• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
So it wasn't unobtainium in Sweden after all (but darn close to it). But finally I got the Triton X-100!
Unfortunately I am not at liberty to disclose any information of where, how and how much it cost. Have to protect my source ;)...
My source calls it 100% Triton but the label says 50% Triton and 50% Propan-2-ol.
So as I posted above, how much of this stuff for 1000ml cleaning solution? 10ml should mean 0.5 percent strength if I do the math right?
View attachment 1389371
I would tell you but it's a secret and I am not at liberty to tell you..
 
Just a reminder from the US CDC: In order for a quat disinfectant to be fully effective, the surface has to remain wet for 10 minutes. How long are you leaving your disinfectant/sanitizing on the record? As for the ingredients in the various commercial products, search for the MSDS (or SDS). Any potentially hazardous ingredients must be listed on the safety data sheet.
But I expect that is because the USCDC (US Center for Disease Control) is interested in the anti-bacterial properties of the quat, whereas for record cleaning my interest in using quats is for the anti-static properties. I expect the anti-static effect takes very little time at all. Can anyone with more knowledge than I have (not a chemist) comment?
 
I clean via Record Doctor and often wonder how long to leave the cleaning fluid on (the formula with the quat) before vacuuming. Mostly it’s on for maybe 10-15 seconds. After that no static problems.
 
I've done the quick clean with paint pad, vacuum wand, and distilled water rinse. No static problem even with a quick clean. All of my records (for the record) have undergone a 10 minute ultrasonic cleaning beforehand.
 
But I expect that is because the USCDC (US Center for Disease Control) is interested in the anti-bacterial properties of the quat, whereas for record cleaning my interest in using quats is for the anti-static properties. I expect the anti-static effect takes very little time at all. Can anyone with more knowledge than I have (not a chemist) comment?
Removal of static charge occurs instantaneously, even with plain water. The purpose of the quat is to provide long-term static protection. Increases in time or temperature during cleaning is to allow for better solubilization of contaminants in the detergent (similar to soaking a dirty pan in warm soapy water).
I respect everyones DIY formulas but is there any good pre-made solutions that you folks can recommend that do the job?
This thread is about making your own that is better than anything you could buy (kind of like a thread on a chefs group discussing the best soufflé recipe). The fact is that most pre-made solutions are simple detergent formulations that don't even contain an anti-stat. Yes, there are a few that now do, but even then, you are stuck with one formulation with little ability to adjust individual ingredients for specific applications. There are many other threads on commercial solutions if you search around.
...I am no chemist, but it looks to be weaker than Hepistat, with the composition detailed as 1%-5% on the COSHH datasheets (where as Hepistat runs to 8.7%) so I suspect a little more would be needed (I'll approximate the ratios if I have to, but if there are any chemists reading this it would be really useful to have an informed comparison of the two products in terms of ingredients, and a suggested ratio for Selgiene if it is a good substitute.
My other concern given that my USC is heated is the use of ethanol / alchohol due to the flash point. Does anyone have experiences of solutions without them? I have read that they add little to the cleaning process, and are more a drying agent? If so would Ilford Ilfotol and Triton-X100 alone produce the results needed?
Your ignoring the other quat compounds in these mixes. Hepastat is a mix containing almost 22% quat and the Selgiene (which looks promising) is 2-10% quat. Both also contain non-ionic detergent (Triton-like alcohol ethoxylates), with 6% in the Hepastat and 1-5% in the Selgiene. It could be used by itself (at 1:1000 dilution for example) and likely be quite effective.
 
Anyone know if I can use tergitol in a Spin Clean?
This has been covered here many times. You can, but these systems are designed for solutions containing a flocculant that helps settle and gather the removed contaminants to the bottom of the tank. You could make your own by adding alum (aluminum sulfate), but you are better off using the manufacturers solution or ditching the device and using an RCM or ultrasonic cleaner so you aren't grinding the removed debris back into the record.
 
Maybe this has been coberec in this massive thread and I've missed it. Sorry if so. But: if I skip rinse after vacuuming the cleaning solution off, is this better to keep the anti static effect of the Triton x100 on the vinyl?
 
Maybe this has been coberec in this massive thread and I've missed it. Sorry if so. But: if I skip rinse after vacuuming the cleaning solution off, is this better to keep the anti static effect of the Triton x100 on the vinyl?
Triton X-100 is a non-ionic detergent. It is neutral and has no anti-static effect. For that, you need to add a cationic detergent. Even after this addition, you should never skip the rinse step. A molecular layer of surfactant remains even after multiple deionized water rinses.
 
So I've been trying to make the mixture that has been posted here multiple times and I keep getting hard clumps or chunks. Is there a proper order to adding the ingredients and is there anything I'm missing? I'm not sure if it's the EDTA (which I added last) or maybe I heard the Triton can be hard to mix. But this latest batch had real hard to break chunks in it that looked like maybe the EDTA. I did all the mixing at room temp FWIW
 
So I've been trying to make the mixture that has been posted here multiple times and I keep getting hard clumps or chunks. Is there a proper order to adding the ingredients and is there anything I'm missing? I'm not sure if it's the EDTA (which I added last) or maybe I heard the Triton can be hard to mix. But this latest batch had real hard to break chunks in it that looked like maybe the EDTA. I did all the mixing at room temp FWIW
Just to validate, what is the formula you are using?
This is what I use to make a small batch of concentrate and then just add distilled water until the total is 500 ml:

BATCH 500.00 ml
HepaStat 256 1.00 ml
Triton X-100 1.40 ml
IPA 91% 25.00 ml
DH20 472.60 ml
TOTAL 500.00 ml
Concentrate ml 27.40 ml
Concentrate Oz 0.93 oz

I haven't seen any clumps and I can't say that I remember the exact order that I've followed; but I probably just added them in the order shown. Maybe the key is don't add water until the other ingredients have a time to mix together.
 
So I've been trying to make the mixture that has been posted here multiple times and I keep getting hard clumps or chunks. Is there a proper order to adding the ingredients and is there anything I'm missing? I'm not sure if it's the EDTA (which I added last) or maybe I heard the Triton can be hard to mix. But this latest batch had real hard to break chunks in it that looked like maybe the EDTA. I did all the mixing at room temp FWIW
Depends in what form the ingredients come in, I guess. For me, the quats come in pellets that take a long time to dissolve, even in warm water. The rest I mix in after the quats are fully dissolved. The Tergs are thick, syrupy liquids but dissolve readily, and the EDTA is a powder that also dissolves readily. It helps to shake the bejeezus out of it....
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom