• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

7199 vs 6U8

I completed the pin out changes and installed two new old stock 6u8 tubes, RCA I believe. All the reading I have done says it should perform better; maybe so with the best test equipment connected however, I can hear NO difference as compared to the 7199 tubes. I will also be doing some associated component changes soon as well. Sometimes the ear test works best. Being an electronics person and a musician, I will believe my ears! I will be trying a couple of 6gh8's soon and will let you know.
Cheers!
 
I completed the pin out changes and installed two new old stock 6u8 tubes, RCA I believe. All the reading I have done says it should perform better; maybe so with the best test equipment connected however, I can hear NO difference as compared to the 7199 tubes. I will also be doing some associated component changes soon as well. Sometimes the ear test works best. Being an electronics person and a musician, I will believe my ears! I will be trying a couple of 6gh8's soon and will let you know.
Cheers!

I am not surprised. Now you have options. Yes, the 7199 is a fine vacuum tube. But since it is desired by us, there are those who think we all have deep pockets and are willing to spend our bread and milk money for them. Horse feathers! You will be happy with the 6U8 and the 6GH8 tubes. If you find NOS 6GH8 tubes, they will often be actually Sylvania. If the numbers are on the side of the tube and not inside of the "stop sign", but rather just printed on the envelope, they are Sylvania. Actually, RCA used 6GH8 tubes labeled "RCA" that were actually made by Sylvania because they worked much better in their early tube color sets.

Easy rewire wasn't it?
 
My ASR333 certainly sounded better with GE 6U8s in it, than any other 6GH8/6U8/6BL8 variant. That's what's going into my '433, too...

Regards,
Gordon.

Find some Fisher branded German 6AV6s too Gordon, they really helped tighten up the bass on my 433. Not sure who made them, but it could have been Ultron?? No Mullard markings that I could see.
 
Update:

Installed 2 new 6gh8a tubes and found the 6u8's performed a bit better. Changed the .05uf caps to .33uf as suggested to increase bass and they did. I am not yet sure about the .33uf change as I need to listen to it more with a variety of music. It seemed a bit muddy.

On another note, I am restoring another ST70 to as close as possible to original. I am currently assessing the on going debate about electrolytic capacitors. My preliminary findings are if the capacitor is functioning properly it probably will continue to do so. I am running some long term active tests and will keep you posted. I see more problems with high microfarad valued, lower voltage capacitors used in solid state equipment far more likely to fail.

Be a bit cautious of the stated voltages for the ST70 power supply. I have re-caped and tried several rectifier tubes and have yet to achieve stated voltages; and yes, I maintain a 117vac input. This has been done on more than one unit.

OK, enough for now. Hope you found some of this useful if not at least interesting.

Stay tuned,
Cheers!
 
No offense but the engineers of Dynaco products built those units to achieve measurements throughout the product line. Although there are "tweaks" to be done, such as stiffening the power supply or such, if you can't get the voltages they laid out in the schematic, something else is amiss. I would be checking resistors, especially in the power supply. Just a re-cap isn't always going to fix things.
Mike
 
Sorry, you may have missed my point. As for electrolytic capacitors, too many people are condemning old electrolytic capacitors before assessing thier true condition.

As for the power supply comment, the power supply used in the ST70 and many, many other early tube power supplies is really basic power supplies 101. At the time of initial design and market offering (which I remember!) the stated voltages were derived from 2 sources: typical power supply design and actual voltage readings taken on new production units. The design criteria will remain the same yet there are no units currently coming off the assembly line.

The voltages I have recorded for the ST70 seem to be a bit shy of the stated voltages, on all the units I have tested. I have yet to find one that equals design voltages. However, this is to be expected but not for a particular component failure, just the aging of all components that are associated with the power supply, which as I am sure you know, are many.

So, when taking voltages around the power supply, don't be alarmed if they are a bit low, yet still proportional within the different section of the supply filters; this is normal. Any large deviations are a sure sign of a problem.

Hope this clears up my position. Thanks for your response.

Cheers!
 
Last edited:
Sorry, you may have missed my point. As for electrolytic capacitors, too many people are condemning old electrolytic capacitors before assessing thier true condition.

They're long past they're rated life expectancy, and they don't stay in any unit I work on. End of story. Even if they're OK now, they could fail at any time.
 
If you buy a new set of tires they too could fail at anytime. Hmmm!

Yeah...and if they've been sitting around for 30 years they're more likely to fail than if they're brand new.

Fool yourself into thinking whatever you like. It's your equipment that will burn up, not mine. ;)
 
I am not going to sit behind this keyboard and be a hypocrite by telling you I never use an amplifier with an old electrolytic capacitor in it. My daily use LK-72 still has the original ones in it. But I do not leave it unattended and it is in the queue for replacements. Everything else necessary is replaced. And it just plays like an opera singer. It was mentioned that these vintage can caps were not designed to last as long as we have extended them to. We (myself included) have been fortunate (not lucky, fortunate) to squeeze more life out of them. I am one who prefers to pry them open and replace the "guts" with new discrete 105˚C capacitors. It only takes about an hour.

I hate to sound like a parent, "Don't do as I do, do as I say!" But I know I am playing with a time bomb and will soon have more time to rectify the situation (pun intended ;)) Just don't want someone to have a meltdown on a nice piece of equipment...
 
You should listen to these guy's, all my amps I done, I recaped or restuffed the
can caps, and after taking some apart for restuffing you'll see why.

Tube
 
I have a power supply for a Hammond PR40 tone cab amp that is pretty much a boat anchor due to a can cap that shorted when I plugged it in and took out the PT. Glad it happened on that as I only had a few $$ in that tone cab. A mistake I wont make again. The Packard Plamor amp that I am currently playing with got a PS redo before I even plugged it into my dim bulb setup. JOHN:nono::nono::nono:
 
As far as I'm concerned there is no need to read any more info when it comes to
old/vintage electrolytic capacitors in power supplies.

They have a lifespan.

When they die(unpredictable even if "test fine") they often take things with them.
(I would not leave an restored piece on if not right there next to it monitoring)

As they age (quite a few years) they just don't perform like they did and or should.

Todays caps are smaller for larger amounts of capacitance to fit in the same spaces.
(I tend to up the PS capacitance on vintage equipment, usually it is rather shy there)

Old power supply caps can have very high ESR, slight leakage, which will in turn create
heat in power tranny's and quite often a low output DC voltage with higher AC content.

If you care about an piece of equipment, want to use it daily, PS caps should be redone.
(It's just good solid preventative maintenance and piece of mind to rebuild there supply)
 
I recently converted a Stromberg Carlson amp to the 6U8 family of tubes instead of the 7199. The 6U8 sounded better than the 7199 that were in it, but that isnt a very fair comparison as the 7199 were on their last leg.

I have done quite a bit of tube rolling in this amp with the 6U8 family, and my favorite is the TungSol 6U8. They are kind of hard to find but show up on Ebay once in awhile. I ordered 5 of these from a vendor, and received a sleeve of tubes, not indentical boxes but all looked very old. Out of the 5 tubes, one was a blackplate, two were greyplates, and two had one grey plate and one black plate! All sounded similar, and very nice, so any of the TungSols are worth snagging. I have not tried a Telefunken or a Brimar yet, those are next on the acquire list.
 
Just to put my 2 cents in here, I did some re-wiring of the original ST-70 driver boards to accommodate the 6GH8 tube some time back. Yes, it sounds fine with that tube as a sub for the 7199. BUT......in some email exchanges with Kevin at Dynakitparts.com, I was informed that he'd been working with someone else regarding the 'adapters' he sells for just such a purpose (I don't recall who). In those tests, they found there were a couple of parts on the board that, when changed, 'optimized' the use of the 6GH8. He sells these parts along with his adapters. I believe there are some internal differences that alter the performance to some degree beyond just the simple pin-out. As such, making a few changes isn't unusual. I think Don (KVflyer) mentioned that Scott uses both tubes in their amps in the same location for the same purpose. However, (and perhaps Don may know this specifically) there may be some other passive part changes associated with the use of these two different tubes. If so, one would also want to make the appropriate changes beyond just simply re-wiring the socket if planning to swap from one tube to the other. I can tell you that after carving on 3 different ST-70 driver boards, and swapping around between both different tubes, including all the associated resistors and capacitors that Kevin suggested changing.....in the end......I don't know that it was really worth it. In consideration of the fact that many of those old amps are 60 years old with original drivers in them.....seems to me that a few more years isn't gonna change 'em much! If you really want to do something to change the performance of that amp....this is NOT what I'd do! I either change out the driver board completely to something like the VTA or other 'up-grade' board......or I'd add the SDS Filter Board or something similar.........or both! For what it's worth!! Tom D.
 
I was going to say something about the circuit the tubes are ran in affecting
performance but figured it would just take up space. But since were here now.

--------------

Some may be aware of some or all of the following, so bear with me.

The driver circuit in the original 70 is, voltage gain pentode direct coupled to a
triode in a concertina phase splitter/driver arrangement. (all in 1 dual tube)

Now being direct coupled means the plate of the pentode section of the 7199's
are connected directly to the grid of the triode section, so the plate voltage of
the pentode section sets the whole circuitry in motion.

Ideally you want 80-100v at the plate of the pentode, then double the cathode
voltage of the triode at it's plate, screen of the pentode 10-15v less than plate.

---
Example: Say there is 90v at the plate of the pentode.
You'd want it's screen at somewhere around 78v or so.

The triode section would have roughly 95v at it's cathode.
So you want it's plate to be about 190v, (double the cathode)
---

So with dropping any of these tubes in here then stating this or that sound and
perform better then others, you really should be checking there operating range.
(some tubes may possibly even be running to hard for there own good/lifespan)

Now the ST70-2 ran 6GH8 tubes with all the exact same circuitry, I haven't been
able to find voltage readings for an driver section on the original or the second to
see how the tubes were actually ran, I can only assume the 6GH8 "worked" there.

--------------------

So if it were me I'd get some Holland 6BL8's, test say 5 of them in the circuit then
adjust the circuit values/voltage to have the tubes setup best as they could there.
(I'd also cut the plate and cathode resistors values on the splitters in half, say 24k)
(Also cut the grid resistors on the output tubes in half, then triple coupling caps to)

Don't just test 1 tube either to see how the circuit is running, test at least 5 of any
one type to get the fair assessment of the voltages at all the driver section layouts.
 
Kegger, I think you're basically saying with full technical back-up what I was attempting to allude to with my comment. Sure wish I had the 'know-how'...... But, that was exactly my point: The tube may 'sound-good'....but, it ain't right....may not last long, and I suppose in some circumstances may potentially lead to other failures?

And, while we're on the subject; why does not the venerable 6AN8 ever come up in these discussions? I see that tube often in amps.....probably got 20 of 'em in my tube drawer. Dynaco used 'em on the Mk II and Mk III..... yet, I rarely see anyone commenting that they used one in their own design. I'm just curious; is this a particularly 'bad' tube for one reason or another?

Tom
 
Back
Top Bottom