• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Dac Scam Video

I suspect that some of the things that we cannot hear consciously may have an effect at subliminal level, to which some people may be more sensitive than others.
I have listened to my DAC while unconscious & heard no difference.
But, thats just me & I'm trying cut back on my consumption.

On subject, the video has a good point but like many You Tubers, perhaps overgeneralizes.
I'm a little surprised to see the emotion & anger its caused tho.
He hit some sore spots apparently.
 
The DAC chip is only one part within a system, and EVERYTHING matters - the power supply, the digital input stage, all of the circuitry around the DAC chip (heck, different decoupling caps can make a difference!) and the analogue output stage. The DAC chip is not immune to changes to any and all of these aspects of DAC design.
I fully agree, Everything does matter. But depending on your system (amps & speakers) you will not hear any change as you go up the DAC ladder. Your base system needs to be resolving enough to fully appreciate what a better DAC can & does do.
 
I fully agree, Everything does matter. But depending on your system (amps & speakers) you will not hear any change as you go up the DAC ladder. Your base system needs to be resolving enough to fully appreciate what a better DAC can & does do.

Absolutely - the resolving capabilities of a system are critical.

In my experience there are some DACs that largely sound alike, but also plenty that sound different.

Due to differences in system quality, system and room setup, and critical listening experience of the individual, I’ve always taken the view that just because one person can’t hear a difference in their own system, doesn’t mean someone else won’t hear a difference in theirs.
 
Spend enough you can not only hear an ant fart but you can tell whether had a beef or bean burrito for lunch.
Gonna have to spend more if you want to know if its wearing sneakers or sandals when waltzing tho.

If you're going to play the resolution game, then go all in.
 
I have listened to my DAC while unconscious & heard no difference.
But, thats just me & I'm trying cut back on my consumption.

On subject, the video has a good point but like many You Tubers, perhaps overgeneralizes.
I'm a little surprised to see the emotion & anger its caused tho.
He hit some sore spots apparently.
The sloppy application of science riddled with confounding variables does indeed rub some up the wrong way.
 
Absolutely - the resolving capabilities of a system are critical.

In my experience there are some DACs that largely sound alike, but also plenty that sound different.

Due to differences in system quality, system and room setup, and critical listening experience of the individual, I’ve always taken the view that just because one person can’t hear a difference in their own system, doesn’t mean someone else won’t hear a difference in theirs.
Some of us just put the very minor differences we sometimes perceive down to failure to do a proper listening comparison. It's not about those who don't hear differences vs those who do.

People with very 'basic' systems also perceive differences in DACs so the whole 'insufficiently resolving system' argument doesn't really hold water.

At least some of the minor differences perceived will be real. Not all DACs are identical in their frequency response and some have a lot of noise that could have an audible effect. Added to which not all DACs have the same output voltage so for the same position on the volume dial one can be slightly louder than the other. Not enough to be consciously noticeable, but enough to make us think one is different or 'better.'
 
In short, no two people hear exactly the same. That's why, even at the highest-performance levels of audio, we still have- and rightfully so- different equipment with slightly different "flavors", of tonal balance, perceived transient response and such.
Well said, Gordon. I find most of these arguments to be specious at best.
 
Some of us just put the very minor differences we sometimes perceive down to failure to do a proper listening comparison. It's not about those who don't hear differences vs those who do.

People with very 'basic' systems also perceive differences in DACs so the whole 'insufficiently resolving system' argument doesn't really hold water.

At least some of the minor differences perceived will be real. Not all DACs are identical in their frequency response and some have a lot of noise that could have an audible effect. Added to which not all DACs have the same output voltage so for the same position on the volume dial one can be slightly louder than the other. Not enough to be consciously noticeable, but enough to make us think one is different or 'better.'

I agree on the need to provide an even playing field for listening comparisons - that is an assumed "lock-in" from my perspective.

I also agree that some basic systems are very much capable of showing difference between DACs. However, the better and more resolving the system, the more apparent the differences become at both the macro and micro level. This is where it becomes fun comparing DACs using the exact same DAC chip in different implementations, which is where the premise of the "DAC scam" video in question falls over in my experience.
 
I agree on the need to provide an even playing field for listening comparisons - that is an assumed "lock-in" from my perspective.

I also agree that some basic systems are very much capable of showing difference between DACs. However, the better and more resolving the system, the more apparent the differences become at both the macro and micro level. This is where it becomes fun comparing DACs using the exact same DAC chip in different implementations, which is where the premise of the "DAC scam" video in question falls over in my experience.
I've done my fair share of CD player and DAC comparisons in the past, have to say I did not find it fun but each to his own.

My take away from that was that even though they did not all sound exactly the same to me, I found the differences were small and inconsequential. I no longer have any further interest in auditioning or changing DACs and am happy with the performance of the DAC in my pre-amp.

(Note: This was not the conclusion reached by some of the other people involved in those comparisons, and they continue to trial and to buy expensive DACS. I spent the money on better speakers instead since I was at least confident I was getting some sonic upgrade there. As always, people have to follow their own path).

The 'sufficiently resolving' thing is always a thorny point. My one source system would retail around $35K and my room is acoustically treated so I'd hope that at that price level it could manage to show up any differences that do exist, but you can never be sure about these things since there is no benchmark to go by, it's all very subjective.
 
Sure. And I'm not trying to be contradictory. I'm just skeptical. I have concerns that a lot of what we here from DACs have more to do with things within the circuitry that have nothing to do with converting a digital signal to analog. And have more to do with just "sweetening" the sound through manipulation of the signal down stream of the conversion. Having said that, how much can actually be done to improve the basic conversion? I'm not an engineer nor pretend to play one on TV, but ow far can one actually go in improving the basic function of converting digital to analog? Judging by the market, the answer would be thousands of dollars. But really? Anyway, if I could use some education here then please feel free to some schoolin'.

PS - In my 40-plus years in this hobby I have had a number of products that were marketed as sound processors. A common product would be a parabolic or graphic equalizer. I once had a product that was marketed as a sound expander. So, in one sense, how do we know that we are not simply getting a DAC chip that was placed in a box that also contained circuitry designed for sound processing. Maybe something like a graphic equalizer without the sliders that also contained a DAC chip. This may sound a bit absurd, but I think it addresses the question you asked me. Thanks.
Well gosh, get a load of this!


And a month ago I referred to myself as sounding absurd with such a suggestion.
 
Well gosh, get a load of this!


And a month ago I referred to myself as sounding absurd with such a suggestion.

I'm not quite clear which product you're linking to as that's a generic google search link, but I'm assuming it's the new DAC with the built-in parametric EQ? (EDIT: ah, just saw the other thread... it's the Mirmir)

Certainly an interesting and pretty cool addition!

In this situation the manufacturer is specifically adding a user adjustable EQ - much like adding user adjustable tone controls on an amplifier. This is different than a manufacturer deliberately EQing the frequency response of a DAC (or amplifier) so that it the response is not flat, which seemed to be what your original post was alluding to.
 
Last edited:
I'm not quite clear which product you're linking to as that's a generic google search link, but I'm assuming it's the new DAC with the built-in parametric EQ? (EDIT: ah, just saw the other thread... it's the Mirmir)

Certainly an interesting and pretty cool addition!

In this situation the manufacturer is specifically adding a user adjustable EQ - much like adding user adjustable tone controls on an amplifier. This is different than a manufacturer deliberately EQing the frequency response of a DAC (or amplifier) so that it the response is not flat, which seemed to be what your original post was alluding to.
Sorry, I didn't realize the link didn't work. However, you are correct. And I have no complaint with it. I just figured that gear like this would eventually be offered for sale from the hifi industry.
 
The Schiit Yggy MIB uses the TI chips that actually recalibrate themselves depending on temperature. Temperature affects the resistance of the ladder network.
Stavro,

Temperature-dependent DAC linearity is hardly a new engineering challenge. Back in the 1990s, some telecom equipment already used temperature-indexed calibration lookup tables (LUTs) stored in ROM, automatically selecting correction coefficients as temperature changed, without requiring a new calibration cycle.

Those familiar with resistor-ladder DACs used in 1980s polyphonic synthesizers will also remember that resistor matching and thermal drift were well-known engineering concerns.

Of course, there's a substantial difference between those older discrete resistor networks and the monolithic 20-bit R-2R architecture of the TI DAC11001B used in the Schiit Yggdrasil More Is Better (MIB). Integrated resistor matching and thermal tracking offer significant advantages.

According to TI's DAC11001B datasheet (section 7.3.5), the chip includes a temperature-dependent INL/DNL calibration function. However, this function must be enabled and explicitly triggered by the host controller. The chip doesn't autonomously initiate recalibration when temperature changes.

Schiit's original documentation for the Yggdrasil MIB confirms the use of four DAC11001B converters, but doesn't describe whether or how this calibration feature is implemented. The MIB is also absent from Schiit's current Yggdrasil lineup, which now lists the Less Is More and Singular versions.

There's another interesting aspect to this. Schiit previously recommended leaving the original Yggdrasil powered on for best performance, specifically because its precision DACs benefited from thermal stabilization. That recommendation concerned an earlier converter architecture, but it raises a relevant question about the MIB.

Does Schiit trigger the DAC11001B's recalibration at startup, after thermal stabilization, periodically, or in response to temperature changes? Or does the implementation primarily rely on maintaining a stable operating temperature?

And if temperature-dependent linearity is significant enough to justify calibration, could the converter's measured performance vary depending on whether it was just switched on or had been operating for several hours?

A calibration performed at one temperature may no longer provide the same correction after the converter warms up, unless another calibration cycle is initiated.

This also raises a practical question for listening comparisons: are we comparing DACs under equivalent thermal operating conditions, or could their performance vary with warm-up time and power cycling?

Recalibration is a legitimate engineering solution to a known limitation of precision resistor-ladder converters. Its presence alone isn't evidence of superior conversion performance.

Ultimately, the meaningful comparison is the actual linearity, distortion, and thermal stability achieved by the complete DAC, and whether those differences are large enough to produce an audible improvement over other well-designed architectures.

A sophisticated solution to an old engineering problem isn't necessarily an advance in audio reproduction.

References:
Texas Instruments DAC11001B datasheet, section 7.3.5:
https://www.ti.com/lit/ds/symlink/dac11001b.pdf
 
If your a member of an audio forum for long enough you will start to notice the same questions, and statements being asked, and asserted.

Do not be drawn into an argument, simply point out that it's not possible for one person to have listened to all variables (of DACs in this case), and even if they have, their 'findings' will only ever apply to their ears, and their system, in their room.
 
Mostly agree with him. Not all DACs are identical in performance, but most are. When it's transferring a varying voltage representing digital data to a varying voltage representing an analogue waveform there's only one right answer and most get it.

Differences tend to be due to the analogue filter i,e frequency response. I am too old to hear the slight FR differences at high frequencies.

To really 'trust your ears' you need to do a comparison without knowing which DAC you have in play.

IMV the DAC is the least consequential component and I would not spend big money (i.e thousands) to buy one.
the chip is only part of the DAC. the analog sections are as different from each other as any other line amplifiers are. the differences in power supplies are as different as the power supplies of any other source or line level component. sometimes these differences are vast, and sometimes they are not.
 
the chip is only part of the DAC. the analog sections are as different from each other as any other line amplifiers are. the differences in power supplies are as different as the power supplies of any other source or line level component. sometimes these differences are vast, and sometimes they are not.
The differences are not vast they're small at best. Analogue filters are the same or only marginally different, maybe 1dB at best and only in the high frequencies. I agree that can be audible as I mentioned in my post that you quoted, but unlikely for anyone over 30 since you need acute hearing in the high frequencies.

Power supplies don't usually have audible noise levels. There's always exceptions to this if you look hard enough, there's thousands of DACs on the market and some are junk. But mostly the things you list cannot be differentiated.
 
The differences are not vast they're small at best. Analogue filters are the same or only marginally different, maybe 1dB at best and only in the high frequencies. I agree that can be audible as I mentioned in my post that you quoted, but unlikely for anyone over 30 since you need acute hearing in the high frequencies.

Power supplies don't usually have audible noise levels. There's always exceptions to this if you look hard enough, there's thousands of DACs on the market and some are junk. But mostly the things you list cannot be differentiated.

the differneces ARE vast and they ARE negligible. the differences between two dacs are as big or as small as the differences between any two amplifiers of any other kind.

if you have two DACs using the same chip built the same way using the same opamps for the analog section and the same wall wort, the differences will likely be little to "small at best," as you say. of course. the differences between the two DACs are small at best.

however.

two dacs, even using the same DAC ship, with totally different analog sections and totally different power supplies can sound as different as two completely different amplifiers of any type, no special hearing required. if you cant differentiate between two things that sound very different that doesnt mean theres no difference.
 
Last edited:
the differneces ARE vast and they ARE negligible. the differences between two dacs are as big or as small as the differences between any two amplifiers of any other kind.

if you have two DACs using the same chip built the same way using the same opamps for the analog section and the same wall wort, the differences will likely be little to "small at best," as you say. of course. the differences between the two DACs are small at best.

however.

two dacs, even using the same DAC ship, with totally different analog sections and totally different power supplies can sound as different as two completely different amplifiers of any type, no special hearing required. if you cant differentiate between two things that sound very different that doesnt mean theres no difference.
I suspect we're not going to agree here since I don't think differences in amplifiers can be vast either. Barring edge cases, solid state amps don't have a 'sound' unless run into clipping. We're a long way apart on this subject. :)

Regarding power supply differences here's an anecdote I'll tell for entertainment more than anything:

I have a couple of stand alone DACs here. One is expensive and has 2 linear power supplies, one each for the digital and analogue sections. The other is cheap and runs off a mobile phone charger. I mentioned to a couple of 'golden ear' pals that I could not differnetiate between them. They scoffed at that and said they must sound different. I said 'come over and try.'

So the first turns up, we swapped between these DACs for about 4 hours (very tedious). He couldn't come up with any difference he could hear and gave up.

Second one comes over. He was more determined. We spent 6 hours going back and forth, went out to a restaurant to eat, came back, spent another 2 hours. By this point my brain was addled and I started thinking 'Hey, maybe the cheap one does sound a little brighter.' Literally as I was thinking that my pal says 'Hey you know what, I think the cheaper one sounds a bit duller.'

At that point I said 'Enough!!'
 
Back
Top Bottom