Been thinking about saving up around $250 to get myself a decent turntable. Am I have no idea of whats "good" in that price range.
Alright, I will NOT buy a new turntable. What would be some good, OLD options for me to look at / for. What should I check works? What should I do about a cartridge?
What sets one turntable apart from another in terms of sound quality is their respective levels of mechanical engineering and their current condition.
Paraphrasing from Linn, and ignoring what goes on inside the cartridge itself for the time being, information is retrieved from the grooves of a record only by the relative movement between the stylus and the cartridge body. A major part of the turntable's job is to keep the cartridge effectively fixed in relation to the disc surface so the stylus can accurately trace all the modulations in the groove. The record groove itself drives the stylus up and down and side to side, powering the generator inside the cartridge that makes the electrical signal we hear as music.
Any slop in a turntable's platter bearing, tonearm bearing, headshell/tonearm interface, etc., etc., results in musical information being lost because some of the energy that should be driving the stylus is being lost to these various mechanical deficiencies. Linn puts the problem in perspective by pointing out that delicacies like fine violin notes occupy spaces of less than a millionth of an inch in the groove.
The problem with buying an old turntable is that the mechanical parts are subject to wear and/or damage. Just taking the Linn design as an example, they make exceptional platter and tonearm bearings that will give high performance for 20 years or more, but they can also be easily damaged. If the turntable is transported without first removing or shimming up the subplatter from the bearing well, the main bearing can get damaged, meaning you get less information from your records, and it isn't necessarily going to be something you can hear, see, or feel--the damaged bearing simply won't sound as good as an undamaged one.
Similarly, Linn cautions not to tighten the cartridge bolts to the headshell without first removing the tonearm because the force needed to get the cartridge "Linn tight" might otherwise stress and damage the tonearm bearings. Again, this might not be apparent by sight or touch, but it will be audible as reduced sound quality compared to undamaged bearings.
A modestly-priced turntable that's brand new can often outperform a higher-priced, better designed older turntable because that older table may have wear or damage, even if it's too subtle to be obvious by sight or touch, that's crippling the performance it was originally capable of. As Brett said, you can't beat fresh new mechanics.
I don't know where you live or what local shops might be available to you, but if I were shopping for a used turntable to be an upgrade over what I've got, I'd want to work with a local shop that is set up to do comparative auditions in-store, or who is willing to let me buy a 'table on the condition that I may return it if I don't hear an improvement over what I've got at home.
In terms of brands and models, I'd look for anything by Pro-Ject, Music Hall, or Rega. They've all made, and continue to make, budget-priced turntables with decent bearings and tonearms. The companies are all in business, so you can likely get parts when you need them.
I know you said you were concentrating on used now, but one other new model to consider might be the recently-designed Pro-Ject Essential; listing at about $300, it's not much more than your proposed budget.
http://www.whathifi.com/Review/Pro-Ject-Essential/