Agreed.
I admit, I get a little cranky about people expecting instant gratification from vinyl. I understand it's what the younger demographic is accustomed to, but there should be some understanding that if one wants to pursue the highest quality of audio possible (within one's budget), it's a never-ending quest. I've been spinning vinyl since I got a Barbie record player as a little girl, and that hunger has always been there. I graduated to a hand-me-down Magnavox console, then components. I'm still fiddling, adjusting, tweaking, looking for that nth bit of performance out of vinyl.
We're really fortunate to have a place like AK where we can benefit from the experiences of others...and hopefully not make the costly and sometimes misguided mistakes that I and probably a lot of other older people here made back in the day when it was kind of difficult to get more than one or two opinions on a particular model of turntable or cartridge. At the same time, I think we have to be somewhat vigilant about the integrity of advice dispensed here...not that I'm an expert by any stretch of the imagination--when something is clearly not the case, clearly a misrepresentation of fact, it needs to be called out. The alternative to that IS to end up like the turntable reviews on Amazon.
I lurked here for a long time before joining up...I wanted to make sure that I had a pretty good feel for the lay of the land and that I had learned enough from others to make a positive contribution before posting stuff. I think everyone has valuable things to contribute, I think that for some people the 1200 knockoffs are just fine, but I'd caution against recommending them to just anyone. Even if a new Audio Technica did come new in the box, there's still some important things that a newbie must know to get decent sound out of one...and almost all of those things apply also to vintage tables. Overhang, alignment, tracking force, arm height (if adjustable), leveling the table, the preamp (I've heard that the AT built in preamp is less than great), so on. For a person who DJ's...and I don't necessarily mean club-scratch kind of DJ'ing, but even making 'mix tapes' or 'mix mp3's' or what-have-you, something like a 1200 knockoff might be a great deal. Having all that torque for slip cueing and back-cueing is nice. But for someone who may have a large classical collection and already has some monoblock tube amps and high end speakers...it's clearly not a good choice.
I guess what I try to do, if 'recommending' something, rather than to say, "Get this", is to say what works for me and why. That way, it's up to the person doing the asking to figure out if that works for them or not.