• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
I also have forgone the EDTA.
I take 1 liter lab grade H20 - Ebay
Remove 50mls
Add 50mls lab grade Isopropanol - Ebay
Add 1 ml Triton X-100 - Talasonline
Add 1 ml 15-S-7 (hard to get) 15-S-9 available from Talasonline
Add 0.4 ml Hepastat - Staples online

Let sit for a couple of hours. The Triton sits on the bottom for a bit. I usually invert the bottle a few times.


Done!
No heating, no stir plates, just let it be for a while.
 
Hello everyone! LONGTIME reader of this thread, trying to figure out the best solution to make. I'm fairly new getting back into vinyl since I was a kid, so a lot of the records I've started obtaining definitely need some cleaning. After all the pages I've read through I had thought I had come up with the right ingredients/amounts/measurements for my solution.

The unfortunate thing is I am not noticing a huge difference if any on the older records I've tried to clean. The only big thing I've noticed is obviously less static on my records. For example I have a 1st pressing of Metallica's Master of Puppets, and a 1st pressing of Anthrax's Among the Living (Yes I'm a metalhead lol). No major scratches/jumps/skips, some surface wear for sure, but no matter how many times I have tried to clean it, the crackles and pops from dirt or whatever in the grooves persists, no real difference. Below is what I am using for my cleaning and solution. If anyone could chime in and tell me what I could do to switch it up or change it would be greatly appreciated, kind of at a loss here lol, thanks!

Using a GEM Dandy Record Cleaner
1st started using the paint pads from Home Depot, when that didn't results I got the Mobile Fidelity Record Brush
I rotate the record about 10-15 times each side using the pad with the solution
I then take a pressure sprayer (the ones you buy for fertilizer, etc) and spray/blast each side with distilled water, until the water beads as I know the solution has been completely rinsed off
Once complete I take the record and dry it with a Flitz microfiber cloth, holding the edge of the record against me so not to touch the actual record with my hands
Let it sit in a dish rack to dry

Here is my solution measurements.

For the stock solution:
Triton X-100 - 10 ml
Isopropyl alcohol (91%) 25 ml
DH2O. 15 ml

When I'm ready to create gallon of the cleaning solution:

I add the 50 ml stock solution above to a 1 gallon container.
3.8 ml Hepastat,
183 ml Isopropyl,
and fill with DH20.
 
Back during the dollar bin days … legacy Vinyl was dirt cheap. Often buying multiple copies of the same pressings in search of the best condition copies. $1 per LP .. sometimes if I had to buy the same album 3 or 5 times … so what? Cheap as chips. Anyway, this is what I found out.

Long story short .. over time you figure out that some playback problems are due to the pressing issues (all copies have the same surface noise issues) .. while others are due to condition (wear & tear) of the pre-owned copies .. also some problems are due to foreign contaminants in the grove that can be removed (possibly) w/ subsequent cleaning(s), while others will never be any better than they are "now". It just depends. One's cleaning methods may be perfectly fine and will work on the right "candidates" .. records that just need a good cleaning.

As a dealer told me some 19 years ago .. welcome to the wonderful world of analog. :)
 
Last edited:
First just let me say it's not my place to tell anyone what to use in there mix. Use what you wish and what works best for you. I use what works best for me and this is for info only. There had been some conversation on the differences between the use of ethanol or ISO. It's my opinion that it's best to use ethanol. ISO is a petroleum distillate. Vinyl that the record is made of is also made from a petroleum distillate. So over time depending on the concentration and time used will damage a vinyl record. You may not see it but it will be there in the grooves. Then the sound quality will be affected. Ethanol being a plant based product will not attack vinyl in the same way. I have been using it as part of my mix in a ultrasonic unit for a a while now with great success. Just my two cents.
 
First just let me say it's not my place to tell anyone what to use in there mix. Use what you wish and what works best for you. I use what works best for me and this is for info only. There had been some conversation on the differences between the use of ethanol or ISO. It's my opinion that it's best to use ethanol. ISO is a petroleum distillate. Vinyl that the record is made of is also made from a petroleum distillate. So over time depending on the concentration and time used will damage a vinyl record. You may not see it but it will be there in the grooves. Then the sound quality will be affected. Ethanol being a plant based product will not attack vinyl in the same way. I have been using it as part of my mix in a ultrasonic unit for a a while now with great success. Just my two cents.
I've been saying these things for years, but many seem satisfied that there is no problem. I'm no longer concerned whether other people screw up their records and assure themselves that they have the right approach. The inablity to consider all relevant aspects of any action and the failure to consider the details to a logical conclusion, will always return with negative consequences for those who are satisfied to only half think things through. It is cause and effect pure and simple.
 
First just let me say it's not my place to tell anyone what to use in there mix. Use what you wish and what works best for you. I use what works best for me and this is for info only. There had been some conversation on the differences between the use of ethanol or ISO. It's my opinion that it's best to use ethanol. ISO is a petroleum distillate. Vinyl that the record is made of is also made from a petroleum distillate. So over time depending on the concentration and time used will damage a vinyl record. You may not see it but it will be there in the grooves. Then the sound quality will be affected. Ethanol being a plant based product will not attack vinyl in the same way. I have been using it as part of my mix in a ultrasonic unit for a a while now with great success. Just my two cents.

Thanks for the response! So where is the best place to buy Ethanol alcohol? And would the measurements be the same as the ISO?
 
Hello everyone! LONGTIME reader of this thread, trying to figure out the best solution to make. I'm fairly new getting back into vinyl since I was a kid, so a lot of the records I've started obtaining definitely need some cleaning. After all the pages I've read through I had thought I had come up with the right ingredients/amounts/measurements for my solution.

The unfortunate thing is I am not noticing a huge difference if any on the older records I've tried to clean. The only big thing I've noticed is obviously less static on my records. For example I have a 1st pressing of Metallica's Master of Puppets, and a 1st pressing of Anthrax's Among the Living (Yes I'm a metalhead lol). No major scratches/jumps/skips, some surface wear for sure, but no matter how many times I have tried to clean it, the crackles and pops from dirt or whatever in the grooves persists, no real difference. Below is what I am using for my cleaning and solution. If anyone could chime in and tell me what I could do to switch it up or change it would be greatly appreciated, kind of at a loss here lol, thanks!

Using a GEM Dandy Record Cleaner
1st started using the paint pads from Home Depot, when that didn't results I got the Mobile Fidelity Record Brush
I rotate the record about 10-15 times each side using the pad with the solution
I then take a pressure sprayer (the ones you buy for fertilizer, etc) and spray/blast each side with distilled water, until the water beads as I know the solution has been completely rinsed off
Once complete I take the record and dry it with a Flitz microfiber cloth, holding the edge of the record against me so not to touch the actual record with my hands
Let it sit in a dish rack to dry

Here is my solution measurements.

For the stock solution:
Triton X-100 - 10 ml
Isopropyl alcohol (91%) 25 ml
DH2O. 15 ml

When I'm ready to create gallon of the cleaning solution:

I add the 50 ml stock solution above to a 1 gallon container.
3.8 ml Hepastat,
183 ml Isopropyl,
and fill with DH20.

As was mentioned, all the cleaning in the world cannot repair a worn record. Some wear is going to resolve as surface noise, so that may be your issue.

I think the positive pressure of the water is a good rinse, but for my efforts, following with some kind of vacuum drying brings superior results to wipe and dry. Currently I just have microfiber cushioning on a 4" wide vacuum nozzle. Not my end game, but it beats any results from wipe and let dry.
 
Vacuum drying is near complete reclamation of the cleaning solution from the record surface. I regard ultrasonic cleaning done right and vacuum drying to be the best methods I could consider.
 
As was mentioned, all the cleaning in the world cannot repair a worn record. Some wear is going to resolve as surface noise, so that may be your issue.

I think the positive pressure of the water is a good rinse, but for my efforts, following with some kind of vacuum drying brings superior results to wipe and dry. Currently I just have microfiber cushioning on a 4" wide vacuum nozzle. Not my end game, but it beats any results from wipe and let dry.


Thanks. I’ve definitely considered the vacuum step. Just trying to build the right one. The issue I’ve read is if you use a basic shop vac and a homemade nozzle the pressure can be too much. It seems some people recommend getting the $30 cheap shop vac at Walmart and that does the trick.
 
Thanks for the response! So where is the best place to buy Ethanol alcohol? And would the measurements be the same as the ISO?

I purchased it on Amazon. Its not expensive and it's fine to ship threw the mail in the U.S. I am not sure about Europe as I am not there. As for how much to use that's up to the mixer. I will say it does not take alot. In my opinion you don't need a 3/4 to 1/4 mix of the stuff. There is such a thing as too much if the good thing. But that's just me. Without giving away the farm start out with a little as you think and give that a try. Working up is always better when formulating. So says my chemist.
 
Would an aqueous 0.01%(m/v) concentration of trimethyloctadecylammonium chloride (CAS# 112-03-8) be as effective (antistatic and antimicrobial properties) and SAFE in an ultrasonic bath along 0.2%(v/v) Triton X-114 in solution than all the quaternary ammonium compounds suggested already? I work in a lab and have access to some "ingredients" not easily available to most folks.
 
Last edited:
Moderation Note:

This thread has a very specific topic. The last few posts have been removed for not honoring that topic. This thread is about squeezing the last few drops of goodness from custom cleaning solutions, not about what off the shelf solutions may be available, nor is it about making solutions from simple household cleaners.

Posts not in keeping with the specific topic shall continue to be removed.

Rich P
 
I have been using an ultrasonic machine with the cleaning formula that has been discussed in this forum (the Rushton formula). I dissolve the cleaning agents in de-ionized water to use in the US tank.

Today, I came across the following on the website of an industrial ultrasonic cleaning machine manufacturer:

"Fluids which are circulating in deionized water rinse tanks are subject to complete elimination of ultrasonic activity. Deionized water is very difficult to cavitate for any ultrasonic cleaning system since the tensile strength of the liquid is very high, making molecular separation of water difficult to achieve. Circulating deionized water is highly detrimental to the ultrasonic cleaning action in these tanks."​

According to this, deionized water interferes with the ultrasonic activity. Is it better to use distilled water for the US tank, followed by de-ionized water rinse? I would appreciate comments from the experts in this forum.
 
Never heard of this, but remember, you aren't using pure water in your tank....you have added detergents, alcohols, and other components if you are using this cleaning formula and these strongly affect the properties of pure water. I have my doubts about that manufacturers statement though, as most industrial applications (including semi-conductor producers) use and recommend de-ionized water in their tanks for cleaning. That said, it might be useful to re-visit the types of water at our disposal. The most pure DI water we use in the laboratory is Type I, obtained by multi-stage deionization and filtration. It is a strong solvent and will leach minerals out of anything it touches (which is why it is not suitable for drinking!). The lack of minerals makes it have a resistivity of >18 MOhm-cm and it is considered ultra-pure water. It is expensive and only used for specific laboratory applications...not record cleaning. Type II water is more common in the laboratory, it is also de-ionized using ion-exchange filters, with a resistivity of >1 MOhm-cm. Then there Type III (>4 Mohm-cm) and Type IV (>0.2MOhm-cm) which are typically produce using reverse osmosis. So which type of DI water are you using? If it is store-bought (or made using a home-deionizer) I imagine it is 0.1-1 MOhm-cm, but it should be labelled with a resistivity, conductivity, or a total dissolved solids value so you can assess. While these treatments remove ions, they leave behind organics, which can be removed by further filtration. Distillation will leave the non-volatile organics behind, but is not as free of minerals as DI so it is like 0.5-2 MOhm-cm. So when it comes to choosing what to use in a tank for record cleaning, it isn't that critical as we are adding chemicals to the water. We just don't want to use water that can leave mineral deposits so we choose basic DI or distilled rather than tap water (which is typically 1-2 KOhm-cm). Some ion content is actually useful for detergents to best do their job. It is easy to get carried away with laboratory grades of water, but the truth is the chemicals we are adding, the vessels and glassware we are using, all contribute some minerals to the mix. We just want to minimize deposits so we start with something that has been de-mineralized either by distillation or de-ionization. If we were doing complex chemical experiments it would be a different matter, but we are merely cleaning records with mixed solutions. An exception is when we are doing enzymatic cleaning treatments. Many enzymes require cations and anions for their optimum activity so we do not recommend highly de-ionized water in this case.
 
Question: isn’t Reverse osmosis at the Home level using a pre-carbon filter and a post carbon filter to remove organics? The one I have claims to reduce most of the organics to the 98.3% range were higher. I’m assuming the organic carbon are caught up in those carbon filters?
 
Last edited:
Thank you for the info, Phantomrebel.

The deionized water I use for the US tank is by, I believe, Pure Fresh Waters. They have dispensers at some of my local whole foods stores. This particular source of DI water is recommended for the formula that I use.

I also use several grades of water in my cleaning process, as follows:
- Spring water with Nexazyme for initial enzyme bath (about 20-25 mins/record)
- Pure Fresh Waters with the cleaning formula for US for US tank (11 mins/record)
- Pure Fresh Waters Rinse on a Nitty Gritty Machine
- Rinse with Reagent Grade water (by Ricca) + Denatures Ethyl Alcohol on a VPI machine (I use a record cleaning brush to spread the water on the record and slightly scrub the record during this rinse, also)
- Final Rinse with the above Ricca water without the alcohol on VPI machine (using a record brush to spread and scrub)

Here is a link to the site that talks about using deionized water in US tanks:
http://www.zenith-ultrasonics.com/fluid_circulation.htm

I could run the Aluminum Foil test in the US tank with De-ionized (plus cleaning formula) water followed by distilled water (plus cleaning formula) and compare the cavitation patterns. Would that be useful?

BTW, The US tank that I use is 40KHz, but, I should be getting an 80KHz tank in about a week. It will be interesting to do the Al Foil test on these two, also.
 
Question: isn’t Reverse osmosis at the Home level using a pre-carbon filter and a post carbon filter to remove organics? The one I have claims to reduce most of the organics to the 98.3% range were higher. I’m assuming the organic carbon are caught up in those carbon filters?
Yes, most organics are removed with this extra filtration step. Some pass through and it doesn't fully remove viruses and bacteria. However, filtered water that goes through RO is perfectly fine for record cleaning needs.

.....
Here is a link to the site that talks about using deionized water in US tanks:
http://www.zenith-ultrasonics.com/fluid_circulation.htm

If you read that link more carefully and in context, it is about tanks with CIRCULATING fluids, not about tanks that have water that is standing still in the tank.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom