As a follow-up to my original post, it seems that some people have interpreted my comments as a statement that the higher the price of a component, the better the sound. However, that is not what was said and certainly not what I meant. A $10K amplifier is not necessarily “better” than a $5K amplifier. However, both had better be better than a $500 amplifier because if they weren’t, companies making them would find themselves out of business overnight. That rule applies to pretty much any product. If a Yugo can outrun a Ferrari, why should Ferrari even exist? We can all argue about the amp’s size, weight and number of knobs and switches on the front panel, etc, but there can be no argument about the internal circuitry and quality of components that go into it. If my $2K amp outputs 4 Hz to 40 KHz with practically zero distortion at whatever power level, that is most definitely much better than an awesomely handsome, good sounding, golden front panel amp that puts out 20 Hz to 20 KHz and cost $300K.
Top quality transistors, capacitors, resistors and a rock solid chassis all cost money. The quality and placement of the power supply alone can decide and differentiate a great sounding amp from an average one. “Internal organs” are what reputable audio companies spend money on in high-end audio. That, and of course, research and years of refinement as well. Painstaking research to figure out how to eliminate vibration or undesirable cross-talk and dozens of other negative effects are what we as consumers have to pay for in addition to the cost of equipment or audio companies would not be able to survive.
That being said, what I said originally was about a comparison of amplifiers to speakers in the same class, rather than amplifiers compared to each other. In my experience, it matters a great deal what kind of amplifier I listen to through the same set of speakers. Here is an example of what I mean illustrated through what I consider an average set of Athena Technologies S2/P2. Not a high-end set by any means, but not a slouch either. I listened to them through a Naim system (separate amp, preamp and power supply), Rogue Audio Tempest II and Creek 4330R all of which I own and therefore am very familiar with. All three produced very different results on a $1,200 or so set of speakers playing the same recording through the same CD player. Then I hooked up a $200 Kenwood amp just for fun. Again, a totally different sound experience, but hardly worth mentioning. I repeated the same test again with my Von Schweikert speakers that have a much lower sensitivity rating and discovered that my most expensive Naim gear performed terrible. Creek was OK and Rogue sounded the best. By comparison, Naim sounded hollow, anemic and lifeless, kinda like the average boombox from the 1980’s. If I had to write a review about that experience and be honest about it, I’d have to say that Naim makes terrible amplifiers hardly worthy of being on a Walmart shelf at $47.96, which would have been an insane thing to say. So my point was and still is that choosing the right amplifier/speaker combo is critically important no matter the price point which is why trying them with our own gear is the only way to be certain that what we are getting satisfies our musical tastes.
Thanks to all who have commented and provided examples of their personal experience with various amp/speaker combos. Your comments have helped me conclude that the high sensitivity of the Pendragons and their transparent nature are most likely going to produce the musical results I was looking for. I was a bit concerned about making a purchase without hearing upfront what the speakers sound like. I feel better now.
Top quality transistors, capacitors, resistors and a rock solid chassis all cost money. The quality and placement of the power supply alone can decide and differentiate a great sounding amp from an average one. “Internal organs” are what reputable audio companies spend money on in high-end audio. That, and of course, research and years of refinement as well. Painstaking research to figure out how to eliminate vibration or undesirable cross-talk and dozens of other negative effects are what we as consumers have to pay for in addition to the cost of equipment or audio companies would not be able to survive.
That being said, what I said originally was about a comparison of amplifiers to speakers in the same class, rather than amplifiers compared to each other. In my experience, it matters a great deal what kind of amplifier I listen to through the same set of speakers. Here is an example of what I mean illustrated through what I consider an average set of Athena Technologies S2/P2. Not a high-end set by any means, but not a slouch either. I listened to them through a Naim system (separate amp, preamp and power supply), Rogue Audio Tempest II and Creek 4330R all of which I own and therefore am very familiar with. All three produced very different results on a $1,200 or so set of speakers playing the same recording through the same CD player. Then I hooked up a $200 Kenwood amp just for fun. Again, a totally different sound experience, but hardly worth mentioning. I repeated the same test again with my Von Schweikert speakers that have a much lower sensitivity rating and discovered that my most expensive Naim gear performed terrible. Creek was OK and Rogue sounded the best. By comparison, Naim sounded hollow, anemic and lifeless, kinda like the average boombox from the 1980’s. If I had to write a review about that experience and be honest about it, I’d have to say that Naim makes terrible amplifiers hardly worthy of being on a Walmart shelf at $47.96, which would have been an insane thing to say. So my point was and still is that choosing the right amplifier/speaker combo is critically important no matter the price point which is why trying them with our own gear is the only way to be certain that what we are getting satisfies our musical tastes.
Thanks to all who have commented and provided examples of their personal experience with various amp/speaker combos. Your comments have helped me conclude that the high sensitivity of the Pendragons and their transparent nature are most likely going to produce the musical results I was looking for. I was a bit concerned about making a purchase without hearing upfront what the speakers sound like. I feel better now.



