• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hard to believe this thread is nearly 4yo.

Anyhoo, someone elsewhere is advocating a mixture of Span and Tween with a pinch of alcohol. I know nothing about the stuff, so was hoping for an expert opinion on the pros and cons.

Phantomrebel?
 
Wow, it has indeed been awhile. Sorry if I haven't contributed much lately; Huge project just completed so should have more time going forward.

Lowtherdream; sorry for the delayed response. Glad you found a substitute. How did the Virex II work out for you? Where did you find it and how much/gal?

Ulizy: that solution should be worth a try. A little high in chelating agent (5-10% n,n- bis(carboxymethyl)-alanine, which is similar to EDTA), but contains plenty of quat 6-12% and non-ionic detergent (1-2.5%). I would use at 1:1000 dilution. Let us know how it works out.

Rip: I don't see any advantage to using Tween. It is very gentle, and less likely to solubilize certain hydrophobic contaminants. We use it in the lab when followed by spectrophotometric analysis (as the aromatic Triton would interfere), but for record cleaning, why bother? I'm sure Tergitols are available worldwide. They would be the first to seek out. So what is Span?
 
Rip: I don't see any advantage to using Tween. It is very gentle, and less likely to solubilize certain hydrophobic contaminants. We use it in the lab when followed by spectrophotometric analysis (as the aromatic Triton would interfere), but for record cleaning, why bother? I'm sure Tergitols are available worldwide. They would be the first to seek out. So what is Span?
I was hoping you'd know. It's made by the same company and is intended to be mixed together with Tween to form a broader spectrum surfactant with soil targeting capabilities depending on the mixture, not unlike blending tergitols, it seems to me. Tween is easier and cheaper to get than tergitol, it's also environmentally degradable and less toxic. Don't know anything about the Span.

The mixture doesn't have a long shelf life, apparently....a point that works against it for me, but my overriding concern is, what is the nature of these particular surfactants when trace amounts are left behind after the rinse? Beneficial? Benign? Bad?
 
I was hoping you'd know. It's made by the same company and is intended to be mixed together with Tween to form a broader spectrum surfactant with soil targeting capabilities depending on the mixture, not unlike blending tergitols, it seems to me. Tween is easier and cheaper to get than tergitol, it's also environmentally degradable and less toxic. Don't know anything about the Span.

The mixture doesn't have a long shelf life, apparently....a point that works against it for me, but my overriding concern is, what is the nature of these particular surfactants when trace amounts are left behind after the rinse? Beneficial? Benign? Bad?


I see, Span is a reference to the sorbitans, which are similar to Tweens (polysorbates). The good thing about these surfactants is that they have very low CMCs so you can get away with using less. But they are very mild detergents. They might actually be good for a daily wash solution, something dilute that doesn't require a rinse. I know many are seeking such a solution. I have just focused on deep cleaning of very dirty records. Maybe the person advocating the mixture is going that direction? I'm interested!
 
I see, Span is a reference to the sorbitans, which are similar to Tweens (polysorbates). The good thing about these surfactants is that they have very low CMCs so you can get away with using less. But they are very mild detergents. They might actually be good for a daily wash solution, something dilute that doesn't require a rinse. I know many are seeking such a solution. I have just focused on deep cleaning of very dirty records. Maybe the person advocating the mixture is going that direction? I'm interested!
So, you're not against it, then? What about the residue?

Most records are not that dirty, having being exposed mostly to salty, oily fingers; coughs, sneezes and other face splash, and soot from the air. None of this necessitates an industrial strength cleaner if a more environmentally friendly one does the job.

But what of the residue? I know people who swear one type of rinse water is better than another of equally high purity. Surely, the surfactant residue leaves an even more profound signature?
 
With regards to strength, most non-ionic detergents are much milder than ionic counterparts. Not even close to industrial strength. This is why they are often chosen for delicate biochemical extractions (like isolating a protein from cells without denaturing it) and are often included in products for consumption (Tween-20 in breath mint drops, for example).
Multiple rinses after the detergent step is typically recommended. These detergents wash away well with water, the only residual is a molecular layer, not something that necessarily affects playback in a dramatic way. That said, these molecules, in mass, will effect the properties of the record. If they are negatively charged (like SDS found in dish soaps and shampoos), they can contribute to the attraction of dust and particles (much of this world is negatively charged). If they are positively charged (like quats) they can neutralize static charge (PVC based plastics inherently acquire a negative charge). If they are neutral (like non-ionics) it is assumed they have no effect in this regard. The problem with Tween-20 and other detergents that biodegrade easily is that they are susceptible to mold growth. Dilute solutions of Tween must be used rapidly, not stored. Even the concentrate breaks down (turning yellowish) upon prolonged storage, releasing free fatty acids. For these reasons (and the fact that it isn't that easy for the average person to acquire) I have not recommended it.
So when choosing a detergent, there are a lot of factors to consider if you want to get really into it, like: How well does it solubilize the contaminants a record typically encounters? How much of the endogenous chemicals in the record does it extract? What is the minimum amount that can be used and still be effective? How does it effect surface charges? How well does it rinse off? Do the hydrophilic and hydrophobic moieties effect the record in other ways?, etc.
The real question though is how these surfactants effect playback and this it is mostly a matter of trial and error once a detergent (and useful concentration) is selected based on these questions. I don't think enough work has been done to determine the audible differences, if any, between one molecule or class of molecules and another. I have found that issues arise from low solubility detergents with super long hydrophobic chains as they can leave behind a waxy-like layer that accumulates on the stylus. But audible signature between Tergitols, Tritons, Tweens, and other nonionics?...simply not enough is known. I think this is mostly because we have focused on effectively removing the debris that actually causes noise in a way that best preserves the record.

Edit: I should add that environmental concerns are also a legitimate factor in choosing a detergent. In fact, Triton X-100 is set to be banned in the EU by 2021 as it is thought to negatively effect aquatic environments.
 
Last edited:
With regards to strength, most non-ionic detergents are much milder than ionic counterparts. Not even close to industrial strength. This is why they are often chosen for delicate biochemical extractions (like isolating a protein from cells without denaturing it) and are often included in products for consumption (Tween-20 in breath mint drops, for example).
Multiple rinses after the detergent step is typically recommended. These detergents wash away well with water, the only residual is a molecular layer, not something that necessarily affects playback in a dramatic way. That said, these molecules, in mass, will effect the properties of the record. If they are negatively charged (like SDS found in dish soaps and shampoos), they can contribute to the attraction of dust and particles (much of this world is negatively charged). If they are positively charged (like quats) they can neutralize static charge (PVC based plastics inherently acquire a negative charge). If they are neutral (like non-ionics) it is assumed they have no effect in this regard. The problem with Tween-20 and other detergents that biodegrade easily is that they are susceptible to mold growth. Dilute solutions of Tween must be used rapidly, not stored. Even the concentrate breaks down (turning yellowish) upon prolonged storage, releasing free fatty acids. For these reasons (and the fact that it isn't that easy for the average person to acquire) I have not recommended it.
So when choosing a detergent, there are a lot of factors to consider if you want to get really into it, like: How well does it solubilize the contaminants a record typically encounters? How much of the endogenous chemicals in the record does it extract? What is the minimum amount that can be used and still be effective? How does it effect surface charges? How well does it rinse off? Do the hydrophilic and hydrophobic moieties effect the record in other ways?, etc.
The real question though is how these surfactants effect playback and this it is mostly a matter of trial and error once a detergent (and useful concentration) is selected based on these questions. I don't think enough work has been done to determine the audible differences, if any, between one molecule or class of molecules and another. I have found that issues arise from low solubility detergents with super long hydrophobic chains as they can leave behind a waxy-like layer that accumulates on the stylus. But audible signature between Tergitols, Tritons, Tweens, and other nonionics?...simply not enough is known. I think this is mostly because we have focused on effectively removing the debris that actually causes noise in a way that best preserves the record.

Edit: I should add that environmental concerns are also a legitimate factor in choosing a detergent. In fact, Triton X-100 is set to be banned in the EU by 2021 as it is thought to negatively effect aquatic environments.
Except for touching upon chelating agents, as close to a nutshell consideration as exists in this thread. :thumbsup:

Rich P
 
Hello all, I am coming very late to the party so I’m hoping that my questions can be answered and the scientists & chemist have not left the conversation. I see some advocate the Triton-X100 while others say to use a 50/50 blend of Tergitol 15-S-3 & 15-S-9. I’m curious what’s the difference between these 3 detergents? I understand that 15-S-3 is oil soluble & 15-S-9 is water soluble, not sure about how similar (or different) Triton X100 is? I understand the proper dilution and method of dissolving the detergent into a concentrated stock solution of H20 & IPA. So mainly interested in what each of these does for the cleaning process and is there a preference? I’m mixing to use in a US tank, and post vacuum with DIH20.
I have read the whole thread (speedily so I may have missed the explanation) till about page 70. Happy to re-read the post that explains if you can direct me to it.

Thanks
Gregg
 
Moderation Note:

I have approached @phantomrebel , the defacto authority in this thread, and have asked him to create a comprehensive resource thread, for all of you dedicated AudioKarma vinyl enthusiasts. The thread you are reading is filled with very valuable information and the supporting science, but it is dispersed though almost 100 pages of discussion, which is also quite valuable.

phantomrebel has graciously consented to, in part, distill this thread, for the underpinning science and information. It shall be provided in semi-regular installments, each installment addressing a topic that is specific to our shared passion. It has been requested that a thread be made available for discussion on these topics, and we have decided that this thread shall continue to serve that purpose. If you have questions, comments or suggested topics regarding coverage in the new resource thread, feel free to post them in this thread. As usual, you should find phantomrebel quite responsive.

Here is the new AK resource: Record Cleaning, a Comprehensive Resource

Feel free to take a look at the new resource. I am sure that you will find it well worth the price of admission already. If you appreciate the work going into the new resource, please contact the author and express yourself. He is doing this work as a gift, just for you fine folks.

Rich P
 
Hello all, I am coming very late to the party so I’m hoping that my questions can be answered and the scientists & chemist have not left the conversation. I see some advocate the Triton-X100 while others say to use a 50/50 blend of Tergitol 15-S-3 & 15-S-9. I’m curious what’s the difference between these 3 detergents? I understand that 15-S-3 is oil soluble & 15-S-9 is water soluble, not sure about how similar (or different) Triton X100 is? I understand the proper dilution and method of dissolving the detergent into a concentrated stock solution of H20 & IPA. So mainly interested in what each of these does for the cleaning process and is there a preference? I’m mixing to use in a US tank, and post vacuum with DIH20.
I have read the whole thread (speedily so I may have missed the explanation) till about page 70. Happy to re-read the post that explains if you can direct me to it.

Thanks
Gregg
Hi Gregg. Excellent question. It has been addressed previously (e.g. https://audiokarma.org/forums/index...youre-doing-it-wrong.689430/page-91#post-1801) but only in brief. In a nutshell, the different detergents have slightly different properties in terms of solubilizing different contaminants (a longer, hydrophobic aliphatic chain detergent is more effective on oils, for example.). For the most part, a single general use detergent should suffice (Triton X-100 or Tergitol 15-S-7 as examples). However, there is some synergy brought to the table when you mix a more hydrophobic surfactant (oil loving) with a more hydrophilic (water loving): You might be casting a bigger net to catch a wider range of contaminants. Furthermore, a hydrophobic surfactant like 15-S-3 isn't very soluble in water by itself (yet soluble in oil) whereas it's mixture with 15-S-9 (mixed-micelles) is soluble in water (important to make sure it rinses away). Then there is the foaming potential of a particular detergent when used in a particular device. The choice of detergent is important enough though to warrant a deeper discussion. In fact, the next post in the resource thread Rich mentioned above will delve deep into detergents, their properties and uses to help us choose what is best for our application. Stay tuned. Meanwhile, rest assured that either the Tergitol mix or Triton X-100 typically work just fine as they are all gentle, non-ionic surfactants that help solubilize a wide range of contaminants and have been extensively tested on records.
 
Last edited:
Audiokarma should be proud that you are posting this here. Thanks phantom.

Thank you Theophile, for your continued support and encouragement! When I took this on, I was hesitant because I thought it would just be a lot of work. I was wrong, it actually gives this old fart something to look forward to and a very satisfying sense of community (karma I guess?). So thanks should be given to Rich, it is all his fault...err...idea!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom