• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

What determines speaker efficiency?

When someone says a ported design is more efficient, they often forget to mention, it only applies to the bass region.

Which almost (?) always controls the speaker's overall sensitivity, making the qualification somewhat meaningless.
 
They are, but for day to day conversational purposes among hobbyists they mean the same thing.

Yeah, I know. I was actually trying to toss a light onto the subject in the outside hope that peoples light-bulb might go off and they could correct themselves as necessary.
 
Yeah, I know. I was actually trying to toss a light onto the subject in the outside hope that peoples light-bulb might go off and they could correct themselves as necessary.

I use the one term and then the other, hoping to be correct half the time.
 
While we're discussing efficiency and sensitivity, perhaps we should cover damping and dampening, too. I've never liked wet speakers.
 
Parts Express used to sell this stuff called "Wet Look" that made your* speaker cone look as though it were** wet. Not sure if that counts as dampening or not... cause the stuff looks wet even when it's dry.

Now, that's meta...

----------
* Not necessarily your (Redboy's) speaker cone... one's speaker cone, you know?

** "were" = subjunctive mood. Used to denote a statement contrary to fact (e.g., "if I were a rich man...").
 
Parts Express used to sell this stuff called "Wet Look" that made your* speaker cones look like they were wet. Not sure if that counts as dampening or not... cause the stuff looks wet even when it's dry.

Radical fringe single driver guys are treating their speakers with Brylcreem.
 
You can all turn on your flamethrowers, but with my limited knowledge (and I'm no EE), I consider efficiency to be electrical efficiency. How much juice does it take to make a driver move, based on resistance/impedence as presented to an amplifier. Basically, how much electrical power is required to activate the motor structure of the driver (magnet and voice coil). I consider sensitivity to be more a factor of cabinet design in conjunction with driver selection. How much SPL can I get out of these drivers with a given amperage/voltage in a given scenario. Please correct my misinterpretation.
 
I consider efficiency to be electrical efficiency
No flames, just fact.

Electrical efficiency is the ratio of electrical input to work output. It is most easily expressed as a percent.

I consider sensitivity to be more a factor of cabinet design in conjunction with driver selection.
This depends on whether we're talking about raw components(drivers) or a complete speaker SYSTEM.

How much SPL can I get out of these drivers with a given amperage/voltage in a given scenario.
In a nutshell yes, sensitivity generally represents a speaker's acoustic output when driven with a "standard" input level, measured at a standard distance. It is a useful benchmark in determining how well a speaker SYSTEM might mate with your amplifier in terms of your preferred listening level, and in comparing the same factor against other speaker SYSTEMS without doing a real world comparison.
 
The main factors that determine the efficiency of a driver are:
- cone area (larger is more efficient)
- Bl product (magnetic strength- greater is more efficient)
- cone mass (lower mass is more efficient)
- electrical resistance (lower DCR is more efficient)

A 100% efficient speaker would have, in theory, infinite magnetic strength, infinite cone area, zero mass, and zero electrical resistance. At the same time, it would have uniform dispersion into all directions, at all frequencies from DC to light.

Obviously, these, at first glance, seem to be contradictory requirements at best, and impossible at worst.

And, most speakers are, by first glance, appallingly inefficient, compared to almost any other commonly used device. What is commonly thought of as a "relatively efficient speaker"- 92dB sensitivity @ 1 watt radiating into a spherical space at all frequencies- is only ONE PERCENT efficient. The other 99% of all power, is dissipated as heat.

One other factor to consider, is dispersion. A perfect driver would disperse 112dB per watt, at one meter, in EVERY direction simultaneously (uniform spherical radiation). Each time that dispersion is restricted by half (half sphere, quarter sphere, eighth sphere, and so on), the SPL will go up by 3 dB, into the remaining space.

Horn/compression drivers come closest to perfect efficiency of all acoustic drivers. They can reach as high as 5-10% efficiency (99-102dB @ 1w into free space, which translates into up to 116dB @ 1W or so, into a 60 by 90 degree dispersion pattern). However, that's still only one tenth, max, of the electrical input power turned into acoustic energy...

Enclosures, OTOH, rarely (except for bandpass designs) have very little effect on the effective efficiency (more accurately, sensitivity) of a driver. The enclosure has a LOT to do with the low-frequency rolloff point- but the efficiency is set by the driver itself.

Bandpass enclosures- by changing the effective "acoustic impedance" the driver sees (similarly to a compression horn driver, in essence)- can increase the effective sensitivity of a driver within a small bandwidth- that's the trade-off. There's never something for nothing...

Regards,
Gordon.
 
BTW: I was referring to magnetic-motor speakers (ones with voice coils, magnetic planars, and the like).

The same principles (and results) can be applied to electrostatic speakers- just replace "infinite magnetic strength" with "infinite stator polarizing voltage"...

Regards,
Gordon.
 
Good thread. So when we talk of band pass design is that the same as transmission line (TL) design?

I am currently using a couple different models of pmc's. Generally speaking how do TL type speaker designs effect efficiency given the same driver used in a ported bass reflex design. I read something about better driver control down into lower range. In effect the cabinet is adding better response but is this the same as better efficiency?
 
Back
Top Bottom