• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Dac Scam Video

He is an idiot. What matters as much as the chip is the implementation - meaning power supplies, shielding, component placement, topology, etc. He is entitled to his opinion, as are we all.

Let’s move it to a realm we can all understand a little better - analog. Compare volume pots to stepped attenuators. They cost more and sound better - it is a part of the implementation.
I agree with implementation, but I have to ask how much of this this improves the digital conversion and how much involves everything else we hear? People say that a good DAC sounds neutral. But how do you establish this? How do I create a baseline of comparison to make such a statement with my gear? I am not convinced that what we get when we move up the price ladder in DACs actually has anything to do with improving the basic function of this equipment, which is converting a digital signal to analog so we can plug the source into the back of our amps and preamps. I have concerns that the ballyhoo we hear about higher end DACs, or any DAC within a competitive price range, has more to do with processing the sound through circuitry that has nothing to do with the signal conversion.
 
I have concerns that the ballyhoo we hear about higher end DACs, or any DAC within a competitive price range, has more to do with processing the sound through circuitry that has nothing to do with the signal conversion.

Can you clarify what kind of "processing" you think is occurring?

A DAC is a chain of components, so any influence that the power supply, the digital receiver/input stage and analogue output stage has on sound quality embodies the character of the DAC itself. How can you define where the "basic function" of the DAC begins and ends? You can't exclude those components/stages from the equation, so any sonic differences between a basic bare-bones implementation and a more nuanced implementation are legitimate and not simply processing of the sound through circuitry (in my view and experience anyway).
 
Last edited:
Can you clarify what kind of "processing" you think is occurring?

A DAC is a chain of components, so any influence that the power supply, the digital receiver/input stage and analogue output stage has on sound quality embodies the character of the DAC itself. How can you define where the "basic function" of the DAC begins and ends? You can't exclude those components/stages from the equation, so any sonic differences between a basic bare-bones implementation and a more nuanced implementation are legitimate and not simply processing of the sound through circuitry (in my view and experience anyway).
Sure. And I'm not trying to be contradictory. I'm just skeptical. I have concerns that a lot of what we here from DACs have more to do with things within the circuitry that have nothing to do with converting a digital signal to analog. And have more to do with just "sweetening" the sound through manipulation of the signal down stream of the conversion. Having said that, how much can actually be done to improve the basic conversion? I'm not an engineer nor pretend to play one on TV, but ow far can one actually go in improving the basic function of converting digital to analog? Judging by the market, the answer would be thousands of dollars. But really? Anyway, if I could use some education here then please feel free to some schoolin'.

PS - In my 40-plus years in this hobby I have had a number of products that were marketed as sound processors. A common product would be a parabolic or graphic equalizer. I once had a product that was marketed as a sound expander. So, in one sense, how do we know that we are not simply getting a DAC chip that was placed in a box that also contained circuitry designed for sound processing. Maybe something like a graphic equalizer without the sliders that also contained a DAC chip. This may sound a bit absurd, but I think it addresses the question you asked me. Thanks.
 
Last edited:
I can tell the difference quite readily between different speakers, between different phono cartridges, between amplifiers, and even preamps.
I can tell the difference between CDs of the same album; each mastered and remastered version of the same album on CD sounds different to me.

It's a lot harder to tell the difference between CD players and DACs. I can do it but only if I am listening very carefully. I have never heard a cheap DAC or an old CD player or even a DVD player playing CDs and thought, "That thing sounds horrible". They all sound really good to me. Every cheap CD player or DAC I own sounds really good. I would never spend thousands on a DAC.
But I would spend a lot of money on a good stylus or cartridge though, and as a matter of fact... I have.
 
Last edited:
Sure. And I'm not trying to be contradictory. I'm just skeptical. I have concerns that a lot of what we here from DACs have more to do with things within the circuitry that have nothing to do with converting a digital signal to analog. And have more to do with just "sweetening" the sound through manipulation of the signal down stream of the conversion. Having said that, how much can actually be done to improve the basic conversion? I'm not an engineer nor pretend to play one on TV, but ow far can one actually go in improving the basic function of converting digital to analog? Judging by the market, the answer would be thousands of dollars. But really? Anyway, if I could use some education here then please feel free to some schoolin'.

PS - In my 40-plus years in this hobby I have had a number of products that were marketed as sound processors. A common product would be a parabolic or graphic equalizer. I once had a product that was marketed as a sound expander. So, in one sense, how do we know that we are not simply getting a DAC chip that was placed in a box that also contained circuitry designed for sound processing. Maybe something like a graphic equalizer without the sliders that also contained a DAC chip. This may sound a bit absurd, but I think it addresses the question you asked me. Thanks.

I'm not really sure what else I can add that I haven't said already in this and other threads on the topic. The DAC chip is only one part within a system, and EVERYTHING matters - the power supply, the digital input stage, all of the circuitry around the DAC chip (heck, different decoupling caps can make a difference!) and the analogue output stage. The DAC chip is not immune to changes to any and all of these aspects of DAC design.

On the second point, I am not aware of any DACs out there that deliberately EQ the DAC output, apart from the inclusion of user-selectable equalisation or the like on some DACs - usually in the digital domain. Concealing an EQ would absolutely show up in measurements and be immediately obvious when the frequency response of the DAC is measured. To be honest, I think you're jumping at shadows with this line of thinking.
 
I'm not really sure what else I can add that I haven't said already in this and other threads on the topic. The DAC chip is only one part within a system, and EVERYTHING matters - the power supply, the digital input stage, all of the circuitry around the DAC chip (heck, different decoupling caps can make a difference!) and the analogue output stage. The DAC chip is not immune to changes to any and all of these aspects of DAC design.

On the second point, I am not aware of any DACs out there that deliberately EQ the DAC output, apart from the inclusion of user-selectable equalisation or the like on some DACs - usually in the digital domain. Concealing an EQ would absolutely show up in measurements and be immediately obvious when the frequency response of the DAC is measured. To be honest, I think you're jumping at shadows with this line of thinking.
The Schiit Yggy MIB uses the TI chips that actually recalibrate themselves depending on temperature. Temperature affects the resistance of the ladder network.
 
There is so much passion on this topic here that I doubt people will be convinced by any argument. And not everyone is corruptly arguing a viewpoint for profit.

However, with electronics and with digital components in particular, graphs of input and output signals can be easily compared to look for differences. For DAC tests that I've seen, those graphs are identical except past the limits of human audibility and beyond the component specs. I expected there would at least be noise or artifacts but the signals were exact copies roughly from 10hz to 40khz. Other tests, like signal to noise, showed microscopically low distortion exactly as the signal graphs predicted.

For that reason I am in the camp that there may differences in implementations but I certainly can't hear them, or at least I haven't been able to yet. So I agree with the video dude. I have several DACs, computer sound cards, and CD players. All of them put together were well short of $1000 and to my ears they sound excellent (and identical).

If you do not believe that testing can measure the audio being output, you will of course not agree with my reasoning. Buy what you want and enjoy the heck out of it, as I am doing. Most of us on AK can at least agree on that.
 
I agree with your last sentence only. If they all cost less than $1000 combined then you haven’t heard a great one yet I suspect. It is more than frequency response curves. It is also about ringing - pre and post as well as timing (phase coherence) and filtration.
 
I suspect that some of the things that we cannot hear consciously may have an effect at subliminal level, to which some people may be more sensitive than others.
What we consider to be the limits of human hearing was established based on what we can consciously detect when we listen deliberately. But we don't hear with our ears. We hear with our brains. And the fact that our brains filter out certain frequencies, or that they ignore others under certain circumstances (e.g. by masking), doesn't mean that our ears don't detect them. They actually do, we're just not aware of it.
If we had two DACs that measured exactly the same in the audible range, but one of them showed some unwanted artifacts outside that range, they should theoretically sound the same. And, while listening intently, they probably would sound exactly the same, indeed. And yet the latter might be more tiring (or at least less pleasant) to listen to than the former. We would have a vague feeling that something might be slightly amiss, even though we wouldn't be able to put our finger on it.
 
Last edited:
There is certainly a subliminal aspect to it.
The layperson inherently understands that more money = more better, so that's what they are inclined to believe. Just look at all the people walking around wearing ugly "high fashion" clothing with gaudy designer logos emblazoned upon them.

There is a reason that when audio products reach a certian price level, specs start dissappearing, and insane buzzwords and magic incantations replace them.

Often, the only people you will find praising such products are 'influencers' and people whos hearing started to naturally decline due to age 30 or 40 years ago, and they will also spout all of these same nonsense jargon that makes the retro encabulator seem sensible.


One example that also falls in line with audiophilia, healing crystals, and astrology, comes from the guitar community.

People were going nuts about this bland but rare overdrive pedal called the klon centuar to the point that fuctioning examples now cost between 3 and 5 thousand dollars. For decades, rational people were saying that there was nothing special about it, but 'the elite' claimed that only the klon could produce that sound and denigrating the naysayers as just being too poor to understand.

Recently, a very popular influencer broke ranks and did a side by side comparision of the klon and one of the most common overdrive pedals you can find. The result... they sound exactly the same.

For perspective, this would be like stereophile deciding they didn't like advertizers anymore, and coming to the conlusion that this:


sounds just like this:
 
DACs sound different. That doesn't always mean better. I don't drop a
bundle on any I've owned. But I don't buy the cheapest either. I haven't
spent more than $200. Most have been used. The two I currently use
did cost quite a bit more new, but getting them used saved a lot. And if
I decide to dump one, I won't be out much cash. The Schiit Bifrost 2 only
Set me back $180. The Audio-gd nfb3 cost $200. Both sound good enough
for me. Dumping thousands into one is overkill.
 
There is certainly a subliminal aspect to it.
The layperson inherently understands that more money = more better, so that's what they are inclined to believe. Just look at all the people walking around wearing ugly "high fashion" clothing with gaudy designer logos emblazoned upon them.

I wait with bated breath for the creation of the fashionsciencereview.com forums where the objective clothing needs of the population are clearly measured and established, and spending more on subjective fashion is poo-pooed. ;)
 
Last edited:
For decades, rational people were saying that there was nothing special about it, but 'the elite' claimed that only the klon could produce that sound and denigrating the naysayers as just being too poor to understand.
The Emperor's new clothes? :)
 
I wait with bated breath for the creation of the fashionsciencereview.com forums where the objective clothing needs of the population are clearly measured and established, and spending more on subjective fashion is poo-pooed. ;)
Well, to be fair, it's not quite the same thing. Fashion is solely about looks and projecting an image, not about needs. Nobody has ever said, "my expensive Armani suit is much better at keeping me warm, or is much more comfortable, than a cheap sweater". Not to mention high-heeled shoes, which are as far removed from the concept of need as is humanly possible to be.
If we were to liken our hobby to fashion, it would be like, "I prefer this DAC because I love its big, colorful display, and I think its brushed aluminium finish looks great". Most AKers won't have an issue with that. It's only when it comes to "I prefer this one because it sounds better" that discussions start heating up.
 
Last edited:
Well, to be fair, it's not quite the same thing. Fashion is solely about looks and projecting an image, not about needs. Nobody has ever said, "my expensive Armani suit is much better at keeping me warm, or is much more comfortable, than a cheap sweater". Not to mention high-heeled shoes, which are as far removed from the concept of need as is humanly possible to be.If we were to liken our hobby to fashion, it would be like, "I prefer this DAC because I love its big, colorful display, and I think its brushed aluminium finish looks great". Most AKers won't have an issue with that. It's only when it comes to "I prefer this one because it sounds better" that discussions start heating up.
My post was tongue-in-cheek, hence the winkey-face. It's best to read it in the context of the thread that I quoted ;)
 
Yeah, mine too. :)
I did look for a "geek" or "pedant" emoticon, perhaps one wearing glasses or a monocle, but there isn't any. :)
 
Back
Top Bottom