• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Record Cleaning: Developing the Best Possible Methods

Status
Not open for further replies.
I've been using the cleaning formula to great event.
Albums have come back to life.
I hope to get a US cleaner sometime in the near future. Though for know I'm very impressed with just my SqueakyClean and Mofi brushes.
 
Ollie: Very nice to hear! US cleaning can really help, but not always necessary. Lots of inexpensive tanks on the market now though. Because they take large volumes of cleaning liquid, it's nice to make your own!

All: The detergents section of the resource thread was posted yesterday. Quite a lot of "chemical speak", but hopefully it will help with some of the questions regarding options that are out there.
 
If I may, I would like to request an installment in the resource thread. It would be better saved for when the first principles have been addressed, as it has to do with details. What I would like to see is a discussion of how micelles actually function, with images and such. Also, what we might be doing to interfere with the process. It might help us to "visualize" what we are trying to accomplish with our processes.

Likewise, I would like to have a similar treatment applied to the chelating agents we should be using in our ultrasonic baths.

I know you would have eventually taken us there. I just want to go on record, expressing my interest.

Thanks for your work so far. Each installment is just superb.

Rich P
 
Hello phantomrebel and thanks for all the work you are doing here. I, as others, surely appreciate it. Having said that, I started reading this thread a long time ago and then dropped off with other concerns. Now, I'm back in gear and have a brand new US setup consisting of a VinylStack 3 record rig and a 6L US tank. So, I'm kinda like the kid who just got his first car, landed a date with the most wonderful girl in the school but no gas to put in the tank!!! Literally, all I really need is a good formula and just haven't found that yet but really need to get going or the date might just wind up "gone with the wind!" So, do you have any suggestions for me? I sure would appreciate it and thanks in advance......just a simple formula please.
 
..just a simple formula please.
Hey, we don't do simple here! Seriously though, the most simple formula for an ultrasonic tank is just 0.025% non-ionic detergent like Tergitol 15-S-7 or Triton X-100 in DI water. Let the records air dry, don't dry rub them. If you have issues with static, you can add 0.01% of a quat. detergent.


Update: I just put up a new Resource post that provides a more basic introduction to detergents. Just wanted folks to have a starting point.
 
Hey, we don't do simple here! Seriously though, the most simple formula for an ultrasonic tank is just 0.025% non-ionic detergent like Tergitol 15-S-7 or Triton X-100 in DI water. Let the records air dry, don't dry rub them. If you have issues with static, you can add 0.01% of a quat. detergent.
What about sucking them dry with a vacuum RCM, especially considering the addition of a bit of a quat to deal with any static generated this way? Would this cause problems?

Is there no need for a rinse cycle or two with this formula?

I'm not challenging. Rather, I'm in learning mode.

Enjoy,
Rich P
 
Last edited:
OK, thanks phantomrebel, much appreciated......so, as I've been reading thread after thread, I've seen so many US solutions that contain IPA, a detergent (usually Triton X-100 or Tergitol), and a wetting agent, usually Photo-Flo along with the distilled water.

1) Do you encourage or discourage the use of IPA, and if the former, at what strength (as in % of total solution)?

2) How do you suggest the Triton X-100 should be added to the solution? I've read that it is not very soluble in DI water and should first be mixed in a separate container, usually with distilled water, IPA and perhaps the Photo-Flo to create a "batch" that is then added to each fresh mix in the tank. Is that how it should be done? If so, can you give steps to get the best results? In other words, how does one ensure that the Triton X-100 is going to mix well with the distilled water?

3) Some have suggested that a bath should be discarded after cleaning approx. 12-15 records (depending on how soiled they are, more often if necessary). Then, pouring this bath through something like a coffee filter into a clean container and re-using the mix to conserve on the ingredients. Is this something to do or not to do? If so, how many times, or for how long, is the solution viable?

Thank you so much!

Yes, Rich P, learning mode is so right!

PS - You are so right about air drying.....with my new rig, I have only done 3 records because I do not have a final solution (used 6L distilled water, 8 fl.oz. IPA, 1 fl.oz. Photo-Flo) and have been waiting to settle on that before going any further.....just a "trial run," so to speak. After 15 minutes at the 6V setting, which means the records made 5 complete revolutions, I put the stack on the drying stand and watched the water literally cascade off of the records (thanks to Photo-Flo maybe???). To aid the process a bit, I set up a small fan to blow air lightly through the stack and it took a little less than 10 minutes for them to be bone-dry, clean and super-shiney with no need to do anything else. When I removed the records from the stack, there was a very slight amount of moisture near the labels where the 0-rings are. I wiped that off with the supplied soft microfiber cloth, never touching the grooves, and all was good. Several of the good folks here, notably 4-2-7, have also suggested not touching the records post-bath and so far I would have to agree, with the caveat of drying that area near the label if necessary with the soft cloth.

This is very exciting, by the way, and seems to hold great promise as I have over 1,500 records in my collection that have not been cleaned, not to mention the other 1,500 that I have cleaned using my DIY cleaning technique that will now be US cleaned again.
 
Last edited:
What about sucking them dry with a vacuum RCM, especially considering the addition of a bit of a quat to deal with any static generated this way? Would this cause problems?
Is there no need for a rinse cycle or two with this formula?
I'm not challenging. Rather, I'm in learning mode.
Enjoy,
Rich P

Yes, using an RCM to rinse and dry post US is the ultimate, but Fishead was asking about simple and it did not appear he had this equipment. Hence, a bath rinse post US with DI H20 and air drying is the next best thing. I always recommend a rinse, just like you wouldn't take your dishes directly from a soap bath and call it good. If you look at the last detergency step (after dispersion), you see that the contaminant micelles must be rinsed away along with the excess detergent monomer.

The rinse step can indeed benefit from a bit of quat (0.01% or less) to aid in static protection in future handling (sleeve removal, etc). This would be what I call "record conditioning". The choice of quat is important as the long chain, highly hydrophobic ones can be waxy and some quats are better antistats than others. For the average user, the quats found in products like Hepastat will work. Here is a subject that deserves a future resource post though, if nothing else so that commercial products can be improved.

Even with a quat addition, rubbing can cause static so it is baffling to me why some (even manufacturers) recommend a microfiber cloth wipe. There is a whole new body of research now on static charge that has changed the way we think about it. For example, it is now accepted that molecules from each material are transferred to each other (not just the charge) and the result is patches of charge transfer, not fields. Strange, but proven. I have a whole presentation on static charge that I'll put up on the resource thread when I have time. Static is something easy to avoid and easy to deal with.


Edit: Let me clarify one thing. Some say that using a RCM to dry records will produce static. I disagree. The RCM does not remove all the water, in fact the only things in contact with the record, the pads, stay moist throughout the process. You cannot have static charge when moisture is present. Water is too good of a conductor. All you need is a little humidity and it is dissipated. It is dry wiping that causes static charging. I suppose there could be a situation where the vacuum is left on for too long and the pads dry out where this could arise, but not if the machine is used appropriately. In other words, just use the RCM to remove the bulk of the liquid and air dry afterwards. Similarly, one could wipe with a wet cloth, but this is not as consistent.
 
Last edited:
OK, thanks phantomrebel, much appreciated......so, as I've been reading thread after thread, I've seen so many US solutions that contain IPA, a detergent (usually Triton X-100 or Tergitol), and a wetting agent, usually Photo-Flo along with the distilled water.

1) Do you encourage or discourage the use of IPA, and if the former, at what strength (as in % of total solution)?

2) How do you suggest the Triton X-100 should be added to the solution? I've read that it is not very soluble in DI water and should first be mixed in a separate container, usually with distilled water, IPA and perhaps the Photo-Flo to create a "batch" that is then added to each fresh mix in the tank. Is that how it should be done? If so, can you give steps to get the best results? In other words, how does one ensure that the Triton X-100 is going to mix well with the distilled water?

3) Some have suggested that a bath should be discarded after cleaning approx. 12-15 records (depending on how soiled they are, more often if necessary). Then, pouring this bath through something like a coffee filter into a clean container and re-using the mix to conserve on the ingredients. Is this something to do or not to do? If so, how many times, or for how long, is the solution viable?

Firstly, I do not recommend Photo-Flo and suggest Edwal LFN instead if photographic supplies are all you have access to. Please read the resource thread, it is a waste to add both Triton and Photo-flo as they contain the same detergent. Don't be confused by the term "wetting agent". This is the first thing any detergent does.

1). I do not encourage the use of IPA in a US bath as it is usually unnecessary and wasteful. Some put nothing but water in the bath as it is a good enough solvent, but in this scenario there is no way to capture and remove contaminants. The US can be seen like the agitator in your clothes washing machine. It helps with the dispersion step, but not removal of contaminants. You need a detergent for that and IPA has little detergency. That said, if the contaminants are mostly oils, an alcohol can help break them up so detergents can better adsorb them. This is more important in a hand-washing situation than US since the forces in the latter process break up the oily contaminants. An exception would be a record that someone coated with something oily, there you have no choice but to add solvents. Don't be surprised, you will encounter these examples (wiping with a dry Swiffer pad deposits mineral oil, for example).
2). See the Triton entry in the Resource thread. Either dissolve it first in alcohol or stir it for a few hours.
3). The amount of detergent gets exhausted with time as micelles trap the contaminants. You deplete the amount enough and you no longer can form micelles (below CMC). We are talking very small molecular aggregates here, not something a coffee filter will remove. This type of filter is for large particles and precipitates that are in the solution so it really isn't helping extend the life of the solution. Use your judgement like you do in dishwashing: you likely discard the bath water quite frequently. If you are making your own cleaning solution with just detergent as I describe, it probably is costing you about the same as the dishwashing liquid solution (pennies per gallon) so why not use it similarly? Your records deserve the best.

The number one reason we make our own solutions is so that we don't have to try and reuse and conserve some expensive commercial product that we need large volumes of.
The second reason is so that we can adjust the ingredients to suit the particular record we are cleaning.
The third is so that we make them even better than they do (like including a conditioner).
 
Last edited:
OK, I think I'm starting to get it......I DO have a DIY record cleaning machine that has worked quite well for a number of years, but what I'm reading now is that the less we handle the records, the better off they will be. So, I'm thinking that the bath in the US, followed by a rinse with distilled water and then air drying would be the preferred method.

The reason I say this is because in my experience, when cleaning lots of records, there is always going to be a build-up of contaminants on the vacuum wand unless one changes those pads after "sucking" only a very few records dry. That can become not only time and labor-consuming, but pretty expensive as well.

The only step I left out after doing the first 3 records is the rinse.....this should be easy enough with the records still attached to the record stack, spraying with distilled or maybe even just running some water out of the faucet over them with the head set to spray might be even better and quicker as it would allow for a more complete and thorough rinse.....that is of course, unless using tap water would introduce unwanted contaminants and offset the effectiveness of the process??? Your take?

Also, while you do not recommend the use of IPA in the bath, if one dissolves the Triton 100-X in a 50% alcohol solution that would be adding it de-facto. Nothing wrong with that, is there? Otherwise, I don't have several hours to stir it in distilled, which is the other way you suggested it might be dissolved.
 
My advice:
Do not rinse with tap water, unless you have a reverse osmosis system. Use distilled or de-ionized.
Nothing wrong with the small amount of IPA used to dilute the Triton. It gets vastly diluted out before it touches your records.
 
Thanks, I was hoping you would not say that because it would have made things real easy. Using distilled, I have to figure out a way to spray them down really good for the rinse to be effective, or put them on my RCM and spread the distilled with the paint pad while rotating the record on the platter. That's how I have done the rinse in the past so I guess I will just have to put that step in there after the US bath.....thank you sir!

And, just to be clear, you are saying (in the resource thread) that 50% IPA/Triton X-100 mix to dilute, which I read as to make a quart, use a pint of Triton and a pint of IPA, shake well and store in a cool, dry, dark place. Add to the tank of 6 liters of distilled water using a mix of ??% to that 6 liters before the cleaning session. That right? How much of the mixture do I add to the 6 liters of distilled? Sorry if you have already answered that.....

How long can I keep that mix of IPA/Triton before it is no longer useable?
 
Last edited:
And, just to be clear, you are saying (in the resource thread) that 50% IPA/Triton X-100 mix to dilute, which I read as to make a quart, use a pint of Triton and a pint of IPA, shake well and store in a cool, dry, dark place. Add to the tank of 6 liters of distilled water using a mix of ??% to that 6 liters before the cleaning session. That right? How much of the mixture do I add to the 6 liters of distilled? Sorry if you have already answered that.....

Fishead: No, I'm not saying that at all. Assuming you are starting with a 100% stock Triton solution, and desire a final 0.025% Triton, you need to just add 1.5 ml of the stock to a small amount (like 10 ml) of 50% alcohol to get it to disperse, before adding int to the 6L of water (1:4000 dilution). In this scenario, that is like 0.08% final alcohol which is insignificant. If you desire a certain alcohol percentage in your cleaning mix, go ahead and add it separately as needed.

ALL: The fact that the alcohol helps disperse the Triton illustrates a very important point. Alcohols can similarly help disperse certain contaminants, which is why I'm not opposed to their use. However they aren't always necessary. For example, you could just add the Triton to water, put it in the US tank, and let it run for awhile and it would disperse. Similarly, contaminants disperse under these forces. It really depends on how you are cleaning your records and what is on them. With vinyl records, there aren't many downsides to including alcohols at low concentrations (I suggest 15% or less), other than cost. What I am opposed to is using them at high concentrations (where they can remove endogenous chemicals from the record) or using them alone, without a detergent (where there are no micelles to entrap and remove the contaminants). I know there are people out there who just wipe their records down with 50% alcohol and call it good, I will never be one of them.
 
Last edited:
Whew! Glad you clarified that and thanks! Now I think I have it straight in my head, especially when you give the details in ml. The Triton 100-X is, I believe, just that....a 100% stock solution(it is from Biopharm and nothing else is on the label, just 100-X). 50% alcohol would be half 99% IPA and half distilled, so 5ml IPA and 5ml distilled for a total of 10ml. Add 1.5 ml of the Triton, shake it up and then add that to the 6L of distilled in the bath and I'm good to go, right?
 
Whew! Glad you clarified that and thanks! Now I think I have it straight in my head, especially when you give the details in ml. The Triton 100-X is, I believe, just that....a 100% stock solution(it is from Biopharm and nothing else is on the label, just 100-X). 50% alcohol would be half 99% IPA and half distilled, so 5ml IPA and 5ml distilled for a total of 10ml. Add 1.5 ml of the Triton, shake it up and then add that to the 6L of distilled in the bath and I'm good to go, right?
Yes, except the shaking part. There is no need and it causes issues; just stir or gently invert, it goes in right away. This ain't no martini!
 
Confirmed, sir! I'll save the shaking for the martinis which will come whilst listening!!!:beerchug:

Seriously, I'm so happy to now have a formula fit for my 6L tank. Actually, I think that the tank is more like about 5L, at least that is where the overfill line is at but the solution should be just fine in any case.

There is a thread over on another forum where someone by the name of Rushton gives you a lot of nods for having helped him perfect his solution. He adds Hepastat (a quat, as you mentioned) and several here do as well. That might be the last thing added to my formula. Is that the same thing as what they call Hepastat 256 and can be had at Walmart in one-gallon jugs (you have to order it though)?
 
Last edited:
Confirmed, sir! I'll save the shaking for the martinis which will come whilst listening!!!:beerchug:

Seriously, I'm so happy to now have a formula fit for my 6L tank. Actually, I think that the tank is more like about 5L, at least that is where the overfill line is at but the solution should be just fine in any case.

There is a thread over on another forum where someone by the name of Rushton gives you a lot of nods for having helped him perfect his solution. He adds Hepastat (a quat, as you mentioned) and several here do as well. That might be the last thing added to my formula.
Yes, I helped Rushton develop his recipe and he asked my permission to share it on another site. It seems to work well for many US tank users, though I think one can tweak the detergent levels down a bit for most situations. But you asked for something simple and his has multiple ingredients.
Good luck with your cleaning and let us know how it works out.
 
For sure! I will be off to the mountains tomorrow early and be gone for a week camping and doing some fly fishing so won't be cleaning until I get back. That will give the Hepastat time to arrive and I'll be all set. Yes, I did notice that his levels are much higher than what we've been discussing. Further, he uses an 8L tank, but adds a full 14 oz. of IPA!!! That's a ton, isn't it?
 
The only step I left out after doing the first 3 records is the rinse.....this should be easy enough with the records still attached to the record stack, spraying with distilled or maybe even just running some water out of the faucet over them with the head set to spray might be even better and quicker as it would allow for a more complete and thorough rinse.....that is of course, unless using tap water would introduce unwanted contaminants and offset the effectiveness of the process??? Your take?
FWIW, when I was using my GEM Dandy clone I used tap water to do the bulk of the heavy rinsing, then a copious rinse of distilled from a spray bottle to displace the tap water. No issues, provided your tap water is clean, potable drinking water.
 
Question about the stirring part of this. I have salt water reef aquarium tanks, and having such we "make" our own salt water from RODI water and in my case dehydrated salt water salt.
We do this in quantities as small as 5 gallon buckets but as large as 55 gallon drums.
What all of these have in common and in common with this subject is that the mixture must be constantly stirred.
We do this using submersible "pumps" which are nothing more than propellers to move the water.
We also use these inside of our tanks to provide the "Ocean Motion"
Would it be feasible to use one of these small pumps to do the mixing for us?

https://www.amazon.com/Jebao-Propel...ef=sr_1_8?keywords=wp10&qid=1570155262&sr=8-8
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom