the product, they know who they are as I've discussed it with them (basically got a "too bad" type response from the 2 I know of....and they are technically correct). I am more tolerant of cleaning services using the solution since they are providing value added service. An example is www.perfectvinylforever.com who have publicly stated they use the formula (https://www.audionirvana.org/forum/...perfect-vinyl-forever-record-cleaning-service). A little irritating is they don't give any credit to AK and lift info (almost verbatim from my posts) and use it on their website FAQ.
 
Last edited:
No. The principle is the same as previously discussed here: a mixture that includes a quat. The improvements are in ease of use, water solubility, purity, lack of residue, acid neutralization, and long term resistance to static build up. There are minor improvements in contaminant solubilization in lab tests, but in practice there would be little benefit to re-washing records already washed with the Hepastat mix. That mix already works very well and actually has better biocidal properties (useful if you store solutions long term or are starting with moldy records). I should add that we found benefit to reducing the concentrations of detergent and quat significantly in all applications, including Ultrasonic baths so I recommend you go light when making the Hepastat mixes.

I'm curious what you would now recommend for the recipes previously established in this thread, both RCM and US, based upon the statement above in bold. I'm about to make a new batch of cleaning fluid. Thanks!
 
For US baths, Ruston was recommending 0.13% Triton, 0.1% Hepastat. I recommend cutting that down to 0.04% Triton, 0.04% Hepastat. Double the concentrations (0.08% Triton, 0.08% Hepa) for most RCMs. Of course, a lot depends on how grungy the starting material is. The best results I've seen with very dirty (typical thrift store find) records with the US was when the records were first hand-washed (lightly scrubbed) with a mix near Ruston's concentrations, rinsed, then put through a US bath containing just 0.04% Hepastat (no Triton).
 
This has certainly become one of the longer and quite interesting threads I've followed incl all its
updates.

For those new to the thread and perhaps not willing to read through all 1700 plus current posts perhaps
a short overview or synopsis like the information in the post above by @phantomrebel would tie things together.

Unfortunately not my particular area of expertise if I even have one.
 
For US baths, Ruston was recommending 0.13% Triton, 0.1% Hepastat. I recommend cutting that down to 0.04% Triton, 0.04% Hepastat. Double the concentrations (0.08% Triton, 0.08% Hepa) for most RCMs. Of course, a lot depends on how grungy the starting material is. The best results I've seen with very dirty (typical thrift store find) records with the US was when the records were first hand-washed (lightly scrubbed) with a mix near Ruston's concentrations, rinsed, then put through a US bath containing just 0.04% Hepastat (no Triton).

I am no scientist. Can someone translate the concentration part per gallon for the US baths. Please. You all are the best.
 
For US baths, Ruston was recommending 0.13% Triton, 0.1% Hepastat. I recommend cutting that down to 0.04% Triton, 0.04% Hepastat. Double the concentrations (0.08% Triton, 0.08% Hepa) for most RCMs. Of course, a lot depends on how grungy the starting material is. The best results I've seen with very dirty (typical thrift store find) records with the US was when the records were first hand-washed (lightly scrubbed) with a mix near Ruston's concentrations, rinsed, then put through a US bath containing just 0.04% Hepastat (no Triton).

If I did my math right for one gallon (3785ml) of distilled water I'd add 3ml of both Triton and Hepastat for RCM cleaning. At what concentrations are the Triton and Hepastat to start? I recall diluting the Triton 10x or so to get it to disperse but the Hepastat out of the bottle will disperse. Triton and Hepastat must be more potent than we discussed earlier in order to clean records on a RCM at these concentrations let alone in a US cleaner. Does this change also impact the amount of isopropyl alcohol? It sort of begs the question why not just use distilled water and isopropyl alcohol?
 
^^^ The "distilled water and isopropyl alcohol only" mix does not sheet very well in an ultrasonic tank. The mix beads up as the vinyl rotates up out of the tank and then back down. I added a few drops of the old formula to this "distilled water and isopropyl alcohol" mix and the water sheeted nicely. I just don't know how much is enough.
 
Just occurred to me for those not using metric the US gallon and the imperial gallon are not quite the same
of course the same goes for old school quarts etc.
 
Last edited:
Afraid I have no chemistry knowledge :( and would appreciate a little help.

I can't find any UK supplier for Hepastat 256 anywhere and I spent many hours searching for this without any luck, without importing it. I wonder if anyone, especially from the UK, can make any suggestion.

However I wonder, if quat is a key ingredient of Hepastat, would this product be ok http://www.impact-supplies.co.uk/webshop-search/?Page_ID=3610&refpid=4&id=750721

The MSDS for this can be downloaded from here https://s3-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/cdn.webfactore.co.uk/sr_645888.pdf
 
Hepastat and the quaternary cleaner I use, Virex II 256, are more likely to be found in a hospital or medical supply stores versus standard janitorial supply houses. They are amazing at killing a number of very nasty viruses so are used to clean doctors offices, hospitals and research labs. They are routinely used to de-bug the surfaces (hand rails, elevator buttons, door handles, etc) on cruise ships to minimize illnesses. Very often you fill find "256", the standard dilution ratio for cleaning, in the product's name. Hope this helps.
 
^^^ The "distilled water and isopropyl alcohol only" mix does not sheet very well in an ultrasonic tank. The mix beads up as the vinyl rotates up out of the tank and then back down. I added a few drops of the old formula to this "distilled water and isopropyl alcohol" mix and the water sheeted nicely. I just don't know how much is enough.


Of COURSE it will bead up! Add some Triton X. DON'T use dish detergent. I cringe every time I read about someone "swearing" by the use of it.
 
Just occurred to me for those not using metric the US gallon and the imperial gallon are n to quite the same
of course the same goes for old school quarts etc.
Both gallons have 4 quarts but with the imperial system there is 40 ounces to a quart versus 32 for the US. Therefore the imperial gallon has 5 quarts US.
 
I can update my spreadsheets to include versions with the new formula and share on Sunday.

@phantomrebel - are you no longer recommending the addition of edta?

I'm not suggesting this is any magic formula, just that good results can be achieved with less in our recent experience. As to the EDTA, there is a small amount already in the Hepastat product. If you are using de-ionized water throughout, and pure reagents, I don't feel there is much need for additional chelator. OTOH, if you are hand washing and initially rinsing with filtered tap water, or storing solutions for extended periods, I would include it.

Afraid I have no chemistry knowledge :( and would appreciate a little help.

I can't find any UK supplier for Hepastat 256 anywhere and I spent many hours searching for this without any luck, without importing it. I wonder if anyone, especially from the UK, can make any suggestion.
However I wonder, if quat is a key ingredient of Hepastat, would this product be ok http://www.impact-supplies.co.uk/webshop-search/?Page_ID=3610&refpid=4&id=750721
The MSDS for this can be downloaded from here https://s3-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/cdn.webfactore.co.uk/sr_645888.pdf
The MSDS shows it contains a non-ionic detergent (unspecified alcohol alkoxylate) along with some quats (one being Benzalkonium Chloride, which we have discussed using previously in this thread). It appears the solution is more dilute than Hepastat, containing 2-10% quat and 1-5% non-ionic, so you will dilute less. Still enough dilution that I wouldn't be concerned about the high pH of the stock (10) however. Looks like it could work very well and definitely worth giving a try. Let us know how it works out!

Of COURSE it will bead up! Add some Triton X. DON'T use dish detergent. I cringe every time I read about someone "swearing" by the use of it.
LOL. You and me both brother! Surfactants can greatly aid in the US cleaning process. I'm not sure whether this is due to the effect reducing surface tension has on cavitation as some suggest (I'm no physicist), but records come out cleaner when they are included. The tricky part comes later, in the subsequent drying step. Using anionic dish soap and wiping with a cloth is a proven recipe for static build up. There is some benefit to wiping with a softened cloth (quat-treated) but I personally prefer a vacuum method as it minimizes exposure. So one CAN use dish detergent in a US tank effectively, as long as they have a means to deal with the subsequent handling.
Speaking of static and wiping, I recently experimented with materials made with Thunderon (copper sulfide infused fibers developed by Nihon Sanmo in Japan). The conductive brushes made by Gordon Brush that combine Thunderon with Goat hair work very well at reducing static charge on records while removing light surface dust. They come in a variety of sizes, and places like Sleeve City and Acoustic Sounds have them at available marked up prices (Gordon Brush is much less, but requires a minimum qty 6 order and other industrial supply houses require min $50 orders). Either way, brushes offer much less cost and greater convenience over the folder apparatus with this fiber sold by Furutech (their SK-X-III at around $450).
 
Last edited:
I'm not suggesting this is any magic formula, just that good results can be achieved with less in our recent experience. As to the EDTA, there is a small amount already in the Hepastat product. If you are using de-ionized water throughout, and pure reagents, I don't feel there is much need for additional chelator. OTOH, if you are hand washing and initially rinsing with filtered tap water, or storing solutions for extended periods, I would include it.


The MSDS shows it contains a non-ionic detergent (unspecified alcohol alkoxylate) along with some quats (one being Benzalkonium Chloride, which we have discussed using previously in this thread). It appears the solution is more dilute than Hepastat, containing 2-10% quat and 1-5% non-ionic, so you will dilute less. Still enough dilution that I wouldn't be concerned about the high pH of the stock (10) however. Looks like it could work very well and definitely worth giving a try. Let us know how it works out!


LOL. You and me both brother! Surfactants can greatly aid in the US cleaning process. I'm not sure whether this is due to the effect reducing surface tension has on cavitation as some suggest (I'm no physicist), but records come out cleaner when they are included. The tricky part comes later, in the subsequent drying step. Using anionic dish soap and wiping with a cloth is a proven recipe for static build up. There is some benefit to wiping with a softened cloth (quat-treated) but I personally prefer a vacuum method as it minimizes exposure. So one CAN use dish detergent in a US tank effectively, as long as they have a means to deal with the subsequent handling.
Speaking of static and wiping, I recently experimented with materials made with Thunderon (copper sulfide infused fibers developed by Nihon Sanmo in Japan). The conductive brushes made by Gordon Brush that combine Thunderon with Goat hair work very well at reducing static charge on records while removing light surface dust. They come in a variety of sizes, and places like Sleeve City and Acoustic Sounds have them at available marked up prices (Gordon Brush is much less, but requires a minimum qty 6 order and other industrial supply houses require min $50 orders). Either way, brushes offer much less cost and greater convenience over the folder apparatus with this fiber sold by Furutech (their SK-X-III at around $450).

The method I use is 1) apply cleaning solution to the record (from a spray bottle) and make several revolutions with a goat hair brush, 2) vacuum, 3) apply distilled water and vacuum (record appearance is that of partial surfactant), 4) apply a second application of distilled water and this time the entire record beads up as expected and as is needed to demonstrate that for all intents and purposes the cleaning solution is totally removed, and vacuum, 5) remove from homemade cleaning "machine", and allow to air dry at least 45 minutes before placing in a MOFO sleeve.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom