• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Dac Scam Video

Heres another. '

One of the same pals bought a quite expensive DAC, from memory it was a Soekris. He modded it by swapping the SMPS for an LPS, I think he also swapped some caps for boutique ones. He brought it round and we compared it to my cheap DAC with the phone charger supply.

We were listening to some music with a xylophone and he observed that there was a difference, his DAC had a little more 'body' to the notes. So we concentrated on that and I agreed it did seem to be the case, although over several hours we couldn't pin down any other differences.

Toward the end we were listening to 'The Last Time I Saw Richard' by Joni Mitchell which has quite a long piano intro. My pal says 'The piano sounds quite different! On my DAC it sounds like a grand piano, the cheap DAC makes it sound like an upright!'

The punchline - the piano on that recording is an upright.
 
I suspect we're not going to agree here since I don't think differences in amplifiers can be vast either. Barring edge cases, solid state amps don't have a 'sound' unless run into clipping. We're a long way apart on this subject. :)

Regarding power supply differences here's an anecdote I'll tell for entertainment more than anything:

I have a couple of stand alone DACs here. One is expensive and has 2 linear power supplies, one each for the digital and analogue sections. The other is cheap and runs off a mobile phone charger. I mentioned to a couple of 'golden ear' pals that I could not differnetiate between them. They scoffed at that and said they must sound different. I said 'come over and try.'

So the first turns up, we swapped between these DACs for about 4 hours (very tedious). He couldn't come up with any difference he could hear and gave up.

Second one comes over. He was more determined. We spent 6 hours going back and forth, went out to a restaurant to eat, came back, spent another 2 hours. By this point my brain was addled and I started thinking 'Hey, maybe the cheap one does sound a little brighter.' Literally as I was thinking that my pal says 'Hey you know what, I think the cheaper one sounds a bit duller.'

At that point I said 'Enough!!'
if you cant hear the difference between two things that sound different, thats your hearing.
 
sure, the same way maybe lindt and ritter sport dont taste any different from hersheys milk chocolate.
You're right. chocolate and audio electronics are exactly the same thing.

A chocolate DAC would be no use to me, I'd end up eating it. :)

Seriously though I stopped doing these comparisons years ago now. They're so tedious and really there's nothing worse than using music to listen to equipment. I found it was substantially reducing my ability to listen to music for enjoyment. I no longer worry about the idea that there might be marginal sonic differences in amps or DACs.
 
You're right.
the fact of differences in topologies, build quality and so on has nothing to do with me.
chocolate and audio electronics are exactly the same thing.
ooh, not to me.
A chocolate DAC would be no use to me, I'd end up eating it. :)
if its dark chocolate? me, too
Seriously though I stopped doing these comparisons years ago now. They're so tedious and really there's nothing worse than using music to listen to equipment. I found it was substantially reducing my ability to listen to music for enjoyment. I no longer worry about the idea that there might be marginal sonic differences in amps or DACs.
well, sure, who has time for the "idea of marginal differences?"
obsessing over small differences isnt fun, but we hear the real differences in sound and SQ among DACs, speakers, turntables, stylus, line stages, etc. and use the best we can get to have the best listening experience.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom