• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Transistor Substitutions

Note KSA733 needs "C" suffix for center collector - "KSA733C"!
Good catch. Thanks!

They seem to be the original to me. Order some BC5566A earlier without knowing they are A733 actually instead. Wondering do I need to order KSA733C? What is better? And at the same time, since I have some KSA992 in hand, thinking about doing a quick swap on this pair to see can they fix my high DC issue. But even the readings on the original A733 seem pretty “matched”.
Better...HMMM. I always think what's original is better, but that's not always possible. The KSA733C is End of Life at Mouser and NLA at Digikey. The KSA992 is a little slower, with a little more gain. BC556A is faster and with more classifications for gain. I'd measure the hFE and select from the grade that best matches the original. The Y classification on the 733 best matches the 556A. Not any real issues selecting between these three.

If the originals are not bad, why do you want to change?
 
If the originals are not bad, why do you want to change?

This.
Changing every single transistor in a unit really doesn't gain you anything, and can cause trouble. Unless it's confirmed faulty, or a known recurring failed device, leave it be.
 
As I mentioned, I was suspecting this pair is the cause of the high DC offset at that channel, but the readings, hfe 253/268, Vbe 698/702, seems “matched”, I think. I don’t want to hijack this post, see this https://audiokarma.org/forums/index...acquired-nad-7020.982268/page-3#post-15337456 regarding my NAD 7020. Any comment is welcome there.

At least, I know that any of these 3 transistors seem to be ok here in this application. Below is the rating of these transistors posted by other member. Ic of KSA comparing to others seems much lower?
4B669F0E-CC43-4023-AB96-9696FBF9E234.png
 
Well, I got to go into the RT-1020L for a slight distortion on low speed rec/playback. Looking at the schematic, I have a bunch of the 2SC1344s, pair of 2SC1213s and 2SC1000s in the signal path. I think my notes are right here, especially the 1344s. Are the other two right on?

2SC1344 E or D --> KSC1845FTA
2SC1213 B or C --> KSC2383YBU or 2SC1815
2SC1000 GR --> KSC1815Y or KSC1845F
 
IME, there is nothing inherently wrong with any of those part numbers. Unless some are actually are faulty, I would leave them alone. ^^^
 
Looking for pre-drivers for my Crown D150A. They've got +/- 45V at the collectors.

Originals are NSD106 (NPN) / NSD206 (PNP). Original pin-out is E/B/C.

Wondering what a good, available equivalent pair would be.

Thanks in advance.

Can I use KSA1220/KSC2690 or KSA1381/KSC3503 here? Asking because I have them on hand.

For what it's worth, the Motorola cross reference book called out 2N4919 for the NSD106.
The Crown DC-300A manual calls out 2N4929 for the SS7304 which seems to be an equivalent to the NSD206.
 
Last edited:
The originals, 1A devices, and being EBC, would make it a bit challenging, but if the PCB has the "triangle" pads you can orientate the KSA1220/C2690 pair (1.2A) so they'll fit in.
KSA1381/KSC3503 are 0.1A devices, maybe not enough for the task (pre-drivers in the D150A).
 
New request for substitution assistance on two transistors, please. These are for a MCS 3222 receiver, the first is the BC559B that is no longer available on mouser and the second one I have attached a photo of it. It is marked "9934" I checked it on my DCA55:

NPN
HFE = 134
Ic = 2.50mA
Vbe = 0.719V
Ib = 4.229mA
Ic = 0.000mA
9434.jpg
 
New request for substitution assistance on two transistors, please. These are for a MCS 3222 receiver, the first is the BC559B that is no longer available on mouser and the second one I have attached a photo of it. It is marked "9934" I checked it on my DCA55:

NPN
HFE = 134
Ic = 2.50mA
Vbe = 0.719V
Ib = 4.229mA
Ic = 0.000mA
View attachment 2522626
It's the BC549B, the compliment to the BC559B... A "general purpose" transistor. Just check the datasheets for an equivalent and available Center BASE transistor. The "B" is the gain group Somewhere between 300 and 500hFE will suffice, and at least a 100mA (0.1A) current rating. Low noise type preferred.
 
KSA1220 / KSC2690 have higher Cob, where 2SA899 / 2SC1904 have impressively low ~3pF Cob.
In applications like VAS/predriver, KSA1381 / KSC3503 (also with low ~3pF Cob) will be superior to the 1220/2690 pair and the TTA/TTC004 pair.

The place the latter parts would be beneficial is where a higher Ic is needed (the originals are 0.05A, so not this particular application).
Those TTA/TTC parts are definitely nice though (with good "all round" numbers), will be useful to keep on hand for other substitutions.
Thank you for the info , I have replace the 2SA899/2SC1904 in the Sansui AU717 (pre drivers ) with Toshibas TTA/TTC’s .
I have on hand original BF470/469 complementary pairs , with 1,8pf Cob and 60mhz min. ft vs 100mhz of the the original 2SC/SA’s
(I can’t find out if it’s min or max value ) I was debating , if it’s a better sub …. any comment will be appreciated!
Cheers Kostis
 
Hello @ducati2, 2SK68 is quite expensive here but still available. A 2SK117-GR would be my choice for substitution but it is hard to find (but stil out there). In my opinion you could substitute it with 2SK301 which is cheaper. There may be others. The 2SK121 has comparable Idss and transconductance but a bit shy in voltage (30V), you need to see if in your circuit this is not a limitation.
 

Attachments

Last edited:
Edit 08/09/2018:

WARNING: This above list is only meant to be a guideline and not a list of absolute substitutes. Use with caution!
Replacing transistors depends on multiple factors and blindly using these as replacements without additional consideration based on your circuit and individual application, is not recommended.

It might help a lot of less-experienced folks if this caution appeared before the first long list of possible replacements. If I found a match for some transistor I was trying to replace in the list, I would likely not continue reading all the way down to where this very important piece of advice appears.

Below is a very good decision path example
Link to flowchart for choosing a substitute transistor...this case a 2SA726

There is a long thread on "how to find a replacement transistor" that leads one through the whys and covers the application-specific question that is sometimes critical (and might just save the surrounding vintage components when considered). Will you add this to the bottom of the first post in this thread for those who want to understand why considering the application is important?
 

It might help a lot of less-experienced folks if this caution appeared before the first long list of possible replacements. If I found a match for some transistor I was trying to replace in the list, I would likely not continue reading all the way down to where this very important piece of advice appears.



There is a long thread on "how to find a replacement transistor" that leads one through the whys and covers the application-specific question that is sometimes critical (and might just save the surrounding vintage components when considered). Will you add this to the bottom of the first post in this thread for those who want to understand why considering the application is important?
Agreed,
I will work on that first page.
 
I have attached a photo of it. It is marked "9934" I
The part is the MPS9434:
upload_2022-4-18_16-16-22.png

in my opinion, the BC337-40 could be a conservative substitute for the MPS9434, but depending on which table one looks they state lower Ic parameters.
For the BC337 Vceo=45V, Ic=0.8A, 250 < hfe <630 and Ft=210 MHz. But it is not specified as a low noise part.
 

Attachments

  • upload_2022-4-18_16-16-22.png
    upload_2022-4-18_16-16-22.png
    147.5 KB · Views: 8
Back
Top Bottom