• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Test record opinions

this is where i have to ask questions, and i'm not trying to be a smart arse, but the question bugs me. lets say the majority of the album is playing in the 12db gain range, and rarely goes to 14 or 16 db gain. But one has set the antiskate to pass the 16db setting. wouldn't the majority of said album have excessive groove wear due to the bias being set to a much higher amplitude than the album has?

The vast majority of stones i have looked at for folks, that have wear predominately on one side, is the side that shows too much bias added, or very poor horizontal bearings.

At the risk of hijacking the OPs thread I will have to question how you are measuring the wear on the "stone".

The advantage of using a scope with a hot track is the ability to balance the mistracking to be equal in both channels.

I found back in the day that the basic manufacturers setting via a spring were all over the place but for most market table seemed to be on the low side.

The skating force we are trying to correct for is a complicated reaction, it should be noted that most quality test disc will position those test tracks on the inner part of the record. I believe the HIFI record has the tracks in multiple locations.
 
What kind of scope, what degree of wear are you measuring of the 25 per quadrant that border the threshold of damage.

I have been using a Wild M5 since 1979, well actually in '78 but only knew how to look at the worthless pictures Shure provided dealers until I was taught the correct way by Dirk Roos in 1979.
 
Last edited:
Maybe I will borrow the Ortofon. Let me do some research and see if it would be useful. For example, my RSD Grateful Dead Live July 26, 1966 P.N.E Gardern Aud. Vancouver Canada has obvious phase cancellation when summed to mono. I blame this on the recording, but maybe it is on my end. ...
It’s in the recording.
@4-2-7 For example on my recent Grateful Dead release, why would the engineer not fix the phase issue in the mastering session? Another thing WE have to deal with?! ...
It’s a 53-year-old 2-channel recording off the soundboard at a rock gig. There’s only so much you can fix in mastering when you’re dealing with something like that. They had to wait 24 years for someone to invent the technology to fix the phase issues in one 1968 recording before it could be mixed and released. But that was 8 tracks. It’s a lot tougher when you’ve got drums, vocals, bass, organ, and two guitars all stacked on two tracks. I haven’t pulled it up in a DAW because I haven’t been bored enough, but I’m going to guess that if you shift one track to fix the vocals, for example, you probably lose something else. Jeffrey Norman is a good-enough mastering engineer that he would have fixed it if it was possible to with with typical mastering techniques.

Now, it may be possible to fix that with some of the new computer gear/software. I heard about some new system that they used to retune Earth, Wind & Fire’s horn section (the whole band was recorded across 6 tracks, so the horns were stacked on one, I believe) for the new Woodstock CD release. But that work was painstaking and expensive. And it may or may not work as well for phase issues. I don’t know enough about it. But even if it did work and the producers knew it was out there, I doubt Rhino was going to pay for it for that GD release.
Lets add one more reason, a hippy chick named Betty recorded the master tape with her little R2R off the sound board at a live concert and was wasted.:p
No, some weirdo named Owsley recorded it with his “little” R2R off the sound board at a live concert. And he had probably eaten a lot of meat.
 
It’s in the recording.

Yes. I came to that conclusion late last night. A great show, captured by a flawed method. The hard panned vocals and the weird phasing. I think @AudioFeline was have on to something. They may have used a phasing plug-in to widen the stereo field. I was amazed at how the the mix collapsed in mono. Dramatic on this Dead record, but the high frequency loss when summed is present on many others I have. As long it is not on my end I am fine with that. But I still want the tools to verify that my set-up correct.

Thanks
 
Yes. I came to that conclusion late last night. A great show, captured by a flawed method. The hard panned vocals and the weird phasing. I think @AudioFeline was have on to something. They may have used a phasing plug-in to widen the stereo field. I was amazed at how the the mix collapsed in mono. Dramatic on this Dead record, but the high frequency loss when summed is present on many others I have. As long it is not on my end I am fine with that. But I still want the tools to verify that my set-up correct.

Thanks
I understand. I use a test record to check that stuff because I occasionally wire up something backwards. If that happens, I catch it immediately and don’t have to spend time tracking down the problem. I have the CD of this particular Dead show, so I checked it real quick and yeah, there are some issues. I’d be surprised if they used a plug-in, though. Doesn’t mean they didn’t. If they did, though, it might be easier to fix that than I initially thought. My guess is that it’s phase-cancellation from how it was miked.

So, now that I’m interested, I probably will pull it up in a DAW and have a look. I’m pretty sure I have some other recordings from the same time period. I’ll have a listen and a look and see if they have the same problem.
 
I have a couple test records that I have mainly just used to measure resonance.

I am having some distortion in louder passages and tried the HiFi news test record to check some other stuff. I cannot figure out what is causing the distortion.
1. All three tracking tracks on outer, middle and inner at 15dB are fine.
2. The 14dB track is fine, 16dB distortion starts to be heard. 18dB it is bad.
3. Compliance is about 7 horizontal and 7-8 vertical.
4. Azimuth and channel balance are good.

Any thoughts?
 
Increasing tracking force to 1.8 instead of 1.2 made the 16dB track pretty good.
 
Last edited:
So for shits and giggles last Friday I put the HiFi Stereo Review test record on one of my tables. I had absolutely no issues so I guess my ears are pretty good and don't need a noob record to set my tables up.

Should I do another one? come-on pick one that will throw my arm.

image.jpg
 
So for shits and giggles last Friday I put the HiFi Stereo Review test record on one of my tables. I had absolutely no issues so I guess my ears are pretty good and don't need a noob record to set my tables up.

Should I do another one? come-on pick one that will throw my arm.

View attachment 1604941
@4-2-7, repectfully, I don't understand why the attitude.
I totally get you don't need or want a test record. Any test record. And I'm OK with that. No qualms. No judging. You're happy. :thumbsup:
Why do you persevere in downplaying the potential efficacy of their use to someone else that would like to have one as a reference and/or aid for their turntable/cartridge setup? Other than the money spent, and who among us hasn't spent money frivolously, what's to lose? :dunno:
 
@4-2-7, repectfully, I don't understand why the attitude.
Read page one and get down to earth again, it's the ones who are promoting a test record that have attitude.

Why do you persevere in downplaying the potential efficacy of their use to someone else that would like to have one as a reference and/or aid for their turntable/cartridge setup? Other than the money spent, and who among us hasn't spent money frivolously, what's to lose? :dunno:
I already in one of my post a few pages back said I'd send you a record or two to try out and keep for free. Then you can come to your own conclusion as others did on page one.
 
In fact take your pick of two of the test records in my photo above except for the sound effects and the Stan Ricker. I'll send them to you for free so you will learn if this is for you, if not pass them on to someone else as good karma that might feel they need them.

I'm sure on this site many would chose the HiFi Stereo Review as one of the main go to test records, the others are also good, hold a poll.
Right here in case you missed it @ctjetta
 
Right here in case you missed it @ctjetta
I saw it the first time and I truly appreciate the generosity of your offer.
So for shits and giggles last Friday I put the HiFi Stereo Review test record on one of my tables. I had absolutely no issues so I guess my ears are pretty good and don't need a noob record to set my tables up.

Should I do another one? come-on pick one that will throw my arm.

View attachment 1604941
And despite your protests otherwise this posting express nothing but contempt for the thesis of this thread.
I'm not implying others haven't presented an attitude in their posts, nor was yours necessarily the first or worst, you so far have been the most contrarian.
Okay, you've made your point.
I do truly your input on many topics including this one and look forward to any other opinions you may have. But do you really think you have more to offer here?
 
the thesis of this thread.
I went back and looked at the OP, your right, it's not about the validity of these test records. Myself and others brought it there and I was first in doing so. You just want to know what others think is the best ones they have used.
I'm not implying others haven't presented an attitude in their posts, nor was yours necessarily the first or worst, you so far have been the most contrarian.
I always try to do my best:D
I do truly your input on many topics including this one and look forward to any other opinions you may have.
Trust your ears, listen to the music and records you normally play, they will tell you if you need to make an adjustment.
But do you really think you have more to offer here?
Nope, but my offer still stands.
 
I went back and looked at the OP, your right, it's not about the validity of these test records. Myself and others brought it there and I was first in doing so. You just want to know what others think is the best ones they have used.

I always try to do my best:D

Trust your ears, listen to the music and records you normally play, they will tell you if you need to make an adjustment.

Nope, but my offer still stands.
:thumbsup:
 
Back
Top Bottom