• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Tom's Hardware articles on audio

Register to hide this ad
This thread is doomed to be closed, they all are eventually.

The simple fact is that speaker and audio cables are religion, not science. There are believers and non-believers, no factual measured repeatable engineering data will change that.
 
Worlds Best Cables (WBC) are good enough for me. ~$35 per rca signal cable. Nice connectors - good flexibility - many lengths to order from. They look and smell better than the bananas. I tried mud but my wife kept cleaning it up.
 
Does the fact that the banana and the mud use what appears to be a significant length of copper wire to make connection account for anything?
 
Last edited:
Electrical measurements and hearing perceptions are two different things. Ears are not oscilloscopes.

...and oscilloscopes are not ears!

Understood, and agree.

However, if sellers were to simply claim “it sounds better to me and others who I have quoted below”, this would be an honest seller. The ones who claim that skin-effect, cryogenic-treatment of copper wire, shielded power cables, magnets, directional wire, break-in and other (mis)uses of science and engineering somehow affect cables in a significant enough way to make the sound more accurate, … either it’s science and can be proven with numbers and proper test data, or it isn’t. My point was/is that if it’s simply a matter of it sounds better to your ears, that’s great and should be the end of the discussion. If it is some abstract application of a scientific principle, then scientific data (the oscilloscope in your examples) should be able to prove that it is an audible improvement of accuracy.

I go with it looks better, sounds better, feels better, is part of the fun of shopping/trying/buying/discussing audio equipment in most cases, and just like how I can “justify” a custom boron-fiber shift knob, … it can exist without science and I don’t have to prove that it does anything else, and the manufacturer shouldn’t claim it will improve my lap times unless it can be proven scientifically with accurate data.
 
Last edited:
Daniel von Recklinghausen, one of the top engineers in the HiFi field once gave this advice regarding sound:
"If it measures good and sounds bad, — it is bad. If it sounds good and measures bad, — you've measured the wrong thing."
His opinion was that the human ear played the largest part in the sound equation, and should not be disregarded because the sound measurements were “perfect”.
 
His opinion was that the human ear played the largest part in the sound equation, and should not be disregarded because the sound measurements were “perfect”.
Yeah, but I don't necessarily agree that's the crux of many debates.

Personally I have little interest what constitutes preference re. "sounds good" other than mine for me. But, to me that's a completely different matter than claiming to be able to hear a difference yet also asserting or insinuating measurements can't show some difference.

(Which I think is about what SaturationPt was saying earlier too.)
 
Last edited:
Yeah, but I don't necessarily agree that's the crux of many debates.

Personally I have little interest what constitutes preference re. "sounds good" other than mine for me. But, to me that's a completely different matter than claiming to be able to hear a difference yet also asserting or insinuating measurements can't show some difference.

(Which I think is about what SaturationPt was saying earlier too.)
I agree with @SaturationPt, and with your point. I'm just not a big fan of those who claim if it measures good, then it must sound good. I don't discard their measurements, as they may work great for some folks. My preference is to let my ears be the ultimate judge for me. I'm also a big fan of Recklinghausen, and not only because of his HiFi accomplishments, but also his wartime stance during WWII.
 
I was composing a post in this regard on another thread that got killed off.
But has anyone measured the electrochemical effects of joining dissimilar metals in an audio signal path? Here's a thought exercise.
If you use copper or silver in a wire, then tinned braid as a shield, then terminate these into a gold-plated or tin/lead soldered?? Could this result in the creation of one or more thermocouples functioning as a glorified IC?

Distortion is defined as anything added or removed from the original signal. One type of distortion is a current electropotential brought on by different metals.
If we're gonna split atoms...sorry, but I'm skeptical.
-k
 
Bananas? Mud? Ha! Isn’t good old fashioned H2O supposedly the best conductor? Duh!

***
I just put my tube amplifier in one bathtub and my tube preamplifier in another, just below the surface. Going to spin some Sinatra mono. I’m in a third bathtub (between the two) and holding onto the bare copper wires connecting the amp to the preamp. I’ve instructed my dutiful wife to turn everything on from the breaker downstairs. (Thrilled to be part of science, she was more than willing to oblige.) After we do some AB / ABC / ABCD & etc. Blind and Triple Blinds, using Monster Cable and others and distilled vs. soft water, etc., I’ll let you know the results…
 
Last edited:
Look at it like this - about half of the audio industry would go away if companies were forced to prove their claims in order to be granted a sales permit. When exclusivity, kept, and unaffordable are the driving force
of a product category, skepticism is high - and rightly so. You just have to listen ... Why? No two people hear the same let alone have identical bias or preferences.

As a former trainer of audio professionals, I can tell you firsthand that there are off-limits topics. When someone holds an opinion dearly and you prove them wrong in a room full of their peers, you lose - no matter how PC you pull that off.

I buy Kimber PBJ products mainly because they are made extremely well from very high quality parts. At the asking price I feel that's what I'm paying for and that's my value proposition. I also build many cables and have for 35 years now. There is a distinct pleasure in knowing it was built correctly by your hands and fits perfectly.
 
Back
Top Bottom