• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Test record opinions

The Shure records I am refering to came with the dealer purchase of a CPEC and were available via co-op funds.

I can not remember the numbers, maybe the TTR-xxx series, but without a scope were pretty much worthless.

Those were different to the consumer test records.
 
I bought a test record for its 3150 Hz tone, which was used by an Apple iPhone app called PlatterSpeed to compute wow and flutter. In retrospect, I could have gotten that tone from an internet signal generator. Anyway, I got an accurate measurement of one turntable, which confirmed the manufacturers spec, which was not a particularly good one. The next time I wanted to measure a different turntable, but I couldn't find the test record for awhile. By the time I did, the PlatterSpeed app had become useless, as the authors never updated it for Apple's new, 32-bit-only iOS version. The app was not cheap, either.

:(
The bastards!
What matters is that the miced recording matches our speakers at the end of the chain.
What you're saying is I need to introduce rodents to my sound system?
 
I never said you or anyone can't use them. I did say they will have you chasing your tail around and noobs think you need them to setup a table right and why this thread was started. Clearly it's not the case and yes I see a lot of snobbish post saying you need one to setup a table right. I look at it as a crutch for a listener who is unsure they are setting their table up right. Kinda like the grass is greener on the other side, it's the not knowing that sells these records in the first place.

I have never got better SQ from a test record, better SQ comes from better equipment, setup and learning to listen to the music and decipher if there is a issue in the first place.

People can get adequate performance without going the test record route, no doubt. However, the only way to know your setup is good at the extremes is via measurement, though gross errors can be heard. This is beyond what the average hobbyist is capable of doing, though I don't understand the need to belittle those who want to try.

It may be of no interest to you, which is your prerogative. Stating as fact that you don't need one to properly setup a 'table and that it's a crutch isn't true. It's not a must-do, but if you want to get it dialed-in the best that can be, it's absolutely needed.

Below is a bias/azimuth issue causing gross mis-tracking at high velocity in the right channel. This setup sounded fine 95% of the time, but there was an issue with peaks on hot records. This gross example isn't difficult to hear if you know what you're listening for, but good luck getting it dialed-in beyond the obvious by ear.

V15VMR_TTR103_IMD-30_osc-1024x791.jpg V15VMR_TTR103_IMD-30_spec-1024x791.jpg
 
Last edited:
Those were different to the consumer test records.

I believe the OP was asking about the for the trade test records not the typical consumer records.

I still have my Shure and AT test records that I have been using for 40 years. Certainly not the original copies as I have replaced them at every opportunity.

I have been sorting through a number of new current releases and with the experimenting a laptop based osciliscope posted in other threads some of the results.

So far the HIFI news disc has offered the most but does lack a few important test tracks. I recently heard of another record pressed in Germany that I will have to get my local record store to order for me. Once I remember the name of it.

I restored my Shure CPEC and still have a Techtronix scope which I use as my old school reference.

The CBS records we had around the shop decades ago were well worn out and since we had a bunch of new Shure records obtained as co-op it made sense to keep rotating new copies in as we wore them out. When we started doing business with AT again we ended up with a stack of those also.

I really should obtain and evaluate a CBS record or two, will need to add that to the list.........
 
I believe the OP was asking about the for the trade test records not the typical consumer records.

I still have my Shure and AT test records that I have been using for 40 years. Certainly not the original copies as I have replaced them at every opportunity.

I have been sorting through a number of new current releases and with the experimenting a laptop based osciliscope posted in other threads some of the results.

So far the HIFI news disc has offered the most but does lack a few important test tracks. I recently heard of another record pressed in Germany that I will have to get my local record store to order for me. Once I remember the name of it.

I restored my Shure CPEC and still have a Techtronix scope which I use as my old school reference.

The CBS records we had around the shop decades ago were well worn out and since we had a bunch of new Shure records obtained as co-op it made sense to keep rotating new copies in as we wore them out. When we started doing business with AT again we ended up with a stack of those also.

I really should obtain and evaluate a CBS record or two, will need to add that to the list.........

I appreciate your effort to infer what my original post was asking. I hadn't really stated properly- trade test records would be of interest, but, as I lack the associated test equipment required, nor am the intended target (CBS test record for broadcasters) I am more interested in those test records that I can currently use by ear. And though they may have useful tracks on them not enough, I imagine, to warrant choosing one over the a more consumer oriented product.
Not that I don't wish to acquire an oscilloscope (would need to be small and inexpensive, for starters). So, baby steps.
 
I can only speak for myself, but to me good test records are mandatory. Without them I would know so much less about the vinyl front end. Be it freq response, be it distortion, be it you name it.
 
Michael Fremer can probably eyeball any cartridge set-up better than anyone on this forum. He's not a "noob" and even he uses test records (along with other tools) when he want's to know for sure and extract the most out of a set-up... and this is a guy who has changed thousands of cartridges and listens critically for a living.
 
Last edited:
I appreciate your effort to infer what my original post was asking. I hadn't really stated properly- trade test records would be of interest, but, as I lack the associated test equipment required, nor am the intended target (CBS test record for broadcasters) I am more interested in those test records that I can currently use by ear. And though they may have useful tracks on them not enough, I imagine, to warrant choosing one over the a more consumer oriented product.
Not that I don't wish to acquire an oscilloscope (would need to be small and inexpensive, for starters). So, baby steps.

I do not know of any new "professional" for the trade test records being pressed.

So my trials have been using the end user type and comparing them to and evaluate how well they work with my 40 year old test gear as well as trying new things like a A to D converter and a laptop osciscope. $25.00 for the Berringer A to D. There are freeware scopes.......

The established general standard for perceived distortion threshold has been 3% for most human hearing.......a scope can let you see 1/2% easily.

So far I have found the HiFi news record to be the best bang for the buck with the proviso that I have not tried it as a listening test, only with my scopes.
 
I do not know of any new "professional" for the trade test records being pressed.

So my trials have been using the end user type and comparing them to and evaluate how well they work with my 40 year old test gear as well as trying new things like a A to D converter and a laptop osciscope. $25.00 for the Berringer A to D. There are freeware scopes.......

The established general standard for perceived distortion threshold has been 3% for most human hearing.......a scope can let you see 1/2% easily.

So far I have found the HiFi news record to be the best bang for the buck with the proviso that I have not tried it as a listening test, only with my scopes.
Thank you for taking the time to reply. When referring to test records for professionals (broadcasters) I wasn't assuming there would be any in current production. Given the nature of broadcasting today, probably mostly of a digital format of one type or another, and certainly lots more talk/sports, it wouldn't have occurred to me there would be a need to calibrate a broadcast operation via the use of an LP record.
Though I imagine if one was so inclined . . .
 
I don’t own a test record. But I want one.

I do a lot of comparisons of aftermarket styli on vintage cartridges. I would love to do FR sweeps, original styli vs aftermarket, to see where the failings are of aftermarket styli. See if they introduce a resonant peak, are shy on bass response, or trail off on higher frequencies.
 
Just to clarify, when you are referencing azimuth are you speaking of crosstalk measurement, that is in aero terms "roll"? Or pitch or yaw?


Crosstalk. After some more testing I think I am dialed in pretty well. I think I will invest in the Clear Audio Azimuth test record for verification.
 
Last edited:
I'll try to describe what bias settings with the HFN analog test LP is like, letting you be the judge of how suitable it is for you.

There are 4 bias (anti-skate) obstacle tracks on that record, each more 'difficult' for the stylus than the previous. There's also a strip of blank vinyl groove in the middle of side 1, so you can ballpark your AS settings and configure it to stay put at the middle of that blank strip while spinning the test LP. That's a good start.
  • The first bias setting track plays a 300Hz signal at 12dB and if your anti-skate settings is correct, you will hear a smooth continuous tone for the next 15 seconds.
  • It's pretty easy to tell, pretty straight forward, you'll most likely nail it with the default 'blank groove settings' that you begun with.
  • However, if, for some reason, your AS settings are off, you will determine, very noticeably, a buzz in one channel or the other. The buzz is audible and unmistakable.
  • This means the forces applied to the stylus while it rubs against the inner and outer sides of the groove are unbalanced.
  • This also means your anti-skate is off and you need to improve it - reduce or increase the force applied, until that track is smooth sounding.
  • No oscilloscope required, no lab gear, no fancy shmancy anything - just some peace and quiet and common sense.
.

this is where i have to ask questions, and i'm not trying to be a smart arse, but the question bugs me. lets say the majority of the album is playing in the 12db gain range, and rarely goes to 14 or 16 db gain. But one has set the antiskate to pass the 16db setting. wouldn't the majority of said album have excessive groove wear due to the bias being set to a much higher amplitude than the album has?

The vast majority of stones i have looked at for folks, that have wear predominately on one side, is the side that shows too much bias added, or very poor horizontal bearings.
 
Tnsilver has a nice review of the HIFI news record although I have been trying to find discrete spot L and R frequencies to test as we did with our CPEC.

With the end user at home tests and the included alighnment setup it strikes me as a well done package.
 
Back
Top Bottom