Some good stuff goin' on here!
edd9000 - you have a good eye for composition and perspective. I am thoroughly enjoying your B&W and color posts. Keep up the good work!
There's no impressing dimwits, fruitless to try. Do your thing for you. For YOUR satisfaction. FTW.Here's a B&W shot with a discouraging story:
I took this shot with a Casio digital at EPCOT in 2001, and at that time I was in the habit of printing shots I liked and pinning them up on the side of my cube at work.
![]()
I printed it in black and white because I thought the color in the kiosk was really distracting from the geometry of the tent:
![]()
I got not one comment on the composition, good or bad. The only comments I got were "why isn't it in color?" :thumbsdn:
I got discouraged about posting any prints after that.
Do your thing for you. For YOUR satisfaction.
Here is one that from my Monument Valley trip that I finally got around to converting to B&W. I had posted a similar shot in "landscape" format vs. this example I made in "portrait" mode.
![]()
The texture in the butte is fantastic. How is it done? Did you change the color emphasis in the B&W conversion in addition to contrast/brightness adjustments?
Wow - thanks for looking all the way back at that post. I think is it most discouraging of all to get NO comments - much rather hear what people don't like or would change, than hear nothing; but when the comments didn't even consider that B&W might have SOME positive aspects, I was non-plussed.
I used NIK Silver Effex Pro and used the "orange" filter application which, when I shoot with black and white film, is one of the filters I like to use. The others are the yellow, red, and on occasion, the green filter.