• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Transistor Substitutions

I would go with the KSA1381 and the KSC3503.
Another choice is the pair 2SA1380/2SC3502 (Vceo=200V)
I would like to avoid on semis , the Sanyos looks suitable replacement especially when the drivers can be 2SC2344/2SA1011.

How does this complementary pair looks to you (Vceo 120V and applications “low frequency amplifier “ , plus that it need an adaptor that I have ) 2SCR375 by ROHM
https://www.digikey.dk/en/products/detail/rohm-semiconductor/2SCR375P5T100R/10443936
 
How does this complementary pair looks to you (Vceo 120V and applications “low frequency amplifier “ , plus that it need an adaptor that I have ) 2SCR375 by ROHM
I would not go with the surface mount option. My criterion is the following:
1- For the Rhom parts, being conservative their rated dissipated power is only 0.5W while the original parts in TO126 package are 1W and the KSA/KSC are rated at 7W and the Sanyo 1.5W
2-Because these may run at quite high voltage in some stages of the amplifier, particularly in the pre-driver stage, I would go with the ON semiconductor parts, or the Sanyo. Please note that the part that you quoted from Rhom, being a 120V 1Amp transistor, only supports 10mA at 50V (I chose this voltage which may be close to the rails where you are going to be using it) while the KSA/KSC parts (300V , Ic=0.1A ) can handle 20mA at 50V. Depending on the location this could mean that the Rohm part may be running with too litle margin. The Sanyo parts I suggested can handle 25mA at 50V.
3-The transition frequencies are ok for all of them so I did not worry about it.
If you like the Sanyo ones, they are an excellent choice in my opinion. But the ON semi shold work just as well.
 
I would not go with the surface mount option. My criterion is the following:
1- For the Rhom parts, being conservative their rated dissipated power is only 0.5W while the original parts in TO126 package are 1W and the KSA/KSC are rated at 7W and the Sanyo 1.5W
2-Because these may run at quite high voltage in some stages of the amplifier, particularly in the pre-driver stage, I would go with the ON semiconductor parts, or the Sanyo. Please note that the part that you quoted from Rhom, being a 120V 1Amp transistor, only supports 10mA at 50V (I chose this voltage which may be close to the rails where you are going to be using it) while the KSA/KSC parts (300V , Ic=0.1A ) can handle 20mA at 50V. Depending on the location this could mean that the Rohm part may be running with too litle margin. The Sanyo parts I suggested can handle 25mA at 50V.
3-The transition frequencies are ok for all of them so I did not worry about it.
If you like the Sanyo ones, they are an excellent choice in my opinion. But the ON semi shold work just as well.
Hello Josse ,
Much appreciated the time you spend to answer ! As I have said before , your opinion in this matters is valuable !
I’m putting together a BOM for an
“AU-D907 Limited” that I don’t own yet but possibly soon enough . The Sanyos are on the BOM !
I couldn’t buy anything from
“b-dent enterprises” before, as their website didn’t allow me to search or add parts in my basket (I don’t know why but it couldn’t work) when you send the link for the Sanyos seems that I could order them with no technical problems , so thank you for that too!

The on semis certainly look great on paper but from experiment I perform in an AU-717 they don’t “sound” as great as a Japanese semiconductor , using my speakers , listening space and my preferences in sound , so I’m trying to avoid them like the devil the holy water.
I have one more question if I may ?
I’m looking for replacement for the 2SC1845/SA992.
I have two Japaneses candidates from ROHM , unfortunately TOSHIBA is not producing anything at 120v with more than Pc100mW, otherwise it would have been a lot more greater choice’s from TOSHI.

1) 2SCR372/2SCRA372
https://fscdn.rohm.com/en/products/...crete/transistor/bipolar/2scr372p5t100q-e.pdf

2) 2SC3906K/2SA1514K ( data sheet is the same but different package )
https://fscdn.rohm.com/en/products/...crete/transistor/bipolar/2sa1579u3t106r-e.pdf

The first one looks as a very good substitute but when you compare the data sheets , ROHM does not give noise figure and the graphs are not detailed plus that I can’t read them correctly and with confidence!

The second one is looking even better in all specs …. Except the Pc :200mW when the 2SC1845 is is rated at 500mW…… but in a conversation between GrisPato and Fojica in this thread (page 3-4) :
https://audiokarma.org/forums/index.php?threads/sansui-jpd-adventure.963332/page-4
seems that Sansui in different models but in the same application have used the 2SC2459 which is rated at 200mw .
Can this be an indication that a 200mW transistors can sub the 2SC1845 in this particular application ? (Diamond differential stage ).

Thank you for reading Josse , any comment will help but mind that I’m not asking you to take the responsibility for my actions just a comment if I’m in a “right” line of thinking !
 
I don't think transistors have a sound signature, at least not that I am aware of anyway.
That’s what I thought too .
Accidentally I tried as pre drivers the following complementary pairs in an AU-717 :
KSA1380/KSC3502
KSA1220/KSC2690
2SA899/2SC1904
TTA/TTC006

The Toshibas was producing a way better sound stage ( according to my hearing ability, speakers , listening room ) than all the others.
I even try to adjust the BIAS in a way that is deferent between the pairs and in a way that they will sound the same . No way .
The on semis was equal between them and producing a sound stage that I would say PERSONALLY , was a degrade for the capabilities for the existing topology .

The Japanese NECs and Toshibas was close to the sound stage but the Toshibas, again , in my ears was sounding by far a superior devise!
All this I’m describing was auditable ….
Maybe my speakers ? The room ? I don’t know.

What I know and I’m not trying to convince anyone ,as I can’t prove this with numbers/measurements ,that a Japanese sound system does not like a non Japanese replacements in their guts .
 
I’m looking for replacement for the 2SC1845/SA992.
In my opinion, I would use ON semi KSA992F/KSC1845F. They have good gain, and match quite well between the PNP and NPN in most of the parameters.
This substitution has been proven to work really well by hundreds of people now. I struggle to imagine that someone could hear the difference with the original NEC parts.

There is no difference with the Japanese parts; Fairchild produced them with the same process as NEC and eventually ON (former Motorola) merged with Fairchild, and there you have them. Japan and US had a long history of licence agreements between semiconductor companies with engineers exchanging all the details of their production to ensure the same specifications.

You could try to source 2SA970/2SC2240 from Japan. But is hard not to receive fake parts. The 2SA1049/2SC2459 are identical die as the 2SC2240/2SA970 but in the smaller package TO-92s which can dissipate only 200mW. They may work where this power dissipation limit is met.

The Rohm parts you mention would work on paper, but they do not seem to have the same gain as the C1845/A992 counterparts. What is the complementary part for the 2SCR372?. Also, that is a low saturation voltage transistor, more suitable in other applications like a Schmidt trigger circuit for muting or for relay coil driving. In my opinion is a good substitute for a 2SC945P but not for the 2SC1845.
The other part looks better, as they are complementary NPN and PNP, but normally the range of gain that you can get is on the lower end of the specified interval. So you may find that the 2SARA41/2SCRC4 specified hfe 180-560 but in practice, you get parts that hardly go above the 180-250 range and that will limit their performance if you use them in differential pairs. The A992F/C1845F are better in all respects, no matter if they are the old NEC or the new ON semi parts.
 
What is the complementary part for the 2SCR372?.

The complementary pair is the 2SAR372 ….

The A992F/C1845F are better in all respects, no matter if they are the old NEC or the new ON semi parts.

Roger that.
Thank you for your thorough reply !
I will consider my options , not many and sourcing from Japan can be tricky but better than “@bay” or “Allie@“
Wishing you a nice weekend !
 
Lower noise devices can improve SQ
Does it not just change the noise floor, as opposed to doing anything to change the sound?
I understood using high gain low noise transistors allowed the amp to be quieter, less background hiss or noise.
Is this incorrect? Thanks
 
Last edited:
Does it not just change the noise floor, as opposed to doing anything to change the sound?
I understood using high gain low noise transistors allowed the amp to be quieter, less background hiss or noise.
Is this incorrect? Thanks
That is my understanding. Maybe purity of silicone factors in a slightly. It would be nice to get noise figures for the small signals we have been using here. The gentleman on this site has an interesting method to analyze noise in semis www.dicks-website.eu/low_noise_amp_part3/part3.html
 
I hope a newb thats still learning can ask about 2 on my Sansui 4000... Those are, 2SC536, and 2SA564P
 
Hey everyone, quick question. Replacing transistors on my Sherwood 7100A for every board except tuners. Got some advice that KSC1845 and KSA992 should work for all of them? Can anyone verify? If not, would love some help finding correct replacements.

Here's the list of transistors along with schematic. To the right are a few replacements sourced from several AK threads, but again unsure if fully accurate. Any help would be great appreciated as this is my first refurbish rodeo!

2SA202B
2SA203B
2SA354A
2SA666A
2SC693F : KSC1845
2SC710C
2SC710D
2SC711F
2SC828Q
2SC828R
2SC871E
2SC945 : KSC2383 or KSC945
2SC1047C
2SC1318Q : KSC2690AYSTU
2SC1318S
2SD315D
2SK41F
CDC8002C
CDC9002C

Screen-Shot-2022-10-17-at-10-22-26-AM.png
 
Hey everyone, quick question. Replacing transistors on my Sherwood 7100A for every board except tuners. Got some advice that KSC1845 and KSA992 should work for all of them? Can anyone verify? If not, would love some help finding correct replacements.

Here's the list of transistors along with schematic. To the right are a few replacements sourced from several AK threads, but again unsure if fully accurate. Any help would be great appreciated as this is my first refurbish rodeo!

2SA202B
2SA203B
2SA354A
2SA666A
2SC693F : KSC1845
2SC710C
2SC710D
2SC711F
2SC828Q
2SC828R
2SC871E
2SC945 : KSC2383 or KSC945
2SC1047C
2SC1318Q : KSC2690AYSTU
2SC1318S
2SD315D
2SK41F
CDC8002C
CDC9002C

Screen-Shot-2022-10-17-at-10-22-26-AM.png

Leave the first three they are germanium, skip the last one unless its shorted. A lot of early silicone in there, surely modern silicone will help lower floor noise.

Sherwood 7100A.jpg
 
Leave the first three they are germanium, skip the last one unless its shorted. A lot of early silicone in there, surely modern silicone will help lower floor noise.

View attachment 2693267

Thank you so much for making and sharing this! Seriously appreciate the time. Extremely helpful. Maps closely to replacements my friend recommended.

Everything is available to order online except for the list of replacements for 2SC710 = KSC161674, 2SC930, 2SC2839. Unavailable on Mouser or Digi-Key so assuming old stock? Was told KSC1845F should work instead - thoughts?
 
Last edited:
There may be other options better suited for IF amplification but it seems that for the 2SC710 you could use KSC945C (center collector) . Watch the pin orientation.
 
Thank you so much for making and sharing this! Seriously appreciate the time. Extremely helpful. Maps closely to replacements my friend recommended.

Everything is available to order online except for the list of replacements for 2SC710 = KSC161674, 2SC930, 2SC2839. Unavailable on Mouser or Digi-Key so assuming old stock? Was told KSC1845F should work instead - thoughts?

Here's my current list. Any feedback? Could use some help deciding between a few options and vetting these selections.

Main Amp:
2SA666 (TR601a, 601b) = KSA1015
2SC945 (TR603a, 603b) = KSC2383 or KSC945
CDC8002 (TR604a, 604b) = MJE340
CDC9002 (TR605a, 605b) = MJE350
2SC1318Q (TR602a, 602b) = KSC2690

Tone Amp:
2SC693F (TR901a, TR901b) = KSC1845

Pre Amp:
2SC871 (TR501a, 501b) = KSC1845
2SC693F (TR502a, 502b) = KSC1845

FM MPX:
2SC828Q (TR301, 302, 303) = KSC1845 or KSC945
2SC828R (TR304) = KSC1845 or KSC945
2SC1318S (TR305) = KSC2690

FM IF:
2SC710C (TR202, 205) = KSC1845
2SC710D (TR201, 203, 204) = KSC1845
2SC711 (TR206, 207) = KSC1845

Power:
2SC1318Q (TR606, 607) = KSC2690
 
Back
Top Bottom