Snip--Don't step over a dollar to pick up a dime! It's one thing to be frugal, and another to waste the money you spend by being cheap. You have invested some decent money into this, and you need to spend just a bit more to see it through.
1. Buy a good cartridge. Don't break the bank, but don't waste money by buying something you are going to upgrade from shortly.---snip
That can be risky without knowing what you're getting and if you'll like it. A Shure V-15 type-who-cares was the biggest disappointment of my career, a total waste of time and money. I'm not crazy about the Audio Technica MM sound either but it was better than the Shure. I still can't think of a better lo-risk good entry-level investment than 3 Digitrack 200 NE carts from jettsales. They sound more like an Ortofon moving coil than a cheap cart and come with 1st class nude elliptical stones. You need 3 to assure getting one good one but the extra stylii are worth each at least 5 times the cost of one. A better sounding cart will run you somewhat more than $140, mebbe much more.
Well I tend to look at cartridge recommendations with this thought in the back of my head. Analog playback has the most variation in the hobby. There are so many mechanical variables affecting the retrieval of information off the records that there cannot be any absolute statements made about analog components.(Yes I know I think the regular series of Grado cartridges suck...and thats as close as I can get to an absolute) Unless you are feeding reference quality electronics and speakers, there is another variable to contend with.
Given this context I can understand you not liking the Shure V15. Actually the V15 is a polarizing product, people seem to love it or hate it. There are very few people who feel ambivalent about it.
But unless you have the same turntable, phono stage, and set up parameters as another person, then there is a large window of variation that must be accounted for. What phono cartridge that works well in one system may not shine in another. It may be that the V15 was not a good fit for your system.
Personal preference is going to be a major factor, since every cartridge has a distinct personality. Someone may gravitate to a certain sound, such as the Ortofon which you prefer. I have owned several Ortofon cartridges such as the X1,X3, MC20 Super, and MC30 Super. They were good products, and I enjoyed my time with them.
Many people recommend the products they like, and expect others would feel the same way if they were to hear it. This is a natural inclination, but it may not be the best course of action for the potential buyer. The plain truth is that the buyer is going to have to spend the money and experience the product before they can form an opinion. There are no "can't miss" recommendations.
Now the crux of my opinion (and thats all it is) is not to go cheap. I am not saying to spend the kids inheritance mind you, but consider cartridges that are a step up from entry level, and look at the level of performance versus price. I gave a list of companies to consider, but really didn't recommend one particular model. Its up to the buyer to do their research. I just suggested concentrating the dollars on a well designed and built cartridge. Also spend the money needed to maintain it and the records. Use the free protractors, and source an inexpensive tracking force tool.
Once again, these are just the musings of a barnyard animal. The farmer doesn't let us get out much, so we ponder these kinds of things during our free time.
Regards
Mister Pig