• Check out the Annual AK Secret Santa exchange Program, signup before November 23rd in the AK Charities & Christmas forum!

Good, decent turntable?

Excuse me, guys, but I have to wonder how this exchange is helping the OP. May I respectfully suggest that we offer him some basic, non-technical advice on a source for a reliable turntable that will meet his needs? Below I will make a couple of recommendatons. May I suggest if others have differing views on a source they offer them in a non-judgmental way?

First recommendation: Become a subscriber and seek out a turntable through Barter Town.
Second recommendation: Carefully search ebay for a seller who has a documented reputation for selling reliable turntables and who knows how to ship them. That info is easily gleened through the ebay feedback feature.
 
Excuse me, guys, but I have to wonder how this exchange is helping the OP. May I respectfully suggest that we offer him some basic, non-technical advice on a source for a reliable turntable that will meet his needs? Below I will make a couple of recommendatons. May I suggest if others have differing views on a source they offer them in a non-judgmental way?

First recommendation: Become a subscriber and seek out a turntable through Barter Town.
Second recommendation: Carefully search ebay for a seller who has a documented reputation for selling reliable turntables and who knows how to ship them. That info is easily gleened through the ebay feedback feature.

I'd agree with those recommendations, though I'd put more weight on the first than the second.

The other recommendation that has surfaced often in this thread is to buy a new Audio-Technica AT-LP120. I don't concur fully with it, though I can see the appeal of buying something brand-new with a warranty and eliminating the risk of getting a used unit that needs immediate repair or breaks down soon after purchase. IMO the first risk can be mitigated and the second is low, but buying new is even less risky.
 
Midfi? That's quite a stretch for the AT LP120, lets be realistic and call it what it is, lowfi. About all the reviewers could say was at the $250 price point compared to a similarly priced "audiophile" model Crosley they would have to recommend the AT LP120. As for the Stanton STR8-80 another winner from Hanpin that was designed for scratching, you really know how to pick them, did you also own two Ford Pintos or was it two Chevy Vegas?

Misinformation coupled with sneering, taunting remarks? "All audio, no attitude" is a tough standard to find at AK some days.

The review RamblinE provided a link for makes no mention of Crosley. Do you have a different review you could provide a reference for?

Yes, I do know how to pick them, though I credit an article on audio restoration for pointing me to the Stanton STR8-80. It read, in part:

"I've been criticized by a couple of readers for recommending a turntable with a straight pickup arm for 78 RPM restoration. I'll explain my reason and give you an alternative -- then you can take your choice. A "bent" or offset pickup arm does have a lower tracking error than a straight arm, but at a price. The offset arm tends to pull towards the center of the disc. 78's are often worn or warped so the inward pull tends to make the pickup arm jump out of the groove, especially when using a low tracking force. So we have two opposing needs: track with minimum distortion and keep the pickup stylus in the groove. I suggested the straight arm because it maximizes your chance of playing worn and warped records. If your 78's are all in good to excellent condition, then go with a turntable with an offset arm."

My experience with the STR8-80 was nothing but positive, and I found that the comments above about better tracking of worn or warped 78's also applied to lp's. The STR8-80, using the same cartridge and VTF, could cleanly track albums that neither a Dual 1218 (either lp's or 78's) nor an LP12/Ittok III were able to deal with. It made the most of my beat-up, bargain-bin finds.

But the point of referencing it in this thread was that it has the same 0.2% WRMS w&f rating as the AT-LP-120, and I heard no audible problem with that performance area.

Edit: Dr. Tinear, if you're buying for iLUVanalog, your drinks are on me!
 
Last edited:
Are the failings of the LP120 really something a new person would notice? Is the fact that it's made somewhere in asia a reason to dislike it? People used to treat Japanese products the way they now treat Chinese stuff. However the Japanese make quite a lot of good stuff. Is there any reason to discount the LP120 other then specs and snobbery? I for one don't consider snobbery a valid argument. $250 isn't going to buy you a silver bullet, be all, end all, turntable. Maybe one you have to restore but this request came from a newbie, not somebody who sounds like they're chomping at the bit for something to restore.
 
If there is any component which audiopholks get more passionate about than turntables, I'm not aware of it. I prefer a used table, but then I know what to check, look for, and look out for, so I can sorta understand someone preferring a new table, even though they could acquire a better one for the same - or even less - dough. The only reason for the qualifier 'sorta' here is that a newbie can often find local assistance with a willing AKer.

However, a sad day is soon arriving for me. Some of you may be aware of my fondness for the Thorens TD-165 turntable - I bought my first in 1972 which was the year of its introduction, and they stopped producing that model in '76. A few years ago, I bought a third one, having sold the first two - I said I'd never sell this one. Well, never say never.

Health issues make the LP process too difficult and tiring for me now. So, since I can no longer use it, I have offered it for local sale, and it looks like tomorrow, or Friday, it will likely be gone. Had I family to leave it with who would use it, of course I would do so, but that just isn't the case. Have family, just none into LP, or even much into audio, for that matter.

I've actually considered keeping it just to be able to see it, but it just wouldn't get played. My potential buyer says he's buying to use it, not to flip or, God forbid, part out. He's under thirty and I hope he does show up to buy, and then use it for all his life. I believe the table has another 40+ years left to offer - it's a good 'un - and will likely still be going strong when they throw a new AT into a landfill somewhere. I say that not to dinigrate the AT, but because the ole Thorens is more valuable, and likely will be treated better as a result. And it is a much better table, too.

Buying a good vintage table which is rising in market value vs a new one which takes an immediate resale plunge makes sense, too.

EDIT: Reading back through this, it almost sounds as if I'm on my deathbed, LOL. Things are not that dire, but I do have physical deficits which make using a TT very difficult, to the point that it just isn't worth the effort to me now.
 
Last edited:
I'm a musician, so I'm going to assume that I can tell the sound difference between a good turntable and a bad one pretty easily. I was just asking what are some specific models / brands I should be looking for, and stuff pertaining to the needle/cartridge (Buy a new one or not), and setting it up.

I just want something that won't damage my records and last.
 
Aloc,

Unless you have obsessive compulsive disorder and constantly trying (hoping?) to find problems (I have a local friend like that....he spends so much time looking for problems and listening for problems and switching cables and switching cartridges and switching speakers and micro fine-tuning everything that he can't just sit back and enjoy the music....I don't visit him that much anymore), I still say Ramblin's suggestion was a good one. The ATLP120 is not perfect, but then NO table is.
 
I'm with RamblinE and gagelle--the Audio Technica AT-LP120-USB is probably the best option in that price range.
Agreed. Plug-play trouble-free listening while you continue to get familiar. And if you keep all the packaging clean and dry, it could retain much of its value should you want to resell it.

Looks pretty darn nice and you can't beat fresh new mechanics!
 
The thing is, I already have an okay usb turntable, a numark tti usb. I want to get something better.
 
The thing is, I already have an okay usb turntable, a numark tti usb. I want to get something better.



The ATPL120 will be an impvement over the Numark. If you don't need or want the USB part of it, AT has the AT P L 120....exactly like the LP120....just no USB connectivity.
 
Last edited:
The thing is, I already have an okay usb turntable, a numark tti usb. I want to get something better.

Then in that case the LP120 wouldn't be too huge of an improvement. Not $250 worth of improvement anyway. Subscribe to AK and see what's being sold on Bartertown. If I was in the market for used I'd look there before Ebay or even local CL.
 
Midfi? That's quite a stretch for the AT LP120, lets be realistic and call it what it is, lowfi. About all the reviewers could say was at the $250 price point compared to a similarly priced "audiophile" model Crosley they would have to recommend the AT LP120. As for the Stanton STR8-80 another winner from Hanpin that was designed for scratching, you really know how to pick them, did you also own two Ford Pintos or was it two Chevy Vegas?



So is your comment based on ACTUAL USE AND LISTENING to this table or are you just spewing and calling it fact??? And is it even remotely possible for you to post a comment without belittling???
 
Alright, I will NOT buy a new turntable. What would be some good, OLD options for me to look at / for. What should I check works? What should I do about a cartridge?
 
Alright, I will NOT buy a new turntable. What would be some good, OLD options for me to look at / for. What should I check works? What should I do about a cartridge?

If you know how to use a bubble level and turn a knob..............AR XB.
 
There are quite a few budget minded cartridges on the market that perform really well. The Shure M97xe is really popular here. I have a Grado Prestige Green. It has a warmer sound that balances out my over-analytical main headphones.
 
Been thinking about saving up around $250 to get myself a decent turntable. Am I have no idea of whats "good" in that price range.
Alright, I will NOT buy a new turntable. What would be some good, OLD options for me to look at / for. What should I check works? What should I do about a cartridge?

What sets one turntable apart from another in terms of sound quality is their respective levels of mechanical engineering and their current condition.

Paraphrasing from Linn, and ignoring what goes on inside the cartridge itself for the time being, information is retrieved from the grooves of a record only by the relative movement between the stylus and the cartridge body. A major part of the turntable's job is to keep the cartridge effectively fixed in relation to the disc surface so the stylus can accurately trace all the modulations in the groove. The record groove itself drives the stylus up and down and side to side, powering the generator inside the cartridge that makes the electrical signal we hear as music.

Any slop in a turntable's platter bearing, tonearm bearing, headshell/tonearm interface, etc., etc., results in musical information being lost because some of the energy that should be driving the stylus is being lost to these various mechanical deficiencies. Linn puts the problem in perspective by pointing out that delicacies like fine violin notes occupy spaces of less than a millionth of an inch in the groove.

The problem with buying an old turntable is that the mechanical parts are subject to wear and/or damage. Just taking the Linn design as an example, they make exceptional platter and tonearm bearings that will give high performance for 20 years or more, but they can also be easily damaged. If the turntable is transported without first removing or shimming up the subplatter from the bearing well, the main bearing can get damaged, meaning you get less information from your records, and it isn't necessarily going to be something you can hear, see, or feel--the damaged bearing simply won't sound as good as an undamaged one.

Similarly, Linn cautions not to tighten the cartridge bolts to the headshell without first removing the tonearm because the force needed to get the cartridge "Linn tight" might otherwise stress and damage the tonearm bearings. Again, this might not be apparent by sight or touch, but it will be audible as reduced sound quality compared to undamaged bearings.

A modestly-priced turntable that's brand new can often outperform a higher-priced, better designed older turntable because that older table may have wear or damage, even if it's too subtle to be obvious by sight or touch, that's crippling the performance it was originally capable of. As Brett said, you can't beat fresh new mechanics.

I don't know where you live or what local shops might be available to you, but if I were shopping for a used turntable to be an upgrade over what I've got, I'd want to work with a local shop that is set up to do comparative auditions in-store, or who is willing to let me buy a 'table on the condition that I may return it if I don't hear an improvement over what I've got at home.

In terms of brands and models, I'd look for anything by Pro-Ject, Music Hall, or Rega. They've all made, and continue to make, budget-priced turntables with decent bearings and tonearms. The companies are all in business, so you can likely get parts when you need them.

I know you said you were concentrating on used now, but one other new model to consider might be the recently-designed Pro-Ject Essential; listing at about $300, it's not much more than your proposed budget.

http://www.whathifi.com/Review/Pro-Ject-Essential/
 
jrtrent, you made some good points about arm and platter bearings and how they could be damaged or worn on used turntables. Now tell us about turntable drive systems and why most of the new budget-priced turntables do a much poorer job than their vintage counterparts at holding a steady or accurate speed. One would think that a turntable with all those new, precision-manufactured parts would be able to hold speed at least as well as a $100 Pioneer PL-10 belt-drive turntable did when it was new, but I haven't found one yet that betters the Pioneer's 0.10% WRMS wow and flutter. The Pro-Ject Essential you recommended specs out its wow and flutter at 0.25%. You might not be able to hear that flutter on your music, but rest assured that some of us audiophiles can hear it and don't want it superimposed on our music.

If the OP is considering a new Pro-Ject or Music Hall turntable, or one of the Hanpin OEM turntables marketed by Audio-Technica, Stanton or half a dozen other brands, I strongly recommend that he give it a critical audition before buying or purchase from a retailer with a generous return policy.
 
Aloc
Become a subscriber and you can look at the offerings in barter town which is a subscribers only area.
Someone will hook you up well within your budget there.
Good luck.
Eric

I agree with Eric. Become a subscriber and buy a table from Barter Town, You'll be glad you did. :yes:
 
Back
Top Bottom