• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Good, decent turntable?


Yep, a pretty positive review for such a full-featured, low-cost, new turntable. In the Audio Circles forum, Jeff Dorgay had said of its predecessor (the AT-PL120), "It's way better than it should be for that kind of dough! Im using mine with a Shure M97 and love it! I haven't sold the SME yet, but as an entry level table that should be able to serve a vinyl lover well, it's the way to go."
 
Agreed.

I admit, I get a little cranky about people expecting instant gratification from vinyl. I understand it's what the younger demographic is accustomed to, but there should be some understanding that if one wants to pursue the highest quality of audio possible (within one's budget), it's a never-ending quest. I've been spinning vinyl since I got a Barbie record player as a little girl, and that hunger has always been there. I graduated to a hand-me-down Magnavox console, then components. I'm still fiddling, adjusting, tweaking, looking for that nth bit of performance out of vinyl.

We're really fortunate to have a place like AK where we can benefit from the experiences of others...and hopefully not make the costly and sometimes misguided mistakes that I and probably a lot of other older people here made back in the day when it was kind of difficult to get more than one or two opinions on a particular model of turntable or cartridge. At the same time, I think we have to be somewhat vigilant about the integrity of advice dispensed here...not that I'm an expert by any stretch of the imagination--when something is clearly not the case, clearly a misrepresentation of fact, it needs to be called out. The alternative to that IS to end up like the turntable reviews on Amazon.

I lurked here for a long time before joining up...I wanted to make sure that I had a pretty good feel for the lay of the land and that I had learned enough from others to make a positive contribution before posting stuff. I think everyone has valuable things to contribute, I think that for some people the 1200 knockoffs are just fine, but I'd caution against recommending them to just anyone. Even if a new Audio Technica did come new in the box, there's still some important things that a newbie must know to get decent sound out of one...and almost all of those things apply also to vintage tables. Overhang, alignment, tracking force, arm height (if adjustable), leveling the table, the preamp (I've heard that the AT built in preamp is less than great), so on. For a person who DJ's...and I don't necessarily mean club-scratch kind of DJ'ing, but even making 'mix tapes' or 'mix mp3's' or what-have-you, something like a 1200 knockoff might be a great deal. Having all that torque for slip cueing and back-cueing is nice. But for someone who may have a large classical collection and already has some monoblock tube amps and high end speakers...it's clearly not a good choice.

I guess what I try to do, if 'recommending' something, rather than to say, "Get this", is to say what works for me and why. That way, it's up to the person doing the asking to figure out if that works for them or not.

What part of the OP said he wanted instant gratification or was young? Your attacks and that's what they were, were uncalled for. I don't think you lurked long enough if you would have you would have noticed its all audio no attitude. No attitude is what I love about this site if I wanted to rude comments like yours I would go to others. Seems lately the newbies around here have an attitude issue. You can disagree no problem but don't bring a rude, arrogant attitude into. State your opinion offer a suggestion and go on.
 
For what it's worth, this is what set me off:



Without starting the argument all over again, that just sort of threw down the gauntlet. So he didn't say pee, or junk, or whiny pukes, or what-have-you. If it's ok to make such ridiculous statements about such a large chunk of people who frequent AK, then clearly I'm in the wrong place and should have remained a lurker.

Sorry about the bad timing on my part. After seeing your latest response to RamblinE, and not yet seeing this one, I deleted my post, thinking it was now counterproductive.

I can understand your taking exception to gagelle's post, though he at least excluded AKers from his sweeping generalization. I have to say that my experience with buying used, even from local shops who offer a warranty period, has been less than successful in terms of getting a quality product that lasts very long, but I wouldn't characterize them as pawning off garbage to the gullible.
 
I'm not entirely agreeing with the guy who said that the used market is full of con artists but I've been burned in the used market and it's really discouraging. Knowing what you're looking for and having experience helps but those things only come with time. Internet research helps some but experience helps you make the best decision and gaining experience takes time.

A lot of variables with the used market. Maybe I fear monger myself a bit too much with Ebay shipping/packing horror stories but I'd be less then happy if I spent what is to me a large amount of money and it showed up trashed. I haven't bought anything much bigger then headphones on Ebay for that very reason.

I've mostly ignored Bartertown as I'm not a subscriber and have no experience with it yet but from what I hear it is a place where people pack and ship very well and stand by the products they sell. For a used unit I'd look there before Ebay. Craigslist varies by market.

Without making another case for my suggestion I just thought I ought to mention that there is at least one viable option in the stated price range that can be had brand new. Yes, just one.
 
Dudes! It's only a TT. An inanimate object. Be cool!

As for my two cents, see above. Buy from those who you can trust. I've never been burned on vintage doing that! YMMV.

cnh2
 
Thought I'd chime in. Reason I want to get a better turntable is the fact that the $100 newmark I have is worthless. I was given my parent's old record collection about a year ago, and many new bands I actively see and listen to put out tons of records. $250 is quite a sum of money for me, so I just want something that won't damage my records, sound decent, and be reliable.

Thanks.
 
Gentelmen this thread has beeen cleaned up all all those involved will Please refrain from straying Way off topic as per the OP`s request!
 
Myself and all who post here will do everything we can to offer practical, positive tips for good vinyl reproduction within your means. If any AK member is near Eastern Tennessee and wants to spend a day, if you need a turntable, I will happily inspect and evaluate your prospective find. My desire is your satisfaction and good vinyl reproduction with minimal worries. And reliable good music, I do not charge for it either. I love all vinyl fans. I like meeting AK members! Small adjustments and setup I will assist on. If I can't find know how on your desired turntable, tonearm, or cartridge, I will refer you to someone who knows it. I desire no attitude and encouragement on that path.
 
Been thinking about saving up around $250 to get myself a decent turntable. Am I have no idea of whats "good" in that price range.

Aloc

Become a subscriber and you can look at the offerings in barter town which is a subscribers only area.

Someone will hook you up well within your budget there.

Good luck.

Eric
 
I've never bought a used table that wasn't physically close enough to where I live that I couldn't drive and inspect. Bringing it home on the floor of the passenger seat is a lot safer than shipping.

I live in the boonies, so TT's don't come up locally often, but in the last two years I've scored a KD550 (perfect except for the dried out lifter) and a KD5070 (worked but had some scratched on the cover). I paid $100 or less for both, with an Ortofon and Shure cartridge on each. Another $50 each for new stylus' and I was in business again after my NAD quit two years ago.

Just my 2 cents.
 
Do your home work and keep your eyes open, I've picked up TD 124's and AR ES-1's for less money than your budget.




I would be cautious about this advice. The OP sounds like he's new to this, and if you're going to buy used/preowned/whatever the buzz word is, YOU HAVE TO KNOW WHAT YOU'RE DOING. I would agree with what Ramblin said about the ATLP120....it's very much a no-apologies-needed table that will perform well and sound good, and...above all else...it will be NEW.
 
I would be cautious about this advice. The OP sounds like he's new to this, and if you're going to buy used/preowned/whatever the buzz word is, YOU HAVE TO KNOW WHAT YOU'RE DOING. I would agree with what Ramblin said about the ATLP120....it's very much a no-apologies-needed table that will perform well and sound good, and...above all else...it will be NEW.

No-apologies-needed turntable? I beg to differ. A-T and/or Hanpin should be offering profuse apologies for that 0.20% WRMS wow and flutter spec. Thirty years ago, that number would have instantly marked a turntable as mid-fi or worse. I stand by my earlier recommendation that the OP consider a used turntable and get some assistance in finding a good one.
 
No-apologies-needed turntable? I beg to differ. A-T and/or Hanpin should be offering profuse apologies for that 0.20% WRMS wow and flutter spec. Thirty years ago, that number would have instantly marked a turntable as mid-fi or worse. I stand by my earlier recommendation that the OP consider a used turntable and get some assistance in finding a good one.



Fine....beg to differ all you want. And I stand by MY recommendation. Unless a person's hearing is that of a canine, most are unlikely to hear (or care about) the wow/flutter....you're talking TWO-TENTHS OF A PERCENT, which may not be "great", but it's also not so awful that it would clearly be heard. Also....the official spec is LESS THAN 0.2%, which implies that the MAXIMUM W/F will be 0.2%. And if AT or Hanpin should be offering profuse apologies, perhaps you should contact them directly. I think it also goes without saying that the ATLP120 is very much within the "mid-fi" category....no allusions to anything more or better than that.
 
Last edited:
Fine....beg to differ all you want. And I stand by MY recommendation. Unless a person's hearing is that of a canine, most are unlikely to hear (or care about) the wow/flutter. And if AT or Hanpin should be offering profuse apologies, perhaps you should contact them directly.

It's not worth my time and trouble to contact Hanpin or Audio-Technica. As long as they're making money selling crap turntables, they have no incentive to improve the design. What I will do is point out the deficiencies in their products and refrain from buying them.

BTW, most of the musicians I know would have little trouble hearing 0.20% wow and flutter and would agree with me that it detracts from the listening experience. You don't need the hearing of a canine (frequency extension to 40 kHz) to detect that a turntable is fluttering like an epileptic pigeon; all you need to do is select music that exposes the problem, such as solo piano or oboe, and listen. If you know what those instruments sound like live, you'll hear the difference and you won't like it.
 
MUSICIANS??? Of course! I would expect THEY would hear the difference. I wasn't necessarily talking about professional musicians, professional scientists, OCD-afflicted audiophiles, or anyone else of that caliber whose hearing and sense of perfect pitch are critical to their profession. I was referring to the average person (such as the OP) who has never owned a table and wants something decent without having to obsess about every little thing. If the W/F spec was 20% or even 2%, I would be more concerned. The ATLP120 has no aspirations to anything other than mid-fi. For that matter, in a world where turntables can cost tens/hundreds of thousands, the SL-1200....even with its superior W/F spec....would be mid-fi. Further, there is NO turntable anywhere that has a W/F spec of absolute zero.

Specs aren't everything.

In any event, I'm not going to debate this to death with you because it's really pointless, so I'm done here.
 
Last edited:
crap turntables . . . fluttering like an epileptic pigeon . . .

I think you might be guilty of a bit of hyperbole, but then, I haven't auditioned one myself. I have heard its predecessor, and I owned the Stanton STR8-80 (both of which had the same 0.2% w&f rating) and both sounded fine to me. Professional reviews from What HiFi, Stereophile, and Tone Audio, to name a few, have also reported on these 'tables with the 0.2% wow and flutter rating, and didn't find that area of performance to affect their positive recommendation.

If you've auditioned the turntable and found that its level of wow and flutter was unacceptable to your ears, then by all means let the world know, but your generic and sweeping condemnation of turntables with a particular w&f rating seems a bit irrational in the face of favorable reviews, high levels of owner satisfaction on sites like Amazon, and my own experience with similar 'tables.
 
I think you might be guilty of a bit of hyperbole, but then, I haven't auditioned one myself. I have heard its predecessor, and I owned the Stanton STR8-80 (both of which had the same 0.2% w&f rating) and both sounded fine to me. Professional reviews from What HiFi, Stereophile, and Tone Audio, to name a few, have also reported on these 'tables with the 0.2% wow and flutter rating, and didn't find that area of performance to affect their positive recommendation.

If you've auditioned the turntable and found that its level of wow and flutter was unacceptable to your ears, then by all means let the world know, but your generic and sweeping condemnation of turntables with a particular w&f rating seems a bit irrational in the face of favorable reviews, high levels of owner satisfaction on sites like Amazon, and my own experience with similar 'tables.

Perhaps I am guilty of a bit of hyperbole. I enjoy a good turn of phrase and try to incorporate them in my writing, which I hope justifies my use of an epileptic pigeon as a simile for a turntable that flutters energetically.

I have not heard the A-T LP120. I have heard other turntables with comparable flutter specs, going all the way back to some of the BSR and Garrard changers with MM cartridges that Radio Shack marketed in the 1970s, and had no trouble hearing their speed instability on classical music. I also learned early on that professional reviews had to be taken with a grain of salt, as reviewers don't always share my sonic priorities and some of them have hidden agendas that compromise their objectivity. This was true of the reviewers in the print magazines of the 1970s and 1980s, and it is true of the reviewers in the print and electronic publications of today.

If I run across a Hanpin turntable for $10-$20 at a garage sale or thrift store, I may just buy it, vet it and give it a good audition. So far I haven't run across one.
 
I think you might be guilty of a bit of hyperbole, but then, I haven't auditioned one myself. I have heard its predecessor, and I owned the Stanton STR8-80 (both of which had the same 0.2% w&f rating) and both sounded fine to me. Professional reviews from What HiFi, Stereophile, and Tone Audio, to name a few, have also reported on these 'tables with the 0.2% wow and flutter rating, and didn't find that area of performance to affect their positive recommendation.

If you've auditioned the turntable and found that its level of wow and flutter was unacceptable to your ears, then by all means let the world know, but your generic and sweeping condemnation of turntables with a particular w&f rating seems a bit irrational in the face of favorable reviews, high levels of owner satisfaction on sites like Amazon, and my own experience with similar 'tables.



jr.....there is no winning with this guy. specs/numbers are everything to him, and the fact that he may not have actually LISTENED to a particular piece of equipment is a matter of complete indifference. his thinking is that if the numbers are bad, the product is bad....period....end of discussion....and as far as he's concerned, you can't argue with numbers.

ugh.....he's a little too intense and over-bearing for me.
 
Last edited:
jr.....there is no winning with this guy. specs/numbers are everything to him, and the fact that he may not have actually LISTENED to a particular piece of equipment is a matter of complete indifference. his thinking is that if the numbers are bad, the product is bad....period....end of discussion....and there is no arguing with him.

Wrong, wrong, wrong. I gave up that approach to audio in 1986, when a Dynaco ST-70 that I'd just repaired made sonic mincemeat of a Kenwood KA-8100 with far better specs. IMO some specs such as THD are meaningless as predictors of audio quality. Others such as WRMS wow and flutter can be useful as filters based on my past listening experiences. If a turntable or tape deck has higher flutter than past models I've heard that didn't satisfy me, I cross it off the audition list. If the flutter is lower, I'll give it a listen.

FWIW, I remember hearing the barest trace of flutter on the CEC-built Pioneer PL-10 and PL-12 in the 1970s. I had to pick my recordings carefully to hear the problem; most rock LPs effectively masked it. Those turntables had a W&F spec of 0.10%. After hearing them, I decided to stick with my AR XA, which had flutter so low that I couldn't hear it, and resign myself to cueing records by hand. I think it's reasonable to assume that I could hear flutter from a turntable such as the A-T LP120 that has twice the specified flutter of those old Pioneer models, and it's on that basis that I view this turntable with a jaundiced eye.

ugh.....he's a little too intense and over-bearing for me.

Sad part is, we'd probably get along just fine if we met at an AK Fest or other audio event. lf we have that opportunity some day, I'll buy you a drink and we can talk music and audio.
 
Midfi? That's quite a stretch for the AT LP120, lets be realistic and call it what it is, lowfi. About all the reviewers could say was at the $250 price point compared to a similarly priced "audiophile" model Crosley they would have to recommend the AT LP120. As for the Stanton STR8-80 another winner from Hanpin that was designed for scratching, you really know how to pick them, did you also own two Ford Pintos or was it two Chevy Vegas?
 
Back
Top Bottom