• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Transistor Substitutions

Note KSA733 needs "C" suffix for center collector - "KSA733C"!

Is this actually important or can you just turn the transistor and put the right legs in the right places? Its only 3 points and you can change them any way you want...? Just making sure cause I saw it a couple times in this thread and I see no point in pointing it out except to pay attention to it not to get one specific so it goes in the same exact way? Checking if I was missing something else important? Thanks everyone for the amazing thread! Learning a lot!

Another thing I have been asking a lot lately and not finding anyone with an answer, had some people say if a component tester reads a transistor as a transistor then should it just work or can it have other problems and still show correct readings off a cheapie component tester?
Using tester: LCR-T4 M328
Thanks again!
 
Last edited:
Is this actually important or can you just turn the transistor and put the right legs in the right places?
You can do that, but why not order the proper part if it's available without needing the cross transistor legs.

I'm not sure who came up with the idea of dropping the first 2 characters from a transistor marking but it's brilliant to clone it and change the first character from 2 to K and change the pin out configuration!
 
Another thing I have been asking a lot lately and not finding anyone with an answer, had some people say if a component tester reads a transistor as a transistor then should it just work or can it have other problems and still show correct readings off a cheapie component tester?
A transistor could test good in one of these testers but in the real circuit it could breakdown and not function properly. A transistor can also be noisy.
 
A transistor could test good in one of these testers but in the real circuit it could breakdown and not function properly. A transistor can also be noisy.
just recently had a 2sd313 testing fine but it would not turn on unless fed a signal , remove the signal and sometimes it would stay on, sometimes not. obviously setting idle current was not working. it took a minute to figure it out but it got replaced and all is fine.

i knew those testers had limitations but this was my first first hand experience .
 
You can do that, but why not order the proper part if it's available without needing the cross transistor legs.
Appreciated! The main reason for me would be to reduce price by using less different parts. If one will fit multiple different pinouts and has absolutely nothing else different about it then I could order a reasonably bulk order if its something at all common and get a better price and only pay shipping once. I wish I had a local place to buy from but its all online order and price drops dramatically - sometimes 500%+ when you order 100-400+ of things.

A transistor could test good in one of these testers but in the real circuit it could breakdown and not function properly. A transistor can also be noisy.
Ok, I was thinking the same but no one I knew seemed to have a direct answer, they were just guessing too. Then had a EE tell me that if it tested good it was fine but from things I had read I was finding that hard to believe. Is there an easy way to test/realize a specific noisy transistor, is it going to be obvious on oscilloscope? Is there any way to test the breakdown? Like freeze spray/heat while testing? Will a curve tracer tell you if its noisy or if it will break down under load?
 
Is this actually important or can you just turn the transistor and put the right legs in the right places? Its only 3 points and you can change them any way you want...? Just making sure cause I saw it a couple times in this thread and I see no point in pointing it out except to pay attention to it not to get one specific so it goes in the same exact way? Checking if I was missing something else important? Thanks everyone for the amazing thread! Learning a lot!

Another thing I have been asking a lot lately and not finding anyone with an answer, had some people say if a component tester reads a transistor as a transistor then should it just work or can it have other problems and still show correct readings off a cheapie component tester?
Using tester: LCR-T4 M328
Thanks again!
On triangle patterns, it is easy to use Center Base. Straight line are a PITA, but still doable. Low voltage testers cannot detect any issues that might occur at operating voltage and temperature. But they are very handy for quick checks, and identifying pinouts.
 
Hello guys ,
I need an advise with out asking anyone taking the responsibility of the replacement
I need to replace the drivers on a AU517 (2SB537/2SD382) , the only part I have on hand at the moment are the complementary pair (2SC4793LBTF3T / 2SA1837LB-TF3T)by UTC manufacture.
The UTCs electrically are grater compare to the NECs , only missing 500mA at Collector-Current (IC) .
So the questions are if it’s safe to go with this mismatch knowing that the rules are “ we replace transistors that have the same or greater electrical characteristics”
And has anyone try using in their units this manufacture with no problems ?
Thank you in advance !

https://datasheetspdf.com/mobile/1404031/NEC/2SB537/1

http://www.utc-ic.com/uploadfile/2011/1101/20111101111250426.pdf
 

Attachments

  • 3350C1B0-08AF-4EA5-B220-C4F65B656E1A.png
    3350C1B0-08AF-4EA5-B220-C4F65B656E1A.png
    185.3 KB · Views: 11
  • DD71EFBD-0D94-487A-A79C-B03448B0F591.png
    DD71EFBD-0D94-487A-A79C-B03448B0F591.png
    230.1 KB · Views: 8
Hi all, I'm planning on doing a pretty much full rebuild of a Luxman 5C50 preamp, and I'm doing a preliminary sourcing of components before buying anything. It looks like it might be wise to replace nearly all the transistors, as they are 70's Hitachi, and their silver plated legs are flaking pretty badly, I've read this can spread into the 'body' of the transistor causing failure/noise?

I've seen 'NOS' of the same models, but they all looked tarnished, and I figured there should be replacements with a lower noise floor available. Here's what I was thinking for substitutes : 2SA836/2SC1940 with BC550C/BC560C (these have a different pin out) and 2SC1775A with 2SC1890A which looks like a direct swap, there's also a lot VD1221 dual diodes, is it okay to replace these with 2 1N4148s ?

Also, would there be any benefit of replacing the 1N4002/1N4004 rectifier diodes ?
 
I've seen 'NOS' of the same models, but they all looked tarnished, and I figured there should be replacements with a lower noise floor available. Here's what I was thinking for substitutes : 2SA836/2SC1940 with BC550C/BC560C (these have a different pin out) and 2SC1775A with 2SC1890A which looks like a direct swap, there's also a lot VD1221 dual diodes, is it okay to replace these with 2 1N4148s ?
Also, would there be any benefit of replacing the 1N4002/1N4004 rectifier diodes ?

I am fairly new in the field but I see no one has responded yet so I will give my thoughts, hopefully it can be helpful.

2SC1940 I believe is the incorrect transistor for those first 4 listed? It is not even close to the others?
2SA836 for BC560C might work if your circuit is running < 45v, if your B+/B- are < 45v then I do not see why it would not work, if its 45v or more then not a good substitute. Also if you were working with the complementary pair then they should both work but I do not think it would be the 2sc1940?

2SC1775A to 2SC1890A - looks perfect to me.

2x 1N4148 in series, as I have seen everywhere, is an excellent replacement for VD1221, for me those are "shoot on sight" too, definitely replace.

If you are doing a restoration or if you are not time/cost limited, I don't see any reason not change the diodes, they are working a heavy job. It's easiest to just order a boatload of 1N4007 and use those as replacements, they are just higher rated so they can be used in all cases of 1N4001 through 7.
 
I am fairly new in the field but I see no one has responded yet so I will give my thoughts, hopefully it can be helpful.

2SC1940 I believe is the incorrect transistor for those first 4 listed? It is not even close to the others?
2SA836 for BC560C might work if your circuit is running < 45v, if your B+/B- are < 45v then I do not see why it would not work, if its 45v or more then not a good substitute. Also if you were working with the complementary pair then they should both work but I do not think it would be the 2sc1940?

2SC1775A to 2SC1890A - looks perfect to me.

2x 1N4148 in series, as I have seen everywhere, is an excellent replacement for VD1221, for me those are "shoot on sight" too, definitely replace.

If you are doing a restoration or if you are not time/cost limited, I don't see any reason not change the diodes, they are working a heavy job. It's easiest to just order a boatload of 1N4007 and use those as replacements, they are just higher rated so they can be used in all cases of 1N4001 through 7.

KSC1890 is an obsolete part
For many applications, like Marantz equipment, you can use the KSC1845 with its complementary part, SA992
 
I am fairly new in the field but I see no one has responded yet so I will give my thoughts, hopefully it can be helpful.

2SC1940 I believe is the incorrect transistor for those first 4 listed? It is not even close to the others?
2SA836 for BC560C might work if your circuit is running < 45v, if your B+/B- are < 45v then I do not see why it would not work, if its 45v or more then not a good substitute. Also if you were working with the complementary pair then they should both work but I do not think it would be the 2sc1940?

2SC1775A to 2SC1890A - looks perfect to me.

2x 1N4148 in series, as I have seen everywhere, is an excellent replacement for VD1221, for me those are "shoot on sight" too, definitely replace.

If you are doing a restoration or if you are not time/cost limited, I don't see any reason not change the diodes, they are working a heavy job. It's easiest to just order a boatload of 1N4007 and use those as replacements, they are just higher rated so they can be used in all cases of 1N4001 through 7.

Thanks for the reply, yeah I had to double check but in the flat amp section it's the 2SC1940's with the 2SA836's else where it's 2SA1345's with the 2SA836's theres also a single 2SA915 that will probably need replacing if it's also a Hitachi. So I take it the BC550C can't replace the 2SC1940's ?
 
Lol Roger thank you for that, overlooked the 1890 being obsolete. I also really should have that 1845 memorized with how many places it can fill.

I am not sure you are finding pairs with those, they might be drivers or switches of some kind? 836, 1345, and 915 are all PNP. Complementary pairs are PNP & NPN together. By the looks of it, its possible that the 2SC1940 and the 2SA915 could be a pair together but doesn't have to be.
 
Here is an "Updated" list, I went through every page and tried to add anything missing and delete duplicates while removing the unnecessary suffix like TA/TU/BU
Squished a couple of the whole lists together and a couple of Kill on Sights as well. Not sure if some of the information I added from early in the thread was removed for any reason so I am also posting what I added to the list, hopefully someone will give it a look and see if anything added was incorrect and I will happily fix those and repost. If anyone has any more sources that are missing on the list, please let me know, I will attempt to add those as well next chance I get.

First file is the whole spreadsheet w/ multiple pages for different info.
Second file is update to the main list that was being updated by rottalpha
Third file is update for the Kill on Sight list I had found on AK

I am very grateful for all the assistance I have received from AK, hopefully this can be helpful to another. :)
 

Attachments

Try to find substitutes of 2SB649A for my Proton D940 power amp board, Q616 to be exact. search here find recommendations of KSA1220A or KSB546Y or TTA004B. The first 2 are obsolete, only TTA004B is still available now from Digikey. Will it work for my application. Thanks.

1C034C9A-39F5-42FE-B36E-8F4336C413E7.jpeg
 
TTA004B is still available now from Digikey. Will it work for my application.

Looks like a good fit to me.

If it was me, though, I would want to also replace Q614 with a complementary part, and TTC004Bs seem to be scarce.

ampslab.com seems to have the original Toshiba complements. You have to buy them in sets of 10 pairs, but they aren't terribly expensive.
 
If it was me, though, I would want to also replace Q614 with a complementary part, and TTC004Bs seem to be scarce.


agree, I always sub the compliment as well in situations like this. Mostly just because I'm not sure what would happen with mismatched parts, other than being reasonably sure it wouldn't be anything good.

shame these aren't so available, it seems to be a nice transistor. I had to use a pair of them to fix an amp not long ago but at that point they were both available and quite cheap.
 
Back
Top Bottom