Alright, I will NOT buy a new turntable. What would be some good, OLD options for me to look at / for. What should I check works? What should I do about a cartridge?
I already suggested a
Thorens TD-165, and you may find one in good condition at or near your budget - less if you get lucky. One reason I love it so much, other than the very good SQ, is it's simple design. A completely manual table with no complicated, potentially vibration-inducing automatic linkages, no complicated electronics to fail, it's an early example of the KISS (yes, keep it simple, stupid) school of design.
It uses the mass of the heavy zinc platter, with a good, simple long-life motor to achieve low W&F. Of course it is belt-driven, and the platter and tonearm are mounted to a spring-suspended sub-chassis for excellent isolation from external vibrations. It plays at 33 and 45 rpm only so for 16/78 speeds look elsewhere. Two large mechanical switches provide all you need for control, and have a nicely satisfying tactile feel in operation.
The switch on the left has three positions 33-off-45 - the platter starts turning when you flip it to a speed selection. An identical flipper-switch on the right is purely mechanical and raises and lowers the viscous-damped tone-arm lift. That's it - what more do you want?
What to look for: a clean, uncracked dust-cover with unbroken hinges is a sign that the TT has been well-treated during its long life. Why would that be true? Because the simple cutouts in the dust-cover plastic that sits on small pins is the weakest link of the design. Someone heavy-handed can break off pieces of the plastic which results in the dustcover being unable to raise to the 'up' position and stay there properly. So this is a good sign if working properly - it's not a big deal (actually, to me it really is), but a good sign.
Also the TP-16 headshell should have the top metallic, shiney plate with the familiar Thorens name-logo in place on top without anyone having drilled mounting holes through it and no dimples from long cartridge-mounting screws poking up at you. An indication that previous owner(s) took the time to obtain correct-length M2 screws when changing cartridges - an indication that this is the type of person(s) you like to buy from.
The walnut-veneered plinth should look good without splits or unsightly dents. In other words, just look at the table and judge its past by its appearance - this says a lot. Make sure the viscous-damped cuing drops slowly - there is no reason why this should be a problem for a well-treated table, despite its age. The lettering should still be sharp and look good on the thin metal covering the top plinth. Lift the outer platter off, remove the belt, sit the outer platter back in place and give it a spin by hand at about 33 rpm - it should spin for a couple minutes before it comes to rest. The antiskate counter-weight on a string at the rear of the tonearm should not be missing. This came with two weights and it is also nice - but not mandatory - if both are still present. This is not readily apparent because the smaller weight nests under and inside the larger (both are small), and you just try to slide the weight up the string to determine whether both are present, sometimes the larger goes missing however and this is no biggie, the owner's manual (free online) explains how to set anti-skate with either both weights, or just the smaller. It's a plus if the big one was kept, and another good sign of a previous fastidious owner. As long as the platter rotates when turned on and sounds good, and all these other tell-tales are true, then you are very, very likely to be looking at a table which may well provide a lifetime of high-quality LP playback.
Also, because the
AR turntables share a lot of the basic design type of this table, I would also recommend that brand as well, for a simple, well-designed-and-built TT for which there are not a lot of things to go wrong. Also, I will add that this type of manual TT tended to be bought by budding audiophiles who were more interested in performance rather than convenience and were often the sort of folks who didn't abuse their 'stuff.' I say this due to my own experience in being able to find these in excellent condition as recently as about four years ago, which even included one NOS in the box which I just missed at the time, and which sold for about $260.
Finally, I will also add that I personally have bought audio equipment through AK's Barter Town listings and saved more than the annual subsciption fee with just one purchase. It's worth it to support the site, from that aspect alone.