• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Do Not Tolerate Mistracking-Ever!!

I have probably around 300 records dating from the early 60's to 2006 or so. Just guessing, I probably have over 60 that exhibit slight sibilance, and maybe dozen or so that exhibit objectionable sibilance. Some of them are worn, but a few are in NM-mint condition, recently purchased. I suppose it's possible that they are all damaged, but not probable. A few of these I have acquired multiple copies of, and encountered the same results.

...

I do hear many vinyl listeners swear up and down that sibilance and mistracking don't exist on their system... It makes me wonder if it's really not there, or if some don't really even notice when IGD, sibilance, or mistracking in general is taking place? :scratch2:

I'd be willing to bet something like an AT-440MLa would track those records just fine; or, another microline stylus based cartridge.

The 440MLa isn't for every system, but if you have low capacitance phono cables and phono stage and your system er's on the warm side, it's a fantastic thing. I had it in a NAIM based system once and it was a sheer ear-bleeder. In my current Marantz/NHT system it sings as beautifully as any cartridge I've ever owned - many costing 8-10 fold the AT's cost - and never ever mistracks or exhibits unnatural sibilants.

Another route may be the Jico SAS styli for your M97xE if your system wouldn't be a good fit, but I found it not as quiet in the groove as the 440MLa.

Oh, and I agree with your assessment of some who claim never to have experienced IGD or mistracking. I had a good friend who swore up and down he never ever had IGD with his Denon DL103 conical stylus. I tried one and drove myself nuts trying to eradicate horrible IGD on some LP's with lengthy sides. Finally gave up and visited said friend a year later at his home. First record he spun, the IGD was painfully present to me with the DL103.
 
Mistracking is really inacceptable, it appears only when are big problem with the turntable, damaged or bad tonearm, sibilance may appear but nothing it's perfect, some crack and pops and a bit of sibilance[sometimes] is needed for an original audition. :yes:
 
I completely agree with Sparky and it does seem there are some in the vinyl world who promulgate the inevitability of certain aspects of vinyl reproduction like inner groove distortion or mistracking under certain circumstances.

It just isn't that way.

Back in vinyl's heyday, we never accepted those ideas and strove to achieve perfect tracking. If mistracking was heard, it was, "There's something wrong and it must be corrected." because we knew there was a cause and it was not an inevitability of vinyl reproduction.

The only thing we accepted then was determining whether distortion was caused by mistracking in the present system or as a result of previous damage to the record in question. It becomes easy enough to find out.

The same things are true today as have always been.

Doug
 
On some records that are in good condition, I have heard a little distortion on the last track of the record. It is not very much. I think my cartridge is aligned properly. Is this normal?
 
On some records that are in good condition, I have heard a little distortion on the last track of the record. It is not very much. I think my cartridge is aligned properly. Is this normal?

I had the same issue, you must use a good simple protractor, i've used 2 points protractor, 63mm and 120 mm exactly from middle of spindle, no distortion anymore:thmbsp:
 
I think there a few (very few) records that were poorly mastered and the dulling of the sound towards the center can be perceived as distortion. Vast majority of the time it's not an issue.
 
I think there a few (very few) records that were poorly mastered and the dulling of the sound towards the center can be perceived as distortion. Vast majority of the time it's not an issue.

This is what I thought. I have some records that do not even have this distortion at the end, but some do. I am just very sensitive to this and I wanted to make sure this isn't stylus Mistracking.
 
In my case was alignment problem, distorted play at inner track's was present on all the records, that's why i need an simple alignment method and it works. Distortion can be caused by previous play on other turntable with alignment problem, i have some damaged record's that way.
 
I think there a few (very few) records that were poorly mastered and the dulling of the sound towards the center can be perceived as distortion. Vast majority of the time it's not an issue.

It does happen. I can't imagine that every record with perceptible distortion or sibilance has groove damage. I know that there ARE differences in mastering and cutting. There are also diffences in the quality of pressing. I have some records that have a great deal of surface noise, groove echo, crackles and hiss, and have not been worn or abused. Some records will even have bubbles, pits, or foreign materials pressed into the surface! Others look "glazed" and worn, yet sound great! :dunno:

Vinyl can be an inconsistant format. :scratch2:

Worn records are a problem though, too. I have found more than my fair share. Most end up getting re-donated. You can't alway tell by outward appearence, but it seems that most people that don't bother to replace a bad stylus, or to set up their turntable, don't take meticulous care of their records...

If a record's surface doesn't have a lusterous shine, and appears hazy or gray, it's probably going to sound worn. Greasy fingerprints in the grooves usually indicate that the record has been mishandled. Also if the record is very dirty, like it's sat out of the jacket for weeks or months on end, (especially if the dirt has been pressed into the grooves by the previous owner's stylus,) that is a big warning sign! Also, if there are a bunch of scratches on the label around the spindle hole, it's probably spent some time spinning on the platter.

Sometimes dirty records clean up great... just make sure you clean them well before you play them! I always "wet wash" thrift store records before I play them. A carbon fiber brush just won't cut it! :nono:
 
Last edited:
Alot of people like the Audio-technica AT92E. I have both the AT92E and the AT3482. I am not using either one of these cartridges right now. On my Technics SL-Q30 The AT92E didn't seem to track the inner grooves of some of my records very well. I could hear a lot of sibilance toward the end of some records. When I put the AT3482 on my turntable, this distortion went away. The AT3482 has a conical stylus with a carbon Fiber cantalever. I will say, a conical stylus should not sound this good, but it does. The AT3482 sounds more impressive on my JVC Q-L5.

I bring this up because eliptical styli tipically sound better. I think the AT3482 is a little overlooked. What is causing the AT92E to sound this way on my P-mount table? Is this because of stylus Mistracking? If it was stylus Mistracking, wouldn't the AT3482 display the same behavior?
 
That is odd... I have both as well. On my system, the AT92ECD tracks a little better than the conical, though there is not a huge difference. Mostly, the difference is in sound quality. My conical sounds very bright, yet still somehow lacks detail. Though both cartridges have that typical bright "AT sound," my 92ECD sounds more balanced and much more detailed to my ear.

Are you sure the AT92ECD stylus is clean? How old is it?

Another thing... If you happen to play a record with groove damage, the AT92ECD will more readily reveal it.
 
That is odd... I have both as well. On my system, the AT92ECD tracks a little better than the conical, though there is not a huge difference. Mostly, the difference is in sound quality. My conical sounds very bright, yet still somehow lacks detail. Though both cartridges have that typical bright "AT sound," my 92ECD sounds more balanced and much more detailed to my ear.

Are you sure the AT92ECD stylus is clean? How old is it?

Another thing... If you happen to play a record with groove damage, the AT92ECD will more readily reveal it.

the stylus is clean. I have an extra stylus that I have tried as well. these cartridges do sound better to me on my JVc, that is what I find interesting. there is a review of the AT3482 on audiogon and the person who reviewed it said some of the same things I have mentioned.

On my Technics the At3482 does not sound as detailed as the At92E, but on the JVC the AT3482 sounds amazing. Maybe it is just a good match.
 
The AT92E does sound more balanced with more detail, but I hear more sibilance with it than my other cartridges. Right now I am using a digitrak 200 NE and a Shure MP94E. Both of these are great trackers and have exelent sound.
 
I put a 92ECD in the mod'ed H-K T60 and got the best I've heard from that cart, not bad. It's not in regular use however so cannot comment in depth.
 
Last edited:
The AT92E does sound nice. I would like to hear it with a Shibata, but for that price, I could find a better cartridge. I guess once you hear the digi, there is no going back.
 
Last edited:
There undoubtedly are better cartridges than the AT92ECD out there, but I don't think there is ANY better bang for the buck. I know of no other offerings in the $20 range with a .3 x .7 mil elliptical stylus. It tracks well, and sounds good.

The only bummer is that it is only offered as a P-mount, and the included P-mount to 1/2" adaptor leaves a little to be desired. It doesn't work well on some tonearms that don't have adjustable VTA.
 
Last edited:
The 'P' mount adapter pretty much tops out the VTA adjustment range of most TT's, making set-up somewhat simpler. That's why I like them in the H-K TTs both RABCO and 'T' series, no spacers. Same for the ReVoX Linatrack.
 
The AT92 and AT3482 are the exact same body - the 3482 (and 3472 and other relatives) - us a carbon fibre cantilever on the stylus. (The 92 uses aluminium)

If you want a 1/2" mount AT92, you can get one, it is called an AT95...

The cartridge is electrically identical (you can measure the resistance and inductance....)

BUT: - the AT92/3482 are designed for p-mount arms, which are low mass and require high compliance - so the styli are designed accordingly

The AT95 is intended for mid mass S-Arm tables, and is therefore lower compliance for a heaver arm. - ALL IN THE STYLUS

It is possible to cross fit AT92 styli onto AT95 bodies, but it requires some creative carving of the plastic surround of the stylus (the central plug that holds the stylus is identical - the side wings need to be "carved").

bye for now

David
 
Back
Top Bottom