• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Test record opinions

img_5106.jpg
 
Sounds like a lot of manual work when all I have to do is put on the test record and bam! it's done. Some people are noobs and some are snobs. If I want a test record I will buy one I certainly don't need approval from anyone other than my wife.
I never said you or anyone can't use them. I did say they will have you chasing your tail around and noobs think you need them to setup a table right and why this thread was started. Clearly it's not the case and yes I see a lot of snobbish post saying you need one to setup a table right. I look at it as a crutch for a listener who is unsure they are setting their table up right. Kinda like the grass is greener on the other side, it's the not knowing that sells these records in the first place.



I have never got better SQ from a test record, better SQ comes from better equipment, setup and learning to listen to the music and decipher if there is a issue in the first place.
 
I humbly apologize for starting a thread so innocently that of course turned contentious. Sigh.I thought it was simple enough. Though I have been setting up turntables for 40+ years I thought I would "up my game", as it were, and maybe learn something.
To paraphrase- What do you think is a good test record and what particular features did you think was useful.
But, in apparent AK fashion, attitudes were bared, daggers were drawn. Can't we all just get along?!
Now, for all who'e replied, I appreciate the opinions you've stated. It's good to see what has been used and has been useful. I don't know that I would have seen all that you've shown me in my own research- I mean, who knew that The National Lampoon put out a test record?
So, by all means please continue to enlighten, elucidate, and inform.
 
It seems to me that a test record would be a good way to evaluate azimuth. I have dialed in my Ortofon 2M black as best I can by visual alignment, but a reference track would be useful. Just when I think I have azimuth dialed in - -I will be playing a record and it sounds out of phase. I sum the channels and the highs disappear. Did my alignment change, is the problem with the recording or the pressing, is there some other issue I am not aware of?

I have always used 10 or 15 Khz test tapes for setting heads on reels and cassette, so I think this is a valid question the OP presented. Why the attitude over a reference disk? I would think you would find one being used at every audio design lab.

Just another arrow in the quiver, no need to shoot someone in the back.
 
Last edited:
I humbly apologize for starting a thread so innocently that of course turned contentious. Sigh.I thought it was simple enough. Though I have been setting up turntables for 40+ years I thought I would "up my game", as it were, and maybe learn something.
To paraphrase- What do you think is a good test record and what particular features did you think was useful.
But, in apparent AK fashion, attitudes were bared, daggers were drawn. Can't we all just get along?!
Now, for all who'e replied, I appreciate the opinions you've stated. It's good to see what has been used and has been useful. I don't know that I would have seen all that you've shown me in my own research- I mean, who knew that The National Lampoon put out a test record?
So, by all means please continue to enlighten, elucidate, and inform.

No need for you to apologize.
Anyone of these that I have will be good for you to experience and learn from. The old saying you don’t know till you try holds true. I have and stated my opinion based on my experience over years setting up all levels of equipment.

image.jpg
 
I bought a test record for its 3150 Hz tone, which was used by an Apple iPhone app called PlatterSpeed to compute wow and flutter. In retrospect, I could have gotten that tone from an internet signal generator. Anyway, I got an accurate measurement of one turntable, which confirmed the manufacturers spec, which was not a particularly good one. The next time I wanted to measure a different turntable, but I couldn't find the test record for awhile. By the time I did, the PlatterSpeed app had become useless, as the authors never updated it for Apple's new, 32-bit-only iOS version. The app was not cheap, either.

:(
 
Though I have been setting up turntables for 40+ years I thought I would "up my game", as it were, and maybe learn something.
In fact take your pick of two of the test records in my photo above except for the sound effects and the Stan Ricker. I'll send them to you for free so you will learn if this is for you, if not pass them on to someone else as good karma that might feel they need them.

I'm sure on this site many would chose the HiFi Stereo Review as one of the main go to test records, the others are also good, hold a poll.
 
It seems to me that a test record would be a good way to evaluate azimuth. I have dialed in my Ortofon 2M black as best I can by visual alignment, but a reference track would be useful. Just when I think I have azimuth dialed in - -I will be playing a record and it sounds out of phase. I sum the channels and the highs disappear. Did my alignment change, is the problem with the recording or the pressing, is there some other issue I am not aware of?
I can send you a test record also.
 
I can send you a test record also.

Maybe I will borrow the Ortofon. Let me do some research and see if it would be useful. For example, my RSD Grateful Dead Live July 26, 1966 P.N.E Gardern Aud. Vancouver Canada has obvious phase cancellation when summed to mono. I blame this on the recording, but maybe it is on my end. My mono recordings have zero high frequency loss when summed to mono, but some stereo recordings do. Can an out of alignment stylus cause phase cancellation that becomes obvious when summed to mono? I am pretty familiar with azimuth as it relates to tape heads, but not so much with phono cartridges.

I am going to listen to more of the Dead album and see with the phase issue changes on other tracks, that would be interesting.
 
Last edited:
Just when I think I have azimuth dialed in - -I will be playing a record and it sounds out of phase. I sum the channels and the highs disappear. Did my alignment change, is the problem with the recording or the pressing, is there some other issue I am not aware of?

For example, my RSD Grateful Dead Live July 26, 1966 has obvious phase cancellation when summed to mono. I blame this on the recording, but maybe it is on my end.

And this has been my point in this thread.

I'll say it, test records are for noobs that are unsure they are setting up a table or system right.

Set the table and cartridge up as their instructions state and play music on the records you have. Listen for things like distortion, sibilance on many records to rule out a bad mastering. Then make adjustment accordingly with VTF, VTA, Anti Skate and Azimuth. And don't expect every record to sound perfect because they are all different and thats not your fault, or the records fault it's just the way it is. It can be many many variables that a given record does not sound it's best on your setup. It can be you phono stage loading doesn't like your cartridge, it can be the records got a hot mastering that your stage and system doesn't like, there are things a basic system can not adjust for. But a different mastering of the same title might sound perfect.

As I stated before there are many other variables like every single record one plays is different. I think many try to make this look like rocket science and it's not.
 
I never said you or anyone can't use them. I did say they will have you chasing your tail around and noobs think you need them to setup a table right and why this thread was started. Clearly it's not the case and yes I see a lot of snobbish post saying you need one to setup a table right. I look at it as a crutch for a listener who is unsure they are setting their table up right. Kinda like the grass is greener on the other side, it's the not knowing that sells these records in the first place.



I have never got better SQ from a test record, better SQ comes from better equipment, setup and learning to listen to the music and decipher if there is a issue in the first place.
I haven't chased my tail anywhere. I get it you don't think they are of value for you. I am sure some people agree with you and some don't. It is opinion and nothing more. What I don't get is your insistence that they are not of any value to anyone else. I am no noob and I don't agree with you on this topic. I don't think you will be able convince me otherwise. SQ comes from the combination of many factors. If a test record can help someone do a better setup then I say. "go for it".
 
Last edited:
For example, my RSD Grateful Dead Live July 26, 1966 P.N.E Gardern Aud. Vancouver Canada has obvious phase cancellation when summed to mono. I blame this on the recording, but maybe it is on my end.
Try changing the polarity on your speakers the next time you put this record on.

img014_zpsrsinlflc.jpg
 
@4-2-7 For example on my recent Grateful Dead release, why would the engineer not fix the phase issue in the mastering session? Another thing WE have to deal with?!

So if pressings are all over the place, out of azimuth alignment master transfers and inexcusable out of phase channels, one MUST have a reference disk, or several and a scope.

What? -- you just eyeball it and throw on a Journey album and say it is good. No, it is 2019 we need verifiable, proof that our carts are setup right. Reference tones can guide us to vinyl nirvana. :)
 
Last edited:
What I don't get is your insistence that they are not of any value to anyone else.
Again, I guess your not reading clearly, I never said that nor implied it. I said "a test record is for someone who is unsure they are setting up their table correctly"<that must have value to them. I also said "I look at it as a crutch for a listener who is unsure they are setting their table up right. Kinda like the grass is greener on the other side, it's the not knowing that sells these records in the first place." < that must also be of value to some.

Your grip is that it must offend you in some way that I don't feel the need to use these test records and stated that. Take a look as your the one that started quoting me in a bad attitude. Now please do put me on ignore as I see no value in your post.
 
Last edited:
@4-2-7 Why would the mastering engineer not fix that in the mastering session? Another thing WE have to deal with?!
A recording can get flipped in every gain stage from recording to mastering and then through our system. What matters is that the miced recording matches our speakers at the end of the chain.

What you just eyeball it and throw on a Journey album and say it is good.
No, I setup my table with a protractor for overhang, digital scale for VTF, VTA measurements for rake angle and anti-skate settings. SME series 309, series V arms are very accurate and rock solid in holding their settings
 
Last edited:
No, I setup my table with a protractor for overhang, digital scale for VTF, VTA measurements for rake angle and anti-skate settings. SME series 309, series V arms are very accurate and rock solid in holding their settings

Yeah, that is what I did as well. I was just surprised at how many records I play have phase issues. Still, I would feel better if I could look at a test tone from a disk, on a scope or in Protools, and know that my rig is set-up correctly or if it is drifting out of spec.
 
Last edited:
A recording can get flipped in every gain stage from recording to mastering and then through our system. What matters is that the miced recording matches our speakers at the end of the chain.

I think the phase issue may be from azimuth of the source tape, but can not say for sure. If it is, it could have been an easy fix. When I have some time I will look into it some more.
 
@4-2-7 For example on my recent Grateful Dead release [with phase problems}, why would the engineer not fix the phase issue in the mastering session? ...
A couple more reasons come to mind.
  • The mastering engineer may not be very talented, and may have introduced the problem through lack of skill. The abundance of poor-quality in the mastering of thousands of CDs provides ample evidence of this (and fortunately, some examples of high competence out there as well).
  • The mastering equipment may not have been setup/installed correctly (genuine mistakes happen, and/or incompetence).
  • And finally, when I asked this question on another audio forum, a mastering engineer replied that he often uses phase shifts in a stereo mix for effects, such as widening the stereo stage.
 
A couple more reasons come to mind.

  • And finally, when I asked this question on another audio forum, a mastering engineer replied that he often uses phase shifts in a stereo mix for effects, such as widening the stereo stage.

That's interesting. The recording is rather flat, so this is quit possible. Thanks for the input.
 
Back
Top Bottom