• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

What determines speaker efficiency?

Dclapp

Active Member
Friends,

I don't understand what determines the efficiency of speakers. I can see that horns, by their nature, are highly efficient. But speaker drivers? I believe I understand (most of) the physics behind the drivers and how they "work," but I just don't understand why, say, a AR3 is inefficient, while speakers like my Wharfedale W-90s -- full of drivers, some quite large -- are highly efficient and are said to mate well with low-powered tube amplifiers, for example.

Thanks for some schooling!

doug
 
Register to hide this ad
Friends,

I don't understand what determines the efficiency of speakers. I can see that horns, by their nature, are highly efficient. But speaker drivers? I believe I understand (most of) the physics behind the drivers and how they "work," but I just don't understand why, say, a AR3 is inefficient, while speakers like my Wharfedale W-90s -- full of drivers, some quite large -- are highly efficient and are said to mate well with low-powered tube amplifiers, for example.

Thanks for some schooling!

doug
Two things that have the most direct effect on lower frequency driver efficiency are: The tolerances within the voice coil gap. The tighter the clearance between the inside and outside of the voice coil in relation to the pole piece and top plate, the higher the efficiency will be; The winding width of the voice coil. A narrow voice coil winding will be more efficient than a longer voice coil winding. The most inefficient woofers have very long throw voice coils and wide voice coil gaps.
 
Numerous factors affect speaker efficiency.

The materials used in the drivers construction, the size of the voice coil, how the VC is wound, how it fits in the gap, the stiffness of the suspension, the weight of the cone material and the size and type of surround.

The crossover components and complexity have an affect, as does enclosure design and the number of drivers.

Speaker design, as with many other endeavors is an exercise in choosing compromises. There are a myriad of variables that can enhance or detract from each other, all having an affect on the final product.

Perhaps someone with relevant experience designing speakers such as Mr Kantor will chime in and offer some additional insight.
 
A rhetorical question....

Are you asking about efficiency or sensitivity?

I am not an engineer but I've heard some say they are quite different topics.
 
A rhetorical question....

Are you asking about efficiency or sensitivity?

I am not an engineer but I've heard some say they are quite different topics.

They are, but for day to day conversational purposes among hobbyists they mean the same thing.
 
Stronger magnet, lighter cone and larger surface area = higher efficiency.

That's it in a nutshell; think of it like a car--the stronger the motor and lighter the vehicle the faster. Of course that doesn't account for the larger cone thing. Think of the large cone as a low geared rear axle that gives acceleration at the expense of top speed, just as higher efficiency comes at the expense of bandwidth. I'm winging it here, if I'm full of **** I'll soon hear about it.

Speakers like ARs are inefficient because they use heavy cones with weak motors. That's not a bad thing, it's just what's needed for the design to work.
 
Last edited:
A speaker whose voice coil overhangs the magnetic structure will not be a high effiency type. Example: heighth of the structure which contains the gap
the voice coil operated in is 3/8" tall. Voice coil is 2" wide, 3/4" tall.

Difference between the 3/4" and 3/8" is that there is another 3/8" of voice coil that has little interaction in the magnetic circuit. This is not necessarily a detriment. It allows a suitable suspension to have a greater throw, but with more electrial losses.

Always refer to Hoffman's Iron Law.

I've never destroyed a high efficiency speaker motor, but I expect they keep the voice coil totaly enclosed in the gap. I have the cone assembly of a Altec 416a and the coil is 3" x 1/4".

There are high performance speakers both of high efficiency and overhung voice coil types.
 
Efficiency issues for a speaker system, in a practical application, is all about the bass vs driver/cabinet size. Mid/treble is easy and is not a consideration as far as amplifier power and cabinet type/size is concerned.

To produce bass you have to move a lot of air. You can move a lot of air with a large cone and minimal excursion or you can move a lot of air with a smaller cone and more excursion. But to control a long excursion cone, you need a more linear method of "suspension" than a woofer spider can provide.

A large speaker cone in free air can be easily moved by an amp - it is very "efficient." If the cone is large enough, it can produce "good" bass. The problem is, the cone/cabinet design has to be quite large.

An acoustic suspension design is inefficient by it's nature simply because the air in the sealed cabinet becomes the primary suspension for the speaker. Sealed air is a "stiffer," and much more linear suspension but it therefore takes more power to move the woofer farther and against the stiffer suspension. The air suspension is the reason that a "tiny" AR3a (for example) can go lower in the bass and with less distortion than a Klipschhorn and is why it was a quantum leap in speaker design when the acoustic suspension system was developed. OTOH, the KH can be easily driven to very loud levels (105dB at one meter) with one watt while the AR3a would need a bit over 64W to do the same thing. Go up 6 more db and we're up to 4W with the KH and 256W for the AR. So it's all about compromise - a high efficiency speaker system generally has to be fairly large to produce deep bass whereas you can get equal bass from an acoustic suspension cabinet a fraction of the size…with a corresponding need for more power to produce the same volume.

Interestingly, although acoustic suspension systems are considered inefficient, a current Blumenstein Orca, for example, has an efficiency rating of 89dB and it's totted up by Blumenstein/Bottlehead as being suitable for a 3W SET amp. An AR 3a, which when new had a far wider frequency response in both directions, going more than an octave lower in the bass, has an efficiency rating of 86dB. Basically, that means that the volume difference between the two systems at max power from the same amp would be JUST noticeable. IOW, you would be able to hear that "that one seems a LITTLE bit louder."

If you look at what are considered to be good traditional speaker response curves - as flat as possible (we won't argue whether that's the RIGHT way to measure vs what we hear), acoustic suspension designs go lower and "flatter" with the same size woofers than any other design.

NOTE: I have used AR speakers for examples, above, since I have owned more of them than any other brand of air suspension speakers but acoustic suspension system by any maker exhibits the same characteristics.
 
Last edited:
Cabinet design is a factor. Acoustic (air) suspension designs would generally be least efficient I'm guessing.

Woops! What Mexico Mike said!
 
Open Baffle is probably the most efficient design, followed by ported cabinets.
A sealed cabinet is generally the least efficient design.
 
Regarding the efficiency of sealed vs. ported designs, it ONLY applies to the bass region, at 1KHz, a sealed design is just as efficient as a ported one.

When someone says a ported design is more efficient, they often forget to mention, it only applies to the bass region.
 
Efficiency is usually referring to that of the Driver.
However many speaker makers add in the effect of their Boxes (when it actually aids efficiency.. sometimes they don't :-).. in their marketing copy.
 
Sensitivity generally concerns itself with the "first watt", and is what most above have incorrectly described as efficiency.

Efficiency has more to do with power response across the drivers usable parameters. Efficiency is largely dictated by the motor assembly's ability to cool itself. Efficiency in a speaker measures it's ability to convert electrical energy into acoustic energy.
 
I'm glad to know the voice coil gap factor. Explains why some cheap woofers are only 84dB/watt... Probably a monster gap.
 
Sensitivity generally concerns itself with the "first watt", and is what most above have incorrectly described as efficiency.

Efficiency has more to do with power response across the drivers usable parameters. Efficiency is largely dictated by the motor assembly's ability to cool itself. Efficiency in a speaker measures it's ability to convert electrical energy into acoustic energy.

Well, while I agree that efficiency and sensitivity are two different things, in the practical world of buying/using speakers, it's a difference that is not particularly meaningful. The reality is that an 89 dB speaker takes more power to drive at a given volume than a 94dB speaker. That "first watt" can, in theory, produce 89 dB out of the first, and 94 out of the second at one meter.

The "quality" of a bass driver has much less affect on the system efficiency than the design of the system. It is not possible to make a highly efficient acoustic suspension system, no matter the quality of the driver simply because of the physics involved. And you can't take an "efficient" woofer that works great in a horn-loaded design and put it in a small sealed cabinet and get anything other than poor performance.
 
with respect to the post above: 92 dB SPL, not 94 dB, @ 2 watts for a loudspeaker with sensitivity of 89 dB per watt @ 1 meter.

FWIW, I think that the efficiency of most "domestic" (i.e., consumer/home audio) loudspeakers runs from about 1 to 10 percent. 1% efficiency, e.g., can represent 1 watt of acoustic power output for 100 watts of electrical power input.

As a rule of thumb, 1 watt of acoustic power is, I have read, roughly the power output of a symphony orchestra playing, more or less, at full tilt.
 
When someone says a ported design is more efficient, they often forget to mention, it only applies to the bass region.

Also of note is that ported designs <allow> the use of inherently high sensitivity drivers that won't make good bass in sealed boxes--the Altec 416 for example. Thus a vented box isn't more sensitive in and of itself but because it allows the use of drivers that are more sensitive. Putting a low sensitivity sealed box type woofer in a vented box isn't going to make the system more sensitive overall.
 
Last edited:
Open Baffle is probably the most efficient design, followed by ported cabinets.
A sealed cabinet is generally the least efficient design.

I see no reason an open baffle would be more efficient in and of itself: it would depend on the inherent efficiency of the driver chosen. Given that many OBs use EQ to boost the bass the amount of boost should be subtracted. In one system I had a used as a subwoofer a pair of JBL Pro bassbins with a combined efficiency of 104 db but I gave them 6db of boost at 30 hz, thus I figured the actual efficiency as 98 db.
 
An acoustic suspension design is inefficient by it's nature simply because the air in the sealed cabinet becomes the primary suspension for the speaker. Sealed air is a "stiffer," and much more linear suspension but it therefore takes more power to move the woofer farther and against the stiffer suspension.

It's not only that Mike, the design demands a woofer with a heavy cone, long coil in a short gap and a high QTS-- a driver that's inefficient by it's nature, regardless of the box type.
 
Back
Top Bottom