• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Tube amps vs solid state

Ad hominem attacks do not strengthen your position.
Your lack of emotionally charged response and refusal to personally counter attack must be very frustrating. I can't imagine the pounding his keyboard must have taken to get thru that post.

Kudo's W99, i for one am glad you're here and ALWAYS appreciate your posts as well as respect your knowledge and experience.:thmbsp:

IBTL :D
 
Your lack of emotionally charged response and refusal to personally counter attack must be very frustrating. I can't imagine the pounding his keyboard must have taken to get thru that post.

Kudo's W99, i for one am glad you're here and ALWAYS appreciate your posts as well as respect your knowledge and experience.:thmbsp:

IBTL :D

+1 :thmbsp: (Except for the IBTL part 'cause I don't know what that means)
Peace
 
+1 :thmbsp: (Except for the IBTL part 'cause I don't know what that means)
Peace
In before the lock. Once the debate degrades into personal attacks and name calling, the lock becomes almost inevitable. Participants should be able to disagree without becoming emotionally charged. Sometimes, that's not as easy as it sounds.

I love a good debate, so long as it's constructive and inspires thought and interest.:yes:

I hope this one can be salvaged before it makes it's final lap around the bowl.
 
And for the last time, what does that have to do with reliability, even though it is not true?

Another ignorant generalization. It's just not true when you insist on the term "semiconductor devices". Which ones? What are you talking about? Be more specific.

You know, there's plenty of "semiconductor devices" in tube gear, starting in the early '60s. Think Fishers for one. And it's very common for those "semiconductor devices" to be the cause of the worse type of failures these tube amplifiers and receivers ever experience.

How many pieces of either type of equipment have YOU personally "reconditioned"?

Just because you own a tube amp doesn't mean anything; you obviously don't know what you are talking about first hand, and are just parroting popular misconceptions and the flawed definition of what the term "reliability" means.

Tube equipment will outlast Solid State stuff by decades. To me that spells reliable.

Just because your tech is a hack and leaves in worn out TO-3s just because they "still work OK" doesn't make your ridiculous comments so. There's plenty of worn out tubes still doing duty just as well; poorly.

I swore I'd stay out of this ridiculous thread, but I just couldn't take your continued insistence to spread bad, borderline false, misinformation.

Thomas

An awful post: not in AK spirit.
 
An awful post: not in AK spirit.

Thankfully there's the ignore list. There isn't anybody home at that house and no information to be learned there.
On the other hand though whoaru99 always has well written, informative posts that are well worth reading.:thmbsp:
 
As with anything audio, it's all about compromises. My systems have been SS so far because, for me, they are easier to live with, and the ones I've owned have more than met my needs. I've had quite a few revelations along the way which has led me backwards in time to '70s and '80's Yamaha amps. Interestingly, I've been drawn to the sound of those SS amps reputed to be the most "tube like".

I've always had the impression that the sound of a tube amp slowly changes as the tube ages with use. I may be (and probably am) wrong here as I've never owned one. I'd be interested to hear from tube owners on this.

I think that the application of the output device, SS or tube, has more to do with the device itself assuming that it has good audio characteristics to begin with.

Cool factor is in the eyes of the beholder. I've seen some tube amps that are drool worthy, and others that just look old and dated. Same with SS. To me it's cool if it sounds great and doesn't look like it's been drug behind a car for a couple of miles. Oh yes, blue lights, it must have lots and lots of blue lights.
 
^^^

Doesn't get much cooler than top plate connections. ;)

attachment.php

Very cool!! Magnavox 175/185 in it's past life, I believe. 6V6 Push-pull originally. (btw thanks for keepin' yours, I would've been on the bench!):D

Regards to the OPs question, I got nothin'. I'm biased in favor of the music.

Sand or tubes? It's all good. I'm listening to a Marantz 2270 (preamp section)>
Magnavox 150 biamped monoblocks (X2) circa 1957.
 
And for the last time, what does that have to do with reliability, even though it is not true?

Another ignorant generalization. It's just not true when you insist on the term "semiconductor devices". Which ones? What are you talking about? Be more specific.

You know, there's plenty of "semiconductor devices" in tube gear, starting in the early '60s. Think Fishers for one. And it's very common for those "semiconductor devices" to be the cause of the worse type of failures these tube amplifiers and receivers ever experience.

How many pieces of either type of equipment have YOU personally "reconditioned"?

Just because you own a tube amp doesn't mean anything; you obviously don't know what you are talking about first hand, and are just parroting popular misconceptions and the flawed definition of what the term "reliability" means.

Tube equipment will outlast Solid State stuff by decades. To me that spells reliable.

Just because your tech is a hack and leaves in worn out TO-3s just because they "still work OK" doesn't make your ridiculous comments so. There's plenty of worn out tubes still doing duty just as well; poorly.

I swore I'd stay out of this ridiculous thread, but I just couldn't take your continued insistence to spread bad, borderline false, misinformation.

Thomas

Hmmm, "worn out TO-3's" .........are you sure somebody else is ignorant?

The fact is, tubes work because they can stream electrons from a cathode. The emmited stream causes the not evacuated gas molecules to become ionized. Getter can help for awhile, but not forever. The emmision does degrade with hours used. That is a fact. I think reliability and maintenance should be used separately with tube gear. Maintenance describes expected service while reliability describes unexpected service.
 
I like the sound of both, cop out I know. Truly though, both have great points in regards to each, sometimes a nice vintage SS reciever or amp can have a tube like sound, I tend to go for older SS pieces myself, due to love of the sound, and the fact that tube gear seems to be a tad high for me to get much of.
 
I have a two channel tube setup, along with a solid state setup that goes between two channel or multi channel.

The solid state setup are all Threshold S series amps with Legacy speakers. The two channel preamp is a McCormack LD-2, and the multi channel preamp is a Classe SSP-300, which provides wonderful, life like sound. Some of the surround recordings actually sound close to being there.

The tube amp is an Eastern Electric M88 integrated amp, with Source Technologies 277SE speakers. Again, wonderful sound, but presents a different "seat" of the performance.

The important thing I've learned is that both tubes and solid state can sound outstanding, and the better equipment will sound more alike than different. Both tubes and solid state can be reliable and long lasting. The single biggest issue with tubes (to me) is making sure you run output tubes that are biased correctly, and are checked/screened to reduce problems. The current crop of Shuguang KT88's, for example, are quite reliable.

Vintage gear, be it tube or solid state, needs to be gone through and worked on to ensure optimum performance. For example, all the Thresholds I own have been restored at moderate to extensive levels of parts replacement. Some of the units needed bias transistors replaced, the 400A needed all new output TO-3, all needed new rectifiers, caps, etc. Replaced emitter resistors as well. It’s too bad this thread got off track regarding this issue.
 
Last edited:
I like the sound of both, cop out I know.


It's not a cop out; it's not as though this is some political or ethical question of great importance that one needs to take a principled stand on. Though I've no doubt there are some screwballs here who think it is.
 
I think reliability and maintenance should be used separately with tube gear. Maintenance describes expected service while reliability describes unexpected service



thats pretty true.

tubes require alot more maintence compared to ss so i would say getting in there doing that maitenence would let the user see what else is going onl. now i know there are alot of older solid sates out there that its a good idea to check your bias but other then that its pretty much unexpected problems that come up to service.
 
Vintage gear, be it tube or solid state, needs to be gone through and worked on to ensure optimum performance. For example, all the Thresholds I own have been restored at moderate to extensive levels of parts replacement. Some of the units needed bias transistors replaced, the 400A needed all new output TO-3, all needed new rectifiers, caps, etc. Replaced emitter resistors as well. It’s too bad this thread got off track regarding this issue

:thmbsp:
 
For anyone interested, here's what the United States Navy has to say about it in the NEETS documentation.

SEMICONDUCTOR COMPETITION
It should not be difficult to conclude, from what you already know, that semiconductor devices can
and do perform all the conventional functions of rectification, amplification, oscillation, timing,
switching, and sensing. Simply stated, these devices perform the same basic functions as the electron
tube; but they perform more efficiently, economically, and for a longer period of time. Therefore, it
should be no surprise to you to see these devices used in place of electron tubes. Keeping this in mind, we
see that it is only natural and logical to compare semiconductor devices with electron tubes.
Physically, semiconductor devices are much smaller than tubes. You can see in figure 1-1 that the
difference is quite evident. This illustration shows some commonly used tube sizes alongside
semiconductor devices of similar capabilities. The reduction in size can be as great as 100:1 by weight
and 1000:1 by volume. It is easy to see that size reduction favors the semiconductor device. Therefore,
whenever miniaturization is required or is convenient, transistors are favored over tubes. Bear in mind,
however, that the extent of practical size reduction is a big factor; many things must be considered.
Miniature electron tubes, for example, may be preferred in certain applications to transistors, thus keeping
size reduction to a competitive area.

Power is also a two-sided story. For low-power applications, where efficiency is a significant factor,
semiconductors have a decided advantage. This is true mainly because semiconductor devices perform
very well with an extremely small amount of power; in addition, they require no filaments or heaters as in
the case of the electron tube. For example, a computer operating with over 4000 solid-state devices may
require no more than 20 watts of power. However, the same number of tubes would require several
kilowatts of power.
For high-power applications, it is a different story — tubes have the upper hand. The high-power
tube has no equivalent in any semiconductor device. This is because a tube can be designed to operate
with over a thousand volts applied to its plate whereas the maximum allowable voltage for a transistor is
limited to about 200 volts (usually 50 volts or less). A tube can also handle thousands of watts of power.
The maximum power output for transistor generally ranges from 30 milliwatts to slightly over 100 watts.
When it comes to ruggedness and life expectancy, the tube is still in competition. Design and
functional requirements usually dictate the choice of device. However, semiconductor devices are rugged
and long-lived. They can be constructed to withstand extreme vibration and mechanical shock. They have
been known to withstand impacts that would completely shatter an ordinary electron tube. Although some
specially designed tubes render extensive service, the life expectancy of transistors is better than three to
four times that of ordinary electronic tubes. There is no known failure mechanism (such as an open
filament in a tube) to limit the semiconductor’s life. However, semiconductor devices do have some
limitations. They are usually affected more by temperature, humidity, and radiation than tubes are.
 
Back
Top Bottom