• Please note that Audiokarma will be offline briefly for updates early on Monday morning, September 28th.

Why are CDs the current hot topic?

You mean, stupid idiots who cannot bother to search for music they like and download an actual file for long-term storage on their own physical media? These are the people who used to listen to payola on FM radio while not being happy with the same fifty tracks being played over and over again.
It's not necessarily about being too stupid or idiot to understand the process, but about enjoying it.
 
It's not necessarily about being too stupid or idiot to understand the process, but about enjoying it.
Enjoying what? That someone - or something - chooses songs for you to listen next? Sure, but don't blame streaming for mechanistic algorithms or whatever other silly bullshit. My point is, if you want to listen to what YOU what, you can do it with streaming just the same as with CDs, vinyl or tapes. I have several playlists on several streaming services, I add to them, I re-arrange them, because ordering matter to me. It is much easier than re-recording a cassette or a CD.

Here is one, The Americans playlist. A couple of the songs are not from the series, but they fit. I suggest using Firefox with adblock :) The whole playlist nicely fits a 90-minute cassette.

 
Shoulda kept this beauty after all perhaps.

.. Gonna be a sought after collectible!
:rflmao: :rflmao: :rflmao:

1023vint.1.jpg


1023vint.promo_.jpg


1023vint.6.jpg

That's so pretty I'd buy it just as a piece of artwork.
 
Enjoying what?
The whole process. Having to fiddle with a tiny phone screen, or to sit in front of a computer. Not owning any of that music, but just renting it and accepting that it could change or disappear at any time (I've had that happen to me countless times - listening to a playlist and noticing that one of the songs had automatically been replaced with a "radio mix" version or some other crap like that).
A lot of people don't enjoy this. Whether you think they should is irrelevant. They just don't.
 
Last edited:
Those with high end systems will tell you that records are noticeably better.
realized there's something deeply unsatisfying about unlimited access and virtual media.
I grew up with vinyls and generally, when I invest in physical media, I'm buying vinyls. That said, while my system isn't truly high end, it is considerably better than average and I would never say that vinyls are noticeably better. They're noisy, with analog hiss as well as pops, they're fragile and easily damaged and they're inconvenient and labor intensive, requiring constant cleaning and futzing, not to mention flipping the platter every 10-20 minutes. There is, however, a tactile quality with vinyls that is satisfying in a way and their limitations engender a focus and intimacy with the music that can be compelling. 80-90% of the time, however, I'm streaming, even when I own the music on vinyls or CD. Far from being unsatisfying, it offers great sound quality, frequently at better resolution and bit-rates available by physical media and the ability to discover new music* with streaming, from the comfort of my living room, is without parallel.

*it's hard for you old fuddies and sticks in the mud to imagine, but there is an enormous amount of great new music being made today, much of it is even very well recorded. Contrary to popular AK opinion, "good music" didn't cease to exist after 1978.
 
*it's hard for you old fuddies and sticks in the mud to imagine, but there is an enormous amount of great new music being made today, much of it is even very well recorded. Contrary to popular AK opinion, "good music" didn't cease to exist after
QFT
 
I listen to a lot of what is likely very obscure rock and metal. I doubt I would even be able to assemble playlists, hence my favoring physical media.

Some is so obscure, their CDs are only available for purchase direct from the artists.

Others are way back in hidden corners in the mists of time. For instance, I wonder if the Harlis albums are available via streaming. Maybe they are? Great guitarist in that band, a contemporary of Ulrich Roth.

I still would rather have the CDs and vinyl.
 
I don't enjoy using streaming. Youtube is adequate for checking out unfamiliar music to see if I like it. If I do then I just buy the CD.

My CDs are organized so if I want something specific it's just seconds to find it.

If I don't want something specific I prefer to browse a physical library rather than a screen.

I always have the mastering of my choice.

Since sampling and bit rate higher than 16/44.1 make no difference to playback quality nothing is lost compared to so called 'High resolution' masters (which are sometimes heavily compressed mastering anyway) so there's no advantage to streaming them over playing the CD.

I don't like to rent or pay monthly subscriptions if I can avoid it.

My choice of music is only limited if there is no CD release, which is rare but I admit it does happen very occasionally. I still have potential access to almost all music ever made. Since my time is not infinite there's only so much I can listen to anyway.

That's the tangible advantages of CD. The intangible advantages to paying for a physical product and owning it are also several.

I accept streaming is a preferred method for many people for whom the above are not major impediments or impediments at all. My point is that CD is a perfectly rational alternative to streaming for at least some people.
 
All the waffle about CD's did make me take some of mine out of storage.
Only to realise that the only CD player I have is in my car.
And that my taste was in parts as poorly refined then as it is now. :rflmao:
Anyway, after a bit of cleaning I'm gonna have a CD party whilst commuting next week.

Compact Disc Partayyy.jpg
 
The whole process. Having to fiddle with a tiny phone screen, or to sit in front of a computer. Not owning any of that music, but just renting it and accepting that it could change or disappear at any time (I've had that happen to me countless times - listening to a playlist and noticing that one of the songs had automatically been replaced with a "radio mix" version or some other crap like that).
A lot of people don't enjoy this. Whether you think they should is irrelevant. They just don't.
I can relate to that. I like the fact that with physical media, I'm not needing to mess with a phone or anything like that. The fact that I can pick up the record jacket or CD cover to see the album graphics and get information on the recording means that I don't have to look stuff up on my phone. I find that whenever I'm dealing with the phone that it becomes a kind of rabbit hole and I get distracted by everything available on it...
 
Owning physical media gives the user the feeling of supporting the artist. I buy downloads that I never download for that reason. Some of them have only a handful of purchases in the world. I realize it's a feel-good measure, but WTF, if it makes me happy it's money well spent.
 
Owning physical media gives the user the feeling of supporting the artist. I buy downloads that I never download for that reason. Some of them have only a handful of purchases in the world. I realize it's a feel-good measure, but WTF, if it makes me happy it's money well spent.
Donate on Bandcamp, download FLACs and listen to your very local files.
 
Not a tech problem.
No, it's certainly not a issue with the tech, and I'm certainly one not to take the technology for granted, as I do a lot of stuff with the computer like digital photography, graphic design and more recently video editing. It's amazing what all of this stuff can do and how truly well designed the interfaces for most of this software is. In this instance the issue isn't with the technology itself, but how I engage with it, and for purposes of engaging with music, I'd prefer to not deal with that extra layer of tech.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom