• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Will adding Marble tops improve speaker performance?

Thanks. I have heard a pair of Heath AS-101 speakers, once identical to mine, in an untreated home with remarkable sound.

I have already improved the speaker low-end response by increasing the amount of polyfill within the cabinets, described in another post.

Adding the top mass will be an improvement - I just need to manage my budget doing so, yet still maintain an acceptable aesthetic.

When I was doing experiments with polyfill in my 10" cabinet, it sounded like it enhanced the bass. But the RTA showed that what it was doing was reducing some of the mids to less than flat, thereby making it sound like the bass had been enhanced. I decided to omit the fill in those cabinets.

The moral is that the ear is not the best indicator of what it really gong on and a nice RTA is a worthwhile investment if you intend to persue similar endevors, or even get the most out of this one. A used Behringer DEQ 2496 is not all that expensive in the grand scheme of things.
 
When I was doing experiments with polyfill in my 10" cabinet, it sounded like it enhanced the bass.
But the RTA showed that what it was doing was reducing some of the mids to less than flat, thereby making it sound like the bass had been enhanced.
I decided to omit the fill in those cabinets.

The moral is that the ear is not the best indicator of what it really gong on and a nice RTA is a worthwhile investment if you intend to persue similar endevors,
or even get the most out of this one. A used Behringer DEQ 2496 is not all that expensive in the grand scheme of things.

I hear you, but - when I play Art of Noise - The Seduction of Claude Debussy, and the track Dreaming in Colour - there is a riff that tonally decends down a scale.
By listening I can tell how far it decends into the lower register.
When I frst got the speakers, the initial note was there, period. Now, I can hear it descend down the scale much further.
I bought a $10 app for my iPhone/iPad that does display wht is going on.
I'm sure its nice to buy an RTA - but this is a hobby, I don't do seaker tuning that often, and I'd rather put the money into the speakers or music.

That said, the Behringer DEQ 2496 looks to be more of a EQ Processor than an RTA -
 
Heather, your best bet for cheap marble or granite pieces in the thickness you want would probably be a high end building project. Sink cutouts are ideal and can be pretty large sometimes. I'm a retired tile installer and was working on some high end condos a few years ago that had all black granite countertops. The owner/builder was just going to toss out the double sink cutouts, I said hell no, I'll take one. The piece I brought home is 33"x18 1/4" and 1.25" thick. I built a coffee table around it out of black stained pine. You might want to check out some building sites, They might just give it to you for nothing,or maybe beer money. ;)
 
The polyfill did enhance the bass, relative to the midrange when you then turn it up to compensate for the minor loss of dB in the midrange. There is no denying that.

But at what cost? The polyfill does not act like a "bass" compensation circuit giving a nice smooth roll-off, but more of a selective reduction of frequencies above that point. I found that while the bass was enhanced, much of the band was less linear. Of course each cabinet/speaker/crossover combination is different and YMMV.
 
Again, as I have said in a couple threads. I noticed a change in low bass response from what I did with polyfill.
Explain it how you like, but for my initial listening experience, I found the Valencias were quite lacking on the bottom end,
and the change I described doing made them much more listenable and usable over the last 2 months. Do I need to do more? Of course.
That is what I am doing right now.
My Guru has a different approach with mixed media - lambswool and other material loaded into the cabinets that gave him
the bass response and sonic improvement he wanted. I will follow that path once I have materials and specifics from him.

Toddalin - you have told me before what I was hearing when I had the 4341s and added a Yamaha 31 band EQ.
My experience then was not as you described. I appreciate you have knowlege - but frankly,
I much prefer to make my own decisions based on personal experiences.
Suggestions are fine - I like hearing different perspectives, but ultimately,
I am the one who will live with them.
 
Last edited:
Heather, your best bet for cheap marble or granite pieces in the thickness you want would probably be a high end building project. Sink cutouts are ideal and can be pretty large sometimes. I'm a retired tile installer and was working on some high end condos a few years ago that had all black granite countertops. The owner/builder was just going to toss out the double sink cutouts, I said hell no, I'll take one. The piece I brought home is 33"x18 1/4" and 1.25" thick. I built a coffee table around it out of black stained pine. You might want to check out some building sites, They might just give it to you for nothing,or maybe beer money. ;)

I'll keep an eye out for that, thanks!
 
I'll keep an eye out for that, thanks!

Sink and other offcuts from counter suppliers are a great way to snag very inexpensive to free materials
and are all over the place.

Being a retired plumber I grabbed a large piece from a job site took it home [granite] and cut it to size
using a diamond 7.5" blade on an old circular saw with water lubrication.
Just wanting to see if it would turn out doing it myself, that was years ago still use it today
so yes it turned out well.

Or take your free material to a supplier and have them cut it for you.
 
@hjames You are looking for something like this? I got them from a local Habitat for Humanity Restore for approx. $9 sq ft.

20180517_134800-800x600.jpg

I picked up 4 black granite slabs for some future audio related projects. Just not sure what yet. Could be plinths on the new equipment rack I am still designing. Could be used to decouple the Chorus II's from the 2nd story wood floor. Could be used to protect the tops of those same speakers. However they get used, I just like the high polish nearly full black look.

3/4" x 22 1/2" x 37" for now, until I cut them up as needed.

20180517_134926-800x600.jpg

20180517_134950-800x600.jpg
 
Update the thread - I found 4 packs of 18 x 18 black granite tiles from Home Depot - not stocked in the store but available by order -
took a bit over a week to get and they sure made a difference in the looks over the smaller 12 x 12 ones!
The project was finished around Memorial Day - I just forgot to update this thread!

Heaths-18square-WIDE_6772.jpg
 
I use and have used pennies, nickles and o-rings to isolate speakers from furniture and shelves over the years. Could work on top to isolate the weight from the cabinet. Not sure if that would be a plus in the desired physics or not.
 
This thread was very ineresting for me and I paid close attention to it as events unfolded. It had a strong influence on what I eventually did with my system. It looks like Heather/hjames/OP has long since reached her goals, but I want to share how the thread had a positive effect.

For a long time I simply placed my speakers on the floor with a pair of small throw rugs under them. I hadn't really thought things through at that point. And when I did decide to get the speakers up off the floor with some small homemade stands I made the same mistake and placed a 10mm rubber pad under the speakers. I wasn't really happy with the bass but hadn't learned what to do about it.

The next step was to do as hjames mentions and I restuffed the cabinets, in my case removing the small amount of polyfill and replacing it with 40mm fiberglass bats, about 90% full. This realized a very nice improvement in not only the amount of bass but also the quality.

DSC00658.JPG DSC03336.jpg

Then I read this thread.

Cheers,
James
 
Last edited:
I decided to first start with some granite slabs and spikes to get the speakers stabilized and firmly planted on the floor. It took about a year before I found some nice polished black granite that was reasonably affordable, and also bought some stainless steel spikes to add to the bottom of my stands in place of the cheap plastic feet that I had been using. I paid €55 each for the granite, 3cm thick, 35x35cm.

DSC07262.JPG DSC07265.JPG DSC07266.JPG

The change in sound was fairly profound. Not only much improved bass/midbass but more of it and (by ear) deeper. The improvement really was rather shocking, far more than I had expected. But in retrospect using those rubber pads was a major mistake and it stands to reason that things could only get better, I just wasn't prepared for the scale of change.

One can see in the last photo that I cut some self-adhesive felt pads to place under the stone to protect the floor. This stuff was 3mm thick and under the weight of the speakers and stone it compressed to a very hard 2mm, with no perceptible movement of the speakers when I tried to rock them by hand. The utility of the felt is that I can still slide the entire unit around fairly easily without scratching the floor. The speakers started out @ 105lbs when new, and with all of the mods that have been done since then they are over 120lbs now.

When I bought the granite I sized it such that if I liked what I heard they would be usable as mass loading on top of the speakers, planning to then buy larger and thicker granite at a later date. That was all done in April of this piece-of-crap year of 2020.

Cheers,
James
 
Last edited:
A week ago I could finally afford to buy some new, larger granite, this time 4cm thick, 40x40cm. The difference in weight is quite a lot, 8kg for the original stone, 19.5kg each for the new slabs.

Yesterday with the help of my wife I got things changed over.

DSC07343.JPG DSC07347.JPG DSC07349.JPG DSC07357.JPG

This time the results are much more subtle. Bass and midbass are a bit tighter. The overall effect is quite pleasing. I have actually reached the point where I wouldn't really want any more bass. But the granite basses do a pretty good job of isolating the speakers from the floor and therefore my neighbors heads. I can play the system pretty loud and get no complaints, the neighbors all claim that they don't hear anything, so we are good to go.

Anyway these are the results, very much an improvement. The cabinet stuffing and bases/spikes made the largest improvement, the mass loading was the icing on the cake so to speak.

Heather, I am very greatful that you started the thread, it proved quite useful to me. :thumbsup::)

Cheers,
James
 
Back
Top Bottom